ANIMADVERSIONS UPON THE BISHOP’S REPLY NO. VI.

In this number he hath brought three places of Scripture to prove

_freewill_. The first is, _If a wife make a vow, it is left to her

husband’s choice either to establish it or to make it void_. And,

_Choose you this day whom ye will serve, &c. But I and my house will

serve the Lord._ And, _I offer thee three things, choose thee which of

them I shall do_. Which in the reply he endeavoureth to make good; but

needed not, seeing they prove nothing but that a man is free to do if he

will, which I deny not. He ought to prove he is free to will, which I

deny.

(_a_) Secondly, “I prove it by instances, and by that universal notion

which the world hath of election.”

His instances are, first, the difference between an hereditary kingdom

and an elective; and then the difference between the senior and junior

of the mess taking their commons; both which prove the liberty of doing

what they will, but not a liberty to will. For in the first case, the

electors are free to name whom they will, but not to will; and in the

second, the senior having an appetite, chooseth what he hath an appetite

to; but chooseth not his appetite.

The English works of Thomas Hobbes of Malmesbury, Volume 05 (of 11) · 第 37 / 101 题