TENTH ARTICLE [I, Q. 12, Art. 10]

Whether Those Who See the Essence of God See All They See in It at the

Same Time?

Objection 1: It seems that those who see the essence of God do not see

all they see in Him at one and the same time. For according to the

Philosopher (Topic. ii): "It may happen that many things are known,

but only one is understood." But what is seen in God, is understood;

for God is seen by the intellect. Therefore those who see God do not

see all in Him at the same time.

Obj. 2: Further, Augustine says (Gen. ad lit. viii, 22, 23), "God

moves the spiritual creature according to time"--i.e. by intelligence

and affection. But the spiritual creature is the angel who sees God.

Therefore those who see God understand and are affected successively;

for time means succession.

_On the contrary,_ Augustine says (De Trin. xvi): "Our thoughts will not

be unstable, going to and fro from one thing to another; but we shall

see all we know at one glance."

_I answer that,_ What is seen in the Word is seen not successively, but

at the same time. In proof whereof, we ourselves cannot know many

things all at once, forasmuch as understand many things by means of

many ideas. But our intellect cannot be actually informed by many

diverse ideas at the same time, so as to understand by them; as one

body cannot bear different shapes simultaneously. Hence, when many

things can be understood by one idea, they are understood at the same

time; as the parts of a whole are understood successively, and not all

at the same time, if each one is understood by its own idea; whereas

if all are understood under the one idea of the whole, they are

understood simultaneously. Now it was shown above that things seen in

God, are not seen singly by their own similitude; but all are seen by

the one essence of God. Hence they are seen simultaneously, and not

successively.

Reply Obj. 1: We understand one thing only when we understand by one

idea; but many things understood by one idea are understood

simultaneously, as in the idea of a man we understand "animal" and

"rational"; and in the idea of a house we understand the wall and the

roof.

Reply Obj. 2: As regards their natural knowledge, whereby they know

things by diverse ideas given them, the angels do not know all things

simultaneously, and thus they are moved in the act of understanding

according to time; but as regards what they see in God, they see all

at the same time.

_______________________

Summa Theologica, Part I (Prima Pars) From the Complete American Edition · 第 94 / 722 题