LAW AND LIFE
"Promises, like piecrust, are made to be broken," so runs the proverb,
and the average man repeats it without a touch of cynicism in his tones.
If you can keep your promise without loss or inconvenience to yourself,
then do it by all means; but if you cannot, invent some excuse and get
out of it. Most men place their material interests before everything
else. "Seek ye first the kingdom of God and His righteousness," is a
saying that few people regard to-day. The children of this age think
they have found a more excellent way. "Seek ye first the kingdom of this
world and the policy thereof," is the popular philosophy.
Lawyers and statesmen are busily engaged in taking the "nots" out of the
Ten Commandments and putting them into the Sermon on the Mount, and this
not only in their own interests, but chiefly in the interests of rich
clients and millionaire trusts. "The race is not to the swift, nor the
battle to the strong," says the Bible. The modern method of
interpretation is to take the "not" out. It makes sense out of nonsense,
say the children of this world; for anyone with half an eye can see that
the "not" must have crept in by mistake, for the race is to the swift,
and the strong always win the battle.
"The meek shall inherit the earth," said the Teacher of Nazareth; but
the modern interpreter, with the map of the world spread out before him,
shakes his head. There is evidently something wrong somewhere. Possibly
there is exactly the right number of "nots" in the Bible, but they have
been wrongly distributed.
"The meek shall inherit the earth"? Look at England. Look at South
Africa. Look at the United States. The meek shall inherit the earth?
Take a "not" out of the Ten Commandments, where there are several too
many, and put it into the gap, then you have a statement that is in
harmony with the general experience of the world.
When Ralph received a polite note from the chairman of the Brick, Tile,
and Clay Company, that from that date his directors would no longer hold
themselves bound by the terms of the concession they had made, he felt
that he might as well retire first as last from the scene; and, but for
Mr. Telfer, he would have done so.
Mr. Telfer's contention was that he had a good point in law, and that it
would be cowardly "to fling up the sponge" without a legal decision.
Ralph smiled and shook his head.
"I have no respect for what you call the law," he said, a little
bitterly. "I have tasted its quality, and want no more of it."
"But what is the law for, except to preserve our rights?" Mr. Telfer
demanded.
"Whose rights?" Ralph questioned.
"Why, your rights and mine, and everybody's."
Ralph shook his head again.
"I fear I have no rights," he said.
"No rights?" Mr. Telfer demanded hotly.
"Put it to yourself," Ralph said quietly. "What rights has a poor man;
or, if he thinks he has, what chance has he of defending them if they
are threatened by the rich and powerful?"
"But is not justice the heritage of the poor?" Mr. Telfer asked.
"In theory it is so, no doubt; but not in practice. To get justice in
these days, you must spend a fortune in lawyers' fees--and probably you
won't get it then. But the poor have no fortune to spend."
"I'll admit that going to law is a very expensive business; but what is
one to do?"
"Grin and abide."
"Oh, but that is cowardly!"
"It may be so. And yet, I do not see much heroism in running your head
against a stone wall."
"But is it manly to sit down quietly and be robbed?"
"That all depends on who the robbers are. If there are ten to one, I
should say it would be the wisest policy to submit."
"I admit that the company is a powerful one. But it is a question with
me whether they have any right to the stuff at all. Their sett extends
from the line of Cowley's farm westward; but their tip has come a
quarter of a mile eastward. For years past they have had to pay for the
right of tipping their waste. In point of law, it isn't their stuff at
all. It isn't even on their land--the land belongs to Daniel Rickard."
"That may be quite true," Ralph answered; "but I can't think that will
help us very much."
"Why not?"
"Because I heard this morning they were negotiating with Daniel for the
purchase of his little freehold."
Mr. Telfer looked grave.
"In any case," he said, "I would get counsel's opinion. Why not run up
to London and consult Sir John Liskeard? He is our member, you know, and
in your case his charge would not be excessive. You can afford to spend
something to know where you stand. I believe in dying game." And with a
wave of his hand, Mr. Telfer marched away.
Two days later Ralph got a second letter from the chairman of the Brick,
Tile, and Clay Company which was much less conciliatory in tone. In
fact, it intimated, in language too plain to be misunderstood, that the
company held him guilty of trespass, and that by continuing his work
after the previous intimation he was rendering himself liable to an
action at law.
Ralph toiled over the fields towards his home in a brown study. That the
letter was only bluff he knew, but it seemed clear enough that if he
resisted, the company was determined to fight the case in a court of
law.
What to do for the best he could not decide. To fight the case would
probably ruin him, for even if he won, he would have to spend all his
savings in law expenses. To throw up the sponge at the outset would
certainly look cowardly. The only other alternative would be to try to
make terms with the company, to acknowledge their right, and to offer to
pay for every ton of stuff he used.
When he got home he found Mary Telfer keeping his sister company. Mary
had been a good deal at the cottage lately. Ruth liked her to come; they
had a great deal in common, and appeared to be exceedingly fond of each
other. Mary was a bright, pleasant-faced girl of about Ralph's age. She
was not clever--she made no pretension in that direction; but she was
cheerful and good-tempered and domesticated. Moreover, as the only child
of Robert Telfer, the contractor, she was regarded as an heiress in a
small way.
Ruth sometimes wondered whether, in the economy of nature, Mary might
not be her brother's best friend. Ralph would want a wife some day. She
did not believe in men remaining bachelors. They were much more happy,
much more useful, and certainly much less selfish when they had a wife
and family to maintain.
Nor was that all; she had strong reasons for believing that Ralph had
been smitten with a hopeless passion for Dorothy Hamblyn. She did not
blame him in the least. Dorothy was so pretty and so winsome that it was
perhaps inevitable under the circumstances. But the pity of it and the
tragedy of it were none the less on that account. Hence, anything that
would help him in his struggle to forget was to be welcomed. For that
Ralph was honestly trying to put Dorothy Hamblyn out of his memory and
out of his heart, she fully believed.
For months now he had never mentioned the squire or his "little maid."
Now and then Ruth would repeat the gossip that was floating about St.
Goram, but if he took any interest in it, he made no sign.
Dorothy had never once come back since she was sent away. Whether she
was still at school, or had become a nun, or was living with friends, no
one appeared to know. Sir John kept his own counsel, and politely
snubbed all inquisitive persons.
That Sir John was in a tight corner was universally believed. He had
reduced his household to about one-third its previous dimensions, had
dismissed half his gardeners and gamekeepers, had sold his hunters, and
in several other ways was practising the strictest economy. All this
implied that financially he was hard up.
He got no sympathy, however, except from a few people of his own class.
He had been such a hard landlord, so ready to take every mean advantage,
so quick in raising rents, so slow in reducing them, that when he began
to have meted out to him what he had so long meted out to others, there
was rejoicing rather than sympathy.
Ralph naturally could not help hearing the talk of the neighbourhood,
but he made no comment. Whether he was glad or sorry no one knew. As a
matter of fact, he hardly knew himself. For Sir John he had no sympathy.
He could see him starve without a pang. But there was another who loved
him, who would share his sufferings and be humbled in his humiliation,
and for her he was sorry. So he refused to discuss the squire's affairs,
either with Ruth or anyone else. He was fighting a hard battle--how hard
no one knew but himself. He did his best to avoid everything that would
remind him of Dorothy, did his best in every way to forget her.
Sometimes he found himself longing with an inexpressible desire for a
sight of her face, and yet on the whole he was exceedingly grateful that
she did not return to St. Goram. Time and distance had done something.
She was not so constantly in his thoughts as she used to be. He was not
always on the look-out for her, and he never started now, fancying it
was her face he saw in the distance; and yet he was by no means
confident that he would ever gain the victory.
If he never saw her in his waking moments she came to him constantly in
his dreams. And, curiously enough, in his dreams there was never any
barrier to their happiness. In dreamland social distinctions did not
exist, and hard and tyrannical fathers were unknown. In dreamland happy
lovers went their own way unhindered and undisturbed. In dreamland it
was always springtime, and sickness and old age were never heard of. So
if memory were subdued in the daytime, night restored the balance.
Dorothy lived in his heart in spite of every effort to put her away.
The sight of Mary Telfer's pleasant and smiling face on the evening in
question was a pleasant relief after the worries and annoyances of the
day. Mary was brimful of vivacity and good-humour, and Ralph quickly
caught the contagion of her cheerful temper.
She knew all the gossip of the neighbourhood, and retailed it with great
verve and humour. Ralph laughed at some of the incidents she narrated
until the tears ran down his face.
Then suddenly her mood changed, and she wanted to know if Ralph was
going to fight the Brick, Tile, and Clay Company.
"What would you do if you were in my place?" Ralph questioned, with a
touch of banter in his voice.
"Fight to the last gasp," she answered.
"And what after that?"
"Oh, that is a question I should never ask myself."
"Then you don't believe in looking far ahead?"
"What's the use? If you look far enough you'll see a tombstone, and
that's not cheerful."
"Then you'd fight without considering how the battle might end?"
"Why not? If you are fighting for principle and right, you have to risk
the cost and the consequences."
"But to go to war without counting the cost is not usually considered
good statesmanship."
"Oh, isn't it? Well, you see, I'm not a statesman--I'm only a woman. But
if I were a man I wouldn't let a set of bullies triumph over me."
"But how could you help it if they were stronger than you?"
"At any rate, I'd let them prove they were stronger before I gave in."
"Then you don't believe that discretion is the better part of valour?"
"No, I don't. Not only isn't it the better part of valour, it isn't any
part of valour. Besides, we are commanded to resist the devil."
"Then you think the Brick, Tile, and Clay Company is the devil?"
"I think it is doing the devil's work, and such meanness and wickedness
ought to be exposed and resisted. What's the world coming to if
gentlemen go back on their own solemn promises?"
"It's very sad, no doubt," Ralph said, with a smile. "But, you see, they
are a hundred to one, and, however much right I may have on my side, in
the long-run I shall have to go under."
"Then you have no faith in justice?"
"Not in the justice of the strong."
"But if you have the law on your side you are bound to win."
He laughed good-humouredly.
"Did you ever know any law," he said, "that was not in the interests of
the rich and powerful?"
"I never gave the matter a thought," she answered.
"If you had to spend a month in prison with nothing particular to do,"
he laughed, "you would give more thought to the matter than it is
worth."
She laughed heartily at that, and then the subject dropped.
A little later in the evening, when they were seated at the
supper-table, Ruth remarked--
"Mary Telfer is like a ray of sunshine in the house."
"Is she always bright?" Ralph questioned indifferently.
"Always. I have never seen her out of temper or depressed yet."
"Very likely she has nothing to try her," he suggested.
"It's not only that, it's her nature to be cheerful and optimistic.
He'll be a fortunate man who marries her."
"Is she going to be married soon?"
"Not that I'm aware of," Ruth answered, looking up with a start. "I
don't think she's even engaged."
"Oh, I beg pardon. I thought you meant----"
"I was only speaking generally," Ruth interrupted. "Mary Telfer, in my
judgment, is a girl in a thousand--bright, cheerful, domesticated,
and--and----"
"Gilt-edged?" Ralph suggested.
"Well, she will not be penniless."
That night as Ralph lay awake he recalled his conversation with Ruth,
and almost heard in fancy the bright, rippling laughter of Mary Telfer;
and for the first time a thought flashed across his mind which grew
bigger and bigger as the days and weeks passed away.
Would it be possible to put Dorothy Hamblyn out of his heart by trying
to put another in her place? Would the beauty of her face fade from his
memory if he constantly looked upon another face? Would he forget her if
he trained himself to think continually of someone else?
These were questions that he could not answer right off, but there might
be no harm in making the experiment--at least, there might be no harm to
himself, but what about Mary?
So he found himself faced by a number of questions at the same time, and
for none of them could he find a satisfactory answer.
Then came an event in his life which he anticipated with a curious
thrill of excitement, and that was a journey to London. He almost shrank
from the enterprise at first. He had heard and read so much about
London--about its bigness, its crowds, its bewildering miles of streets,
its awful loneliness, its temptations and dangers, its squalor and
luxury, its penury and extravagance--that he was half afraid he might be
sucked up as by a mighty tide, and lost.
There seemed, however, no other course open to him. He had tried to come
to terms with the Brick, Tile, and Clay Company, had offered to pay them
a royalty on all the stuff he manufactured, to purchase from them all
the raw material he used. But every offer, every suggestion of a
compromise, was met with a stern and emphatic negative.
So he decided to take Mr. Telfer's advice, and consult Sir John
Liskeard. In order to do this he would have to make a journey to London.
How big with fate that journey was he little guessed at the time.