THE INVESTIGATING COMMITTEE
Meanwhile, the investigating committee had been appointed, and the day
came when witnesses were to be examined. The committee sat in the
afternoon only, so as to make it possible for all to attend without
sacrificing their state work. Masters, of course, was there, Chairo,
too, and Ariston, who continued to act for Chairo. Ariston had consulted
with me as to the wisdom of preparing Masters for the testimony
implicating Neaera, which we knew would be elicited. But I preferred to
allow events to take their course.
The first witness called was one of those who had attacked the House of
Detention and been wounded. He had clearly remained devoted to Chairo;
for to every question put to him, which tended to implicate Chairo, he
displayed astonishing forgetfulness; but as soon as the examination bore
upon my interview with Balbus, at which he had been present, he stated
every circumstance exactly as it had happened, except that he was,
perhaps, more severe on Neaera than she deserved.
"She would not allow Balbus to speak," he said. "She walked right over
from the corner where she was writing and wouldn't allow Balbus to say a
word."
He even insisted that it was Neaera who had ordered my arrest, and
personally supervised the act of binding me to the chair.
Masters' brow grew dark at this attack on Neaera, and he undertook to
cross-examine the witness, but did it clumsily and ineffectually. His
principal effort was to induce the witness to admit that Neaera had
already received orders from Chairo that an attempt at rescue was to be
made whatever apparently contradictory messages might be received,
whether purporting to come from him, Chairo, or from others.
This line of cross-examination incensed Chairo who was indirectly
charged by it with having sent me on a message for the purpose of
assuming an air of innocence, when he all the time intended the attempt
at rescue to be made.
Ariston with great difficulty kept Chairo from angry interruption; and
on redirect examination, which he was allowed in Chairo's interest to
conduct, strengthened the evidence of Chairo's good faith.
The next witness was clearly of Hibernian descent, for he at once took
the entire committee and audience into his confidence. "I'll tell you
all about it," he said. "I'm the janitor of the 'Liberty' offices, and I
know all about it from the beginning."
He then proceeded to give a complete history of his own life from the
earliest years he could remember, and he assured us that he would go
still further back if he could; that he had nothing to conceal from the
committee, and would tell them "all about it from the very beginning."
Over and over again he was interrupted by the committee, who complained
of the irrelevancy of his testimony. "And would you have me hold
anything back?" he said indignantly. "Haven't I sworn to tell the whole
truth as well as nothing but the truth?"
"We only want to hear you in connection with the organization and arming
of forces by Chairo with a view to violence and the subsequent attempt
upon the House of Detention."
"And haven't I known Chairo all my life," responded the witness
triumphantly, "and isn't that just what I'm telling you? Just leave me
quiet," he added, "and I'll tell you the whole thing from the
beginning."
The committee, thinking time would in the end be saved, gave the witness
rope, of which he was not slow to take advantage, for he interlarded his
narrative with stories so comic that the committee was at last obliged
to interfere again. But his wit was equal to every emergency, and after
an hour spent in the futile effort to extract information from him, he
was released. A broad wink at Chairo as he left the witness box set the
audience in a roar, but did not help Chairo's case.
The third witness was another of the party which had attacked the House
of Detention, and he clearly was actuated by no desire to shield Chairo,
for he testified to details so damaging to him that no one had any
longer any doubt as to Chairo having organized a vast conspiracy against
the State. He had himself been one of Chairo's lieutenants, and he gave
the names of the men that had joined him, the weapons that had been
secured, the date of his first instructions from Chairo, and their
tenor; in fact, nothing was left untold. He was not present when I
carried Chairo's message to Balbus.
Ariston cross-examined him with great skill, tripped him up as to some
of his dates and details, and even threw some confusion into his
testimony regarding the character of the instructions. But as to the
main facts his testimony was unshaken.
The examination and cross-examination of these three witnesses occupied
the whole of the first day; and as Chairo, Ariston, and I returned
slowly to our quarters we found it difficult to speak. Chairo was still
angry with Masters, and expressed himself on the subject in a few
explosive sentences. Ariston reminded Chairo that Masters was an old
admirer of Neaera's, and I felt almost guilty at withholding from them
that he had actually married her.
After our plunge, Ariston and I brightened up a little, but Chairo
remained profoundly depressed.
"The fact is," he said, "I am beginning to look at things from a
different point of view. This military organization of ours was a
gigantic mistake."
"Violence can only be justified," said Ariston, "by some public
necessity or injustice; no isolated personal grievance can possibly
justify it."
"We thought that this whole Demetrian cult had become a social evil, but
others evidently do not."
Chairo's manner had so changed from what it was when I first met him
among the hills of Tyringham that my mind was set upon inquiring as to
the cause, and I could not help suspecting that his misgivings were for
the most part due to Lydia.
I felt that I was _de trop_ and found some excuse for leaving them.
Later Ariston told me that although Chairo was profoundly discouraged,
strange to say, he had expressed little concern about himself or his
political aims; what he used to describe as "The Cause," and really
meant his own ambition, seemed to have entirely passed out of his mind;
his whole concern now was for Lydia.
The examination of witnesses during the next few days resulted in a
confirmation of all the facts brought out on the first day; Chairo had
clearly undertaken a vast and dangerous conspiracy against the state; he
had, in good faith, sought at the last moment to prevent violence, and
Neaera was wholly responsible for the attempt at rescue. Masters and his
following alone persisted in endeavoring to shield Neaera. According to
them, instructions had been given by Chairo to both Balbus and Neaera
that in case of any accident happening to himself, the attempt was to be
made to rescue him, and that this attempt was to serve as an excuse for
the violence which they felt indispensable to the defeat of the
Demetrian cult.
As the examination was drawing to a close, Ariston pointed out to me
that I was probably the only man who could persuade Masters of his
mistake; he also urged that not only Chairo's fate hung in the balance
but Lydia's also.
Ariston told me that Lydia's letters to him plainly showed that her own
hopes as to the passage of the amnesty bill had come to an end, and that
the subject under discussion between them now was what they should do in
case the amnesty bill was not passed.
While we were talking over the matter in our apartment, we were
astonished to receive the visit of Masters, for of late Masters had
failed to recognize any of our party in the courthouse, and we feared
that the issue regarding Neaera's responsibility had occasioned a
permanent break in the ranks of the opposition.
When Masters entered the room he made no pretense of cordiality; he
apologized conventionally for intruding, and explained that his visit
was due to a letter received from Neaera that day, in which she had
urged him to see me, as she was convinced I could set his mind at rest
regarding her innocence.
I perceived without difficulty that Neaera must have been reduced to
desperate straits in order to have recourse to such a reckless measure,
and that the correspondence between Masters and her must have betrayed
considerable doubt in Masters's mind as to the truth of her statements
concerning her connection with the business. I was determined to learn
from Masters as far as possible what was his present attitude to Neaera.
So I asked:
"You have heard the witnesses; what is your own impression of the
matter?"
"You could not expect me to believe them, could you?"
There was an expression of agony on Masters's brow which made me feel
strongly drawn to him.
"Shall Ariston stay while we talk about this?" asked I.
"Yes," said Masters, turning to Ariston. "It is well that you should
know that Neaera is my wife."
Ariston put up both hands with an involuntary expression of dismay, the
significance of which Masters did not fail to take in. He looked at me
half in despair, half in inquiry.
"Ariston understands now," I said, "why you have undertaken to vindicate
Neaera."
"I should have undertaken to vindicate her in any event," answered
Masters. "She is a woman, and a concerted effort is being directed
toward making a scapegoat of her."
"The witnesses," I answered, "are certainly unanimous on the subject."
"From what you say," Masters said, "I gather that you do not disbelieve
them."
The veins in Masters's forehead were swelling with the effort he was
making to hide his indignation.
"I have been at great pains to be released from the obligation of
testifying," I answered, "because I have not wished to injure her,
because, above all," I added, "I have not wished to injure you."
We had remained standing during this conversation, but when I said
this--and in saying it I tried to make Masters feel that I was sorry for
him--he turned away a little and sank sideways upon a chair. He leaned
one arm on the back of it, bowing his head upon his hand, and after a
moment's pause turned to me again; his face was white now.
"If that is your reason for not testifying I am obliged to you," he
said. "But which is your real reason--to spare Neaera or to spare me?"
"I have no more reason for sparing Neaera than that she is a woman; I
have every reason for sparing you."
Masters looked at me inquiringly.
"I have nothing to conceal from you," I continued.
"Then tell me just what happened," answered Masters.
I took a seat and so did Ariston, and thought for a moment how I could
tell the facts in so far as they concerned the attempt at rescue without
disclosing Neaera's designs upon myself. I confined myself to the part
she played when I gave Chairo's message to Balbus.
"Might not this have been done by Neaera," asked Masters, "in compliance
with a prior understanding with Chairo?"
"I cannot believe," said I, "that there was any such understanding;
indeed, I am convinced that if Neaera was not herself the cause of
Chairo's capture, she was a party to it." I told then the story of the
tampering with Chairo's carriage.
"Could not this, too, have been a part of the plot?" pleaded Masters
desperately.
"A part of Neaera's plot, not a part of Chairo's. No one can talk ten
minutes with Chairo now without being convinced that his first object
was to get possession of Lydia; the political intrigue in the latest
stage of the affair became altogether a secondary matter."
"Neaera was not," interrupted Ariston, "pleased with the role Lydia
played in the matter. At one time there was no small intimacy between
Chairo and Neaera; Neaera is not a woman to see her place taken by
another without vindictiveness. In preventing the escape of Chairo she
was serving a double purpose; she kept the issue alive, and she
satisfied a personal pique."
Masters looked at me as though to learn my opinion on this view.
"I gathered this: from a few words Neaera dropped after she had set me
free," I said; "she told me that all Chairo wanted was Lydia."
Masters jumped up from his chair.
"Then you would have me believe," said he, "that my wife is a vixen!"
At this I jumped up too.
"Masters," I said, "I have told you the facts because I felt you were
entitled to them. If you cannot stand hearing the facts you should not
have asked for them."
There was a moment when it seemed doubtful whether we might not come to
blows; but the flash went out of Masters's eye as he looked at me, and
presently he held out his hand to me and said:
"I am sure you have intended to render me a service, and I suppose in
the end"--he paused a moment as he shook my hand, and added--"in the end
it will prove to be so."
Then, taking up his cap and cloak, he said:
"At any rate there need be no hard feeling between myself and Chairo,
but I am a little dazed by what I have heard, and so I shall ask you
both to keep this interview confidential for a time. In a few days I
shall know better just how to act."