The Manufacture of Monsters

This industry is by no means peculiar to China. The Chinese (they say)

make physical monsters. We revile them for it and proceed to make moral

monsters of our own children. The most excusable parents are those who

try to correct their own faults in their offspring. The parent who says

to his child: "I am one of the successes of the Almighty: therefore

imitate me in every particular or I will have the skin off your back"

(a quite common attitude) is a much more absurd figure than the man who,

with a pipe in his mouth, thrashes his boy for smoking. If you must hold

yourself up to your children as an object lesson (which is not at all

necessary), hold yourself up as a warning and not as an example. But

you had much better let the child's character alone. If you once allow

yourself to regard a child as so much material for you to manufacture

into any shape that happens to suit your fancy you are defeating the

experiment of the Life Force. You are assuming that the child does

not know its own business, and that you do. In this you are sure to be

wrong: the child feels the drive of the Life Force (often called the

Will of God); and you cannot feel it for him. Handel's parents no doubt

thought they knew better than their child when they tried to prevent

his becoming a musician. They would have been equally wrong and equally

unsuccessful if they had tried to prevent the child becoming a great

rascal had its genius lain in that direction. Handel would have been

Handel, and Napoleon and Peter of Russia _them_selves in spite of all

the parents in creation, because, as often happens, they were stronger

than their parents. But this does not happen always. Most children

can be, and many are, hopelessly warped and wasted by parents who are

ignorant and silly enough to suppose that they know what a human being

ought to be, and who stick at nothing in their determination to force

their children into their moulds. Every child has a right to its own

bent. It has a right to be a Plymouth Brother though its parents be

convinced atheists. It has a right to dislike its mother or father or

sister or brother or uncle or aunt if they are antipathetic to it. It

has a right to find its own way and go its own way, whether that way

seems wise or foolish to others, exactly as an adult has. It has a right

to privacy as to its own doings and its own affairs as much as if it

were its own father.

Treatise on Parents and Children · 第 9 / 65 题