CASE 70 (SEVENTH GRADE)

[Sidenote: Cigarettes]

The practice school of Bodeling College was so good that large numbers

of boys and girls came out by streetcar from the neighboring large city

to attend it. These boys and girls took the cars at a convenient station

near the campus, where an enterprising business man had built a Station

Store, which furnished textbooks, stationery and refreshments, and gave

shelter in bad weather. This store was a great convenience, but the

college authorities found it also much of a nuisance, for here a group

of “smart” high school and town boys gathered, to loaf and smoke and set

a bad example to the smaller boys in many ways.

The grammar grade teachers found the cigarette evil especially hard to

deal with. The seventh and eighth grade boys, seeing their elders

swaggering about with cigarettes, imitated them freely. There were a

number of fine high school boys who did not smoke, but they rarely went

home as soon as the smokers, and so the smaller boys saw most of the

smoking set.

Miss Steele, the seventh grade teacher, went to Miss Hardy of the eighth

and they had a conference. At its close, Miss Steele announced her

program:

“I’m going to appeal to plain reason; I shall show them so clearly that

they can’t fail to understand how cigarettes hurt them in every way, and

then appeal to their sense of loyalty to themselves and their future.

When they know how cigarettes rob them of health and ability, their good

sense will dictate to them what to do.”

Miss Steele planned her campaign well. She was a large, plain,

wholesome-looking woman, a good thinker and a notable figure in all

movements for public welfare in her community. Her pupils all respected

her, and her school-room management was above criticism. She planned and

delivered now a series of talks on cigarettes, in which she explained

clearly just why they are so especially harmful to the young and what a

losing game the cigarette-smoker plays. Her pupils all listened closely,

the smokers with the rest.

When she had exhausted the subject, she asked all those who were

resolved never to smoke cigarettes to raise their hands; for she had had

successful experience with the effectiveness of a public pledge. Every

pupil in the room but one raised his hand. This one pupil was the son of

a prominent attorney, a smoker and a leader among the boys. His father

had instilled in him so keen a sense of honor that, because he did not

intend to stop, he refused to make the promise.

But in spite of this well planned campaign the smoking in the seventh

grade continued. Some of the boys, with the low ideals of honor which

characterize youthful cigarette users, had had no intentions of

stopping; others were sincere in their intentions, but yielded to

example or habit when the effects of Miss Steele’s warning grew cold. As

the stories of the failure of her efforts came to the teacher, she

became more than ever convinced that the use of cigarettes causes

unspeakable moral degradation. It did not occur to her that her method

of attacking the evil could have been a mistaken one.

Practical school discipline(#71746) · 第 43 / 589 题