INTERMEDIARY LIGHT IS UNNECESSARY, PARTLY BEING AN OBSTACLE.

If the light which is contiguous to the eye should become animated,

and if the soul should, so to speak, interpenetrate it, uniting with

it as she unites with the interior light, there would be no need

of intermediary light for the perception of the visible object.

Sight resembles touch; it operates in light by somehow transferring

itself to the object, without the medium experiencing any affection.

Now consider: does the sight transfer itself to the visible object

because of the existence of an interval between them, or because

of the existence of some body in the interval? In the latter case,

vision would occur by removing this obstacle. If, on the other hand,

it be because of the existence of a mere interval, then the nature

of the visible object must seem inert and entirely inactive. This is

however impossible; not only does touch announce and experience the

neighboring object but, by the affection it experiences, it proclaims

the differences of the tangible object, and even perceives it from

a distance, if nothing oppose it; for we perceive the fire at the

same time as the air that surrounds us, and before this air has been

heated by the fire. A solid body heats better than does the air; and

consequently it receives heat through the air, rather than by the

intermediation of air. If then the visible object have the power to

act, and if the organ have the power of experiencing (or suffering),

why should sight need any intermediary (besides light) to exert its

power? This would really be needing an obstacle! When the light of the

sun reaches us, it does not light up the air before lighting us, but

lights both simultaneously; even before it has reached the eye, while

it is still elsewhere, we have already seen, just as if the air was

not affected at all; that is the case, probably, because the medium

has undergone no modification, and because light has not yet presented

itself to our view. Under this hypothesis (which asserts that the air

receives and transmits an affection) it would be difficult to explain

why during the night we see the stars and, in general, any kind of fire.

Plotinos: Complete Works, v. 2 In Chronological Order, Grouped in Four Periods · 第 273 / 381 题