Kirk)

1. X X ?

X

2. X X X X

X

3. X X X X X X

X

4. X

X

5. X

6. X X

7. X X

8. X X X

X

9. X X X

10. X X X X

X

11. X X

12. X X

X

1. 'Intelligent Raps.'

2. 'Movement of objects untouched.'

3. 'Levitation' (floating in air of seer).

4. Disappearance and Reappearance of objects. The 'object' being

the medium in some cases.

5. Passage of Matter through Matter.

6. Direct writing. That is, not by any detected human agency.

7. Sounds made on instruments supernormally.

8. Direct sounds. That is, by no detected human agency.

9. Scents.

10. Lights.

11. Objects 'materialised.'

12. Hands materialised, touched or seen.

There are here twelve miracles! Home and Iamblichus add to Mr.

Moses's repertoire the alteration of the medium's height or bulk.

This feat still leaves Mr. Moses 'one up,' as regards Home, in whose

presence objects did not disappear, nor did they pass through stone

walls. The questions are, to account for the continuity of

collective hallucinations, if we accept that hypothesis, and to

explain the procedure of Mr. Moses, if he were an impostor. He did

not exhibit before more than seven or eight private friends, and he

gained neither money nor dazzling social success by his

performances.

This page in the chapter of 'demoniac affections' is thus still in

the state of ebauche. Mr. Moses believed his experiences to be

'demoniac affections,' in the Neoplatonic sense. Could his

phenomena have been investigated by the Archbishop of Canterbury,

Dr. Parker, Messrs. Maskelyne and Cook, and Professor Huxley, the

public mind might have arrived at some conclusion on the subject.

But Mr. Moses's chief spirit, known in society as 'Imperator,'

declined to let strangers look on. He testified his indignation in

a manner so bruyant, he so banged on tables, that Mr. Moses and his

friends thought it wiser to avoid an altercation.

This exclusiveness of 'Imperator' certainly donne furieusement a

penser. If spirits are spirits they may just as well take it for

understood that performances 'done in a corner' are of no scientific

value. But we are still at a loss for a 'round' and satisfactory

hypothesis which will colligate all the alleged facts, and explain

their historical continuity. We merely state that continuity as a

historical fact. Marvels of savages, Neoplatonists, saints of

Church or Covenant, 'spontaneous' phenomena, Mediumistic phenomena,

all hang together in some ways. Of this the Church has her own

explanation.

Cock Lane and Common-Sense · 第 11 / 32 题