CASE 126 (FIFTH GRADE)

[Sidenote: Displaying Fruit]

Florence Crane attended school in Michigan. She lived on a fine fruit

farm where during the fall one variety of peaches, grapes or pears

followed another and when these had all been sold choice apples followed

in season. So it happened that choice fruit was always a part of

Florence’s lunch. This fruit was displayed on her desk and tempted many

a child’s eyes away from school tasks. Miss Bush, the teacher, requested

all of the children to keep their lunches concealed and away from their

desks. Still at recess time Florence had a little group of children

around her watching her eat her luscious fruit. Miss Bush could scarcely

endure the sight of the hungry eyes devouring every bite with Florence.

One day she was especially tired and without forethought said,

“Florence, you shall not bring another piece of fruit to school unless

you bring enough for all of the girls.” Imagine Florence’s indignation

which was not much greater than that of her associates.

When the girls discussed this together on the playground a little later

Florence said, “I’ve a right to bring whatever I please t’ eat.”

Ethel Green, spokesman for the rest, declared, “Teacher’s crazy. We

don’t want anybody to bring us lunches. If we hain’t got enought to eat

we won’t ask her to give us anything.”

The girls had talked about the matter until the atmosphere of the

school-room was that of slumbering rebellion.

That night when Florence told her parents what Miss Bush said there was

much indignation and a long discussion which ended in a decision to have

Mrs. Crane visit Miss Bush at the schoolhouse next day. On her way there

Mrs. Crane stopped to discuss the situation with Mrs. Green, whom Ethel

had informed of the previous day’s talk. Mrs. Green was very angry and

offered to go with Mrs. Crane to the schoolhouse.

The situation was very awkward for Miss Bush. She was reluctant to say

in the presence of Mrs. Green that the other girls were always hanging

around Florence watching her eat her fruit and yet she had to justify

herself in some way. The mothers took advantage of Miss Bush’s

embarrassment, assuming that it showed guilt and even accusing her of

giving the command to Florence on the previous day in order that she

herself might be given fruit. The conference ended with the remark from

Mrs. Green, “If you’re hungry yourself, say so, but don’t beg vittles

for my children.”

Miss Bush’s joy in her work in that school was ended. The girls might

have forgotten the incident but the mothers whenever they met revived

the feeling of anger against Miss Bush.

Practical school discipline(#71746) · 第 287 / 589 题