A French Rejoinder

In the Revue des Deux Mondes (Paris), of which he is managing editor,

M. Francis Charmes, of the Academie Francaise, replies to a speech

made by von Bethmann-Hollweg before the Reichstag, in which the German

Chancellor expressed sympathy for the deluded French soldiers, who

had not an inkling of the true course which the war was taking. M.

Charmes ironically remarks:

We do not publish, he [von Bethmann-Hollweg] claims, any of

the German dispatches, so that opinion is quite

unenlightened as to what is actually happening on the field

of battle.

One would think, according to M. de Bethmann-Hollweg, that

the German dispatches are a source on which one can rely

with full confidence, and one would imagine, too, since he

had thus reproached us, that the German newspapers published

the French dispatches.

As a matter of fact, they do not and if it is necessary to

hear both sides to know the truth then the Germans are quite

ignorant of it. They are indeed very far removed from

knowing it, and it is a constant surprise to our officers

and our soldiers to discover when they question their

prisoners, the profound illusions under which they labor.

New York Times Current History; The European War, Vol 2, No. 5, August, 1915 · 第 241 / 310 题