ELEVENTH ARTICLE [I, Q. 19, Art. 11]

Whether the Will of Expression Is to Be Distinguished in God?

Objection 1: It seems that the will of expression is not to be

distinguished in God. For as the will of God is the cause of things,

so is His wisdom. But no expressions are assigned to the divine

wisdom. Therefore no expressions ought to be assigned to the divine

will.

Obj. 2: Further, every expression that is not in agreement with the

mind of him who expresses himself, is false. If therefore the

expressions assigned to the divine will are not in agreement with

that will, they are false. But if they do agree, they are

superfluous. No expressions therefore must be assigned to the divine

will.

_On the contrary,_ The will of God is one, since it is the very

essence of God. Yet sometimes it is spoken of as many, as in the

words of Ps. 110:2: "Great are the works of the Lord, sought out

according to all His wills." Therefore sometimes the sign must be

taken for the will.

_I answer that,_ Some things are said of God in their strict sense;

others by metaphor, as appears from what has been said before

(Q. 13, A. 3). When certain human passions are predicated of the

Godhead metaphorically, this is done because of a likeness in the

effect. Hence a thing that is in us a sign of some passion, is

signified metaphorically in God under the name of that passion. Thus

with us it is usual for an angry man to punish, so that punishment

becomes an expression of anger. Therefore punishment itself is

signified by the word anger, when anger is attributed to God. In the

same way, what is usually with us an expression of will, is sometimes

metaphorically called will in God; just as when anyone lays down a

precept, it is a sign that he wishes that precept obeyed. Hence a

divine precept is sometimes called by metaphor the will of God, as in

the words: "Thy will be done on earth, as it is in heaven" (Matt.

6:10). There is, however, this difference between will and anger, that

anger is never attributed to God properly, since in its primary

meaning it includes passion; whereas will is attributed to Him

properly. Therefore in God there are distinguished will in its proper

sense, and will as attributed to Him by metaphor. Will in its proper

sense is called the will of good pleasure; and will metaphorically

taken is the will of expression, inasmuch as the sign itself of will

is called will.

Reply Obj. 1: Knowledge is not the cause of a thing being done,

unless through the will. For we do not put into act what we know,

unless we will to do so. Accordingly expression is not attributed to

knowledge, but to will.

Reply Obj. 2: Expressions of will are called divine wills, not as

being signs that God wills anything; but because what in us is the

usual expression of our will, is called the divine will in God. Thus

punishment is not a sign that there is anger in God; but it is called

anger in Him, from the fact that it is an expression of anger in

ourselves.

_______________________

Summa Theologica, Part I (Prima Pars) From the Complete American Edition · 第 162 / 722 题