Chapter XXIV. The World and its Master

1. In using the term world or _universe_ we include the totality of all

beings at once, and this suggests a stage of knowledge where polytheism is

practically overcome. Among the Greeks, Pythagoras is said to have been

the first to perceive “a beautiful order of things” in the world, and

therefore to call it _cosmos_.(421) Primitive man saw in the world

innumerable forces continually struggling with each other for supremacy.

Without an ordering mind no order, as we conceive it, can exist. The old

Babylonian conception prevalent throughout antiquity divided the world

into three realms, the celestial, terrestrial, and the nether world, each

of which had its own type of inhabitants and its own ruling divinities.

Yet these various divine powers were at war with each other, and

ultimately they, too, must submit to a blind fate which men and gods alike

could read in the stars or other natural phenomena.

With the first words of the Bible, “In the beginning God created the

heavens and the earth,” Judaism declared the world to be a unity and God

its Creator and Master. Heathenism had always beheld in the world certain

blind forces of nature, working without plan or purpose and devoid of any

moral aims. But Judaism sees in the world the work of a supreme Intellect

who fashioned it according to His will, and who rules in freedom, wisdom,

and goodness. “He spoke, and it was; He commanded, and it stood.”(422)

Nature exists only by the will of God; His creative _fiat_ called it into

existence, and it ceases to be as soon as it has fulfilled His plan.

2. That which the scientist terms nature—the cosmic life in its eternal

process of growth and reproduction—is declared by Judaism to be God’s

creation. Ancient heathen conceptions deified nature, indeed, but they

knew only a cosmogony, that is, a process of birth and growth of the

world. In this the gods participate with all other beings, to sink back

again at the close of the drama into fiery chaos,—the so-called “twilight

of the gods.” Here the deity constitutes a part of the world, or the world

a part of the deity, and philosophic speculation can at best blend the two

into a pantheistic system which has no place for a self-conscious,

creative mind and will. In fact, the universe appears as an ever growing

and unfolding deity, and the deity as an ever growing and unfolding

universe. Modern science more properly assumes a self-imposed limitation;

it searches for the laws underlying the action and interaction of natural

forces and elements, thus to explain in a mechanistic way the origin and

development of all things, but it leaves entirely outside of its domain

the whole question of a first cause and a supreme creative mind. It

certainly can pass no opinion as to whether or not the entire work of

creation was accomplished by the free act of a Creator. Revelation alone

can speak with unfaltering accents: “In the beginning God created heaven

and earth.” However we may understand, or imagine, the beginning of the

natural process, the formation of matter and the inception of motion, we

see above the confines of space and time the everlasting God, the

absolutely free Creator of all things.

3. No definite theological dogma can define the order and process of the

genesis of the world; this is rather a scientific than a religious

question. The Biblical documents themselves differ widely on this point,

whether one compares the stories in the first two chapters of Genesis, or

contrasts both of them with the poetical descriptions in Job and the

Psalms.(423) And these divergent accounts are still less to be reconciled

with the results of natural science. In the old Babylonian cosmography, on

which the Biblical view is based, the earth, shaped like a disk, was

suspended over the waters of the ocean, while above it was the solid vault

of heaven like a ceiling. In this the stars were fixed like lamps to light

the earth, and hidden chambers to store up the rain. The sciences of

astronomy, physics, and geology have abolished these childlike conceptions

as well as the story of a six-day creation, where vegetation sprang from

the earth even before the sun, moon, and stars appeared in the firmament.

The fact is that the Biblical account is not intended to depreciate or

supersede the facts established by natural science, but solely to

accentuate those religious truths which the latter disregards.(424) These

may be summed up in the following three doctrines:

4. First. Nature, with all its immeasurable power and grandeur, its

wondrous beauty and harmony, is not independent, but is the work, the

workshop, and the working force of the great Master. His spirit alone is

the active power; His will must be carried out. It is true that we cannot

conceive the universe otherwise than as infinite in time and space,

because both time and space are but human modes of apperception. In fact,

we cannot think of a Creator without a creation, because any potentiality

or capacity without execution would imply imperfection in God.

Nevertheless we must conceive of God as the designing and creating

intellect of the universe, infinitely transcending its complex mechanism,

whose will is expressed involuntarily by each of the created beings. He

alone is the living God; He has lent existence and infinite capacity to

the beings of the world; and they, in achieving their appointed purpose,

according to the poet’s metaphor, “weave His living garment.” The Psalmist

also sings in the same key:

“Of old Thou didst lay the foundations of the earth;

And the heavens are the work of Thy hands;

They shall perish, but Thou shalt endure;

Yea, all of them shall wax old like a garment.

As a vesture shalt Thou change them, and they shall pass away;

But Thou art the selfsame, and Thy years shall have no end.”(425)

5. Second. The numberless beings and forces of the universe comprise a

unity, working according to one plan, subserving a common purpose, and

pursuing in their development and interaction the aim which God’s wisdom

assigned them from the beginning. However hostile the various elements may

be toward each other, however fierce the universal conflict, “the struggle

for existence,” still over all the discord prevails a higher concord, and

the struggle of nature’s forces ends in harmony and peace. “He maketh

peace in His high places.”(426) Even the highest type of heathenism, the

Persian, divided the world into mutually hostile principles, light and

darkness, good and evil. But Judaism proclaims God as the Creator of both.

No force is left out of the universal plan; each contributes its part to

the whole. Consequently the very progress of natural science confirms more

and more the principle of the divine Unity. The researches of science are

ever tending toward the knowledge of universal laws of growth, culminating

in a scheme of universal evolution. Hence this supports and confirms

Jewish monotheism, which knows no power of evil antagonistic to God.

6. Third. The world is good, since goodness is its creator and its final

aim. True enough, nature, bent with “tooth and claw” upon annihilating one

or another form of existence, is quite indifferent to man’s sense of

compassion and justice. Yet in the wise, though inscrutable plan of God

she does but serve the good. We see how the lower forms of life ever serve

the higher, how the mineral provides food for the vegetable, while the

animal derives its food from the vegetable world and from lower types of

animals. Thus each becomes a means of vitality for a higher species. So by

the continuous upward striving of man the lower passions, with their evil

tendencies, work more and more toward the triumph of the good. Man unfolds

his God-likeness; he strives to

“Move upward, working out the beast,

And let the ape and tiger die.”

7. The Biblical story of Creation expresses the perfect harmony between

God’s purpose and His work in the words, “And behold, it was good” spoken

at the end of each day’s Creation, and “behold, it was very good” at the

completion of the whole. A world created by God must serve the highest

good, while, on the contrary, a world without God would prove to be “the

worst of all possible worlds,” as Schopenhauer, the philosopher of

pessimism, quite correctly concludes from his premises. The world-view of

Judaism, which regards the entire economy of life as the realization of

the all-encompassing plan of an all-wise Creator, is accordingly an

energizing optimism, or, more precisely, meliorism. This view is voiced by

the rabbis in many significant utterances, such as the maxim of R. Akiba,

“Whatsoever the Merciful One does, is for the good,”(427) or that of his

teacher, Nahum of Gimzo, “This, too, is for the good.”(428) His disciple,

R. Meir, inferred from the Biblical verse, “God saw all that He had made,

and behold, it was very good,” that “death, too, is good.”(429) Others

considered that suffering and even sin are included in this verse, because

every apparent evil is necessary that we may struggle and overcome it for

the final victory of the good.(430) As an ancient Midrash says: “God is

called a God of faith and faithfulness, because it was His faith in the

world that caused Him to bring it into existence.”(431)

Jewish Theology, Systematically and Historically Considered · 第 21 / 34 章