WHICH RELATIVE PRONOUN TO USE

+373.+ We are sometimes confused as to which relative pronoun to use in

introducing an adjective clause. We hesitate as to whether we should use

_that_ or _who_ or _which_. Remember that _who_ always refers to

_persons_, _which_ refers to _animals_ or _things_, and _that_ may refer

to either _persons_, _animals_ or _things_.

So when referring to a _person_, we may use either _who_ or _that_, and

when referring to _animals_ or _things_, we may use either _which_ or

_that_. As, for example, we may say, either, _The man who was here

yesterday came back today_, or _The man that was here yesterday came

back today_. Either is correct, for _who_ and _that_ both refer to

persons.

+374.+ We may make a little distinction in the use of _who_ and _that_

when referring to _persons_, however. A clause introduced by _that_ is

usually a restrictive clause. It limits or restricts the meaning of the

noun which it modifies. When you say, _The man that was here yesterday_,

you mean _that_ man and no other, limiting your meaning to that

particular man. On the other hand, when you say, _The man who was here

yesterday_, there is no restriction or limitation expressed in the use

of the clause, but it is merely a descriptive clause, adding a new fact

to our knowledge concerning that particular man.

The same is true when we are speaking of _things_ using either _that_ or

_which_. The clause introduced by _which_ is presumably a descriptive

clause. We do, however, often use _who_ or _which_ when the sense of the

clause is restrictive, but we should never use _that_ to introduce an

adjective clause, unless the sense is restrictive. When in your

sentences you can use, instead of the relative pronoun _who_ or _which_,

the conjunction _and_, you can know that the use of the pronoun _who_ or

_which_ is correct. As, for example:

Plain English · 第 454 / 661 题