On this definition we remark--

(1) Comparison by mediation is untrustworthy, unless the qualities

compared be rigidly defined or restricted, as in geometry and the use

of standards (XXII). In geometry the only two qualities recognised

are figure and magnitude. The axiom of mediate comparison means that

things having the same magnitude as a third thing are to be considered

equal, though they may have different outlines. But the axiom is

liable to be untrue in things of three or more qualities. Add colour.

Then a white sphere may resemble a white cube on the one side, and a

black sphere on the other, but the white cube does not at all resemble

the black sphere. This axiom is therefore inadmissible or at

least extremely risky in logic, which treats of things having many

qualities.

(2) Comparison, however correctly performed, is never the end, but

only a means, of reasoning.

Reformed Logic A System Based on Berkeley's Philosophy with an Entirely New Method of Dialectic · 第 84 / 94 题