ATHENIAN ORIENTALISM

Both Diana and Venus were brought to Greece from Asia. Indeed, when we

examine Greek life in the light of comparative _Culturgeschichte_, we

find a surprising prevalence of Oriental customs and ideas, especially

in Athens, and particularly in the treatment of women. In this respect

Athens is the antipode of Sparta. While at Sparta the women wrestled

naked with the men, in Athens the women were not even permitted to

witness their games. The Athenians moreover had very decided opinions

about the effect of Spartan customs. The beautiful Helen who caused

the Trojan war by her adulterous elopement was a Spartan, and the

Athenian Euripides makes Peleus taunt her husband Menelaus in these

words:

"Thou who didst let a Phrygian rob thee of thy wife,

leaving thy home without bolt or guard, as if forsooth

the cursed woman thou hadst was a model of virtue. No!

a Spartan maid could not be chaste, e'en if she would,

who leaves her home and bares her limbs and lets her

robe float free, to share with youth their races and

their sports--customs I cannot away with. Is it any

wonder that ye fail to educate your women in virtue?"

The Athenian, to be sure, did not any more than the Spartan educate

his women in virtue. What he did was to compel them to be virtuous by

locking them up in the Oriental style. Unlike the Spartan, the

Athenian had a regard for paternity and genealogy, and the only way he

knew to insure it was the Asiatic. He failed to make the discovery

that the best safeguard of woman's virtue is education--as witness

America; and to this failure is due to a large extent the collapse of

Greek civilization. Athenian women were more chaste than Spartans

because they had to be, and they were superior also in being less

masculine; but the topsy-turvy Athenian men looked down on them

because they were _not_ more masculine and because they lacked the

education which they themselves perversely refused to give them! Few

Athenian women could read or write, nor had they much use for such

accomplishments, being practically condemned to life-long

imprisonment. The men indorsed the Oriental idea that educating a

woman is an unwise and reprehensible thing.[312]

Widely as the Athenian way of treating women differed from the

Spartan, the result was the same--the frustration of pure love. The

girls were married off in their early teens, before what little mind

they had was developed, to men whom they had never seen before, and in

the selection of whom they were not consulted; the result being, in

the words of a famous orator, that the men married respectable women

for the sake of rearing legitimate offspring, keeping concubines for

the daily wants and care of the body, and associating with hetairai

for pleasant companionship. Hence, as Becker justly remarks (III.,

337), though we come across stories of passionate love in the pages of

Terence (_i.e._ Menander) and other Greek writers, "sensuality was

always the soil from which such passion sprang, and none other than a

sensual love between a man and a woman was even acknowledged."

Primitive Love and Love-Stories · 第 507 / 548 题