ABSURDITY OF PTOLEMEAN ASTROLOGY.

It is evident that the revolution of the stars exercises an influence

first by disposing them in different arrangement; then the things

contained within its spheres; then terrestrial beings, not only

in body, but in soul; further, each part of the heavens exercises

influence on terrestrial and inferior things. We shall indeed inquire

whether the lower things in turn exercise some influence on the

superior ones. For the present, however, granting that the facts

admitted by all, or at least a majority, are what they seem to be,

we shall have to try to explain how they are produced, by following

them up to their origins. We must indeed not say that all things are

caused exclusively by heat or cold, with possibly the other qualities

named the "primary qualities of the elements," or with those that

derive from their mixture[157]; neither should we assert that the sun

produces everything by the heat, or some other star (like Saturn), by

cold. For indeed what would cold amount to in the heavens, which are a

fiery body, or in fire, which has no humidity? Moreover, in this manner

it would be impossible to recognize the difference of the stars. Then

there are many facts that could not be traced to their influence. If

the influence of the stars is to be made to account for the differences

of human character, which are supposed to correspond to mixtures of

corporeal elements, producing a temperament in which there is an excess

of cold or heat, to which such causes would one trace hate, envy, and

malice? Granting even that this were possible, how would one then by

the same causes explain good and bad fortune, poverty and wealth,

nobility of fathers and children, and the discovery of treasures? A

thousand facts equally as foreign to the influence exercised by the

physical qualities of the elements on the bodies or souls of animals,

could be cited.

Plotinos: Complete Works, v. 2 In Chronological Order, Grouped in Four Periods · 第 241 / 381 题