THE EPISODE OF THE MAN WHO WOULD NOT COMMIT SUICIDE
After my poor friend Le Geyt had murdered his wife, in a sudden access
of uncontrollable anger, under the deepest provocation, the police
naturally began to inquire for him. It is a way they have; the police
are no respecters of persons; neither do they pry into the question of
motives. They are but poor casuists. A murder is for them a murder, and
a murderer a murderer; it is not their habit to divide and distinguish
between case and case with Hilda Wade's analytical accuracy.
As soon as my duties at St. Nathaniel's permitted me, on the evening of
the discovery, I rushed round to Mrs. Mallet's, Le Geyt's sister. I
had been detained at the hospital for some hours, however, watching a
critical case; and by the time I reached Great Stanhope Street I found
Hilda Wade, in her nurse's dress, there before me. Sebastian, it seemed,
had given her leave out for the evening. She was a supernumerary nurse,
attached to his own observation-cots as special attendant for scientific
purposes, and she could generally get an hour or so whenever she
required it.
Mrs. Mallet had been in the breakfast-room with Hilda before I arrived;
but as I reached the house she rushed upstairs to wash her red eyes and
compose herself a little before the strain of meeting me; so I had the
opportunity for a few words alone first with my prophetic companion.
“You said just now at Nathaniel's,” I burst out, “that Le Geyt would
not be hanged: he would commit suicide. What did you mean by that? What
reason had you for thinking so?”
Hilda sank into a chair by the open window, pulled a flower abstractedly
from the vase at her side, and began picking it to pieces, floret after
floret, with twitching fingers. She was deeply moved. “Well, consider
his family history,” she burst out at last, looking up at me with her
large brown eyes as she reached the last petal. “Heredity counts.... And
after such a disaster!”
She said “disaster,” not “crime”; I noted mentally the reservation
implied in the word.
“Heredity counts,” I answered. “Oh, yes. It counts much. But what about
Le Geyt's family history?” I could not recall any instance of suicide
among his forbears.
“Well--his mother's father was General Faskally, you know,” she replied,
after a pause, in her strange, oblique manner. “Mr. Le Geyt is General
Faskally's eldest grandson.”
“Exactly,” I broke in, with a man's desire for solid fact in place of
vague intuition. “But I fail to see quite what that has to do with it.”
“The General was killed in India during the Mutiny.”
“I remember, of course--killed, bravely fighting.”
“Yes; but it was on a forlorn hope, for which he volunteered, and in
the course of which he is said to have walked straight into an almost
obvious ambuscade of the enemy's.”
“Now, my dear Miss Wade”--I always dropped the title of “Nurse,” by
request, when once we were well clear of Nathaniel's,--“I have every
confidence, you are aware, in your memory and your insight; but I do
confess I fail to see what bearing this incident can have on poor Hugo's
chances of being hanged or committing suicide.”
She picked a second flower, and once more pulled out petal after petal.
As she reached the last again, she answered, slowly: “You must have
forgotten the circumstances. It was no mere accident. General Faskally
had made a serious strategical blunder at Jhansi. He had sacrificed
the lives of his subordinates needlessly. He could not bear to face the
survivors. In the course of the retreat, he volunteered to go on this
forlorn hope, which might equally well have been led by an officer of
lower rank; and he was permitted to do so by Sir Colin in command, as a
means of retrieving his lost military character. He carried his point,
but he carried it recklessly, taking care to be shot through the heart
himself in the first onslaught. That was virtual suicide--honourable
suicide to avoid disgrace, at a moment of supreme remorse and horror.”
“You are right,” I admitted, after a minute's consideration. “I see it
now--though I should never have thought of it.”
“That is the use of being a woman,” she answered.
I waited a second once more, and mused. “Still, that is only one
doubtful case,” I objected.
“There was another, you must remember: his uncle Alfred.”
“Alfred Le Geyt?”
“No; HE died in his bed, quietly. Alfred Faskally.”
“What a memory you have!” I cried, astonished. “Why, that was before our
time--in the days of the Chartist riots!”
She smiled a certain curious sibylline smile of hers. Her earnest face
looked prettier than ever. “I told you I could remember many things that
happened before I was born,” she answered. “THIS is one of them.”
“You remember it directly?”
“How impossible! Have I not often explained to you that I am no diviner?
I read no book of fate; I call no spirits from the vasty deep. I simply
remember with exceptional clearness what I read and hear. And I have
many times heard the story about Alfred Faskally.”
“So have I--but I forget it.”
“Unfortunately, I CAN'T forget. That is a sort of disease with me.... He
was a special constable in the Chartist riots; and being a very strong
and powerful man, like his nephew Hugo, he used his truncheon--his
special constable's baton, or whatever you call it--with excessive force
upon a starveling London tailor in the mob near Charing Cross. The man
was hit on the forehead--badly hit, so that he died almost immediately
of concussion of the brain. A woman rushed out of the crowd at once,
seized the dying man, laid his head on her lap, and shrieked out in
a wildly despairing voice that he was her husband, and the father of
thirteen children. Alfred Faskally, who never meant to kill the man,
or even to hurt him, but who was laying about him roundly, without
realising the terrific force of his blows, was so horrified at what he
had done when he heard the woman's cry, that he rushed off straight to
Waterloo Bridge in an agony of remorse and--flung himself over. He was
drowned instantly.”
“I recall the story now,” I answered; “but, do you know, as it was told
me, I think they said the mob THREW Faskally over in their desire for
vengeance.”
“That is the official account, as told by the Le Geyts and the
Faskallys; they like to have it believed their kinsman was murdered, not
that he committed suicide. But my grandfather”--I started; during the
twelve months that I had been brought into daily relations with Hilda
Wade, that was the first time I had heard her mention any member of her
own family, except once her mother--“my grandfather, who knew him well,
and who was present in the crowd at the time, assured me many times that
Alfred Faskally really jumped over of his own accord, NOT pursued by the
mob, and that his last horrified words as he leaped were, 'I never meant
it! I never meant it!' However, the family have always had luck in their
suicides. The jury believed the throwing-over story, and found a verdict
of 'wilful murder' against some person or persons unknown.”
“Luck in their suicides! What a curious phrase! And you say, ALWAYS.
Were there other cases, then?”
“Constructively, yes; one of the Le Geyts, you must recollect, went down
with his ship (just like his uncle, the General, in India) when he might
have quitted her. It is believed he had given a mistaken order. You
remember, of course, he was navigating lieutenant. Another, Marcus, was
SAID to have shot himself by accident while cleaning his gun--after a
quarrel with his wife. But you have heard all about it. 'The wrong was
on my side,' he moaned, you know, when they picked him up, dying, in the
gun-room. And one of the Faskally girls, his cousin, of whom his wife
was jealous--that beautiful Linda--became a Catholic, and went into a
convent at once on Marcus's death; which, after all, in such cases, is
merely a religious and moral way of committing suicide--I mean, for a
woman who takes the veil just to cut herself off from the world, and who
has no vocation, as I hear she had not.”
She filled me with amazement. “That is true,” I exclaimed, “when one
comes to think of it. It shows the same temperament in fibre.... But I
should never have thought of it.”
“No? Well, I believe it is true, for all that. In every case, one
sees they choose much the same way of meeting a reverse, a blunder, an
unpremeditated crime. The brave way is to go through with it, and face
the music, letting what will come; the cowardly way is to hide one's
head incontinently in a river, a noose, or a convent cell.”
“Le Geyt is not a coward,” I interposed, with warmth.
“No, not, a coward--a manly spirited, great-hearted gentleman--but
still, not quite of the bravest type. He lacks one element. The Le Geyts
have physical courage--enough and to spare--but their moral courage
fails them at a pinch. They rush into suicide or its equivalent at
critical moments, out of pure boyish impulsiveness.”
A few minutes later, Mrs. Mallet came in. She was not broken down--on
the contrary, she was calm--stoically, tragically, pitiably calm;
with that ghastly calmness which is more terrible by far than the most
demonstrative grief. Her face, though deadly white, did not move a
muscle. Not a tear was in her eyes. Even her bloodless hands hardly
twitched at the folds of her hastily assumed black gown. She clenched
them after a minute when she had grasped mine silently; I could see that
the nails dug deep into the palms in her painful resolve to keep herself
from collapsing.
Hilda Wade, with infinite sisterly tenderness, led her over to a chair
by the window in the summer twilight, and took one quivering hand in
hers. “I have been telling Dr. Cumberledge, Lina, about what I most fear
for your dear brother, darling; and... I think... he agrees with me.”
Mrs. Mallet turned to me, with hollow eyes, still preserving her tragic
calm. “I am afraid of it, too,” she said, her drawn lips tremulous. “Dr.
Cumberledge, we must get him back! We must induce him to face it!”
“And yet,” I answered, slowly, turning it over in my own mind; “he
has run away at first. Why should he do that if he means--to commit
suicide?” I hated to utter the words before that broken soul; but there
was no way out of it.
Hilda interrupted me with a quiet suggestion. “How do you know he has
run away?” she asked. “Are you not taking it for granted that, if he
meant suicide, he would blow his brains out in his own house? But surely
that would not be the Le Geyt way. They are gentle-natured folk; they
would never blow their brains out or cut their throats. For all we know,
he may have made straight for Waterloo Bridge,”--she framed her lips to
the unspoken words, unseen by Mrs. Mallet,--“like his uncle Alfred.”
“That is true,” I answered, lip-reading. “I never thought of that
either.”
“Still, I do not attach importance to this idea,” she went on. “I have
some reason for thinking he has run away... elsewhere; and if so, our
first task must be to entice him back again.”
“What are your reasons?” I asked, humbly. Whatever they might be, I knew
enough of Hilda Wade by this time to know that she had probably good
grounds for accepting them.
“Oh, they may wait for the present,” she answered. “Other things are
more pressing. First, let Lina tell us what she thinks of most moment.”
Mrs. Mallet braced herself up visibly to a distressing effort. “You have
seen the body, Dr. Cumberledge?” she faltered.
“No, dear Mrs. Mallet, I have not. I came straight from Nathaniel's. I
have had no time to see it.”
“Dr. Sebastian has viewed it by my wish--he has been so kind--and he
will be present as representing the family at the post-mortem. He notes
that the wound was inflicted with a dagger--a small ornamental Norwegian
dagger, which always lay, as I know, on the little what-not by the blue
sofa.”
I nodded assent. “Exactly; I have seen it there.”
“It was blunt and rusty--a mere toy knife--not at all the sort of weapon
a man would make use of who designed to commit a deliberate murder. The
crime, if there WAS a crime (which we do not admit), must therefore have
been wholly unpremeditated.”
I bowed my head. “For us who knew Hugo that goes without saying.”
She leaned forward eagerly. “Dr. Sebastian has pointed out to me a line
of defence which would probably succeed--if we could only induce poor
Hugo to adopt it. He has examined the blade and scabbard, and finds that
the dagger fits its sheath very tight, so that it can only be withdrawn
with considerable violence. The blade sticks.” (I nodded again.) “It
needs a hard pull to wrench it out.... He has also inspected the
wound, and assures me its character is such that it MIGHT have been
self-inflicted.” She paused now and again, and brought out her words
with difficulty. “Self-inflicted, he suggests; therefore, that THIS may
have happened. It is admitted--WILL be admitted--the servants overheard
it--we can make no reservation there--a difference of opinion, an
altercation, even, took place between Hugo and Clara that evening”--she
started suddenly--“why, it was only last night--it seems like ages--an
altercation about the children's schooling. Clara held strong views on
the subject of the children”--her eyes blinked hard--“which Hugo did not
share. We throw out the hint, then, that Clara, during the course of the
dispute--we must call it a dispute--accidentally took up this dagger and
toyed with it. You know her habit of toying, when she had no knitting or
needlework. In the course of playing with it (we suggest) she tried to
pull the knife out of its sheath; failed; held it up, so, point upward;
pulled again; pulled harder--with a jerk, at last the sheath came off;
the dagger sprang up; it wounded Clara fatally. Hugo, knowing that they
had disagreed, knowing that the servants had heard, and seeing her
fall suddenly dead before him, was seized with horror--the Le Geyt
impulsiveness!--lost his head; rushed out; fancied the accident would be
mistaken for murder. But why? A Q.C., don't you know! Recently married!
Most attached to his wife. It is plausible, isn't it?”
“So plausible,” I answered, looking it straight in the face, “that... it
has but one weak point. We might make a coroner's jury or even a common
jury accept it, on Sebastian's expert evidence. Sebastian can work
wonders; but we could never make--”
Hilda Wade finished the sentence for me as I paused: “Hugo Le Geyt
consent to advance it.”
I lowered my head. “You have said it,” I answered.
“Not for the children's sake?” Mrs. Mallet cried, with clasped hands.
“Not for the children's sake, even,” I answered. “Consider for a moment,
Mrs. Mallet: IS it true? Do you yourself BELIEVE it?”
She threw herself back in her chair with a dejected face. “Oh, as for
that,” she cried, wearily, crossing her hands, “before you and Hilda,
who know all, what need to prevaricate? How CAN I believe it? We
understand how it came about. That woman! That woman!”
“The real wonder is,” Hilda murmured, soothing her white hand, “that he
contained himself so long!”
“Well, we all know Hugo,” I went on, as quietly as I was able; “and,
knowing Hugo, we know that he might be urged to commit this wild act in
a fierce moment of indignation--righteous indignation on behalf of his
motherless girls, under tremendous provocation. But we also know
that, having once committed it, he would never stoop to disown it by a
subterfuge.”
The heart-broken sister let her head drop faintly. “So Hilda told me,”
she murmured; “and what Hilda says in these matters is almost always
final.”
We debated the question for some minutes more. Then Mrs. Mallet cried
at last: “At any rate, he has fled for the moment, and his flight alone
brings the worst suspicion upon him. That is our chief point. We must
find out where he is; and if he has gone right away, we must bring him
back to London.”
“Where do you think he has taken refuge?”
“The police, Dr. Sebastian has ascertained, are watching the railway
stations, and the ports for the Continent.”
“Very like the police!” Hilda exclaimed, with more than a touch of
contempt in her voice. “As if a clever man-of-the-world like Hugo
Le Geyt would run away by rail, or start off to the Continent! Every
Englishman is noticeable on the Continent. It would be sheer madness!”
“You think he has not gone there, then?” I cried, deeply interested.
“Of course not. That is the point I hinted at just now. He has defended
many persons accused of murder, and he often spoke to me of their
incredible folly, when trying to escape, in going by rail, or in setting
out from England for Paris. An Englishman, he used to say, is least
observed in his own country. In this case, I think I KNOW where he has
gone, how he went there.”
“Where, then?”
“WHERE comes last; HOW first. It is a question of inference.”
“Explain. We know your powers.”
“Well, I take it for granted that he killed her--we must not mince
matters--about twelve o'clock; for after that hour, the servants told
Lina, there was quiet in the drawing-room. Next, I conjecture, he went
upstairs to change his clothes: he could not go forth on the world in
an evening suit; and the housemaid says his black coat and trousers were
lying as usual on a chair in his dressing-room--which shows at least
that he was not unduly flurried. After that, he put on another suit,
no doubt--WHAT suit I hope the police will not discover too soon; for
I suppose you must just accept the situation that we are conspiring to
defeat the ends of justice.”
“No, no!” Mrs. Mallet cried. “To bring him back voluntarily, that he may
face his trial like a man!”
“Yes, dear. That is quite right. However, the next thing, of course,
would be that he would shave in whole or in part. His big black beard
was so very conspicuous; he would certainly get rid of that before
attempting to escape. The servants being in bed, he was not pressed for
time; he had the whole night before him. So, of course, he shaved.
On the other hand, the police, you may be sure, will circulate his
photograph--we must not shirk these points”--for Mrs. Mallet winced
again--“will circulate his photograph, BEARD AND ALL; and that will
really be one of our great safeguards; for the bushy beard so masks the
face that, without it, Hugo would be scarcely recognisable. I conclude,
therefore, that he must have shorn himself BEFORE leaving home; though
naturally I did not make the police a present of the hint by getting
Lina to ask any questions in that direction of the housemaid.”
“You are probably right,” I answered. “But would he have a razor?”
“I was coming to that. No; certainly he would not. He had not shaved for
years. And they kept no men-servants; which makes it difficult for him
to borrow one from a sleeping man. So what he would do would doubtless
be to cut off his beard, or part of it, quite close, with a pair of
scissors, and then get himself properly shaved next morning in the first
country town he came to.”
“The first country town?”
“Certainly. That leads up to the next point. We must try to be cool and
collected.” She was quivering with suppressed emotion herself, as she
said it, but her soothing hand still lay on Mrs. Mallet's. “The next
thing is--he would leave London.”
“But not by rail, you say?”
“He is an intelligent man, and in the course of defending others has
thought about this matter. Why expose himself to the needless risk and
observation of a railway station? No; I saw at once what he would
do. Beyond doubt, he would cycle. He always wondered it was not done
oftener, under similar circumstances.”
“But has his bicycle gone?”
“Lina looked. It has not. I should have expected as much. I told her to
note that point very unobtrusively, so as to avoid giving the police the
clue. She saw the machine in the outer hall as usual.”
“He is too good a criminal lawyer to have dreamt of taking his own,”
Mrs. Mallet interposed, with another effort.
“But where could he have hired or bought one at that time of night?” I
exclaimed.
“Nowhere--without exciting the gravest suspicion. Therefore, I conclude,
he stopped in London for the night, sleeping at an hotel, without
luggage, and paying for his room in advance. It is frequently done, and
if he arrived late, very little notice would be taken of him. Big hotels
about the Strand, I am told, have always a dozen such casual bachelor
guests every evening.”
“And then?”
“And then, this morning, he would buy a new bicycle--a different make
from his own, at the nearest shop; would rig himself out, at
some ready-made tailor's, with a fresh tourist suit--probably
an ostentatiously tweedy bicycling suit; and, with that in his
luggage-carrier, would make straight on his machine for the country.
He could change in some copse, and bury his own clothes, avoiding the
blunders he has seen in others. Perhaps he might ride for the first
twenty or thirty miles out of London to some minor side-station, and
then go on by train towards his destination, quitting the rail again
at some unimportant point where the main west road crosses the Great
Western or the South-Western line.”
“Great Western or South-Western? Why those two in particular? Then, you
have settled in your own mind which direction he has taken?”
“Pretty well. I judge by analogy. Lina, your brother was brought up in
the West Country, was he not?”
Mrs. Mallet gave a weary nod. “In North Devon,” she answered; “on the
wild stretch of moor about Hartland and Clovelly.”
Hilda Wade seemed to collect herself. “Now, Mr. Le Geyt is essentially
a Celt--a Celt in temperament,” she went on; “he comes by origin and
ancestry from a rough, heather-clad country; he belongs to the moorland.
In other words, his type is the mountaineer's. But a mountaineer's
instinct in similar circumstances is--what? Why, to fly straight to his
native mountains. In an agony of terror, in an access of despair, when
all else fails, he strikes a bee-line for the hills he loves; rationally
or irrationally, he seems to think he can hide there. Hugo Le Geyt, with
his frank boyish nature, his great Devonian frame, is sure to have done
so. I know his mood. He has made for the West Country!”
“You are, right, Hilda,” Mrs. Mallet exclaimed, with conviction. “I'm
quite sure, from what I know of Hugo, that to go to the West would be
his first impulse.”
“And the Le Geyts are always governed by first impulses,” my
character-reader added.
She was quite correct. From the time we two were at Oxford together--I
as an undergraduate, he as a don--I had always noticed that marked trait
in my dear old friend's temperament.
After a short pause, Hilda broke the silence again. “The sea again; the
sea! The Le Geyts love the water. Was there any place on the sea where
he went much as a boy--any lonely place, I mean, in that North Devon
district?”
Mrs. Mallet reflected a moment. “Yes, there was a little bay--a mere
gap in high cliffs, with some fishermen's huts and a few yards
of beach--where he used to spend much of his holidays. It was a
weird-looking break in a grim sea-wall of dark-red rocks, where the tide
rose high, rolling in from the Atlantic.”
“The very thing! Has he visited it since he grew up?”
“To my knowledge, never.”
Hilda's voice had a ring of certainty. “Then THAT is where we shall find
him, dear! We must look there first. He is sure to revisit just such a
solitary spot by the sea when trouble overtakes him.”
Later in the evening, as we were walking home towards Nathaniel's
together, I asked Hilda why she had spoken throughout with such
unwavering confidence. “Oh, it was simple enough,” she answered. “There
were two things that helped me through, which I didn't like to mention
in detail before Lina. One was this: the Le Geyts have all of them an
instinctive horror of the sight of blood; therefore, they almost never
commit suicide by shooting themselves or cutting their throats. Marcus,
who shot himself in the gun-room, was an exception to both rules; he
never minded blood; he could cut up a deer. But Hugo refused to be a
doctor, because he could not stand the sight of an operation; and even
as a sportsman he never liked to pick up or handle the game he had shot
himself; he said it sickened him. He rushed from that room last night,
I feel sure, in a physical horror at the deed he had done; and by now
he is as far as he can get from London. The sight of his act drove him
away; not craven fear of an arrest. If the Le Geyts kill themselves--a
seafaring race on the whole--their impulse is to trust to water.”
“And the other thing?”
“Well, that was about the mountaineer's homing instinct. I have often
noticed it. I could give you fifty instances, only I didn't like to
speak of them before Lina. There was Williams, for example, the Dolgelly
man who killed a game-keeper at Petworth in a poaching affray; he was
taken on Cader Idris, skulking among rocks, a week later. Then there
was that unhappy young fellow, Mackinnon, who shot his sweetheart at
Leicester; he made, straight as the crow flies, for his home in the
Isle of Skye, and there drowned himself in familiar waters. Lindner, the
Tyrolese, again, who stabbed the American swindler at Monte Carlo,
was tracked after a few days to his native place, St. Valentin, in
the Zillerthal. It is always so. Mountaineers in distress fly to their
mountains. It is a part of their nostalgia. I know it from within, too:
if _I_ were in poor Hugo LeGeyt's place, what do you think I would do?
Why, hide myself at once in the greenest recesses of our Carnarvonshire
mountains.”
“What an extraordinary insight into character you have!” I cried.
“You seem to divine what everybody's action will be under given
circumstances.”
She paused, and held her parasol half poised in her hand. “Character
determines action,” she said, slowly, at last. “That is the secret
of the great novelists. They put themselves behind and within their
characters, and so make us feel that every act of their personages
is not only natural but even--given the conditions--inevitable.
We recognise that their story is the sole logical outcome of the
interaction of their dramatis personae. Now, _I_ am not a great
novelist; I cannot create and imagine characters and situations. But I
have something of the novelist's gift; I apply the same method to the
real life of the people around me. I try to throw myself into the person
of others, and to feel how their character will compel them to act in
each set of circumstances to which they may expose themselves.”
“In one word,” I said, “you are a psychologist.”
“A psychologist,” she assented; “I suppose so; and the police--well, the
police are not; they are at best but bungling materialists. They require
a CLUE. What need of a CLUE if you can interpret character?”
So certain was Hilda Wade of her conclusions, indeed, that Mrs. Mallet
begged me next day to take my holiday at once--which I could easily
do--and go down to the little bay in the Hartland district of which she
had spoken, in search of Hugo. I consented. She herself proposed to set
out quietly for Bideford, where she could be within easy reach of me, in
order to hear of my success or failure; while Hilda Wade, whose summer
vacation was to have begun in two days' time, offered to ask for an
extra day's leave so as to accompany her. The broken-hearted sister
accepted the offer; and, secrecy being above all things necessary,
we set off by different routes: the two women by Waterloo, myself by
Paddington.
We stopped that night at different hotels in Bideford; but next morning,
Hilda rode out on her bicycle, and accompanied me on mine for a mile or
two along the tortuous way towards Hartland. “Take nothing for granted,”
she said, as we parted; “and be prepared to find poor Hugo Le Geyt's
appearance greatly changed. He has eluded the police and their 'clues'
so far; therefore, I imagine he must have largely altered his dress and
exterior.”
“I will find him,” I answered, “if he is anywhere within twenty miles of
Hartland.”
She waved her hand to me in farewell. I rode on after she left me
towards the high promontory in front, the wildest and least-visited part
of North Devon. Torrents of rain had fallen during the night; the slimy
cart-ruts and cattle-tracks on the moor were brimming with water. It
was a lowering day. The clouds drifted low. Black peat-bogs filled the
hollows; grey stone homesteads, lonely and forbidding, stood out here
and there against the curved sky-line. Even the high road was uneven and
in places flooded. For an hour I passed hardly a soul. At last, near a
crossroad with a defaced finger-post, I descended from my machine, and
consulted my ordnance map, on which Mrs. Mallet had marked ominously,
with a cross of red rink, the exact position of the little fishing
hamlet where Hugo used to spend his holidays. I took the turning which
seemed to me most likely to lead to it; but the tracks were so confused,
and the run of the lanes so uncertain--let alone the map being some
years out of date--that I soon felt I had lost my bearings. By a little
wayside inn, half hidden in a deep combe, with bog on every side, I
descended and asked for a bottle of ginger-beer; for the day was hot and
close, in spite of the packed clouds. As they were opening the bottle, I
inquired casually the way to the Red Gap bathing-place.
The landlord gave me directions which confused me worse than ever,
ending at last with the concise remark: “An' then, zur, two or dree more
turns to the right an' to the left 'ull bring 'ee right up alongzide o'
ut.”
I despaired of finding the way by these unintelligible sailing-orders;
but just at that moment, as luck would have it, another cyclist flew
past--the first soul I had seen on the road that morning. He was a man
with the loose-knit air of a shop assistant, badly got up in a
rather loud and obtrusive tourist suit of brown homespun, with baggy
knickerbockers and thin thread stockings. I judged him a gentleman on
the cheap at sight. “Very Stylish; this Suit Complete, only thirty-seven
and sixpence!” The landlady glanced out at him with a friendly nod. He
turned and smiled at her, but did not see me; for I stood in the shade
behind the half-open door. He had a short black moustache and a not
unpleasing, careless face. His features, I thought, were better than his
garments.
However, the stranger did not interest me just then I was far too full
of more important matters. “Why don't 'ee taake an' vollow thik ther
gen'leman, zur?” the landlady said, pointing one large red hand after
him. “Ur do go down to Urd Gap to zwim every marnin'. Mr. Jan Smith, o'
Oxford, they do call un. 'Ee can't go wrong if 'ee do vollow un to the
Gap. Ur's lodgin' up to wold Varmer Moore's, an' ur's that vond o' the
zay, the vishermen do tell me, as wasn't never any gen'leman like un.”
I tossed off my ginger-beer, jumped on to my machine, and followed
the retreating brown back of Mr. John Smith, of Oxford--surely a most
non-committing name--round sharp corners and over rutty lanes, tire-deep
in mud, across the rusty-red moor, till, all at once, at a turn, a gap
of stormy sea appeared wedge-shape between two shelving rock-walls.
It was a lonely spot. Rocks hemmed it in; big breakers walled it. The
sou'-wester roared through the gap. I rode down among loose stones and
water-worn channels in the solid grit very carefully. But the man in
brown had torn over the wild path with reckless haste, zigzagging madly,
and was now on the little three-cornered patch of beach, undressing
himself with a sort of careless glee, and flinging his clothes down
anyhow on the shingle beside him. Something about the action caught my
eye. That movement of the arm! It was not--it could not be--no, no, not
Hugo!
A very ordinary person; and Le Geyt bore the stamp of a born gentleman.
He stood up bare at last. He flung out his arms, as if to welcome
the boisterous wind to his naked bosom. Then, with a sudden burst of
recognition, the man stood revealed. We had bathed together a hundred
times in London and elsewhere. The face, the clad figure, the dress, all
were different. But the body--the actual frame and make of the man--the
well-knit limbs, the splendid trunk--no disguise could alter. It was Le
Geyt himself--big, powerful, vigorous.
That ill-made suit, those baggy knickerbockers, the slouched cap, the
thin thread stockings, had only distorted and hidden his figure. Now
that I saw him as he was, he came out the same bold and manly form as
ever.
He did not notice me. He rushed down with a certain wild joy into the
turbulent water, and, plunging in with a loud cry, buffeted the huge
waves with those strong curving arms of his. The sou'-wester was rising.
Each breaker as it reared caught him on its crest and tumbled him over
like a cork, but like a cork he rose again. He was swimming now, arm
over arm, straight out seaward. I saw the lifted hands between the crest
and the trough. For a moment I hesitated whether I ought to strip
and follow him. Was he doing as so many others of his house had
done--courting death from the water?
But some strange hand restrained me. Who was I that I should stand
between Hugo Le Geyt and the ways of Providence?
The Le Geyts loved ever the ordeal by water.
Presently, he turned again. Before he turned, I had taken the
opportunity to look hastily at his clothes. Hilda Wade had surmised
aright once more. The outer suit was a cheap affair from a big
ready-made tailor's in St. Martin's Lane--turned out by the thousand;
the underclothing, on the other hand, was new and unmarked, but fine
in quality--bought, no doubt, at Bideford. An eerie sense of doom stole
over me. I felt the end was near. I withdrew behind a big rock, and
waited there unseen till Hugo had landed. He began to dress again,
without troubling to dry himself. I drew a deep breath of relief. Then
this was not suicide!
By the time he had pulled on his vest and drawers, I came out suddenly
from my ambush and faced him. A fresh shock awaited me. I could hardly
believe my eyes. It was NOT Le Geyt--no, nor anything like him!
Nevertheless, the man rose with a little cry and advanced, half
crouching, towards me. “YOU are not hunting me down--with the police?”
he exclaimed, his neck held low and his forehead wrinkling.
The voice--the voice was Le Geyt's. It was an unspeakable mystery.
“Hugo,” I cried, “dear Hugo--hunting you down?--COULD you imagine it?”
He raised his head, strode forward, and grasped my hand. “Forgive me,
Cumberledge,” he cried. “But a proscribed and hounded man! If you knew
what a relief it is to me to get out on the water!”
“You forget all there?”
“I forget IT--the red horror!”
“You meant just now to drown yourself?”
“No! If I had meant it I would have done it.... Hubert, for my
children's sake, I WILL not commit suicide!”
“Then listen!” I cried. I told him in a few words of his sister's
scheme--Sebastian's defence--the plausibility of the explanation--the
whole long story. He gazed at me moodily. Yet it was not Hugo!
“No, no,” he said, shortly; and as he spoke it was HE. “I have done it;
I have killed her; I will not owe my life to a falsehood.”
“Not for the children's sake?”
He dashed his hand down impatiently. “I have a better way for the
children. I will save them still.... Hubert, you are not afraid to speak
to a murderer?”
“Dear Hugo--I know all; and to know all is to forgive all.”
He grasped my hand once more. “Know ALL!” he cried, with a despairing
gesture. “Oh, no; no one knows ALL but myself; not even the children.
But the children know much; THEY will forgive me. Lina knows something;
SHE will forgive me. You know a little; YOU forgive me. The world can
never know. It will brand my darlings as a murderer's children.”
“It was the act of a minute,” I interposed. “And--though she is dead,
poor lady, and one must speak no ill of her--we can at least gather
dimly, for your children's sake, how deep was the provocation.”
He gazed at me fixedly. His voice was like lead. “For the children's
sake--yes,” he answered, as in a dream. “It was all for the children! I
have killed her--murdered her--she has paid her penalty; and, poor dead
soul, I will utter no word against her--the woman I have murdered! But
one thing I will say: If omniscient justice sends me for this to eternal
punishment, I can endure it gladly, like a man, knowing that so I have
redeemed my Marian's motherless girls from a deadly tyranny.”
It was the only sentence in which he ever alluded to her.
I sat down by his side and watched him closely. Mechanically,
methodically, he went on with his dressing. The more he dressed,
the less could I believe it was Hugo. I had expected to find him
close-shaven; so did the police, by their printed notices. Instead
of that, he had shaved his beard and whiskers, but only trimmed his
moustache; trimmed it quite short, so as to reveal the boyish corners
of the mouth--a trick which entirely altered his rugged expression.
But that was not all; what puzzled me most was the eyes--they were not
Hugo's. At first I could not imagine why. By degrees the truth dawned
upon me. His eyebrows were naturally thick and shaggy--great overhanging
growth, interspersed with many of those stiff long hairs to which Darwin
called attention in certain men as surviving traits from a monkey-like
ancestor. In order to disguise himself, Hugo had pulled out all these
coarser hairs, leaving nothing on his brows but the soft and closely
pressed coat of down which underlies the longer bristles in all such
cases. This had wholly altered the expression of the eyes, which no
longer looked out keenly from their cavernous penthouse; but being
deprived of their relief, had acquired a much more ordinary and less
individual aspect. From a good-natured but shaggy giant, my old friend
was transformed by his shaving and his costume into a well-fed and
well-grown, but not very colossal, commercial gentleman. Hugo was
scarcely six feet high, indeed, though by his broad shoulders and bushy
beard he had always impressed one with such a sense of size; and now
that the hirsuteness had been got rid of, and the dress altered, he
hardly struck one as taller or bigger than the average of his fellows.
We sat for some minutes and talked. Le Geyt would not speak of Clara;
and when I asked him his intentions, he shook his head moodily. “I shall
act for the best,” he said--“what of best is left--to guard the dear
children. It was a terrible price to pay for their redemption; but it
was the only one possible, and, in a moment of wrath, I paid it. Now, I
have to pay, in turn, myself. I do not shirk it.”
“You will come back to London, then, and stand your trial?” I asked,
eagerly.
“Come back TO LONDON?” he cried, with a face of white panic. Hitherto
he had seemed to me rather relieved in expression than otherwise;
his countenance had lost its worn and anxious look; he was no longer
watching each moment over his children's safety. “Come back... TO
LONDON... and face my trial! Why, did you think, Hubert, 'twas the court
or the hanging I was shirking? No, no; not that; but IT--the red horror!
I must get away from IT to the sea--to the water--to wash away the
stain--as far from IT--that red pool--as possible!”
I answered nothing. I left him to face his own remorse in silence.
At last he rose to go, and held one foot undecided on his bicycle.
“I leave myself in Heaven's hands,” he said, as he lingered. “IT will
requite.... The ordeal is by water.”
“So I judged,” I answered.
“Tell Lina this from me,” he went on, still loitering: “that if she will
trust me, I will strive to do the best that remains for my darlings. I
will do it, Heaven helping. She will know WHAT, to-morrow.”
He mounted his machine and sailed off. My eyes followed him up the path
with sad forebodings.
All day long I loitered about the Gap. It consisted of two bays--the one
I had already seen, and another, divided from it by a saw-edge of rock.
In the further cove crouched a few low stone cottages. A broad-bottomed
sailing boat lay there, pulled up high on the beach. About three
o'clock, as I sat and watched, two men began to launch it. The sea ran
high; tide coming in; the sou'-wester still increasing in force to a
gale; at the signal-staff on the cliff, the danger-cone was hoisted.
White spray danced in air. Big black clouds rolled up seething from
windward; low thunder rumbling; a storm threatened.
One of the men was Le Geyt, the other a fisherman.
He jumped in, and put off through the surf with an air of triumph. He
was a splendid sailor. His boat leapt through the breakers and flew
before the wind with a mere rag of canvas. “Dangerous weather to be
out!” I exclaimed to the fisherman, who stood with hands buried in his
pockets, watching him.
“Ay that ur be, zur!” the man answered. “Doan't like the look o' ut. But
thik there gen'leman, 'ee's one o' Oxford, 'ee do tell me; and they'm a
main venturesome lot, they college volk. 'Ee's off by 'isself droo the
starm, all so var as Lundy!”
“Will he reach it?” I asked, anxiously, having my own idea on the
subject.
“Doan't seem like ut, zur, do ut? Ur must, an' ur mustn't, an' yit again
ur must. Powerful 'ard place ur be to maake in a starm, to be zure,
Lundy. Zaid the Lord 'ould dezide. But ur 'ouldn't be warned, ur
'ouldn't; an' voolhardy volk, as the zayin' is, must go their own
voolhardy waay to perdition!”
It was the last I saw of Le Geyt alive. Next morning the lifeless body
of “the man who was wanted for the Campden Hill mystery” was cast up by
the waves on the shore of Lundy. The Lord had decided.
Hugo had not miscalculated. “Luck in their suicides,” Hilda Wade said;
and, strange to say, the luck of the Le Geyts stood him in good
stead still. By a miracle of fate, his children were not branded as
a murderer's daughters. Sebastian gave evidence at the inquest on the
wife's body: “Self-inflicted--a recoil--accidental--I am SURE of it.”
His specialist knowledge--his assertive certainty, combined with that
arrogant, masterful manner of his, and his keen, eagle eye, overbore the
jury. Awed by the great man's look, they brought in a submissive
verdict of “Death by misadventure.” The coroner thought it a most proper
finding. Mrs. Mallet had made the most of the innate Le Geyt horror
of blood. The newspapers charitably surmised that the unhappy husband,
crazed by the instantaneous unexpectedness of his loss, had wandered
away like a madman to the scenes of his childhood, and had there been
drowned by accident while trying to cross a stormy sea to Lundy, under
some wild impression that he would find his dead wife alive on the
island. Nobody whispered MURDER. Everybody dwelt on the utter absence of
motive--a model husband!--such a charming young wife, and such a devoted
stepmother. We three alone knew--we three, and the children.
On the day when the jury brought in their verdict at the adjourned
inquest on Mrs. Le Geyt, Hilda Wade stood in the room, trembling and
white-faced, awaiting their decision. When the foreman uttered the
words, “Death by misadventure,” she burst into tears of relief. “He did
well!” she cried to me, passionately. “He did well, that poor father! He
placed his life in the hands of his Maker, asking only for mercy to his
innocent children. And mercy has been shown to him and to them. He was
taken gently in the way he wished. It would have broken my heart for
those two poor girls if the verdict had gone otherwise. He knew how
terrible a lot it is to be called a murderer's daughter.”
I did not realise at the time with what profound depth of personal
feeling she said it.