WHICH PUZZLES THE DOCTORS.
At the inquest held in the big upstair room of the Star and Garter
Hotel at Kew Bridge there was a crowded attendance. By this time the
public excitement had risen to fever-heat. It had by some
unaccountable means leaked out that at the post-mortem we had been
puzzled; therefore the mystery was much increased, and the papers that
morning without exception gave prominence to the startling affair.
The coroner, seated at the table at the head of the room, took the
usual formal evidence of identification, writing down the depositions
upon separate sheets of blue foolscap.
Samuel Short was the first witness of importance, and those in the
room listened breathlessly to the story of how his alarum clock had
awakened him at two o'clock; how he had risen as usual and gone to his
master's room, only to discover him dead.
"You noticed no sign of a struggle?" inquired the coroner, looking
sharply up at the witness.
"None, sir. My master was lying on his side, and except for the stain
of blood which attracted my attention it looked as though he had died
in his sleep."
"And what did you do?"
"I raised the alarm," answered Short; and then he went on to describe
how he switched on the electric light, rushed downstairs, seized the
knife hanging in the hall, opened one of the back doors and rushed
outside.
"And why did you do that, pray?" asked the coroner, looking at him
fixedly.
"I thought that someone might be lurking in the garden," the man
responded, a trifle lamely.
The solicitor of Mrs. Courtenay's family, to whom she had sent asking
him to be present on her behalf, rose at this juncture and addressing
the coroner, said:
"I should like to put a question to the witness, sir. I represent the
deceased's family."
"As you wish," replied the coroner. "But do you consider such a course
wise at this stage of the inquiry? There must be an adjournment."
He understood the coroner's objection and, acquiescing, sat down.
Nurse Kate and the cook were called, and afterwards Ethelwynn, who,
dressed in black and wearing a veil, looked pale and fragile as she
drew off her glove in order to take the oath.
As she stood there our eyes met for an instant; then she turned
towards her questioner, bracing herself for the ordeal.
"When did you last see the deceased alive?" asked the coroner, after
the usual formal inquiry as to her name and connection with the
family.
"At ten o'clock in the evening. Dr. Boyd visited him, and found him
much better. After the doctor had gone I went upstairs and found the
nurse with him, giving him his medicine. He was still sitting before
the fire."
"Was he in his usual spirits?"
"Quite."
"What was the character of your conversation with him? I understand
that Mrs. Courtenay, your sister, was out at the time. Did he remark
upon her absence?"
"Yes. He said it was a wet night, and he hoped she would not take
cold, for she was so careless of herself."
The coroner bent to his paper and wrote down her reply.
"And you did not see him alive again."
"No."
"You entered the room after he was dead, I presume?"
"No. I--I hadn't the courage," she faltered. "They told me that he was
dead--that he had been stabbed to the heart."
Again the coroner bent to his writing. What, I wondered, would those
present think if I produced the little piece of stained chenille which
I kept wrapped in tissue paper and hidden in my fusee-box?
To them it, of course, seemed quite natural that a delicate woman
should hesitate to view a murdered man. But if they knew of my
discovery they would detect that she was an admirable actress--that
her horror of the dead was feigned, and that she was not telling the
truth. I, who knew her countenance so well, saw even through her veil
how agitated she was, and with what desperate resolve she was
concealing the awful anxiety consuming her.
"One witness has told us that the deceased was very much afraid of
burglars," observed the coroner. "Had he ever spoken to you on the
subject?"
"Often. At his country house some years ago a burglary was committed,
and one of the burglars fired at him but missed. I think that unnerved
him, for he always kept a loaded revolver in the drawer of a table
beside his bed. In addition to this he had electrical contrivances
attached to the windows, so as to ring an alarm."
"But it appears they did not ring," said the coroner, quickly.
"They were out of order, the servants tell me. The bells had been
silent for a fortnight or so."
"It seems probable, then, that the murderer knew of that," remarked
Dr. Diplock, again writing with his scratchy quill. Turning to the
solicitor, he asked, "Have you any questions to put to the witness?"
"None," was the response.
And then the woman whom I had loved so fervently and well, turned and
re-seated herself. She glanced across at me. Did she read my thoughts?
Her glance was a glance of triumph.
Medical evidence was next taken, Sir Bernard Eyton being the first
witness. He gave his opinion in his habitual sharp, snappy voice,
terse and to the point.
In technical language he explained the disease from which his patient
had been suffering, and then proceeded to describe the result of the
post-mortem, how the wound inside was eight times larger than the
exterior incision.
"That seems very remarkable!" exclaimed the coroner, himself a surgeon
of no mean repute, laying down his pen and regarding the physician
with interest suddenly aroused. "Have you ever seen a similar wound in
your experience, Sir Bernard?"
"Never!" was the reply. "My friends, Doctor Boyd and Doctor Farmer,
were with me, and we are agreed that it is utterly impossible that the
cardiac injuries I have described could have been caused by the
external wound."
"Then how were they caused?" asked the coroner.
"I cannot tell."
There was no cross-examination. I followed, merely corroborating what
my chief had said. Then, after the police surgeon had given his
evidence, Dr. Diplock turned to the twelve Kew tradesmen who had been
"summoned and sworn" as jurymen, and addressing them said:
"I think, gentlemen, you have heard sufficient to show you that this
is a more than usually serious case. There are certain elements both
extraordinary and mysterious, and that being so I would suggest an
adjournment, in order that the police should be enabled to make
further enquiries into the matter. The deceased was a gentleman whose
philanthropy was probably well known to you all, and we must all
therefore regret that he should have come to such a sudden and tragic
end. You may, of course, come to a verdict to-day if you wish, but I
would strongly urge an adjournment--until, say, this day week."
The jury conferred for a few moments, and after some whispering the
foreman, a grocer at Kew Bridge, announced that his fellow jurymen
acquiesced in the coroner's suggestion, and the public rose and slowly
left, more puzzled than ever.
Ambler Jevons had been present, sitting at the back of the room, and
in order to avoid the others we lunched together at an obscure
public-house in Brentford, on the opposite side of the Thames to Kew
Gardens. It was the only place we could discover, save the hotel where
the inquest had been held, and we had no desire to be interrupted, for
during the inquiry he had passed me a scrap of paper upon which he had
written an earnest request to see me alone afterwards.
Therefore when I had put Ethelwynn into a cab, and had bade farewell
to Sir Bernard and received certain private instructions from him, we
walked together into the narrow, rather dirty High Street of
Brentford, the county town of Middlesex.
The inn we entered was close to a soap works, the odour from which was
not conducive to a good appetite, but we obtained a room to ourselves
and ate our meal of cold beef almost in silence.
"I was up early this morning," Ambler observed at last. "I was at Kew
at eight o'clock."
"Why?"
"In the night an idea struck me, and when such ideas occur I always
seek to put them promptly into action."
"What was the idea?" I asked.
"I thought about that safe in the old man's bedroom," he replied,
laying down his knife and fork and looking at me.
"What about it? There's surely nothing extraordinary in a man having a
safe in his room?"
"No. But there's something extraordinary in the key of that safe being
missing," he said. "Thorpe has apparently overlooked the point;
therefore this morning I went down to Kew, and finding only a
constable in charge, I made a thorough search through the place. In
the dead man's room I naturally expected to find it, and after nearly
a couple of hours searching in every nook and every crack I succeeded.
It was hidden in the mould of a small pot-fern, standing in the
corridor outside the room."
"You examined the safe, then?"
"No, I didn't. There might be money and valuables within, and I had no
right to open it without the presence of a witness. I've waited for
you to accompany me. We'll go there after luncheon and examine its
contents."
"But the executors might have something to say regarding such an
action," I remarked.
"Executors be hanged! I saw them this morning, a couple of dry-as-dust
old fossils--city men, I believe, who only think of house property
and dividends. Our duty is to solve this mystery. The executors can
have their turn, old chap, when we've finished. At present they
haven't the key, or any notion where it is. One of them mentioned it,
and said he supposed it was in the widow's possession."
"Well," I remarked, "I must say that I don't half like the idea of
turning out a safe without the presence of the executors."
"Police enquiries come before executors' inventories," he replied.
"They'll get their innings all in good time. The house is, at present,
in the occupation of the police, and nobody therefore can disturb us."
"Have you told Thorpe?"
"No. He's gone up to Scotland Yard to make his report. He'll probably
be down again this afternoon. Let's finish, and take the ferry
across."
Thus persuaded I drained my ale, and together we went down to the
ferry, landing at Kew Gardens, and crossing them until we emerged by
the Unicorn Gate, almost opposite the house.
There were loiterers still outside, men, women, and children, who
lounged in the vicinity, staring blankly up at the drawn blinds. A
constable in uniform admitted us. He had his lunch, a pot of beer and
some bread and cheese which his wife had probably brought him, on the
dining-room table, and we had disturbed him with his mouth full.
He was the same man whom Ambler Jevons had seen in the morning, and as
we entered he saluted, saying:
"Inspector Thorpe has left a message for you, sir. He'll be back from
the Yard about half-past three, and would very much like to see you."
"Do you know why he wants to see me?"
"It appears, sir, that one of the witnesses who gave evidence this
morning is missing."
"Missing!" he cried, pricking up his ears. "Who's missing?"
"The manservant, sir. My sergeant told me an hour ago that as soon as
the man had given evidence he went out, and was seen hurrying towards
Gunnersbury Station. They believe he's absconded."
I exchanged significant glances with my companion, but neither of us
uttered a word. Ambler gave vent to his habitual grunt of
dissatisfaction, and then led the way upstairs.
The body had been removed from the room in which it had been found,
and the bed was dismantled. When inside the apartment, he turned to me
calmly, saying:
"There seems something in Thorpe's theory regarding that fellow Short,
after all."
"If he has really absconded, it is an admission of guilt," I remarked.
"Most certainly," he replied. "It's a suspicious circumstance, in any
case, that he did not remain until the conclusion of the inquiry."
We pulled the chest of drawers, a beautiful piece of old Sheraton,
away from the door of the safe, and before placing the key in the lock
my companion examined the exterior minutely. The key was partly
rusted, and appeared as though it had not been used for many months.
Could it be that the assassin was in search of that key and had been
unsuccessful?
He showed me the artful manner in which it had been concealed. The
small hardy fern had been rooted up and stuck back again heedlessly
into its pot. Certainly no one would ever have thought to search for a
safe-key there. The dampness of the mould had caused the rust, hence
before we could open the iron door we were compelled to oil the key
with some brilliantine which was discovered on the dead man's dressing
table.
The interior, we found, was a kind of small strong-room--built of
fire-brick, and lined with steel. It was filled with papers of all
kinds neatly arranged.
We drew up a table, and the first packet my friend handed out was a
substantial one of five pound notes, secured by an elastic band,
beneath which was a slip on which the amount was pencilled. Securities
of various sorts followed, and then large packets of parchment deeds
which, on examination, we found related to his Devonshire property and
his farms in Canada.
"Here's something!" cried Ambler at length, tossing across to me a
small packet methodically tied with pink tape. "The old boy's
love-letters--by the look of them."
I undid the loop eagerly, and opened the first letter. It was in a
feminine hand, and proved a curious, almost unintelligible
communication.
I glanced at the signature. My heart ceased its beating, and a sudden
cry involuntarily escaped me, although next moment I saw that by it I
had betrayed myself, for Ambler Jevons sprang to my side in an
instant.
But next instant I covered the signature with my hand, grasped the
packet swift as thought, and turned upon him defiantly, without
uttering a word.