"Its silence made the tumult in my breast
More audible; its peace revealed my own unrest."
Jean Ingelow.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Anthony told everything on their way from the Cathedral to the shop,
for, indeed, he did not know what might not have happened even in so
short a time. But except that the crowd had pretty well dispersed,
leaving only a few of the more curious idlers to hang about, all was
much as he left it, outside and in. Bessie was crying and trembling,
but Winifred went softly in, without looking to the right or left, and,
kneeling by her father's side, clasped his hand in hers.
"We are going to take Mr Chester to my house, where he will be a good
deal more comfortable," said the doctor with the cheerfulness which is
at all events intended for kindness.
"Not home?" Winifred asked, without looking up.
"My dear, the long drive would be more than he could bear while he is in
this condition," said Mr Robert gravely. "And now Dr Fletcher will
have him altogether under his care, which is particularly desirable.
The carriage is here: we only waited for you."
She rose up, showing no agitation except a tremulous shiver which she
could not repress, while Bessie clung to her and sobbed convulsively.
Anthony, who was greatly shocked, had fallen involuntarily into his old
brotherly ways. He brought a fly, and put the two sisters into it, and
when Bessie looked at him imploringly, got in by their side instead of
walking round with Mr Mannering. It was like a dream, the flags, and
the bustle, and the people coming down the street from the concert, and
this sad cloud chilling their hearts. He saw on the other side Mrs
Bennett, and Ada, and Mr Warren: Ada was staring in wonder, but he
cared nothing for that or anything else except the beseeching look in
Winifred's sad eyes.
By the time they reached the doctor's house, Bessie had rallied from the
first terror of the shock, and Winifred was as outwardly calm as
possible, ready to receive her father, quick to comprehend Dr
Fletcher's directions, and so helpful and quiet that it was only now and
then that Anthony knew that she turned to him with a mute appeal in the
look, as if in this wave of sorrow she too had forgotten all
estrangement and coldness, and gone back to the old days which both
believed had passed away forever. There was a strange sort of tender
pride in the way he watched her, which must have startled himself if he
had been aware of it. But he was not. He was not thinking about
himself, and, indeed, might have argued that the veriest stranger must
have been touched and moved at such a time. When he was obliged to
leave her, he could hardly bear to do so.
"I may come back in the morning, may I not?" he said, unable to avoid
saying it.
"Do come," Winifred had answered with a quiet acceptance, of his help,
and going on to tell him what was wanted from Hardlands. As he went out
of the door he met Mr Robert coming to see if he could be of any
further use.
"I have made Charles go home, for he is not fit for this sad business,"
said Mr Robert in an altered voice. "Poor things, poor things! It is
one comfort to know he does not suffer. Fletcher says he will not
recover consciousness. Good Heavens, I can't believe it now! His last
words,--ah! to be sure, Anthony, he was going off after you when it
happened."
And he told him what the Squire had said.
It touched Anthony inexpressibly, but it seemed also to bring back an
avenging army of forgotten things, so that Mr Robert could not
understand what made his face grow dark, and let his voice drop coldly
as if it were a shame to waste a sacred thing on one so unforgiving, not
knowing to what his words had suddenly recalled him. The past had been
sweet through all its sorrow, and now it was over, and he must gather up
his burden.
"The Bennetts are at Griffith's, and were inquiring for you.
Good-night," said Mr Mannering shortly.
Anthony went mechanically towards the bookseller's, knowing exactly all
that would be said to him, the exclamations and questions which Ada was
likely to pour out seeming unutterably wearisome at this moment when
Winifred's face would persistently rise before him, so brave, so
patient, so womanly in its sorrow, that Ada could not stand the
contrast. And yet he was to marry Ada, to become one with her, to swear
to love her. He turned white when the thought struck him suddenly, as
if it were a new knowledge. She was standing at the bookseller's door,
waiting impatiently, and smiling a pretty show of welcome, as usual.
"I am so glad you are come, Anthony; it was such a pity you did not go
to the concert. And poor old Mr Chester,--do tell us all about it I
don't think I shall ever fancy Springfield's shop again."
"I don't wonder you are shocked," Anthony said, rousing himself and
conscious that he owed her amends for the very agony of the last few
minutes. "It seems hardly possible as yet to realise it."
"No, it is dreadful," said Ada, her looks wandering away. "Does Miss
Chester feel it much? She looks as if it would take a good deal to move
her. There are the Watsons,--you didn't bow." Mrs Bennett's face at
the other end of the shop looked like a refuge to which he might escape.
To escape,--and he was to marry her! He had not yet heard the end of
the petty inquiries which fluttered down upon him, but at length he saw
Mrs Bennett and Ada driving away, and Ada pointing towards
Springfield's and explaining. Anthony went quickly into a back room,
wrote two or three letters to the Squire's nearest relations, rode as
fast as he could to Thorpe, gave Miss Chesters directions to the
Hardlands servants, and then, after a moment's thought, turned his
horse's head back to Aunecester.
He said to Dr Fletcher, "Do not say anything of my being here to Miss
Chester; it can do no good, I know, but--we were near neighbours, and I
may as well sleep to-night at the Globe, so as to be at hand if I am
wanted. You'll send for me if I can do anything of any sort? And there
is no change?"
"None whatever. We have, of course, had a consultation, and Dr Hill
entirely takes my view of the case. I regret that I cannot tell you
that he is more hopeful. I am inclined to think Mr Chester's condition
not altogether attributable to the blow, but that there might have been
a simultaneous attack."
There was nothing to stay for, and Anthony went, though not to the inn.
He walked about the old town for more hours than he knew, thinking of
many things. Those last words of the Squire had touched him acutely,
and his thoughts were softened and almost tender towards the friends
whose countenance he had been rejecting. But the idea which seemed to
hold him with a rush of force was that he must see Winifred again; that,
happen what might, it was impossible but that there should be a meeting,
if not one day at least another. It did not strike him as an
inconsistency that this thing which he wanted had been within his reach
a hundred times when he would not avail himself of it; like most men
when under the influence of a dominant feeling, he did not care to look
back and trace the manner in which its dominion had gradually asserted
itself, nor, indeed, to dwell upon it so far as to admit that it was a
dominion at all. Was he not to marry Ada Lovell? Only pity moved him,
pity that was natural enough, remembering the old familiar relations, or
allowing himself to dwell upon the sweet womanly eyes which no darkness
could shut out from him. For gradually the dusk had deepened into
night, the Close in which he found himself was singularly deserted, now
and then a figure that might have been a shadow passed him, a quiet
light or two gleamed behind homely blinds, and by and by was
extinguished, the trees stood black and motionless against the sky, only
the great bell of the Cathedral clock now and then broke the silence,
and was answered far and near by echoing tongues. Such a night was full
of tender sadness, to poor Anthony perhaps dangerously soft and sweet,
for he had been living of late, in spite of his engagement, in an
atmosphere of cold restraint, peculiarly galling to his reserved yet
affectionate nature. All Ada's pretty assurances and the pleasant
amenities of the Bennetts' house had never removed the chill. They were
something belonging to him, at which he looked equably, but they had
never become part of himself. Alas, and yet to-day a word or two of
Winifred's--Winifred whom he did not love--had pierced it.
Winifred--whom he did not love.
With one of those unaccountable flashes by which an image is suddenly
brought into our memory, there started before him a remembrance of her
in the old Vicarage garden, that Sunday morning when he and she had
strolled together to the mulberry-tree,--the quaintly formal hollyhocks,
the busy martins flashing in and out, the daisies in the grass, Winifred
softly singing the old psalm tune, and laying the cool rose against her
cheek. Had he forgotten one of her words that day, this Winifred whom
he did not love? And then he thought of her again at a time which he
had never liked to look back upon, that winter day when she had met him
in the lane, a spot of warm colour amidst the faded browns and greys,--
thought of the gate and the cold distant moorland, and the words which
had struck a chill into his life. It had seemed to him then as if it
had been she who had done it, and he had never been able to dissociate
her from her tidings; so that no generous pity for the woman who had
wounded him, nor any understanding that she had done it because from
another it might have come with too cruel harshness, had stirred his
heart, until now when another compassion had forced the door, turned his
eyes from himself, and shown him what Winifred had been.
The darkness reveals many things to us, and that night other things were
abroad in the darkness,--death, the unfulfilled purpose of one whom he
had chosen to regard as his enemy, if, indeed, it were not rather that
God had fulfilled it in his own more perfect way,--these were working
upon him, however unconsciously. Yet those revelations were full of
anguish, opening out mistake after mistake in a manner which to a man
who has over-trusted himself becomes an intolerable reproach. The
accusation which had seemed literally to blast his life stood before him
in juster, soberer proportions; his manner of meeting it became more
cowardly and faithless, made bitter by an almost entire forgetfulness of
the Hand from which the trial came. And in the midst of his angry
despair, by his own act he must deliberately add another pang to his
lot, and, putting away his friends, bind himself for life to a woman for
whom his strongest feeling was the fancy for a smiling face. Perhaps,
as yet, he hardly knew how slight that feeling was, but even by this
time he was bitterly tasting the draught his own weakness had prepared.
These thoughts all came to him with a quiet significance, adding tenfold
to their power, yet touched by a certain solemn gravity which gave him
the sense for which he most craved just now, the old childlike
trustfulness in an overruling care. As we sow, so we must reap, but
even the saddest harvest may yield us good sheaves, though not the crop
we longed and hoped to gather. And this night was the first hour which
seemed to bring Anthony face to face with his own work.
He had been walking mechanically about the Close. Turning out of it at
last, he went back to Dr Fletcher's house, and looked up at a light
burning in an upper window, little thinking, however, that it was a
watch by the dead, and not by the living, that it marked; for in spite
of what Dr Fletcher had told him, the tidings he heard in the early
morning fell like an unexpected blow. He would have gone away without a
word, but that Dr Fletcher came out at the moment.
"There was never any rally or return to consciousness," he said, leading
the way into the dining-room, where his breakfast was spread, "and
although this naturally aggravates the shock to his daughters, they have
been spared a good deal that must have been very painful, poor things!
My wife is with them. Will you have a cup of coffee with me?"
"He was always supposed to have such a good constitution," said Anthony,
looking stunned.
"Perhaps not so good as it seemed. He led a regular life, temperate and
healthy,--I only wish there were more like him,--and he had never been
tried by any severe illness. As to this, a more tenacious vitality
might only have prolonged the suffering. I think you said you had
written to the relations? I would have telegraphed this morning, but
Miss Chester was anxious that her aunt should be spared the shock."
"My letters will bring them as soon as possible," Anthony said. "There
is a sister of the Squire's, a widow, an invalid, and her step-son is
quartered at Colchester. Besides them there are only cousins. Mrs
Orde will start at once--But, good heavens," he went on, breaking down,
and burying his face in his hands, "it is so awfully sudden! What will
they do?"
Dr Fletcher made no immediate reply. He was a kind-hearted man, but
his sympathies were chiefly bounded by his profession, and it was easier
for him to be energetic in behalf of a suffering body, than to express
anything which touched more internal springs. He was wondering whether
Anthony would have the courage to face a woman's grief, and meditating
on the possibility of giving up his own morning's work, when he said
aloud, quietly,--
"Miss Chester will probably return to Hardlands to-day. Is there any
one who can be with her and her sister?"
"My mother is their oldest friend," Anthony said, without looking up,
and pushing his plate from him with a slight nervous movement. The
doctor waited for some assurance to follow this assertion, but Anthony
could not give it, for his mind quickly ran over the situation, and
foresaw that his mother's kindness would not suffice to guide her past
the little embarrassments which awaken so great throbs of pain at such a
time. Finding he was silent, Dr Fletcher went on,--
"Would you wish me to inquire whether Miss Chester is ready to see you?
That is, unless I can persuade you to take a little more food?"
"I am quite ready," said Anthony, getting up hastily. He dreaded the
interview fully as much as the doctor had divined, and the force with
which he compelled himself to meet it produced a certain hardness which,
to a shallow observer, might appear like cold indifference: certainly
there were hard-set lines on his face as he stood at a window waiting
for Winifred. Trees, with iron railings before them, were planted in
the space in front of Dr Fletcher's house; there were crimson berries
on the thorn-trees, a robin or two hopping about familiarly, a grey
rainy-looking sky, and now and then a warning drop on the pavement
below. Winifred did not come at once, for it was difficult for her to
leave Bessie, who was overwrought as much with terror as sorrow; and
Anthony, having strung himself up to the meeting, lost himself again in
thoughts which grew out of but did not absolutely belong to it, and did
not hear her behind him when at last she entered the room.
When he turned round she was standing close by him, and put out her
hand.
"I thought you would come," she said simply.
But she saw in a moment that it was she who must be the comforter, and
went on without leaving a pause which should oblige him to speak. "It
was all so calm and so peaceful that I cannot realise anything beyond
the comfort of knowing that he had no suffering to endure. Poor
Bessie's grief seems something for which I am very sorry, but in which I
have no share. It must be as I have read and never quite believed, that
a great shock deadens all one's perceptions."
"Yes, indeed," said Anthony, relieved by her quietness and the simple
words which had nothing constrained about them. "And by and by you will
be thankful that you were with him,--so close at hand--"
"O, I am thankful now!" said Winifred, with intense earnestness. "It
does not seem as if one could have borne it to be otherwise; but now I
have all the last looks,--the knowledge that there was nothing lost.
You can think what that must be."
Twenty-four hours had put away on her side all the divisions that had
existed, and taken her back to the old familiar friendship, so that if
she remembered any cause of estrangement, it was that she might touch it
softly, and let Anthony feel that it had only been a shadow, not
affecting the true kindness of her father. With an instinctive loyalty
she would have liked to clothe the dead in a hundred virtues. But
Anthony himself was feeling the separation with a strength that almost
maddened him. There was a gulf between them which was of his own
digging. There they were, he and she, and yet he could not put out a
hand, could not take her to his heart and comfort her. As she spoke he
shook his head with a quick gesture, throwing it back, and turned away
from her towards the window, against which the rain was now pattering
gently. Winifred was surprised, and a little hurt, but as it struck her
that he might dread what she was going to say, she went on with a voice
that faltered for the first time,--
"Dr Fletcher told me that you would settle for me what ought to be
done, but--perhaps--I believe that I can give directions--if it is
painful to you--"
"That is impossible," Anthony said, almost sharply, and without looking
round. "I will do it all,--why else am I here?"
She drew back almost imperceptibly, but then, as if moved by an opposite
feeling, went up to him, and touched his arm.
"Anthony," she said in a low voice.
If it was to oblige him to look at her she succeeded, for he immediately
glanced round, although he did not answer, and indeed she went on
hurriedly,--
"I dare say you think I do not know, but Dr Fletcher explained to me
that there must be an inquest. It is not so painful as you fancy,--
nothing seems painful just now,--do not be afraid to tell us what is
necessary. Dr Fletcher says it had better be here, he will make them
come as soon as possible, and he wishes us to go back to Hardlands at
once. I would rather have stayed, but I can see that it would be bad
for Bessie, and--he would have liked her to be spared. Richardson is in
the house, if you would tell him to go back, and bring the carriage at
once--and,"--she hesitated wistfully, for it did not seem quite so easy
to her to ask anything of Anthony as it had been at the beginning of
their interview--"would it be possible for you to stay,--so as to be at
hand,--to stay until to-morrow, or till my cousin comes? Some one must
be here," she said, with a little passionate cry of sorrow, as her
self-control broke down; "he shall not be left alone." She stopped
again, this time for an answer, but when none came she said with an
effort, "Perhaps you cannot stay,--perhaps Mr Mannering would come?"
"Of course I shall stay," Anthony said, in a bitter, half-choked voice.
He knew that she thought him cruelly hard and cold: he heard her give a
little sigh as she moved away a step or two, but it was with almost a
feeling of relief, anything being better than that she should know the
real feelings of the moment. Winifred was not thinking of him as he
imagined, but something in his manner brought to her a keen impression
of the breach between the dead and the living, which she had been trying
to make him forget. She stood for a moment with her hand on the door,
and her head bent,--thinking. She said at last, softly and
pleadingly,--
"If it has not been between you and him of late quite as it was in the
old days, you will not remember that any more, will you, Anthony? If he
ever did you an injustice in his thoughts, it was not willingly, only--
only one of those misunderstandings which the best, the noblest,
sometimes fall into. If he had lived he would have told you this
himself one day, and therefore I say it to you from him," she added,
lifting her eyes, and speaking with grave steadfastness, as if she were
indeed delivering a message from the dead, "and I know that you will be
glad to think that it is so, and to help us for his sake."
The moment she had said this she went away so quickly that Anthony's
call did not even reach her ears. It was only one word, "Winifred!" but
it was as well she did not hear, since one word is sometimes strong
enough to carry a whole load of anguish and of yearning love.