SUMMARY AND CONCLUSIONS
The positions reached in this study may be gathered up in a few brief
statements:
1. Matthew and Luke depend for the structure of their Gospels, and for
practically all of their narrative material, upon Mark.
2. In the order of Marcan material, Matthew and Luke have made such
changes as were desirable from the use to which they wished to put this
matter. Matthew has made fewer omissions, Luke fewer transpositions.
3. The changes which Matthew and Luke have made in the substance or
wording of the Marcan material, including their omissions from it, may be
accounted for by a desire to produce a better literary form, to avoid
statements that offended the growing sentiment of the church, and to adapt
their own narrative to their own public. Some changes must go unaccounted
for.
4. The hypothesis of a more primitive form of Mark in the hands of Matthew
and Luke is not demanded by the facts. Matthew and Luke used substantially
our Mark.
5. Matthew and Luke also used a document Q, whose content, within limits,
is well agreed upon.
6. Various facts, especially translation variants, require the assumption
that this Q was originally an Aramaic document, used by Matthew and Luke
respectively, in two Greek translations that went back to two different
Aramaic texts.[138]
7. This furnishes the clue for the analysis of Q into QMt and QLk, and for
the assignment to these two recensions of Q of much material which has
hitherto been assigned to unknown sources.
8. Mark has some literary dependence upon Q; but the Q which he knew was
an earlier form than those in the hands of Matthew and Luke.
9. The original order of Q is best seen in the order of the Q material
preserved in Luke.
INDEXES
I. PASSAGES CITED
MARK:
i, 7-8, p. 237.
i, 9-11, pp. 37, 237-38.
i, 12-13, p. 238.
i, 16-20, 21-28, pp. 38, 95.
i, 29-31, pp. 38.
i, 32, p. 100.
i, 32-34, p. 39.
i, 35-38, pp. 39-40.
i, 40-45, p. 41.
ii, 1-12, pp. 41-42.
ii, 9-10, p. 93.
ii, 13-22, p. 42.
ii, 23-28, p. 43.
ii, 25-26, p. 94.
iii, 1-19, pp. 44-45.
iii, 7-8, p. 101.
iii, 20-30, pp. 45, 72-73.
iii, 20-29, pp. 238-39.
iii, 31-iv, 12, p. 45.
iv, 1-33, p. 77.
iv, 13-20, p. 46.
iv, 21-25, p. 47.
iv, 24-25, p. 239.
iv, 30-32, pp. 47, 240.
iv, 35-41, pp. 47-48.
v, 1-20, pp. 48-49.
v. 21-43, pp. 49-50, 72.
vi, 1-6, p. 51.
vi, 6-13, pp. 51-52.
vi, 7-11, p. 241.
vi, 14-16, pp. 52-53.
vi, 17-29, pp. 53-54.
vi, 30-44, pp. 54-55.
vi, 45-52, pp. 55-56.
vi, 45-viii, 26, pp. 92-93.
vi, 53-56, p. 56.
vii, 1-23, pp. 56-57.
vii, 24-30, p. 57.
vii, 32-37, p. 74.
viii, 1-21, p. 57.
viii, 12, p. 241.
viii, 22-26, p. 74.
viii, 27-33, p. 58.
viii, 34-35, pp. 241-42.
viii, 34-ix, 1, pp. 58-59.
viii, 38, p. 242.
ix, 2-13, 59.
ix, 11-13, p. 73.
ix, 14-32, pp. 60-61.
ix, 33-48, p. 61.
ix, 42-48, p. 242.
ix, 49-50, p. 243.
x, 11-12, pp. 61, 243.
x, 13-45, p. 62.
x, 29, pp. 101-2.
x, 31, p. 243.
x, 43-44, p. 244.
x, 46-52, p. 63.
xi, 1-11, p. 63.
xi, 12-14, p. 64.
xi, 20-25, p. 64.
xi, 23, p. 244.
xii, 1-12, p. 65.
xii, 3, pp. 102-3.
xii, 18-27, p. 65.
xii, 28-40, p. 66.
xii, 38-40, p. 244.
xiii, 9-20, p. 66.
xiii, 11, p. 244.
xiii, 24-32, p. 67.
xiv, 1, p. 103.
xiv, 3-9, p. 73.
xiv, 12, pp. 104-5.
xiv, 22-25, p. 68.
xiv, 25, p. 73.
xiv, 28, p. 73.
xiv, 32-54, p. 68.
xiv, 58, p. 73.
xiv, 66-72, p. 69.
xv, 21-32, p. 69.
xv, 42, p. 105.
MATTHEW:
iii, 7-10, p. 129.
iii, 11-12, p. 130.
iii, 13-17, p. 37.
iv, 3-11, pp. 130-31.
iv, 18-22, pp. 38, 95-96.
iv, 25, p. 101.
v, 3, p. 131.
v, 4-5, p. 167.
v, 5-6, p. 132.
v, 7-10, pp. 167-68.
v, 11-13, pp. 132-33.
v, 14, p. 169.
v, 15, pp. 47, 133-34.
v, 16, p. 169.
v, 17, 19-24, 27-28, pp. 170-71.
v, 18, p. 135.
v, 25-26, p. 135.
v, 29-30, p. 171.
v, 31, pp. 171-72.
v, 31-32, p. 61.
v, 33-37, p. 172.
v, 39-40, pp. 135-36.
v, 41, p. 172.
v, 43, p. 173.
v, 44-48, pp. 135-36.
vi, 1-4, pp. 173-74.
vi, 5-8, p. 174.
vi, 9-13, p. 136.
vi, 16-18, p. 175.
vi, 19-23, p. 137.
vi. 24-33, p. 138.
vii, 1-5, p. 139.
vii, 6, pp. 175-76.
vii, 7-11, pp. 139-40.
vii, 12-14, p. 140.
vii, 15, p. 176.
vii, 16-18, p. 141.
vii, 19-20, p. 177.
vii, 21-23, pp. 141-42.
vii, 24-27, p. 143.
vii, 28, pp. 177-78.
vii, 28-29, p. 38.
viii, 1-4, p. 41.
viii, 5-10, pp. 143-45.
viii, 11-12, pp. 145-46.
viii, 13, pp. 178-79.
viii, 14-15, pp. 38-39.
viii, 16, p. 100.
viii, 16-17, p. 39.
viii, 19-22, p. 146.
ix, 1-8, p. 41.
ix, 5-6, pp. 93-94.
ix, 9-13, p. 42.
ix, 13, p. 179.
ix, 14-17, p. 42.
ix, 18-26, pp. 49-50.
ix, 27-31, p. 179.
ix, 32-34, p. 180.
ix, 35, pp. 51-52.
ix, 37-38, p. 146.
x, 2-4, pp. 44-45.
x, 5-8, p. 180.
x, 10-13, pp. 146-47.
x, 15, p. 147.
x, 16, p. 148.
x, 16-25, pp. 180-81.
x, 19-20, p. 148.
x, 24-25, p. 148.
x, 26-33, pp. 149-50.
x, 34-36, p. 150.
x, 37-39, pp. 150-51.
x, 40, p. 151.
x, 41-42, pp. 180-81.
xi, 2-27, p. 152.
xi, 14, p. 181.
xi, 15, p. 182.
xi, 20, p. 182.
xi, 23-24, pp. 182-83.
xi, 28-30, p. 183.
xii, 1-8, p. 43.
xii, 3-4, p. 94.
xii, 5-7, p. 184.
xii, 9-21, p. 44.
xii, 17-21, p. 184.
xii, 22-37, p. 45.
xii, 27-28, p. 153.
xii, 30, p. 153.
xii, 34, p. 184.
xii, 36-37, p. 185.
xii, 38-42, p. 153.
xii, 40, p. 185.
xii, 43-45, p. 154.
xiii, 16-33, p. 154.
xiii, 18-23, p. 46.
xiii, 24-30, p. 185.
xiii, 44-52, pp. 186-87.
xiii, 53-58, p. 51.
xiv, 1-2, pp. 52-53.
xiv, 3-12, pp. 53-54.
xiv, 13-21, pp. 54-55.
xiv, 22-33, pp. 55-56.
xiv, 28-31, p. 187.
xiv, 34-36, p. 56.
xv, 1-20, p. 56.
xv, 14, p. 155.
xv, 21-28, p. 57.
xv, 22-24, pp. 187-88.
xv, 29-31, pp. 188-89.
xv, 32-39, p. 57.
xvi, 1-12, p. 57.
xvi, 13-23, p. 58.
xvi, 17-19, p. 189.
xvi, 24-28, pp. 58-59.
xvii, 1-8, p. 59.
xvii, 6-7, p. 189.
xvii, 9-13, p. 59.
xvii, 14-23, p. 60.
xviii, 1-5, p. 61.
xviii, 4, pp. 189-90.
xviii, 6-9, p. 61.
xviii, 7, p. 156.
xviii, 12-14, p. 156.
xviii, 21-22, p. 157.
xviii, 23-35, p. 190.
xix, 10-12, p. 190.
xix, 13-15, p. 62.
xix, 16-30, p. 62.
xix, 28, p. 157.
xix, 29, p. 101.
xx, 1-16, p. 190.
xx, 17-28, p. 62.
xx, 29-34, p. 63.
xxi, 1-11, p. 63.
xxi, 18-27, p. 64.
xxi, 33-46, p. 65.
xxi, 28-32, p. 191.
xxi, 35, p. 102.
xxii, 1-14, p. 191.
xxii, 34-40, p. 66.
xxii, 41-46, p. 66.
xxiii, 2-3, p. 191.
xxiii, 4, pp. 157-58.
xxiii, 5, 8-10, p. 191.
xxiii, 12-13, p. 158.
xxiii, 15-22, p. 191.
xxiii, 23-26, p. 159.
xxiii, 29-31, p. 159.
xxiii, 34-36, p. 160.
xxiii, 37-39, p. 161.
xxiv, 9-22, p. 66.
xxiv, 26-28, p. 161.
xxiv, 34-36, p. 67.
xxiv, 37-39, pp. 161-62.
xxiv, 40-41, p. 162.
xxiv, 43-51, p. 162.
xxv, 1-46, pp. 191-92.
xxvi, 2, p. 103.
xxvi, 17, p. 104.
xxvi, 26-29, p. 68.
xxvi, 36-58, p. 68.
xxvi, 52-54, p. 192.
xxvi, 67-68, pp. 104-5.
xxvi, 69-75, p. 69.
xxvii, 32-44, p. 69.
xxvii, 57, p. 105.
LUKE:
iii, 7-9, p. 129.
iii, 10-14, p. 193.
iii, 16-17, p. 130.
iii, 21-22, p. 37.
iv, 3-13, p. 130.
iv, 16-30, pp. 51, 194.
iv, 31-39, p. 38.
iv, 40, p. 100.
iv, 40-43, p. 39.
v, 1-11, pp. 38, 40.
v, 12-26, p. 41.
v, 23-24, pp. 93-94.
v, 27-39, p. 42.
vi, 1-5, p. 43.
vi, 3-4, p. 94.
vi, 6-19, p. 44.
vi, 17, p. 101.
vi, 20, p. 131.
vi, 21, p. 132.
vi, 22-23, pp. 132-33.
vi, 24-26, pp. 194-95.
vi, 27-30, 32-36, p. 135.
vi, 31, p. 140.
vi, 37-38, p. 139.
vi, 38, p. 47.
vi, 39, p. 155.
vi, 40, p. 148.
vi, 43-44, p. 141.
vi, 47-49, p. 143.
vii, 1-9, pp. 143-45.
vii, 18-35, p. 152.
vii, 29-30, p. 195.
vii, 36-50, p. 195.
vii, 41-42, p. 139.
viii, 4-10, p. 45.
viii, 11-15, p. 46.
viii, 16-18, p. 47.
viii, 19-21, p. 45.
viii, 22-25, p. 47.
viii, 26-39, pp. 48-49.
viii, 40-56, pp. 49-50.
ix, 1-6, pp. 51-52.
ix, 7-9, pp. 52-53.
ix, 10-17, pp. 54-55.
ix, 18-22, p. 58.
ix, 23-27, p. 58-59.
ix, 28-36, p. 59.
ix, 37-45, p. 60.
ix, 46-50, p. 61.
ix, 57-60, p. 146.
ix, 60-63, p. 196.
x, 2, p. 146.
x, 3, p. 148.
x, 5-8, p. 147.
x, 12, p. 147.
x, 13-15, p. 152.
x, 16, p. 151.
x, 17-20, p. 196.
x, 21-22, p. 152.
x, 23-24, p. 154.
x, 25-28, pp. 66, 197.
x, 29-37, p. 197.
x, 38-42, p. 197.
xi, 2-4, pp. 136-37.
xi, 5-8, p. 198.
xi, 9-13, pp. 139-40.
xi, 14-23, p. 45.
xi, 19-20, p. 153.
xi, 23, p. 153.
xi, 24-26, p. 154.
xi, 27-28, p. 198.
xi, 29-32, p. 153.
xi, 33, pp. 133-34.
xi, 34-35, pp. 137-38.
xi, 36, p. 198.
xi, 39-42, p. 159.
xi, 47-48, p. 159.
xi, 49-51, p. 160.
xii, 2-9, p. 149.
xii, 11-12, p. 148.
xii, 13-21, p. 198.
xii, 22-31, p. 138.
xii, 33-34, p. 137.
xii, 35-38, p. 198.
xii, 39-40, p. 162.
xii, 42-46, p. 162.
xii, 47-50, p. 199.
xii, 51-53, p. 150.
xii, 58-59, p. 135.
xiii, 1-5, p. 199.
xiii, 6-9, p. 200.
xiii, 18-19, p. 47.
xiii, 20-21, p. 154.
xiii, 23-24, p. 140.
xiii, 26-27, pp. 141-42.
xiii, 28-29, pp. 145-46.
xiii, 31-33, pp. 200-201.
xiii, 34-35, p. 161.
xiv, 1-6, p. 201.
xiv, 7-11, pp. 201-2.
xiv, 11, p. 158.
xiv, 12-24, p. 202.
xiv, 26-27, pp. 150-51.
xiv, 28-35, p. 203.
xiv, 34, p. 133.
xv, 1-7, p. 203.
xv, 4-7, p. 156.
xv, 8-32, p. 203.
xvi, 18, p. 61.
xvi, 1-12, pp. 203-4.
xvi, 14-15, p. 204.
xvi, 17, p. 135.
xvi, 19-31, p. 205.
xvii, 1, p. 156.
xvii, 1-2, p. 61.
xvii, 4, p. 157.
xvii, 6, p. 155.
xvii, 7-19, p. 205.
xvii, 9-13, p. 59.
xvii, 20-21, pp. 205-6.
xvii, 23-24, 26-27, p. 161.
xvii, 26-27, p. 161.
xvii, 33, pp. 150-51.
xvii, 34-35, p. 162.
xvii, 37, p. 161.
xviii, 15-17, p. 62.
xviii, 18-30, p. 62.
xviii, 29, p. 101.
xviii, 31-34, p. 62.
xviii, 35-43, p. 63.
xix, 28-38, p. 63.
xx, 1-8, p. 64.
xx, 9-19, p. 65.
xx, 10, p. 102.
xx, 27-40, p. 65.
xx, 45-47, p. 66.
xxi, 12-24, pp. 66-67.
xxi, 32-33, p. 67.
xxii, 1, pp. 103-4.
xxii, 7, p. 104.
xxii, 15-20, p. 68.
xxii, 28-30, p. 157.
xxii, 39-55, p. 68.
xxii, 56-62, p. 69.
xxiii, 26-43, p. 69.
xxiii, 54, pp. 105-6.
II. GENERAL INDEX
Abbott, E. A., 90.
Angels, twelve legions of, 192.
Arrest of Jesus, 68.
Assimilation, 91, 92, 242.
Authority of Jesus questioned, 64-65.
Bacon. B. W., 65, 108, 173, 234.
Bartimeus, 63.
Bartlet, J. V., 60, 108, 212.
Beatitudes, 131-32.
Beelzebul controversy, 238-39.
Birt, 36.
Blessing of the children, 62.
Blind leaders, 155.
Brotherhood of Jesus, 45.
Burkitt, F. C., 109, 112, 206.
Burton, 144, 217.
Calling of the first disciples, 38.
Canaanitish woman, 57.
Care, 138.
Centurion's son, 143-45, 178-79.
Changes of Matthew and Luke in Marcan narratives, chap. iv.
Changes of Matthew and Luke in Marcan order, Table I, 24-27.
"Come unto me," 183.
Conflation, 191, 240.
Crucifixion, 69.
Danger of riches, 62.
Dependence of Luke upon Matthew, 98, 99.
Dependence of Matthew upon Luke impossible, 98.
Detached sayings, 47.
Disciples, instructions to, 146-51, 180-81.
Disciples, mission of, 51-52.
Disciples, return of, 54-55.
Discipleship, demands of, 58.
Distress, predictions of, 66-67.
Doublets, 190, 239, 241-45.
Elijah, 59.
Entry into Jerusalem, 63-64.
Epileptic boy, 60.
Evil husbandmen, 65.
Feeding of the five thousand, 54-55.
Feeding of the four thousand, 57.
Fig tree cursed, 64.
Gadarene demoniac, 48, 49.
Genealogies, 98.
Gennesaret, 56.
Gethsemane, 68.
Golden Rule, 140.
Goodspeed, E. J., 72.
Great Commandment, 66, 197.
Great Omission of Luke, 35, 92, 93.
Harnack, Adolf, 37, 110, 111, 112, 114, 115.
--, On content of Q, 108-19 _passim_, 126, 142, 165, 178, 191, 212, 234,
247.
Hawkins, Sir John, VI, 9, 15, 16, 33, 58, 67, 70, 84, 85, 110, 111, 112,
114.
-- on content of Q, 108-19 _passim_, 164, 165, 170, 191, 208, 211, 247.
Healings in the evening, 39.
Herod, judgment concerning Jesus, 52-53.
Historic present in Mark, 85.
Holtzmann, J. H., 214.
Huck, Adolph, v.
Infancy section:
in Luke, 211;
in Matthew, 208.
Jairus' daughter, 49-50.
Jerusalem, lament over, 161.
Jerusalem narrative, 10.
Jerusalem tradition, 199-200.
John the Baptist:
death of, 53;
preaching of, 129;
preaching of, in Luke, 193.
Jonah, 153, 185.
Judaistic features in Matthew, 167, 168, 170, 172, 176, 180, 188.
Jülicher, Adolf, 73, 125, 194, 211.
Kingdom of Heaven, eschatalogical meaning of, 166.
Last Supper, 68.
Leper healed, 41.
Logia, 97.
Loisy, A., 73, 183.
Lord's Prayer, 136-37.
Lost Sheep, parable of, 156.
Luke's Great Interpolation, 8-9.
Luke's Great Omission, 7, 8, 227-228.
Luke:
matter peculiar to, 207, 210-18;
single tradition of, 206-7;
source peculiar to, 217-18.
Mark:
his use of Q, 234-48;
framework of, in Matthew and Luke, 3-13;
words peculiar to, 85-87.
Matthew, matter peculiar to, 207-10;
not a source for Luke, Robinson Smith's argument on, 100-107;
single tradition of, 206;
tendency to condensation, 189;
messianic proclamation of, 130.
Montefiore, C. G., 183.
Motives of Matthew and Luke, 70, 71.
Mustard Seed, parable of, 47.
Narrow gate, parable cf, 140.
Nazareth, preaching in, 51.
Offences, 61.
Omission of Marcan material by both Matthew and Luke, 30, 31.
Omissions of Luke, 32-36.
Order, deviations in, chap. ii.
Order of narratives of the Synoptics, chap. ii.
Oxford Studies, vi.
Parable of the Sower, 45;
interpretation of, 46;
of Treasure, Pearl, Fish-net, Converted Scribe, 186-87.
Parables peculiar to Luke, 197, 198, 200, 202, 203, 205.
Parables, purpose of, 45.
Paralytic healed, 41.
Parousia, 67, 180.
Passion narrative, 12, 13.
Perean source, 214-17.
Peter:
calling of, 40, 194;
confession of messiahship, 58;
denial of, 69.
Peter's mother-in-law, 38.
Petrine strand in Mark, 75-76, 83-84.
Pharisaic accusation, 45.
Pharisees, 66, 153, 158, 159, 204.
Prediction of sufferings, 58, 60, 62.
Primary and secondary elements in Mark:
according to von Soden, 74-77;
according to Wendling, 74-87.
Primary and secondary traits, 187, 188;
in Mark and Q, 235;
in Luke, 200;
priority of, 3-16.
Q:
existence and content of, 108-20;
analysis of, by Wellhausen, Wernle, Weiss, Hawkins, and Harnack, 112;
distribution of, in Matthew, 112-13;
Mark, overlapping of, 114;
general agreement as to nucleus in Matthew, 114-15;
in Luke, content according to Wellhausen, Wernle, Weiss, Hawkins, and
Harnack, 116-19;
distribution of in Luke, 119;
necessity for further extension of, 120;
originally an Aramaic document, 123-25;
translation variance, 124, 125;
analysis into QMt and QLk, 126-65;
in single tradition of Luke, 193-220;
in single tradition of Matthew, 166-92;
original order of, 249-54.
QMt, QLk:
meaning of the symbols, 127;
advantages of the hypothesis, 219, 221-33.
Resistance and non-resistance, 135-36.
Retirement of Jesus, 39.
Ropes, J. H., 181.
Rördam, T. S., 72.
Sadducees, 65.
Sanday, W., 89, 212-13, 219, 234.
Sanders, H. A., 98.
Schmeidel, Paul, 46, 67, 73, 135, 139, 170, 175, 203.
Seats in the Kingdom, 62.
Secondary traits in Q, QMt, and QLk, 230-33.
Seeking and finding, 139.
Sermon on the Mount, sayings from, 133-43, 167-78.
Seventy, return of the, 196.
Sign demanded, 57.
Smith, Robinson, 100, 107 _passim_, 173.
Soden, von, H. H., 74-84 _passim_.
Special source of Luke, 197, 201, 202, 203;
meaning of, 192.
Stanton, V. H., 112, 171, 228.
Storm on the lake, 47.
Streeter, H. B., 114, 131, 180, 197, 198, 200, 202, 203, 204, 212, 234,
244, 253, 254.
Strife:
about rank, 61;
among relatives, 150.
Summary and conclusions, 255-56.
Synagogue at Capernaum, 38.
Tables:
I, order of Marcan material in Matthew and Luke, 24-27;
II, Q material in Matthew according to five scholars, 110, 111;
III, Q material in Luke according to five scholars, 116-17;
IV, Q material in Matthew, 222-23;
V, Q material in Luke, 224-25;
VI, Q material in Mark, 246;
VII and VIII, on relative order of Q matter in Matthew and Luke, 250;
IX, sections in Q material in their order in Matthew and Luke, 251;
X, sections in Q material, slightly rearranged in order, 252.
Temptation, 130;
in Mark and Q, 238.
Things that defile, 56-57.
Transfiguration, 59.
Translation variants, 240.
Transposition:
in Luke, 70;
in Mark, 72-74.
Tree and fruits, 141.
Twelve:
calling of the 44;
mission of, in Mark and Q, 241.
Two foundations, 143.
Unknown exorcist, 32, 61.
Ur-Marcus, 72, 88-93.
Verbal resemblance illustrated, 93-96.
Vocabulary in Mark and Q, 246-48.
Votaw, C. W., 173.
Widow's mite, 32.
Walk thru the corn, 43.
Walking on the sea, 55.
Weiss, B., 108.
Weiss, J., 46, 110, 111, 112.
-- on content of Q, 108-10 _passim_, 134, 191, 194.
Wellhausen, J., 37, 55, 73, 110, 111, 112, 115.
-- on content of Q, 108-19 _passim_, 133, 150, 183, 191, 198, 234, 240.
Wendling, E., 74-87, 228.
Wernle, Paul, vi, 32, 37, 65, 110, 111, 115.
-- on content of Q, 108-19 _passim_, 191, 198, 210, 234, 244, 245.
Westcott and Hort, 69.
Withered hand, 44.
Yeast, a saying about, 57.
FOOTNOTES:
[1] Mohr, Tübingen, 1906, 3d ed. A fourth edition of this valuable book
appeared in 1911, but without important changes.
[2] Cf. Sanders, _Journal of Biblical Literature_, XXXII, 184 ff., for
evidence that this did not stand in the original text of Luke.
[3] This statement may be questioned, as Lk xiii, 18-19 may be considered
parallel to Mk iv, 30-32. At all events Matthew has the passage with Mark.
The matter is complicated by the fact that the parable apparently stood in
both Mark and Q.
[4] Tho Lk xiv, 34_a_ is apparently taken from Mk ix, 50_a_, as against Mt
v, 13_a_.
[5] For discussion of Luke's non-use of Mark thruout the Great
Interpolation, see pp. 16-18; for an elaborate analysis of the sources of
the section, see Hawkins, _Oxford Studies in the Synoptic Problem_, pp.
29-59.
[6] see Hawkins, _Horae Synopticae_, pp. 139-41, for other instances.
[7] For an elaborate analysis of the sources of the material in the Great
Interpolation, see Hawkins, _Oxford Studies in the Synoptic Problem_, pp.
29-59.
[8] An apparent exception is Lk xiv, 34 = Mk ix, 50; no parallel in
Matthew. Lk xvii, 2 = Mk ix, 42, and Lk x, 27 = Mk xii, 30 should perhaps
be added, but are not so clear.
[9] Chapter and verse for each of these sections being given in the
tabulated arrangement of this same material on pp. 24-27, only such
references are given here as are necessary to help the reader to follow
the analysis at this point.
[10] We do not include here the omission of single words or phrases, or
even occasionally of an entire verse, where it is plain that this is in
the interest of some change or condensation.
[11] See especially the parable of the Weed in the Field (Mt xiii, 24-30),
the Mustard Seed (Mk iv, 30-32; Mt xiii, 31-32; Lk xiii, 18-19), the Sower
(Mt xiii, 1-9; Lk viii, 4-8).
[12] Wernle, _Synoptische Frage_, p. 126.
[13] Thruout this discussion I am greatly indebted to Wernle, as anyone
must be who has read his _Synoptische Frage_.
[14] Wernle includes among these the defense of Jesus in Mk iii, 23-30,
practically duplicated in Lk xi, 17-23. Why not a transposition, rather
than an omission? So considered here.
[15] Wernle, _op. cit._, p. 5.
[16] Yet not always. Cf. his two bands of teachers, his healing of ten
lepers and of one, his two disputes about priority among the disciples,
his three predictions of the passion and two of the resurrection. But cf.
his omission of anointing at Bethany, the barren fig tree, the mocking by
Pilate's soldiers, because of their duplications of his material already
used. See Hawkins, _op. cit._, 69.
[17] Matthew takes no offense at this; for he even adds to it, "I am not
sent except to the lost sheep of the house of Israel."
[18] Hawkins, _op. cit._, p. 71. It seems strange that Hawkins' discussion
of the "great omission" contains no reference to Wernle's treatment of the
same subject.
[19] Wernle, _op. cit._, p. 6.
[20] On the size of ancient books, see Sanday, _Oxford Studies_, pp.
25-26; cf. Birt, _Das antike Buchwesen_.
[21] For complete and detailed discussion, see Wernle, Wellhausen,
Harnack.
[22] See pp. 95-96, where the account of the call of the first disciples
is further discussed, and printed in heavy-faced type.
[23] P. 30; see also pp. 95-96, where the account of the calling of the
first disciples is printed in heavy-faced type and is further discussed.
[24] This latter is not the usual word for "bed," but means a _little_
bed--_some_ sort of bed.
[25] Agreement of Matthew and Luke in these two corrections is held to
show Urmarkus. The need of correction is obvious enough, and the
corrections are the natural ones to make. So also Sinaiticus in Mark, with
other authorities.
[26] Some MSS omit this reference in Mark.
[27] P. 21.
[28] See Lk iii, 21; ix, 18, 28, 29; xi, 1.
[29] See pp. 153, 238-39.
[30] _Das älteste Evangelium_, p. 165.
[31] For further discussion of this and the preceding section see pp.
239-40.
[32] P. 19.
[33] Huck's _Synopse_, pp. 80 and 109, will show the verses belonging
respectively to the two sources.
[34] It is argued later, pp. 234-48, that Mark also is dependent upon Q,
but since he has the Q material in much briefer and more fragmentary form
than Matthew and Luke, his use of Q does not preclude Matthew's and Luke's
preservation of more primary features of the Q tradition.
[35] Wellhausen, _Einleitung_, p. 59.
[36] For further discussion see p. 241.
[37] _Horae Synopticae_, p. 123.
[38] A note on this passage by Professor H. A. Sanders says that this is
Mark's order in B D (k d c) only.
[39] Cf. a similar omission of the address to the waves, p. 48.
[40] See Bartlet, "Sources of St. Luke's Gospel," _Oxford Studies_, p.
321.
[41] I am unable to account for Matthew's addition that Jesus touched the
man's eyes.
[42] See p. 244 for further discussion of the saying as in Mark and Q.
[43] No reason can be given, so far as I know, for Luke's addition of his
xx, 18. Some texts ascribe the same saying to Matthew also.
[44] I think I owe this suggestion to Wernle, but do not find the passage
in his _Synoptische Frage_.
[45] Bacon explains this saying of Mark's to mean that Jahwe is not a god
of the underworld, like Pluto (_Beginnings of Gospel Story_).
[46] Luke (xvii, 34) wishes to suggest that the parousia may occur in the
_night_.
[47] _Horae Synopticae_, p. 120.
[48] See his study, from which these statements are abridged, in _Oxford
Studies in the Synoptic Problem_, pp. 76-77.
[49] The fact that Matthew agrees much more closely with Mark, in those
sections which are omitted by Luke, is a somewhat curious one, for which I
have seen no sufficient explanation offered. A possible explanation might
be that in these sections no opportunity was offered to later copyists to
assimilate the texts of Matthew and Luke, and thus introduce further
changes from Mark. If the extent of such assimilation could be proved to
be great enough, this explanation would perhaps be sufficient.
[50] See Goodspeed on "The Original Conclusion of Mark's Gospel," in
_American Journal of Theology_, Vol. IX (1905), pp. 484-90; also, Rördam,
_Hibbert Journal_, Vol. III, pp. 769-90, "What Was the Lost End of the
Gospel of Mark?"
[51] See Wellhausen, _Einleitung_, p. 56; Loisy, _Gospel and Church_, p.
29.
[52] This study of von Soden's and Wendling's treatment of Mark appeared
in the _Harvard Theological Review_ for April, 1913.
[53] P. 23.
[54] P. 24.
[55] For reasons which he does not explain, he rearranges the sections.
[56] Von Soden, _Die wichtigsten Fragen_, pp. 38, 39.
[57] _Ibid._, pp. 39, 40.
[58] And still more in his _Entstehung_, too elaborate to be here
considered.
[59] Cf. especially the words [Greek: mystêrion, meta charas lambanein,
diôgmos, epithymiai, karpophorein], and see Wendling, p. 35, n. 11.
[60] Cf. ii, 20, also the work of the redactor.
[61] Cf. especially v, 2 with i, 23; v, 6, 7, with i, 24; v, 8-13, with i,
25; v, 13, with i, 26; v, 14-17, with i, 27, and see Wendling, p. 11.
[62] In _Die Entstehung des Marcus-Evangeliums_, p. 204, Wendling arranges
the verses from M1 in chaps. xiii and xiv as follows: xiii, 1-2, 33,
28-29, 34-36; xiv, 1-2, 10-11, 3-7, 22-25, 43-46, 48-50, 65. Some minor
differences in analysis, affecting words or clauses, are registered
_ibid._, p. 237.
[63] Hawkins, _Horae Synopticae_, pp. 12-13.
[64] See Hawkins, pp. 144-48.
[65] The seventy-eight does not include parables, where the present is not
historic.
[66] See Sanday's essay, in _Oxford Studies_, pp. 21-22.
[67] Turner, _Theological Studies_, January, 1909, p. 175, quoted by
Sanday.
[68] See Hawkins, _Oxford Studies_, pp. 64-66.
[69] Both genealogies may easily be suspected of being later additions. If
Luke's genealogy is a gloss there is no apparent reason why it should not
have been inserted in the appropriate place; cf. Sanders, _Journal of
Biblical Literature_, XXX, 11.
[70] E.g., the verses on Peter and the keys, or on Peter walking on the
water, or the conversation of Jesus with John the Baptist at the time of
Jesus' baptism.
[71] In the _Hibbert Journal_, No. 39, April, 1912, pp. 615-25.
[72] This passage has been already treated in a different connection on p.
39.
[73] Omitted in some manuscripts of Mark.
[74] vii, 28; xi, 1; xiii, 53; xix, 1; xxvi, 1.
[75] Hawkins, _Horae Synopticae_, p. 165.
[76] Wernle, p. 110.
[77] Luke uses it twenty-four times against Matthew's seven and Mark's
four.
[78] P. 617.
[79] Mk xiv, 54.
[80] In xiv, 66.
[81] P. 617.
[82] Lk xxii, 54.
[83] See his note, p. 618.
[84] P. 621. This judgment upon Luke is in striking contrast to that
expressed by Müller, _Zur Synopse_, p. 3: "Wellhausen calls Luke a
"historian." This judgment rests on excellent grounds. We see this at once
in the manner in which Luke has used the text-scaffolding of Mark.
Logical, simple, and transparent considerations have moved him," etc.
Müller's judgment is decidedly the better.
[85] P. 625.
[86] In his _Gospel History and Its Transmission_, and _Earliest Sources
for the Life of Jesus_.
[87] E.g., Stanton: see his _Gospels as Historical Documents_, Part II;
and Robinson: see his _Study of the Gospels_.
[88] Cf. especially the prediction of sufferings connected with the
confession of Peter (Mt xvi, 13-23); the speech about Elijah, connected
with the transfiguration (Mt xvii, 9-13); the speech about true greatness,
connected with the request of the sons of Zebedee (Mt xx, 20-28).
[89] _Oxford Studies_, p. xxii.
[90] Hawkins' list comes from his _Horae Synopticae_. In his essay in
_Oxford Studies_ he assigns a considerably larger content to Q.
[91] _Einleitung_, pp. 16-18.
[92] Effort will be made later to determine the extent of QMt and QLk by
themselves.
[93] The writer began the following examination with the intention of
assigning to Q only, and rejecting all passages not showing sufficient
agreement to warrant such assignment. He found this task so difficult,
involving the rejection of so many passages which did not apparently
belong to Q but which nevertheless showed unmistakable signs of literary
relation, that he adopted the theory (suggested but not worked out in the
introduction to Bacon's _Beginnings of Gospel Story_) of QMt and QLk.
[94] See Wellhausen's _Einleitung_, p. 36, and pp. 124-25 of this book.
[95] _Das älteste Evangelium_, p. 175.
[96] _Encyclopaedia Biblica_, col. 1864.
[97] See also pp. 124-25.
[98] See the treatment of this passage on p. 124.
[99] See his _Sayings of Jesus_, pp. 30-31.
[100] _Oxford Studies in the Synoptic Problem_, p. 109.
[101] _Sayings of Jesus_, p. 52.
[102] _Oxford Studies_, p. 133.
[103] _Encyclopedia Biblica_, Vol. II, col. 1864.
[104] P. 78.
[105] [Greek: Kryphaiô] is in vs. 18 substituted for [Greek: kryptô] used
in 4 and 6.
[106] _Oxford Studies in the Synoptic Problem_, p. 149.
[107] Pp. 40-42.
[108] _Schriften des Neuen Testaments_, I, 324.
[109] _The Synoptic Gospels_, I, 608.
[110] Quoted by Montefiore, I, 610.
[111] Sometimes counted as only seven, the similitude in vs. 52 not being
reckoned as a parable.
[112] So regarded, apparently, by J. Weiss in his _Schriften des Neuen
Testaments_, I, 342.
[113] _Oxford Studies_, p. 192.
[114] _Oxford Studies_, p. 193.
[115] _Encyclopedia Biblica_, col. 1864.
[116] _Oxford Studies_, p. 201.
[117] The healing of a dropsical man (Lk xiv, 1-6), tho a narrative
section, has been considered on p. 201, on account of the sayings in it.
[118] Hawkins, _Horae Synopticae_, p. 9.
[119] Unless this should be regarded as a gloss, which would not so well
account for its awkward position. See Sanders, _Journal of Biblical
Literature_, October, 1913.
[120] _Oxford Studies_, Introductory Essay, pp. xx-xxi.
[121] See pp. 8-9, 16-18.
[122] Holtzmann's suggestion that Luke omitted the Mark section because it
ends with the second feeding of the multitude--implying the same sort of
omission by mistake as is often made when two lines end with the same
word--seems strangely insufficient.
[123] Why does Luke have _two_ laments over Jerusalem, as well as two
missions of the disciples, especially considering his apparent avoidance
of duplicates?
[124] This last, quite inappropriate alike in the mouth of Jesus and as a
part of his parable, becomes, in the mouth of Luke, a pathetic commentary
upon the difficulty of preserving the Christian faith while waiting for
the long-delayed parousia.
[125] The soliloquy in the parables of Jesus is introduced by Luke alone.
The dialogue, tho more frequent in Luke than in Matthew, is not restricted
to him.
[126] Sanday, _Oxford Studies_, pp. 25-26.
[127] Pp. 129-206.
[128] So Wendling. Stanton also says Mark's connection is better with Mk
vi, 45-vii, 23, omitted.
[129] It should be said that most of those who argue for Luke's omission
of so much Q material assign these sixteen sections to some special source
of Luke's.
[130] See especially Matthew's "Go not into any way of the gentiles,"
which might be assigned to Q, with obvious reasons for Luke's omission.
[131] Pp. 222-25.
[132] See analyses on pp. 230-33.
[133] Pp. 222-35.
[134] See the reckoning made without inclusion of Marcan Q on pp. 162,
218.
[135] Still according to Harnack.
[136] _Oxford Studies_, p. 146.
[137] See pp. 234-46 for material in Mark and Q.
[138] A note by Professor Sanders says, quite correctly, that "The general
agreement in translation words requires that one of these translations
should have preceeded and influenced the other."
THE MACMILLAN COMPANY
64-66 FIFTH AVENUE NEW YORK
University of Michigan Studies
HUMANISTIC SERIES
General Editors: FRANCIS W. KELSEY and HENRY A. SANDERS
Size, 22.7 x 15.2 cm. 8o. Bound in cloth
VOL. I. ROMAN HISTORICAL SOURCES AND INSTITUTIONS. Edited by Professor
Henry A. Sanders, University of Michigan. Pp. viii+402. $2.50 net.
CONTENTS
1. THE MYTH ABOUT TARPEIA: Professor Henry A. Sanders.
2. THE MOVEMENTS OF THE CHORUS CHANTING THE CARMEN SAECULARE:
Professor Walter Dennison, Swarthmore College.
3. STUDIES IN THE LIVES OF ROMAN EMPRESSES, JULIA MAMAEA: Professor
Mary Gilmore Williams, Mt. Holyoke College.
4. THE ATTITUDE OF DIO CASSIUS TOWARD EPIGRAPHIC SOURCES: Professor
Duane Reed Stuart, Princeton University.
5. THE LOST EPITOME OF LIVY: Professor Henry A. Sanders.
6. THE PRINCIPALES OF THE EARLY EMPIRE: Professor Joseph H. Drake,
University of Michigan.
7. CENTURIONS AS SUBSTITUTE COMMANDERS OF AUXILIARY CORPS: Professor
George H. Allen, University of Cincinnati.
VOL. II. WORD-FORMATION IN PROVENÇAL. By Professor Edward L. Adams,
University of Michigan. Pp. xvii+607. $4.00 net.
VOL. III. LATIN PHILOLOGY. Edited by Professor Clarence Linton Meader,
University of Michigan. Pp. viii+290. $2.00 net.
Parts Sold Separately in Paper Covers:
Part I. THE USAGE OF IDEM, IPSE AND WORDS OF RELATED MEANING. By
Clarence L. Meader. Pp. 1-112. $0.75.
Part II. A STUDY IN LATIN ABSTRACT SUBSTANTIVES. By Professor Manson
A. Stewart, Yankton College. Pp. 113-78. $0.40.
Part III. THE USE OF THE ADJECTIVE AS A SUBSTANTIVE IN THE DE RERUM
NATURA OF LUCRETIUS. By Dr. Frederick T. Swan. Pp. 179-214. $0.40.
Part IV. AUTOBIOGRAPHIC ELEMENTS IN LATIN INSCRIPTIONS. By Professor
Henry H. Armstrong, Drury College. Pp. 215-86. $0.40.
VOL. IV. ROMAN HISTORY AND MYTHOLOGY. Edited by Professor Henry A.
Sanders. Pp. viii+427. $2.50 net.
Parts Sold Separately in Paper Covers:
Part I. STUDIES IN THE LIFE OF HELIOGABALUS. By Dr. Orma Fitch Butler,
University of Michigan. Pp. 1-169. $1.25 net.
Part II. THE MYTH OF HERCULES AT ROME. By Professor John G. Winter,
University of Michigan. Pp. 171-273. $0.50 net.
Part III. ROMAN LAW STUDIES IN LIVY. By Professor Alvin E. Evans,
Washington State College. Pp. 275-354. $0.40 net.
Part IV. REMINISCENCES OF ENNIUS IN SILIUS ITALICUS. By Dr. Loura B.
Woodruff. Pp. 355-424. $0.40 net.
VOL. V. SOURCES OF THE SYNOPTIC GOSPELS. By Rev. Dr. Carl S. Patton, First
Congregational Church, Columbus, Ohio. Pp. xiii+263. $1.30 net.
Size, 28 x 19 cm. 4o.
VOL. VI. ATHENIAN LEKYTHOI WITH OUTLINE DRAWING IN GLAZE VARNISH ON A
WHITE GROUND. By Arthur Fairbanks, Director of the Museum of Fine Arts,
Boston. With 15 plates, and 57 illustrations in the text. Pp. x+371. Bound
in cloth. $4.00 net.
VOL. VII. ATHENIAN LEKYTHOI WITH OUTLINE DRAWING IN DULL COLOR ON A WHITE
GROUND, AND AN APPENDIX: ADDITIONAL LEKYTHOI WITH OUTLINE DRAWING IN GLAZE
VARNISH ON A WHITE GROUND. By Arthur Fairbanks. With 41 plates. Pp. x+275.
Bound in cloth. $3.50 net.
VOL. VIII. THE OLD TESTAMENT MANUSCRIPTS IN THE FREER COLLECTION. By
Professor Henry A. Sanders, University of Michigan.
Part I. THE WASHINGTON MANUSCRIPT OF DEUTERONOMY AND JOSHUA. With 3
folding plates of pages of the Manuscript in facsimile. Pp. vi+104.
Paper covers. $1.00.
Part II. THE WASHINGTON MANUSCRIPT OF THE PSALMS. (_In Press._)
VOL. IX. THE NEW TESTAMENT MANUSCRIPTS IN THE FREER COLLECTION. By
Professor Henry A. Sanders, University of Michigan.
Part I. THE WASHINGTON MANUSCRIPT OF THE FOUR GOSPELS. With 5 plates.
Pp. viii+247. Paper covers. $2.00.
Part II. THE WASHINGTON FRAGMENTS OF THE EPISTLES OF PAUL. (_In
Preparation._)
VOL. X. THE COPTIC MANUSCRIPTS IN THE FREER COLLECTION. By Professor
William H. Worrell, Hartford Seminary Foundation. (_In Preparation._)
VOL. XI. CONTRIBUTIONS TO THE HISTORY OF SCIENCE. (_In Press._)
Part I. ROBERT OF CHESTER'S LATIN TRANSLATION OF THE ALGEBRA OF
AL-KHOWARIZMI. With an Introduction, Critical Notes, and an English
Version. By Professor Louis C. Karpinski, University of Michigan. With
4 plates showing pages of manuscripts in facsimile, and 25 diagrams in
the text. (_In Press._)
Part II. THE PRODROMUS OF NICHOLAS STENO'S LATIN DISSERTATION ON A
SOLID BODY ENCLOSED BY NATURAL PROCESS WITHIN A SOLID. Translated into
English by Professor John G. Winter, University of Michigan. With a
Foreword by Professor William H. Hobbs. (_In Press._)
VOL. XII. STUDIES IN EAST CHRISTIAN AND ROMAN ART.
Part I. EAST CHRISTIAN PAINTINGS IN THE FREER COLLECTION. By Professor
Charles R. Morey, Princeton University. With 13 plates (10 colored)
and 34 illustrations in the text. Pp. xii+87. Bound in cloth. $2.50.
Part II. A GOLD TREASURE OF THE LATE ROMAN PERIOD FROM EGYPT. By
Professor Walter Dennison, Swarthmore College. (_In Press._)
VOL. XIII. DOCUMENTS FROM THE CAIRO GENIZAH IN THE FREER COLLECTION. Text,
with Translation and an Introduction by Professor Richard Gottheil,
Columbia University. (_In Preparation._)
SCIENTIFIC SERIES
Size 28 x 18.5 cm. 4o. Bound in cloth
VOL. I. THE CIRCULATION AND SLEEP. By Professor John F. Shepard,
University of Michigan. Pp. x+83, with an Atlas of 83 plates, bound
Separately. Text and Atlas, $3.00 net.
VOL. II. STUDIES ON DIVERGENT SERIES AND SUMMABILITY. By Professor Walter
B. Ford, University of Michigan. (_In Preparation._)
HUMANISTIC PAPERS
Size, 22.7 x 15.2 cm. 8o. Bound in cloth
LATIN AND GREEK IN AMERICAN EDUCATION, WITH SYMPOSIA ON THE VALUE OF
HUMANISTIC STUDIES. Edited by Francis W. Kelsey. Pp. x+396. $1.50.
CONTENTS
THE PRESENT POSITION OF LATIN AND GREEK, THE VALUE OF LATIN AND GREEK
AS EDUCATIONAL INSTRUMENTS, THE NATURE OF CULTURE STUDIES.
SYMPOSIA ON THE VALUE OF HUMANISTIC, PARTICULARLY CLASSICAL, STUDIES
AS A PREPARATION FOR THE STUDY OF MEDICINE, ENGINEERING, LAW, AND
THEOLOGY.
SYMPOSIA ON THE VALUE OF HUMANISTIC, PARTICULARLY CLASSICAL, STUDIES
AS A TRAINING FOR MEN OF AFFAIRS; ON THE CLASSICS AND THE NEW
EDUCATION; AND ON THE DOCTRINE OF FORMAL DISCIPLINE IN THE LIGHT OF
CONTEMPORARY PSYCHOLOGY.
Handbooks of Archaeology and Antiquities
Edited by PERCY GARDNER, of the University of Oxford, and FRANCIS W.
KELSEY, of the University of Michigan.
The Principles of Greek Art
By PERCY GARDNER, Litt.D., Lincoln and Merton Professor of Classical
Archaeology, University of Oxford.
Makes clear the artistic and psychological principles underlying Greek
art, especially sculpture, which is treated as a characteristic
manifestation of the Greek spirit, a development parallel to that of
Greek literature and religion. While there are many handbooks of Greek
archaeology, this volume holds a unique place.
_Illustrated, cloth, $2.25; postpaid, $2.46_
Greek Architecture
By ALLAN MARQUAND, Ph.D., L.H.D., Professor of Art and Archaeology in
Princeton University.
Professor Marquand, in this interesting and scholarly volume, passes
from the materials of construction to the architectural forms and
decorations of the buildings of Greece, and, lastly, to its monuments.
Nearly four hundred illustrations assist the reader in a clear
understanding of the subject.
_Cloth, $2.25; postpaid, $2.45_
Greek Sculpture
By ERNEST A. GARDNER, M.A., Professor of Archaeology in University
College, London.
A comprehensive outline of our present knowledge of Greek sculpture,
distinguishing the different schools and periods, and showing the
development of each. This volume, fully illustrated, fills an
important gap and is widely used as a textbook.
_Cloth, $2.50; postpaid, $2.67_
Greek Constitutional History
By A. H. J. GREENIDGE, M.A., Late Lecturer in Hertford College and
Brasenose College, Oxford.
Most authors in writing of Greek History emphasize the structure of
the constitutions; Mr. Greenidge lays particular stress upon the
workings of these constitutions. With this purpose ever in view, he
treats of the development of Greek public law, distinguishing the
different types of states as they appear.
_Cloth, $1.25; postpaid, $1.35_
Greek and Roman Coins
By G. F. HILL, M.A., of the Department of Coins and Medals in the
British Museum.
All the information needed by the beginner in numismatics, or for
ordinary reference, is here presented. The condensation necessary to
bring the material within the size of the present volume has in no way
interfered with its clearness or readableness.
_Cloth, $2.25; postpaid, $2.38_
Greek Athletic Sports and Festivals
By E. NORMAN GARDINER, M.A., Sometime Classical Exhibitor of Christ
Church College, Oxford.
With over two hundred illustrations from contemporary art, and bright
descriptive text, this work proves of equal interest to the general
reader and to the student of the past. Many of the problems with which
it deals--the place of physical training, games, athletics, in daily
and national life--will be found as real at the present time as they
were in the far-off days of Greece.
_Cloth, $2.50; postpaid, $2.66_
Athens and Its Monuments
By CHARLES HEALD WELLER, University of Iowa.
This book embodies the results of many years of study and of direct
observation during different periods of residence in Athens. It
presents in concise and readable form a description of the ancient
city in the light of the most recent investigations. It is profusely
illustrated with half-tones and line engravings.
_$4.00 net; postpaid, $4.25_
The Destruction of Ancient Rome
By RODOLFO LANCIANI, D.C.L., Oxford; LL.D., Harvard; Professor of
Ancient Topography in the University of Rome.
Rome, the fate of her buildings and masterpieces of art, is the
subject of this profusely illustrated volume. Professor Lanciani gives
us vivid pictures of the Eternal City at the close of the different
periods of history.
_Cloth, $1.50; postpaid, $1.63_
Roman Festivals
By W. WARDE FOWLER, M.A., Fellow and Sub-Rector of Lincoln College,
Oxford.
This book covers in a concise form almost all phases of the public
worship of the Roman state, as well as certain ceremonies which,
strictly speaking, lay outside that public worship. It will be found
very useful to students of Roman literature and history as well as to
students of anthropology and the history of religion.
_Cloth, $1.25; postpaid, $1.37_
Roman Public Life
By A. H. J. GREENIDGE, M.A., Late Lecturer in Hertford College and
Brasenose College, Oxford.
The growth of the Roman constitution and its working during the
developed Republic and the Principate is the subject which Mr.
Greenidge here set for himself. All important aspects of public life,
municipal and provincial, are treated so as to reveal the political
genius of the Romans in connection with the chief problems of
administration.
_Cloth, $2.50; postpaid, $2.63_
Monuments of the Early Church
By WALTER LOWRIE, M.A., Rector of St. Paul's Church, Rome.
Nearly two hundred photographs and drawings of the most representative
monumental remains of Christian antiquity, accompanied by detailed
expositions, make this volume replete with interest for the general
reader and at the same time useful as a handbook for the student of
Christian archaeology in all its branches.
_Cloth, $1.25; postpaid, $1.39_
Monuments of Christian Rome
By ARTHUR L. FROTHINGHAM, Ph.D., formerly Professor of Archaeology and
Ancient History in Princeton University.
"The plan of the volume is simple and admirable. The first part
comprises a historical sketch; the second, a classification of the
monuments."--_The Outlook._
Profusely illustrated.
_Cloth, $2.25; postpaid, $2.43_
Transcriber's Notes:
Passages in italics are indicated by _italics_.
Passages in bold are indicated by =bold=.
The original text includes Greek and Hebrew characters. For this text
version these letters have been replaced with transliterations.
End of Project Gutenberg's Sources of the Synoptic Gospels, by Carl S. Patton