I cut the following from a Sunday paper in 1849:

"X. Y.--The Chaldeans began the mathematics, in which the Egyptians

excelled. Then crossing the sea, by means {59} of Thales,[110] the

Milesian, they came into Greece, where they were improved very much by

Pythagoras,[111] Anaxagoras,[112] and Anopides[113] of Chios. These were

followed by Briso,[114] Antipho, [two circle-squarers; where is Euclid?]

and Hippocrates,[115] but the excellence of the algebraic art was begun by

Geber,[116] an Arabian astronomer, and was carried on by Cardanus,[117]

Tartaglia,[118] Clavius,[119], Stevinus,[120] Ghetaldus,[121]

Herig_e_nius,[122] Fran. Van Schooten [meaning Francis Van Schooten[123]],

Florida de Beau_m_e,[124] etc."

Bryso was a mistaken man. Antipho had the disadvantage of being in advance

of his age. He had the notion of which the modern geometry has made so

much, that of {60} a circle being the polygon of an infinitely great number

of sides. He could make no use of it, but the notion itself made him a

sophist in the eyes of Aristotle, Eutocius,[125] etc. Geber, an Arab

astronomer, and a reputed conjurer in Europe, seems to have given his name

to unintelligible language in the word _gibberish_. At one time _algebra_

was traced to him; but very absurdly, though I have heard it suggested that

_algebra_ and _gibberish_ must have had one inventor.

Any person who meddles with the circle may find himself the crane who was

netted among the geese: as Antipho for one, and Olivier de Serres[126] for

another. This last gentleman ascertained, by weighing, that the area of the

circle is very nearly that of the square on the side of the inscribed

equilateral triangle: which it is, as near as 3.162 ... to 3.141.... He did

not pretend to more than approximation; but Montucla and others

misunderstood him, and, still worse, misunderstood their own

misunderstanding, and made him say the circle was exactly double of the

equilateral triangle. He was let out of limbo by Lacroix, in a note to his

edition of Montucla's _History of Quadrature_.

A Budget of Paradoxes, Volume II · 第 32 / 123 题