4. CONFLICTING POLICIES

Almost from the first, vital art had been applied to some extent to man

himself, though with hesitation. Certain great improvements had been

effected, but only improvements about which there could be no two

opinions. The many diseases and abnormalities left over from past

civilizations were patiently abolished, and various more fundamental

defects were remedied. For instance, teeth, digestion, glandular

equipment, and the circulatory system were greatly improved. Extreme

good health and considerable physical beauty became universal.

Child-bearing was made a painless and health-giving process. Senility

was postponed. The standard of practical intelligence was appreciably

raised. These reforms were made possible by a vast concerted effort of

research and experiment supported by the world-community. But private

enterprise was also effective, for the relation between the sexes was

much more consciously dominated by the thought of offspring than among

the First Men. Every individual knew the characteristics of his or her

hereditary composition, and knew what kinds of offspring were to be

expected from intercourse of different hereditary types. Thus in

courtship the young man was not content to persuade his beloved that his

mind was destined by nature to afford her mind joyful completion; he

sought also to persuade her that with his help she might bear children

of a peculiar excellence. Consequently there was at all times going on a

process of selective breeding towards the conventionally ideal type. In

certain respects the ideal remained constant for many thousands of

years. It included health, cat-like agility, manipulative dexterity,

musical sensitivity, refined perception of rightness and wrongness in

the sphere of vital art, and an intuitive practical judgement in all the

affairs of life. Longevity, and the abolition of senility, were also

sought, and partially attained. Waves of fashion sometimes directed

sexual selection toward prowess in combat, or some special type of

facial expression or vocal powers. But these fleeting whims were

negligible. Only the permanently desired characters were actually

intensified by private selective breeding.

But at length there came a time when more ambitious aims were

entertained. The world-community was now a highly organized theocratic

hierarchy, strictly but on the whole benevolently ruled by a supreme

council of vital priests and biologists. Each individual, down to the

humblest agricultural worker, had his special niche in society, allotted

him by the supreme council or its delegates, according to his known

heredity and the needs of society. This system, of course, sometimes led

to abuse, but mostly it worked without serious friction. Such was the

precision of biological knowledge that each person’s mental calibre and

special aptitudes were known beyond dispute, and rebellion against his

lot in society would have been rebellion against his own heredity. This

fact was universally known, and accepted without regret. A man had

enough scope for emulation and triumph among his peers, without

indulging in vague attempts to transcend his own nature, by rising into

a superior hierarchical order. This state of affairs would have been

impossible had there not been universal faith in the religion of life

and the truth of biological science. Also it would have been impossible

had not all normal persons been active practitioners of the sacred vital

art, upon a plane suited to their capacity. Every individual adult of

the rather scanty world-population regarded himself or herself as a

creative artist, in however humble a sphere. And in general he, or she,

was so fascinated by the work, that he was well content to leave social

organization and control to those who were fitted for it. Moreover, at

the back of every mind was the conception of society itself as an

organism of specialized members. The strong sentiment for organized

humanity tended, in this race, to master even its strong egotistical

impulses, though not without a struggle.

It was such a society, almost unbelievable to the First Men, that now

set about remaking human nature. Unfortunately there were conflicting

views about the goal. The orthodox desired only to continue the work

that had for long been on foot; though they proposed greater enterprise

and coordination. They would perfect man’s body, but upon its present

plan; they would perfect his mind, but without seeking to introduce

anything new in essence. His physique, percipience, memory,

intelligence, and emotional nature should be improved almost beyond

recognition; but they must, it was said, remain essentially what they

had always been.

A second party, however, finally persuaded orthodox opinion to amplify

itself in one important respect. As has already been said, the Third Men

were prone to phases of preoccupation with the ancient craving for

personal immortality. This craving had often been strong among the First

Men; and even the Second Men, in spite of their great gift of

detachment, had sometimes allowed their admiration for human personality

to persuade them that souls must live for ever. The short-lived and

untheoretical Third Men, with their passion for living things of all

kinds, and all the diversity of vital behaviour, conceived immortality

in a variety of manners. In their final culture they imagined that at

death all living things whom the Life God approved passed into another

world, much like the familiar world, but happier. There they were said

to live in the presence of the deity, serving him in untrammelled vital

creativeness of sundry kinds.

Now it was believed that communication might occur between the two

worlds, and that the highest type of terrestrial life was that which

communicated most effectively, and further that the time had now arrived

for much fuller revelation of the life to come. It was therefore

proposed to breed highly specialized communicants whose office should be

to guide this world by means of advice from the other. As among the

First Men, this communication with the unseen world was believed to take

place in the mediumistic trance. The new enterprise, then, was to breed

extremely sensitive mediums, and to increase the mediumistic powers of

the average individual.

There was yet another party, whose aim was very different. Man, they

said, is a very noble organism. We have dealt with other organisms so as

to enhance in each its noblest attributes. It is time to do the same

with man. What is most distinctive in man is intelligent manipulation,

brain and hand. Now hand is really outclassed by modern mechanisms, but

brain will never be outclassed. Therefore we must breed strictly for

brain, for intelligent coordination of behaviour. All the organic

functions which can be performed by machinery, must be relegated to

machinery, so that the whole vitality of the organism may be devoted to

brain-building and brain-working. We must produce an organism which

shall be no mere bundle of relics left over from its primitive ancestors

and precariously ruled by a glimmer of intelligence. We must produce a

man who is nothing but man. When we have done this we can, if we like,

ask him to find out the truth about immortality. And also, we can safely

surrender to him the control of all human affairs.

The governing caste were strongly opposed to this policy. They declared

that, if it succeeded, it would only produce a most inharmonious being

whose nature would violate all the principles of vital aesthetics. Man,

they said, was essentially an animal, though uniquely gifted. His whole

nature must be developed, not one faculty at the expense of others. In

arguing thus, they were probably influenced partly by the fear of losing

their authority; but their arguments were cogent, and the majority of

the community agreed with them. Nevertheless a small group of the

governors themselves were determined to carry through the enterprise in

secret.

There was no need of secrecy in breeding communicants. The world state

encouraged this policy and even set up institutions for its pursuit.

Last and first men · 第 51 / 79 题