The Evolutionists’ Error

Now, the modern Evolutionists have made no real use of the idea of

evolution, especially in the matter of social prediction. They always

fall into what is (from their logical point of view) the error of

supposing that evolution knows what it is doing. They predict the State

of the future as a fruit rounded and polished. But the whole point of

evolution (the only point there is in it) is that no State will ever be

rounded and polished, because it will always contain some organs that

outlived their use, and some that have not yet fully found theirs. If we

wish to prophesy what will happen, we must imagine things now moderate

grown enormous; things now local grown universal; things now promising

grown triumphant; primroses bigger than sunflowers, and sparrows

stalking about like flamingoes.

In other words, we must ask what modern institution has a future before

it? What modern institution may have swollen to six times its present

size in the social heat and growth of the future? I do not think the

Garden City will grow: but of that I may speak in my next and last

article of this series. I do not think even the ordinary Elementary

School, with its compulsory education, will grow. Too many unlettered

people hate the teacher for teaching; and too many lettered people

hate the teacher for not teaching. The Garden City will not bear much

blossom; the young idea will not shoot, unless it shoots the teacher.

But the one flowering tree on the estate, the one natural expansion

which I think will expand, is the institution we call the Prison.

Utopia of Usurers and Other Essays · 第 21 / 71 题