The Translation

In diction, syntax, word order, and complexity of expression,

Guibert's Latin is more difficult than that of any other Latin

historian of the First Crusade. I have tried to preserve as much of

the complexity of the syntax as is tolerable in comprehensible

English sentences. Guibert's penchant for alliteration, rhyming

clausulae, and pithiness must usually be sacrificed. A

characteristic example of the sonic loss occurs in my attempt to

translate the sardonic description of Arnulf's elevation to patriarch:

...dum vox magis quam vita curatur, ad hoc ut Iherosolimitanus fieret

patriarcha vocatur. (RHC 4.233)

and since a man's voice is of more concern than the life he has led,

he was called to the patriarchy of Jerusalem.

I have followed the paragraphs of the latest edition, often longer

than those to which twentieth-century readers are accustomed, to

allow readers to check the original more easily. Passages which

Guibert composed in verse are translated into prose and indented.

Guizot's early nineteenth-century French translation, although at

times erroneous or misleading, was very helpful.

The Deeds of God Through the Franks · 第 5 / 25 题