WHEN DOCTORS DISAGREE

It is possible that, at about the time at which this story opens, you

may have gone into the Hotel Belvoir for a hair-cut. Many people did;

for the young man behind the scissors, though of a singularly gloomy

countenance, was undoubtedly an artist in his line. He clipped

judiciously. He left no ridges. He never talked about the weather. And

he allowed you to go away unburdened by any bottle of hair-food.

It is possible, too, that, being there, you decided that you might as

well go the whole hog and be manicured at the same time.

It is not unlikely, moreover, that when you had got over the first

shock of finding your hands so unexpectedly large and red, you felt

disposed to chat with the young lady who looked after that branch of

the business. In your genial way you may have permitted a note of gay

(but gentlemanly) badinage to creep into your end of the dialogue.

In which case, if you had raised your eyes to the mirror, you would

certainly have observed a marked increase of gloom in the demeanour of

the young man attending to your apex. He took no official notice of the

matter. A quick frown. A tightening of the lips. Nothing more. Jealous

as Arthur Welsh was of all who inflicted gay badinage, however

gentlemanly, on Maud Peters, he never forgot that he was an artist.

Never, even in his blackest moments, had he yielded to the temptation

to dig the point of the scissors the merest fraction of an inch into a

client's skull.

But Maud, who saw, would understand. And, if the customer was an

observant man, he would notice that her replies at that juncture became

somewhat absent, her smile a little mechanical.

* * * * *

Jealousy, according to an eminent authority, is the 'hydra of

calamities, the sevenfold death'. Arthur Welsh's was all that and a bit

over. It was a constant shadow on Maud's happiness. No fair-minded girl

objects to a certain tinge of jealousy. Kept within proper bounds, it

is a compliment; it makes for piquancy; it is the gin in the

ginger-beer of devotion. But it should be a condiment, not a fluid.

It was the unfairness of the thing which hurt Maud. Her conscience was

clear. She knew girls--several girls--who gave the young men with whom

they walked out ample excuse for being perfect Othellos. If she had

ever flirted on the open beach with the baritone of the troupe of

pierrots, like Jane Oddy, she could have excused Arthur's attitude. If,

like Pauline Dicey, she had roller-skated for a solid hour with a

black-moustached stranger while her fiance floundered in Mug's Alley

she could have understood his frowning disapprovingly. But she was not

like Pauline. She scorned the coquetries of Jane. Arthur was the centre

of her world, and he knew it. Ever since the rainy evening when he had

sheltered her under his umbrella to her Tube station, he had known

perfectly well how things were with her. And yet just because, in a

strictly business-like way, she was civil to her customers, he must

scowl and bite his lip and behave generally as if it had been brought

to his notice that he had been nurturing a serpent in his bosom. It was

worse than wicked--it was unprofessional.

She remonstrated with him.

'It isn't fair,' she said, one morning when the rush of customers had

ceased and they had the shop to themselves.

Matters had been worse than usual that morning. After days of rain and

greyness the weather had turned over a new leaf. The sun glinted among

the bottles of Unfailing Lotion in the window, and everything in the

world seemed to have relaxed and become cheerful. Unfortunately,

everything had included the customers. During the last few days they

had taken their seats in moist gloom, and, brooding over the prospect

of coming colds in the head, had had little that was pleasant to say to

the divinity who was shaping their ends. But today it had been

different. Warm and happy, they had bubbled over with gay small-talk.

'It isn't fair,' she repeated.

Arthur, who was stropping a razor and whistling tunelessly, raised his

eyebrows. His manner was frosty.

'I fail to understand your meaning,' he said.

'You know what I mean. Do you think I didn't see you frowning when I

was doing that gentleman's nails?'

The allusion was to the client who had just left--a jovial individual

with a red face, who certainly had made Maud giggle a good deal. And

why not? If a gentleman tells really funny stories, what harm is there

in giggling? You had to be pleasant to people. If you snubbed

customers, what happened? Why, sooner or later, it got round to the

boss, and then where were you? Besides, it was not as if the red-faced

customer had been rude. Write down on paper what he had said to her,

and nobody could object to it. Write down on paper what she had said to

him, and you couldn't object to that either. It was just Arthur's

silliness.

She tossed her head.

'I am gratified,' said Arthur, ponderously--in happier moments Maud

had admired his gift of language; he read a great deal: encyclopedias

and papers and things--'I am gratified to find that you had time to

bestow a glance on me. You appeared absorbed.'

Maud sniffed unhappily. She had meant to be cold and dignified

throughout the conversation, but the sense of her wrongs was beginning

to be too much for her. A large tear splashed on to her tray of

orange-sticks. She wiped it away with the chamois leather.

'It isn't fair,' she sobbed. 'It isn't. You know I can't help it if

gentlemen talk and joke with me. You know it's all in the day's work.

I'm expected to be civil to gentlemen who come in to have their hands

done. Silly I should look sitting as if I'd swallowed a poker. I

_do_ think you might understand, Arthur, you being in the

profession yourself.'

He coughed.

'It isn't so much that you talk to them as that you seem to like--'

He stopped. Maud's dignity had melted completely. Her face was buried

in her arms. She did not care if a million customers came in, all at

the same time.

'Maud!'

She heard him moving towards her, but she did not look up. The next

moment his arms were round her, and he was babbling.

And a customer, pushing open the door unnoticed two minutes later,

retired hurriedly to get shaved elsewhere, doubting whether Arthur's

mind was on his job.

For a time this little thunderstorm undoubtedly cleared the air. For a

day or two Maud was happier than she ever remembered to have been.

Arthur's behaviour was unexceptionable. He bought her a wrist-watch--

light brown leather, very smart. He gave her some chocolates to eat in

the Tube. He entertained her with amazing statistics, culled from the

weekly paper which he bought on Tuesdays. He was, in short, the perfect

lover. On the second day the red-faced man came in again. Arthur joined

in the laughter at his stories. Everything seemed ideal.

It could not last. Gradually things slipped back into the old routine.

Maud, looking up from her work, would see the frown and the bitten lip.

She began again to feel uncomfortable and self-conscious as she worked.

Sometimes their conversation on the way to the Tube was almost formal.

It was useless to say anything. She had a wholesome horror of being one

of those women who nagged; and she felt that to complain again would

amount to nagging. She tried to put the thing out of her mind, but it

insisted on staying there. In a way she understood his feelings. He

loved her so much, she supposed, that he hated the idea of her

exchanging a single word with another man. This, in the abstract, was

gratifying; but in practice it distressed her. She wished she were some

sort of foreigner, so that nobody could talk to her. But then they

would look at her, and that probably would produce much the same

results. It was a hard world for a girl.

And then the strange thing happened. Arthur reformed. One might almost

say that he reformed with a jerk. It was a parallel case to those

sudden conversions at Welsh revival meetings. On Monday evening he had

been at his worst. On the following morning he was a changed man. Not

even after the original thunderstorm had he been more docile. Maud

could not believe that first. The lip, once bitten, was stretched in a

smile. She looked for the frown. It was not there.

Next day it was the same; and the day after that. When a week had gone

by, and still the improvement was maintained, Maud felt that she might

now look upon it as permanent. A great load seemed to have been taken

off her mind. She revised her views on the world. It was a very good

world, quite one of the best, with Arthur beaming upon it like a sun.

A number of eminent poets and essayists, in the course of the last few

centuries, have recorded, in their several ways, their opinion that one

can have too much of a good thing. The truth applies even to such a

good thing as absence of jealousy. Little by little Maud began to grow

uneasy. It began to come home to her that she preferred the old Arthur,

of the scowl and the gnawed lip. Of him she had at least been sure.

Whatever discomfort she may have suffered from his spirited imitations

of Othello, at any rate they had proved that he loved her. She would

have accepted gladly an equal amount of discomfort now in exchange for

the same certainty. She could not read this new Arthur. His thoughts

were a closed book. Superficially, he was all that she could have

wished. He still continued to escort her to the Tube, to buy her

occasional presents, to tap, when conversing, the pleasantly

sentimental vein. But now these things were not enough. Her heart was

troubled. Her thoughts frightened her. The little black imp at the back

of her mind kept whispering and whispering, till at last she was forced

to listen. 'He's tired of you. He doesn't love you any more. He's tired

of you.'

* * * * *

It is not everybody who, in times of mental stress, can find ready to

hand among his or her personal acquaintances an expert counsellor,

prepared at a moment's notice to listen with sympathy and advise with

tact and skill. Everyone's world is full of friends, relatives, and

others, who will give advice on any subject that may be presented to

them; but there are crises in life which cannot be left to the amateur.

It is the aim of a certain widely read class of paper to fill this

void.

Of this class _Fireside Chat_ was one of the best-known

representatives. In exchange for one penny its five hundred thousand

readers received every week a serial story about life in highest

circles, a short story packed with heart-interest, articles on the

removal of stains and the best method of coping with the cold mutton,

anecdotes of Royalty, photographs of peeresses, hints on dress, chats

about baby, brief but pointed dialogues between Blogson and Snogson,

poems, Great Thoughts from the Dead and Brainy, half-hours in the

editor's cosy sanctum, a slab of brown paper, and--the journal's

leading feature--Advice on Matters of the Heart. The weekly

contribution of the advice specialist of _Fireside Chat_, entitled

'In the Consulting Room, by Dr Cupid', was made up mainly of Answers to

Correspondents. He affected the bedside manner of the kind, breezy old

physician; and probably gave a good deal of comfort. At any rate, he

always seemed to have plenty of cases on his hands.

It was to this expert that Maud took her trouble. She had been a

regular reader of the paper for several years; and had, indeed,

consulted the great man once before, when he had replied favourably to

her query as to whether it would be right for her to accept caramels

from Arthur, then almost a stranger. It was only natural that she

should go to him now, in an even greater dilemma. The letter was not

easy to write, but she finished it at last; and, after an anxious

interval, judgement was delivered as follows:

'Well, well, well! Bless my soul, what is all this? M. P. writes me:

'I am a young lady, and until recently was very, very happy, except

that my fiance, though truly loving me, was of a very jealous

disposition, though I am sure I gave him no cause. He would scowl when

I spoke to any other man, and this used to make me unhappy. But for

some time now he has quite changed, and does not seem to mind at all,

and though at first this made me feel happy, to think that he had got

over his jealousy, I now feel unhappy because I am beginning to be

afraid that he no longer cares for me. Do you think this is so, and

what ought I to do?'

'My dear young lady, I should like to be able to reassure you; but it

is kindest sometimes, you know, to be candid, however it may hurt. It

has been my experience that, when jealousy flies out of the window,

indifference comes in at the door. In the old days a knight would joust

for the love of a ladye, risking physical injury rather than permit

others to rival him in her affections. I think, M. P., that you should

endeavour to discover the true state of your fiance's feelings. I do

not, of course, advocate anything in the shape of unwomanly behaviour,

of which I am sure, my dear young lady, you are incapable; but I think

that you should certainly try to pique your fiance, to test him. At

your next ball, for instance, refuse him a certain number of dances, on

the plea that your programme is full. At garden-parties, at-homes, and

so on, exhibit pleasure in the society and conversation of other

gentlemen, and mark his demeanour as you do so. These little tests

should serve either to relieve your apprehensions, provided they are

groundless, or to show you the truth. And, after all, if it is the

truth, it must be faced, must it not, M. P.?'

Before the end of the day Maud knew the whole passage by heart. The

more her mind dwelt on it, the more clearly did it seem to express what

she had felt but could not put into words. The point about jousting

struck her as particularly well taken. She had looked up 'joust' in the

dictionary, and it seemed to her that in these few words was contained

the kernel of her trouble. In the old days, if any man had attempted to

rival him in her affections (outside business hours), Arthur would

undoubtedly have jousted--and jousted with the vigour of one who means

to make his presence felt. Now, in similar circumstances, he would

probably step aside politely, as who should say, 'After you, my dear

Alphonse.'

There was no time to lose. An hour after her first perusal of Dr

Cupid's advice, Maud had begun to act upon it. By the time the first

lull in the morning's work had come, and there was a chance for private

conversation, she had invented an imaginary young man, a shadowy

Lothario, who, being introduced into her home on the previous Sunday by

her brother Horace, had carried on in a way you wouldn't believe,

paying all manner of compliments.

'He said I had such white hands,' said Maud.

Arthur nodded, stropping a razor the while. He appeared to be bearing

the revelations with complete fortitude. Yet, only a few weeks before,

a customer's comment on this same whiteness had stirred him to his

depths.

'And this morning--what do you think? Why, he meets me as bold as you

please, and gives me a cake of toilet soap. Like his impudence!'

She paused, hopefully.

'Always useful, soap,' said Arthur, politely sententious.

'Lovely it was,' went on Maud, dully conscious of failure, but

stippling in like an artist the little touches which give atmosphere

and verisimilitude to a story. 'All scented. Horace will tease me about

it, I can tell you.'

She paused. Surely he must--Why, a sea-anemone would be torn with

jealousy at such a tale.

Arthur did not even wince. He was charming about it. Thought it very

kind of the young fellow. Didn't blame him for being struck by the

whiteness of her hands. Touched on the history of soap, which he

happened to have been reading up in the encyclopedia at the free

library. And behaved altogether in such a thoroughly gentlemanly

fashion that Maud stayed awake half the night, crying.

* * * * *

If Maud had waited another twenty-four hours there would have been no

need for her to have taxed her powers of invention, for on the

following day there entered the shop and her life a young man who was

not imaginary--a Lothario of flesh and blood. He made his entry with

that air of having bought most of the neighbouring property which

belongs exclusively to minor actors, men of weight on the Stock

Exchange, and American professional pugilists.

Mr 'Skipper' Shute belonged to the last-named of the three classes. He

had arrived in England two months previously for the purpose of holding

a conference at eight-stone four with one Joseph Edwardes, to settle a

question of superiority at that weight which had been vexing the

sporting public of two countries for over a year. Having successfully

out-argued Mr Edwardes, mainly by means of strenuous work in the

clinches, he was now on the eve of starting on a lucrative music-hall

tour with his celebrated inaudible monologue. As a result of these

things he was feeling very, very pleased with the world in general, and

with Mr Skipper Shute in particular. And when Mr Shute was pleased with

himself his manner was apt to be of the breeziest.

He breezed into the shop, took a seat, and, having cast an experienced

eye at Maud, and found her pleasing, extended both hands, and observed,

'Go the limit, kid.'

At any other time Maud might have resented being addressed as 'kid' by

a customer, but now she welcomed it. With the exception of a slight

thickening of the lobe of one ear, Mr Shute bore no outward signs of

his profession. And being, to use his own phrase, a 'swell dresser', he

was really a most presentable young man. Just, in fact, what Maud

needed. She saw in him her last hope. If any faint spark of his ancient

fire still lingered in Arthur, it was through Mr Shute that it must be

fanned.

She smiled upon Mr Shute. She worked on his robust fingers as if it

were an artistic treat to be permitted to handle them. So carefully did

she toil that she was still busy when Arthur, taking off his apron and

putting on his hat, went out for his twenty-minutes' lunch, leaving

them alone together.

The door had scarcely shut when Mr Shute bent forward.

'Say!'

He sank his voice to a winning whisper.

'You look good to muh,' he said, gallantly.

'The idea!' said Maud, tossing her head.

'On the level,' Mr Shute assured her.

Maud laid down her orange-sticks.

'Don't be silly,' she said. 'There--I've finished.'

'I've not,' said Mr Shute. 'Not by a mile. Say!'

'Well?'

'What do you do with your evenings?'

'I go home.'

'Sure. But when you don't? It's a poor heart that never rejoices. Don't

you ever whoop it up?'

'Whoop it up?'

'The mad whirl,' explained Mr Shute. 'Ice-cream soda and buck-wheat

cakes, and a happy evening at lovely Luna Park.'

'I don't know where Luna Park is.'

'What did they teach you at school? It's out in that direction,' said

Mr Shute, pointing over his shoulder. 'You go straight on about three

thousand miles till you hit little old New York; then you turn to the

right. Say, don't you ever get a little treat? Why not come along to

the White City some old evening? This evening?'

'Mr Welsh is taking me to the White City tonight.'

'And who is Mr Welsh?'

'The gentleman who has just gone out.'

'Is that so? Well, he doesn't look a live one, but maybe it's just

because he's had bad news today. You never can tell.' He rose.

'Farewell, Evelina, fairest of your sex. We shall meet again; so keep a

stout heart.'

And, taking up his cane, straw hat, and yellow gloves, Mr Shute

departed, leaving Maud to her thoughts.

She was disappointed. She had expected better results. Mr Shute had

lowered with ease the record for gay badinage, hitherto held by the

red-faced customer; yet to all appearances there had been no change in

Arthur's manner. But perhaps he had scowled (or bitten his lip), and

she had not noticed it. Apparently he had struck Mr Shute, an unbiased

spectator, as gloomy. Perhaps at some moment when her eyes had been on

her work--She hoped for the best.

Whatever his feelings may have been during the afternoon, Arthur was

undeniably cheerful that evening. He was in excellent spirits. His

light-hearted abandon on the Wiggle-Woggle had been noted and commented

upon by several lookers-on. Confronted with the Hairy Ainus, he had

touched a high level of facetiousness. And now, as he sat with her

listening to the band, he was crooning joyously to himself in

accompaniment to the music, without, it would appear, a care in the

world.

Maud was hurt and anxious. In a mere acquaintance this blithe attitude

would have been welcome. It would have helped her to enjoy her evening.

But from Arthur at that particular moment she looked for something

else. Why was he cheerful? Only a few hours ago she had been--yes,

flirting with another man before his very eyes. What right had he to be

cheerful? He ought to be heated, full of passionate demands for an

explanation--a flushed, throaty thing to be coaxed back into a good

temper and then forgiven--all this at great length--for having been in

a bad one. Yes, she told herself, she had wanted certainty one way or

the other, and here it was. Now she knew. He no longer cared for her.

She trembled.

'Cold?' said Arthur. 'Let's walk. Evenings beginning to draw in now.

Lum-da-diddley-ah. That's what I call a good tune. Give me something

lively and bright. Dumty-umpty-iddley-ah. Dum tum--'

'Funny thing--' said Maud, deliberately.

'What's a funny thing?'

'The gentleman in the brown suit whose hands I did this afternoon--'

'He was,' agreed Arthur, brightly. 'A very funny thing.'

Maud frowned. Wit at the expense of Hairy Ainus was one thing--at her

own another.

'I was about to say,' she went on precisely, 'that it was a funny

thing, a coincidence, seeing that I was already engaged, that the

gentleman in the brown suit whose hands I did this afternoon should

have asked me to come here, to the White City, with him tonight.'

For a moment they walked on in silence. To Maud it seemed a hopeful

silence. Surely it must be the prelude to an outburst.

'Oh!' he said, and stopped.

Maud's heart gave a leap. Surely that was the old tone?

A couple of paces, and he spoke again.

'I didn't hear him ask you.'

His voice was disappointingly level.

'He asked me after you had gone out to lunch.'

'It's a nuisance,' said Arthur, cheerily, 'when things clash like that.

But perhaps he'll ask you again. Nothing to prevent you coming here

twice. Well repays a second visit, I always say. I think--'

'You shouldn't,' said a voice behind him. 'It hurts the head. Well,

kid, being shown a good time?'

The possibility of meeting Mr Shute had not occurred to Maud. She had

assumed that, being aware that she would be there with another, he

would have stayed away. It may, however, be remarked that she did not

know Mr Shute. He was not one of your sensitive plants. He smiled

pleasantly upon her, looking very dapper in evening dress and a silk

hat that, though a size too small for him, shone like a mirror.

Maud hardly knew whether she was glad or sorry to see him. It did not

seem to matter much now either way. Nothing seemed to matter much, in

fact. Arthur's cheery acceptance of the news that she received

invitations from others had been like a blow, leaving her numb and

listless.

She made the introductions. The two men eyed each other.

'Pleased to meet you,' said Mr Shute.

'Weather keeps up,' said Arthur.

And from that point onward Mr Shute took command.

It is to be assumed that this was not the first time that Mr Shute had

made one of a trio in these circumstances, for the swift dexterity with

which he lost Arthur was certainly not that of a novice. So smoothly

was it done that it was not until she emerged from the Witching Waves,

guided by the pugilist's slim but formidable right arm, that Maud

realized that Arthur had gone.

She gave a little cry of dismay. Secretly she was beginning to be

somewhat afraid of Mr Shute. He was showing signs of being about to

step out of the role she had assigned to him and attempt something on a

larger scale. His manner had that extra touch of warmth which makes all

the difference.

'Oh! He's gone!' she cried.

'Sure,' said Mr Shute. 'He's got a hurry-call from the Uji Village.

The chief's cousin wants a hair-cut.'

'We must find him. We must.'

'Surest thing you know,' said Mr Shute. 'Plenty of time.'

'We must find him.'

Mr Shute regarded her with some displeasure.

'Seems to be ace-high with you, that dub,' he said.

'I don't understand you.'

'My observation was,' explained Mr Shute, coldly, 'that, judging from

appearances, that dough-faced lemon was Willie-boy, the first and only

love.'

Maud turned on him with flaming cheeks.

'Mr Welsh is nothing to me! Nothing! Nothing!' she cried.

She walked quickly on.

'Then, if there's a vacancy, star-eyes,' said the pugilist at her side,

holding on a hat which showed a tendency to wobble, 'count me in.

Directly I saw you--see here, what's the idea of this road-work? We

aren't racing--'

Maud slowed down.

'That's better. As I was saying, directly I saw you, I said to myself,

"That's the one you need. The original candy kid. The--"'

His hat lurched drunkenly as he answered the girl's increase of speed.

He cursed it in a brief aside.

'That's what I said. "The original candy kid." So--'

The Man Upstairs and Other Stories · 第 27 / 57 题