1. Saturday Evening Post 51
2. Harper's Magazine 50
3. Scribner's Magazine 36
4. New York Tribune (including translations) 33
5. Collier's Weekly 29
6. Stratford Journal (including translations) 28
7. Century 28
8. Pictorial Review 25
9. Smart Set 25
10. Pagan (including translations) 20
11. Bellman (January-June) 18
12. Metropolitan 17
13. Hearst's Magazine 13
14. Cosmopolitan 11
15. Harper's Bazar 10
16. Good Housekeeping 9
17. Delineator 9
18. Everybody's Magazine 9
19. Reedy's Mirror 8
20. American Magazine (excluding September) 8
21. To-day's Housewife 6
_The following periodicals have published during the same period eight
or more "two-asterisk stories." The list excludes reprints, but not
translations. Periodicals represented in this list during 1915, 1916,
1917, and 1918 are represented by the prefixed letters a, b, c, and d
respectively._
1. abcd Harper's Magazine 36
2. abcd Scribner's Magazine 21
3. d Stratford Journal (including translations) 20
4. abcd Century 20
5. bcd Pictorial Review 20
6. abcd Saturday Evening Post 19
7. bd New York Tribune (including translations) 16
8. b Pagan (including translations) 14
9. cd Atlantic Monthly 12
10. b Metropolitan 12
11. abcd Smart Set 12
12. abcd Collier's Weekly 10
13. Little Review 9
_The following periodicals have published during the same period four or
more "three-asterisk stories." The list excludes reprints, but not
translations. The same signs are used as prefixes as in the previous
list._
1. abcd Harper's Magazine 19
2. cd Stratford Journal (including translations) 14
3. acd Pictorial Review 13
4. abcd Century 11
5. abcd Scribner's Magazine 8
6. d New York Tribune (including translations) 8
7. abc Saturday Evening Post 8
8. d Little Review 7
9. cd Atlantic Monthly 7
10. ac Metropolitan 6
11. b Pagan (including translations) 5
12. a Midland 4
13. Harper's Bazar 4
14. d Smart Set 4
_Ties in the above lists have been decided by taking relative rank in
other lists into account. The New York Tribune, The Pagan, and The
Stratford Journal gain their rank chiefly through translations of
foreign stories, and allowance should be made for this in any
qualitative estimate._