THE FOUR STOIC CATEGORIES EVAPORATE, LEAVING MATTER ALONE AS BASIS.

If the (Stoics) say that the "reasons" are only modified matter, they

then admit that qualities are modes, and the (Stoics) should locate

the reasons in the fourth category, of relation. If however relation

be something different from modality, in what does that difference

consist? Is it that modality here possesses greater reality? But if

modality, taken in itself, be not a reality, why then make of it a

category? Surely it would be impossible to gather in a single category

both essence and non-essence. In what then does this modification of

matter consist? It must be either essence or non-essence. If it be

essence, it is necessarily incorporeal. If it be non-essence, it is

nothing but a word, and matter alone exists. In this case, quality

is nothing real, and modality still less. As to the fourth category,

relation, absolutely no reality whatever will inhere in it. This Stoic

system, therefore, contains nothing else but matter.

Plotinos: Complete Works, v. 3 In Chronological Order, Grouped in Four Periods · 第 284 / 442 题