IN AND ABOUT OUR VIRGIN ISLANDS
“It’s all I can do to keep from barking at you,” said a passenger on the
_Virginia_, as he crawled on hands and knees from one of the four
kennels that decorate her afterdeck. As a matter of fact, we all did a
certain amount of growling before the voyage was over. Yet the four of
us who had won the kennels were lucky dogs compared to the unfortunate
dozen or more who had to snatch what sleep they could curled up on the
bare deck or in a single sour-smelling cabin below, where neither color,
sex nor seasickness knew any distinction.
The weakest link in the shipping chain down the West Indies is that
between our own possessions. Once a week a little schooner that was
built to defend America’s yachting championship, but which never reached
the finals, raises its wings in San Juan harbor and, the winds willing,
drops a flock of disgruntled passengers, the United States mails, and an
assorted cargo in St. Thomas and St. Croix in time to return for a
similar venture seven days later. Congressional committees, of course,
have their battleships, and the white-uniformed governors of our Virgin
Islands their commodious steam-yacht; but the mere garden variety of
tax-paying citizen has the privilege of tossing about for several days
on the _Virginia_, subsisting on such food as he has had the foresight
to bring with him, and drinking such lukewarm water as he can coax from
the schooner’s cask.
It is nearly fifty miles from Porto Rico to St. Thomas. All day long our
racing yacht crawled along the coast, San Juan and the island’s
culminating peak, El Yunque, equally immovable on the horizon, while the
half-grown crew alternated between pumping water from the hold and
playfully disobeying the orders of the forceless old mulatto captain.
Nine at night found us opposite Fajardo light—more than an hour by
automobile from our starting-point! While the crew slept, without so
much as posting a lookout, a boy of thirteen sat at the wheel, and the
kennel-less passengers tossed restlessly on their chosen deck spots. A
half-grown pig—the only traveler on board whose ticket specified ship’s
food—wandered disconsolately fore and aft, now and then demanding
admission to one or another of the four “cabins.” No doubt he recognized
them as built for his own, rather than the human, species.
[Illustration: The new church of Guayama, Porto Rico]
[Illustration: A Porto Rican ex-soldier working as road peon. He gathers
the grass with a wooden hook and cuts it with a small sickle]
[Illustration: Porto Rican tobacco fields]
[Illustration: Charlotte Amalie, capital of our Virgin Islands]
Sunrise overtook us still within sight of Porto Rico, but with her
dependencies of Culebra and Vieques abeam, and the hazy mass of the
Virgin group visible on the horizon ahead. Brown, rugged, strangely
aged-looking, Culebra showed no signs of life except the lighthouse set
upon its highest cliff. Vieques, on the other hand, known to
English-speaking mariners as “Crab Island,” is a diminutive replica of
Porto Rico, with four large sugar-mills and a population of some eleven
thousand, American citizens all. The Danes once claimed this also, but
Spanish buccaneers established the more efficacious right of actual
possession, and at length the Porto Rican Government sent an expedition
to annex it to the Spanish crown.
With monotonous deliberation the Virgin group grew in size and
visibility. St. Thomas and St. John took on individuality amid their
flock of rocky keys, and British Tórtola gradually asserted its
aloofness from the American islands. Far off on the blue-gray horizon we
could even make out St. Croix, like a stain on the inverted bowl of sky.
Yet, though the breeze was strong, it was a head wind, and the ocean
current sweeping in from the eastward held us all but motionless when we
seemed to be cutting swiftly through the light waves. For five profane
hours we tacked to and fro within gunshot of a towering white boulder
jutting forth from the sea, and fittingly known as Sail Rock, without
seeming to advance a mile on our journey.
We turned the isolated precipice at last, and headed in toward
mountainous St. Thomas. Neither its scattered keys nor its long broken
coast-line showed any evidence of habitation, but at length three white
specks appeared on its water’s edge, and grew with the afternoon to a
semblance of Charlotte Amalie, a city rivaled in its beauty, at a
distance, by few others even in the beautiful West Indies. We greeted it
with fervent exclamations of delight, piled up white and radiant in the
moonlight on its three hills, like occupants of royal boxes at some gala
performance in its amphitheatrical harbor below. Scarcely a sound came
from it, however, except the languid swish of the waves on what seemed
to be the base of its lower houses, as we dropped anchor near midnight
within rowboat distance of the wharves. It had been an unusually swift
voyage, according to the uncommanding captain, a mere two days instead
of the four or five it frequently requires.
In due course of time a negro youth rowed out to examine us. He was an
exceedingly courteous negro, to be sure, his white uniform was spotless,
and his English impeccable; but there was something incongruous in the
fact that American citizens must have his permission to be admitted into
one American possession from another. The “Grand Hotel,” which virtually
monopolizes the accommodation of transients in St. Thomas, could not
house us, or rather, on second thought, it could, if we would be
contented in the “annex” over a barber-shop across the street. Its
creaking floors were unbroken expanses of spaciousness, but at least
there was a mahogany four-poster in one corner. We sat down on it with a
sigh of contentment—and quickly stood up again, under the impression
that we had inadvertently sat upon the floor. The Virgin Islands have
not yet reached that decadent degree of civilization that requires
bed-springs. As to a bath—certainly, it should be brought at once; and a
half hour later a loose-kneed negro wandered in and set down on the
floor, with the rattle of a hardware-shop in a tornado, a large tin pan,
red with rust. All we had to do, explained the ultra-courteous octoroon
manager, was to call another negro to bring a pail of water _when_—and
the emphasis suggested that the time was still far off—we “desired to
perform our ablutions.” The tub-bearer was evidently too worn out from
his extraordinary exertion to indulge in another before he had taken
time to recuperate.
That loose-kneed stroll of the Virgin-Islander is typical of all his
processes, mental, moral, or physical. It is not merely slow,
rhythmical, and dignified; there is in it a suggestion of limitless
wealth, an untroubled conscience, and an ancestry devoted to leisurely
pursuits for untold generations. In local parlance a “five minutes’
walk” means a block. One must not even speak hastily to a native, for
the only result is wasted breath and the necessity of repeating the
question in more measured cadences. Politeness oozes from his every
pore; “at your sarvice, sar,” and “only too glad to be of use, ma’am,”
interlard every conversation; but any attempt, courteous or otherwise,
to hurry the Virgin Islander brings a sullen resentment which you will
never succeed in smiling away. As the navy men who are governing him put
it in the technical vernacular of their calling, he has only two
speeds,—“Slow Ahead” and “Stop.”
Once the visitor has shaken off the no doubt ridiculous notion that
things should be done in a hurry, or done at all, for that matter, he
will find our newly adopted children an amusing addition to the family.
Like all negroes in contact with civilization, they are fond of
four-jointed words where monosyllables would suffice, and of pompous,
rounded sentences in place of brief-to-the-point statements. “Presently”
means “now”; “He detained from coming” is the local form of “he can’t
come.” Talking is one of the Virgin Islanders’ chief recreations. They
buttonhole the unknown passer-by and unburden themselves to him at
endless length, ceaselessly chattering on until he can forge some excuse
to tear himself away, when they hasten to ask their friends if they,
too, have seen “the stranger with the beard,” “the American who arrived
last night,” “that rich-looking gentleman in a white helmet,” that the
friends may not lose their chance of waylaying the victim who is already
listening to a new monologue around the corner. If they can not find a
hearer, they do not for that reason abandon their favorite sport; it is
commonplace to meet a pedestrian, particularly a woman, chattering
volubly to herself as she shuffles along the street.
Their lack of self-restraint is on a par with their loquacity. When the
first navy hydroplanes flew into the harbor, the entire population
became a screaming mob of neck-craning, pointing, shoulder-clapping,
occupation-forgetting children. The winner of a dollar at the local
“horse” races, in which the island donkeys are now and then pitted
against one another, may be seen turning somersaults in the midst of the
crowd, or throwing himself on the ground, all fours clawing the air, as
he shrieks his ecstasies of delight. It is their joy to parade the
streets in their gayest costumes on any holiday, American, Danish, or
imaginable, that can be dragged into the calendar, dancing and capering
with an energy which their work-a-day manner never suggests. Once a
month, at full moon, the local band marches through the town playing
“Onward, Christian Soldiers,” the population trailing en masse behind
it, singing, clapping hands, and swaying their rather slender, underfed
bodies violently in cadence with the music. They are ardent church-goers
in theory, there being six large churches of as many denominations in
town—but it takes a rousing round of hymns to bring the majority to
indoor services, though boatmen far out in the bay recognize a street
meeting of the Salvation Army by the howling chorus of “Lord, ha’ mercy
on mah sou-ul,” which the cliffs echo out to them.
The Sunday evening band concert, on the other hand, is staid enough to
make a Spanish-American _retreta_ seem uproarious by comparison. It
begins at nine, after the last church service of a Britishly dead
Sunday. The native band, recruited by the administrative Americans, jet
black in features and snow-white in uniform, mounts to the roof of the
old red fortress, while outwardly immaculate negroes, stroll rather
funereally about little Emancipation Park and along the edge of the
quay. The élite of the town sit in their houses, piled steeply up the
pyramidal hills, and let the music float up to them on the harbor
breeze. Our new fellow-countrymen are ostentatiously patriotic in all
that concerns mere formalities. Every morning at eight all St. Thomas
becomes static when the marine band plays our national anthem. The
market-women on the wharf halt as if suddenly turned to stone, holding
whatever posture they happen to be caught in until the last note has
died away; the very boatmen in the bay sit with their poised oars
motionless. Flags burst forth not merely on our own holidays, but on
Danish, on every possible fête day, public or private, even on the
birthdays of distant relatives or mere friends. Curious superstitions
enliven the quaint local color. The appearance of a lizard in the house
is sure proof to the lower classes that there is soon to be an addition
to the family. Servant girls cannot be induced to remove their hats,
whether cooking, making beds, or waiting on table at the most formal
dinner, for fear of sudden death from “dew” falling on their
heads—though it be full blazing noonday.
The great majority of the population is undernourished. Even when their
earnings are sufficient, most of the money is spent on dress. The chief
diet of the rank and file is sugar. A sugar-cane three times a day seems
to be enough to keep many of them alive. The morning meal for the rest
consists of “tea” only, the local meaning of that word being a cupful of
sugar dissolved in warm water. Then along in the middle of the afternoon
they indulge in their only real food, and not very real at that. This is
a plate of “fungee,” a nauseating mixture of fish and corn-meal, which
to the local taste is preferable to the most succulent beefsteak. The
natural result of the constant consumption of sugar is an early scarcity
of teeth. Barely three men in twenty could be enlisted in the native
corps, chiefly because of their inability to cope with navy rations.
It goes without saying that such a population does not furnish model
workmen. From Friday night to Tuesday morning is apt to be treated as
“the Sabbath.” The man who works two days a week at eighty cents has
enough to provide himself with sugar-cane and “fungee.” On the whole,
the women are more industrious than the men, perhaps because the great
disparity of sexes makes the possession of a “man” something in the
nature of a luxury. Time was when the women of St. Thomas were able to
support their husbands in a more fitting manner than at present. In the
good old days hundreds of ships coaled here every month; now many a day
passes without one bringing a throng of negresses scampering for the
coaling-wharf far out beyond “Bluebeard’s Castle.” In a constant stream
the soot-draped women jog up the gang-plank, balancing the eighty-pound
basket of coal on their heads, often without touching it, thrust out a
begrimed hand for the three cents a trip which a local labor leader has
won them in place of the original one, drop the coins into a dust-laden
pocket, dump their load into the steamer’s chute, and trot down again.
Sometimes the ship is a man-of-war that unfairly speeds up the pace of
coalers by having its band play rousing music on the upper deck. Here
and there a man may be made out in the endless chain of black humanity.
At least one of them works with his wife as a “team”—by carrying the
empty basket back to be filled while she mounts with the full one. But
most of the males have the point of view of the big “buck nigger” who
was lying in the shade of the coal-pile watching the process with an air
of languid contentment. “Why de coalin’ is done by women, sah?” he
repeated, scratching his head for a reply. “Why, dat’s woman’s work.”
The population of our Virgin Islands is overwhelmingly negro. Even
Charlotte Amalie cannot muster one white man to ten of African ancestry,
and not a fourth of the latter show any Caucasian mixture. Once upon a
time the Jews were numerous; there is still a Jewish cemetery, but the
synagogue has been abandoned for lack of congregation. Though the
islands were Danish for nearly two and a half centuries, their language
has always been English, probably because their business has ever been
with ships and men who, though it may not always have been their native
tongue, spoke the language of the sea. Some six years before we
purchased the islands the Danes made an attempt to teach Danish in the
schools. But though many little negroes learned to chatter more or less
fluently in that tongue, to the detriment of more essential studies, the
local environment proved too strong, and the very Danish officials
became proficient in English in spite of themselves, though even the
British school superintendent was required to write his correspondence
and reports in the official tongue.
The only element of the population that has never succumbed to its
environment, either racially or linguistically, are the “Chachas.” They
are a community of French fishermen, who have themselves lost any
certain notion of how they came to be stranded on rocky St. Thomas. Some
two hundred of them live in their own village on the outskirts of
Charlotte Amalie; others are scattered along the trail to a similar
village called Hull, on the opposite side of the island. Intermarriage
has given them all a striking family resemblance, and it is hours before
the newcomer realizes that it is not the same man he has met over and
over again, peddling his fish, his goats, or his crude straw hats in the
streets of the town, but a score of more or less close relatives. They
have preserved their blood pure from the slightest negro strain; but
their aloofness has given them a sort of sick-bed pallor, an anemia both
of physique and manner, especially among the women, an almost complete
loss of teeth, and little power to resist disease. Yet the men at least
have by no means lost their old “pep.” They can still fight in a
two-fisted manner that is the awe of their negro neighbors, and they
venture fearlessly far out to sea in their little narrow-chested fishing
boats.
The adults speak a perfectly comprehensible French, but the “creole” of
the children is but little improvement on that of Haiti. For many years
they had their own school, taught by an old Frenchman who drew the
princely salary of five dollars a month. Since his death the children
have been attending the English-speaking Catholic school, and some of
them already mispronounce a certain amount of that tongue—and can beg as
fluently as the little black urchins that swarm about any white
stranger. But their aloofness from the colored population remains. The
latter scorn them as only a negro can the white man who has fallen
socially to his own level, though they take care not to refer to them by
the popular nickname within reach of their hardened fists. The term is
said to have had its origin in the word _chasser_ with which the
fishermen interlard their cries. They call themselves _français_, and
have a simplicity which suggests they have followed the same calling for
many generations. Their houses are mere cabins, with shingled walls and
thatched roofs, scattered about the sand knolls at the edge of the bay.
These are always floored, decorated with a few chromo prints of a
religious nature, and have a better claim to neatness than the hovels of
the negroes about them. While the latter loaf, the “Chachas” ply their
chosen calling diligently, but on Sunday afternoons they may be found in
groups, playing cards in the shade of their date palms, their curious
hats of sewn ribbons of straw tossed on the sandy soil about them. They
profess complete indifference to their island’s change of sovereignty,
except to wonder in vague voices if it is this that has brought the
appalling increase in the prices of food.
* * * * *
Seen from any of its three hills, Charlotte Amalie looks more like a
stage setting than a real town. Its sheet-iron roofs, many of them
painted red, seem to be cut out of cardboard, and the steepness of the
slopes on which the majority of its houses are built suggests the
fantasy of the scene-painter rather than cold practicability. A single
long, level street, still known, on its placards at least, as
Kronprindsens Gade, runs the length of the town and contains nearly all
its commerce. The rest start bravely up the steep hills, but soon tire,
like the inhabitants, and leave their task incompleted. On the eastern
side, where the storms come from, the houses have glass windows, almost
unknown in the larger islands to the westward, and are fitted on all
sides with heavy wooden hurricane-shutters. If these are closed in time,
the roofs can withstand the frequent high winds that sweep down upon the
island, but the local weather prophet has an unenviable task, for to
give the signal for closing the shutters when there is no need for it is
as reprehensible from the native point of view as to fail to foresee
real danger. Bulky stone or brick ovens, separate from the houses, are
the only buildings with chimneys, and many of these were mutilated by
the hurricane of four years ago. Palm-trees and great masses of red and
purple bougainvillea add a crowning beauty to a scene that would be
entrancing even without them.
Of a score of solemn old buildings the most imposing is the residence of
the governor on the middle of the three hills. Higher still stands a
grim tower known as “Blackbeard’s Castle,” about which cling many
legends, but no other certainty than that it was built by a turbulent
colonist of long ago, who was credited, justly no doubt, since that clan
has not wholly died out in St. Thomas to this day, with being a pirate.
But this structure is of slight interest to the average visitor compared
to a similar one on the eastern hill, reputed far and wide as the
original “Bluebeard’s Castle.” Just how it gained this reputation is not
easily apparent, for its real history is almost an open book. Built by
the Danish government in 1700 as a fort, probably to overawe the slaves
in the town below, it remained the property of the king until a century
ago, when it fell into private hands. If any other proof of its entirely
unromantic character is needed, it is sufficient to know that it now
belongs to an Episcopal clergyman living in Brooklyn!
With stone walls five feet thick, three rooms one above the other, and
all in all a pitiless visage, the tower easily lends itself to the
imagination as the scene of marital treachery. The old negro caretaker
will assure you that the dreadful crimes took place in it “jes’ like de
storybook tell.” The yarn that has a wider local belief is somewhat
different. According to this an old trader married a beautiful girl of
Charlotte Amalie and locked her up in the castle while he left the
island on business. During his absence she discovered a mysterious old
chest in the upper story and finally yielded to the feminine impulse to
open it. In it she found letters from a dozen of her husband’s discarded
sweethearts, all of whom still lived in the town. She invited them to a
banquet in the castle—the significant detail of how she got the door
open being passed over in silence—and poisoned them. From there on the
tale forks. One ending has it that the husband returned, repented, and
committed suicide while the beautiful wife was being tried for murder;
the other, that he rushed in and carried her off just as she was about
to be burned at the stake.
The eyes of the modern visitor are sure to be drawn to what looks like
an attempt to pave a large section of the steep hill behind the town. A
great triangular patch of cement gleaming in the sun on one of the
slopes brings to mind the island’s greatest problem. St. Thomas depends
entirely upon the rains for her water-supply, for the water to be had by
boring is so brackish that it ruins even a steamer’s boilers. When
renting or buying a house the most important question is to know the
size and condition of its cistern and what provision has been made for
filling it. In the dry season, which is heartlessly long and appallingly
dry, the poorer people wander from house to house begging a “pan” of
water, and the word means a receptacle of any size or shape that will
hold the precious liquid. The town is convinced that its commercial
decline is due to its lack of water, and that it will come into its own
again if only Uncle Sam will cover its hillsides with cement or
galvanized iron. If they had immense cisterns and a means of filling
them, they say, ships would no longer go to Ponce for water, and perhaps
pick up their coal in Porto Rico also, but would put in at St. Thomas
for all their supplies. To make matters worse, the change of sovereignty
has brought with it the inability to furnish other liquids for which
sea-faring men have looked to St. Thomas for centuries. That seemed the
last straw, but another has since been added to the already crushing
burden. St. Thomas has long been famous for its bay rum. As a matter of
fact the bay oil comes from St. John and the rum came from St. Croix,
until the colonial council voted the islands “dry”—“as if we were not
dry enough already.” But the mixture and sale thereof brought many a
dollar into local pockets. Soon after the “dry” law went into effect,
the natives, to say nothing of our thirsty marines, made the brilliant
discovery that the addition of a bit of bay oil to their favorite
refreshment left it none the less exhilarating. Banished hilarity
returned. The governor was shocked beyond measure, and the sale even of
bay rum is now forbidden except on a police permit, issued only on proof
that it was not to be used for beverage purposes. It is almost as easy
to prove that the moon is made of green cheese. The Virgin Islanders
have several grievances against the Americans who have adopted them, the
strictness of their color-line, for instance; but the greatest of these
is prohibition.
* * * * *
The cluster of islands just east of Porto Rico was discovered by
Columbus on his second voyage; anything that escaped him on the first
journey seems to enjoy at least that secondary distinction. He named
them the Eleven Thousand Virgins; just why, not even his biographers
seem to know. It may be that he had just been awakened from a bad dream,
or possibly the expression was an old-fashioned Italian form of
profanity. It would be easy to think of a more appropriate name, but
they have remained the Virgin Islands to this day.
The Spaniards stopped long enough to exterminate the Indians, but it was
a long time before any one thought it worth while to settle in such a
region. Nothing is more natural than that the name should finally have
attracted to it a party of Frenchmen. Evidently they found it
disappointing, for they did not increase. Then the Danish West India
Company laid claim to St. Thomas and its adjacent islands, and in 1671 a
governor was sent out from Denmark, who founded the town of Charlotte
Amalie, which he named for the then Danish queen. Of course the British
captured the place a few times, and it was often harassed by fires,
hurricanes, and slave rebellions, all of which it more or less
successfully survived. St. Thomas became a harbor of refuge for pirates,
and it frequently became necessary for the English governor of Nevis to
raid it—for the British, you remember, did not believe in piracy. When
the gentlemen enlisted under the skull-and-cross-bones banner had gone
the way of all rascals, the island soon won a place of importance as a
distributing center for slaves.
Meanwhile St. Croix, which is neither geographically, geologically, nor
historically a bona fide member of the Virgin group, had been having a
history of its own. The Knights of Malta colonized it first with three
hundred Frenchmen, but these soon decided that Santo Domingo offered
better real estate possibilities. Then when the Dutch and the British
had concluded that France had a better armed right to it, the latter
sold it to the Danish Company for 750,000 livres. Just how much that was
in real money I am not in a position to state, beyond the assertion that
it would buy far more then than it will nowadays. Thenceforth St. Croix
has followed the fate of the other Danish West Indies.
Many of the colonists were disturbers of the peace or agitators, the
Bolshevists, in short, of those days, who found it to their advantage to
abandon the near-by French and British Leeward Islands. They became too
much for the Company, which in 1764 sold the whole collection to the
Danish crown. All three of the islands of any importance were long
planted in sugar-cane. It covered even the tops of the hills, those of
St. Thomas being cultivated by hand in little stone-faced terraces.
To-day sugar-cane has completely disappeared from St. Thomas, almost
entirely from St. John, and is grown only on the level southern side of
St. Croix. Several slave uprisings had been suppressed with more or less
bloodshed when Denmark subscribed to the then astounding theory that
slavery should be abolished. The agricultural importance of the islands
began at once to decline. Free labor was cheap, but it would not labor.
Then, too, the competition of sugar grown more economically elsewhere
and Napoleon’s establishment of a bounty for beet-sugar growers began to
make life dreary for all West Indian planters.
However, as their agriculture declined, the importance of the Danish
islands as a shipping and distributing center increased, though their
days of greatest prosperity were from 1820 to 1830, when the two
coincided. St. Thomas harbor was forested with the masts of sailing
vessels, carrying goods to and from the four points of the compass. Then
along came Robert Fulton with more trouble for the poor harassed
islanders. Steam navigation made it easy for the West Indies and South
America to import goods direct from Europe, and the Virgin Island
merchants began to lose their rake-off. They picked up, however, by
establishing a coaling station and making St. Thomas a free port and a
general depot of sea-going supplies. Before the World War scores of
ships entered the harbor every week; now the pilot often does not drop
his feet from his hammock to the floor for several days at a time.
For all this, the islands were a liability rather than an asset to the
Danes, and they had long been looking for some kind Samaritan to take
them off their hands. Under Lincoln, Secretary Seward negotiated a
treaty by which we were to have all the group except St. Croix for
$7,500,000. A vote of the population showed them overwhelmingly in favor
of the change; the Danish Government was paternal, but it was far away
and unprogressive. The treaty was ratified in Denmark. The king issued a
manifesto telling his loyal subjects how sorry he was to part with them,
but assuring them, as fathers always do, that it was for their own good.
He did not mention that he needed the money. Two years later he was
forced to admit in another royal document that he was not parting with
them, after all. Senator Sumner, chairman of our Foreign Relations
Committee, did not walk hand in hand with President Johnson. For two
years he kept the treaty in his official pocket, and when it did at
length reappear under Grant, it was adversely reported.
In 1902 a better bargain was struck. A new treaty setting the price of
the whole group at $5,000,000 was drawn up, and ratified by the American
Senate. But this time the Danish Rigsdag turned the tables. Perhaps they
had inside information on the future development of American politics.
If so it proved trustworthy, for by 1916 we were in the hands of an
administration to whom mere money was no object. The Danes quickly
caught the idea, the people themselves voted to sell while the selling
was good, and on the last day of March, 1917, old Danneborg was hauled
down and the Stars and Stripes raised in its place.
* * * * *
I have yet to find any one who knows just why we bought the Virgin
Islands, still less why we paid twenty-five millions for them. As a navy
man engaged in governing them put it, “They are not worth forty cents to
us, or to any one else; though” he added, “it would have been worth a
hundred million to keep Germany from getting them.” If the loss of the
twenty-five millions were an end of the matter, we might forget it; but
it is costing us more than half a million a year to support our little
black children. Furthermore, the Danes made the most of their ripe
opportunity not only in the matter of price, but in an astonishing
number of concessions in their favor. Evidently our Government said to
them, “Go ahead and write a treaty, and we’ll sign it”; and then in the
press of saving the world for democracy we did not have time to glance
it over before adding our signature.
If a farmer bought a farm for, say, twenty-five hundred dollars, and
found, when he came to take possession of it, that it would cost him
fifty dollars a year out of his pocket to run it, that it was inhabited
by a happy-go-lucky lot of negroes who expected him to do many things
for them, from curing their wide-spread disease to sending them to
school; if, furthermore, he discovered that the former owners still held
everything on the farm that was worth owning except the title-deed, he
would probably give it away to the first unsuspecting tenderfoot who
happened along. Unfortunately, governments cannot indulge in that
dying-horse method of laying down their burdens. Even had the purchase
price of almost three hundred dollars an acre included everything of
monetary value on the islands, from the wardrobes of the inhabitants to
the last peasant’s hut, we should have made a bad bargain. But about all
we got for our twenty-five millions is the right to fly our flag over
the islands, and half a dozen old forts and government buildings
entirely stripped of their furniture. The Danish Government has the
reputation of being conservative and economical. It surely is, in more
senses than one. By the terms of the treaty “the movables, especially
the silver plate and the pictures, remain the property of the Danish
Government and shall, as soon as circumstances permit, be removed by
it.” By virtue of that clause they sold at auction every stick of
furniture in the public buildings; they tore the mirrors off the walls;
they removed the gilt moldings from them; they tried to tear off the
embossed leathery wall-paper, and left the rooms looking as if a party
of yeggmen had gutted them; they took down and carried away the rope on
the government flagpole! Economy is a splendid trait, but they might
have left us a chair in which to mourn the loss of our twenty-five—and
more—millions.
Everything worth owning in the islands is still in private, principally
Danish, hands. When we planned to erect a naval station on an utterly
worthless stony hill on St. Thomas harbor, the owners demanded
twenty-five hundred dollars an acre for it. We must maintain all the
grants, concessions, and licenses left by the Danish Government. “Det
Vestindiske Kompagni” retains most of the harbor privileges; another
Danish company, of which the principal shareholder is Prince Axel,
cousin of the king, holds the coaling rights, the electric lighting
rights, the right to operate a dry-dock. We cannot even use American
money in our new possessions. The Danish West Indian bank has the
exclusive concession for issuing notes until 1934, paying a ten per
cent. tax on profits to the Danish Government, and the good old
greenback must be exchanged for the domestic shin-plasters. Naval men
stationed in St. Thomas are forced to pay this institution as high as
two per cent. discount on their U. S. government pay checks; the yearly
budget of our new colony must be made in Danish francs. But though the
domestic money is officially in francs and “bits,” the people talk in
dollars and cents as universally as they speak English instead of
Danish. It is difficult to find anything left by the old régime that is
not protected by that curiously one-sided treaty. An American remarked
casually to an old Danish resident one evening as they were strolling
through Emancipation Park:
“I think we’ll tear down that old bust of King Christian IX and put one
of Lincoln in its place.”
“Vat?” shrieked the Dane. “You can’t do that. Eet ees in de treaty.”
By some oversight the Danes failed to provide for a few of the minor
concessions. There were the apothecaries, for instance. Under Danish
rule one was given exclusive rights in each of the three towns and its
contiguous territory. They were inspected often, old drugs being thrown
out; and they were not allowed to sell patent medicines. Their prices
are reasonable as monopolies go, their stores well kept, and their stock
ample, within Danish limits. When the islands were sold, the
apothecaries complained to the king that they were in danger of being
ruined by American competition; whereupon the king, out of the goodness
of his heart—and the fullness of the twenty-five million—gave them
$30,000 each. Four years have passed since the druggists pocketed this
salve to their injured profits, and they are still doing business at the
old stands without a rival in sight.
Indeed, there is little evidence of that influx of American business men
which was predicted as sure to follow the flag. So far the only one is a
young ex-marine who is breaking into the restaurant and soda-fountain
business. He has been fought at every step by the local merchants.
Living exclusively on trade, with hundred per cent. profits customary
from time immemorial, the wealthier class of the islanders have the
cuteness of the shopkeeper developed to the nth degree, and they will
not readily consent to competition by rank outsiders from the United
States.
Among the things which the Danes left behind were their laws, and their
own judge to administer them. True, Judge Thiele has become an American
citizen, but it is a curious sight to see Americans-born brought into
court by negro policemen, to be tried by a man who is still a foreigner
in point of view and thinking processes in spite of being no longer
officially a subject of the King of Denmark. There are those who claim
he sides with the favorites of the old Government to the decided
disadvantage of Americans, though there are more who speak well of him.
It is enough to know that Americans are being tried in American
territory under the Napoleonic code, in that laborious old-fashioned
style by which the judge questions the witnesses, dictates their answers
in his own more cultured words to a clerk, who writes them all down in
laborious longhand in a great ledger, to be sure that a change should be
made in the judiciary system of our Virgin Islands.
Having bought them, and being forced to support them for the rest of our
natural existence, it might be of interest to make a brief inventory of
our new possessions. The total area of the three islands, with their
seventeen keys, only three or four of which are inhabited, is about 140
square miles. The census taken soon after the raising of the Stars and
Stripes showed something over twenty-six thousand inhabitants, but
several signs indicate that these are decreasing. The only real value of
the Virgin group proper is the splendid harbor of St. Thomas. St. Croix,
forty miles distant from it is considerably larger than all the rest of
this group put together, more populous, more fertile, and could easily
be made self-supporting governmentally, as it always has been privately,
particularly with the introduction of an extensive system of irrigation.
* * * * *
A couple of trails zigzag up the reddish, dry hillside behind Charlotte
Amalie, scattering along the way a few hovels. They really lead nowhere,
however, for there is no other town than the capital on the island. The
hurricane of 1916 blew down most of the farm-houses and many of the
trees, and they were never rebuilt or replanted. Once heavily forested,
later Nile-green with sugar-cane, St. Thomas is now brown, arid, and
dreary, with scarcely a tenth of its acreage under even half-hearted
cultivation. Being all “mountain,” fifteen hundred feet high in one
spot, with buttresses running down to the sea in every direction, it can
hardly be expected to compete with modern agricultural methods.
Moreover, eight of its ten thousand inhabitants have been drawn into
town by the higher wages of harbor work, and though there is now a
scarcity of that, they still remain, to the detriment of what might be
moderately productive plantations, forcing the island to draw its food
from St. John, the British Virgins, or Porto Rico. A journey over the
“mountain” brings little reward except some marvelous views and yet
another proof of how primitive the human family may become.
A so-called road traverses the island from east to west. In company with
a navy doctor I bumped by Ford along the eastern half of this to Water
Bay. A cattle-raising estate called “Tatu,” with a three-story,
red-roofed dwelling, was the only sign of industry along the route. Near
the bay we overtook a man on his way—at nine o’clock in the morning—to
dig a well for the estate owner, and soon talked him into rowing us
across to St. John instead. For the wind was dead ahead, and the old
sail in the bottom of his patched and weather-warped dory would have
been far more hindrance than help in negotiating the stormy three-mile
passage between the islands. Once landed, in Cruz Bay, we rented St.
John’s only public means of conveyance,—two hard-gaited horses named
“Bess” and “Candy Kid”—and rode out into the wilderness.
St. John is little more than that. Its twenty square miles have almost
entirely gone back to forest, through which a few trails meander amid a
silence as unbroken as that of Robinson Crusoe’s place of exile. There
is not a wheeled vehicle on the island; one may ride for miles without
meeting an inhabitant, and the very birds seem to have abandoned it for
more progressive climes. Yet rusted iron kettles and the ruins of stone
sugar-mills, scattered here and there in forest and scrub, show that the
island was once a place of industry. Sugar and cotton plantations almost
completely covered it when, in 1733, a slave rebellion started it on a
decline that has never since ceased. The whites quelled the uprising,
after a half hundred of them and four times as many blacks had lost
their lives, but the negroes won in the end, for the last census showed
but four white men on the island. To-day it has barely eight hundred
inhabitants, of whom, unlike the other islands, the majority are men. A
few mangoes and bananas, yams, okra, and a kind of tropical pumpkin keep
its hut-dwellers alive. Here and there is a little patch of cane, from
which rum was made before the Americans came to interfere with that;
limes are cultivated rather languidly in a few hillside orchards, and
the high ridge between Hope and Bordeaux is covered with bay-trees.
These vary in size from mere saplings to trees twenty feet in height.
The picking is best done in June, when men and boys break off the
smaller branches and carry them to the distilleries. Here the leaves are
cooked in sea water in immense brass decanters, from which the bay oil
is drawn off, and the leaves tossed out, apparently unchanged except
from green to a coppery brown. One hundred and thirty pounds of leaves
are required to produce a quart of oil, which sells at present for six
dollars, and has long had the reputation of being the best on the
market. The bay-tree estates give occasional labor to the inhabitants,
but their livelihood depends chiefly on their own little patches of
tropical vegetables, their cattle, and their fishing. From the high
points of the island one has an embracing view of the British Virgin
Islands, separated from our own by only a few miles, and framed in the
Caribbean like emeralds of fantastic shape in a setting of translucent
blue.
There are no towns on St. John. The nearest semblance to them are a few
scattered clusters of huts around the shores, where customs are as
backward as those of Africa, or Haiti. A handful of these simple
dwellings are rather picturesquely strewn up the steep fishhook-shaped
peninsula that forms the eastern end of the island, connected to the
rest by a narrow neck of land. Between this and what might be called the
mainland is Coral Bay, a harbor of far greater depth than that of St.
Thomas, and so much larger that, experts tell us, the construction of
two break-waters would make it a safe anchorage for the largest navy in
the world. But what, in the name of Neptune, would the world’s largest
navy find to do there?
[Illustration: A corner of Charlotte Amalie]
[Illustration: Picking sea island cotton, the second of St. Croix
products]
[Illustration: A familiar sight in St. Croix, the ruins of an old sugar
mill and the stone tower of its cane grinding windmill]
[Illustration: A cistern in which rain water is stored for drinking
purposes]
We met all the élite of St. John at the Moravian mission of Emmaus at
the head of Coral Bay. The census showed the island inhabited by one
Catholic, forty Lutherans, and the rest Moravians, hence there were few
local celebrities missing at the annual “show” which happened to
coincide with our visit. Negroes dressed in their most solemn garments,
the men in staid black, the women in starched white, poured in on
horseback and afoot from moonrise until the first of the doleful
religious songs and the amusingly stupid dialogues began in the school
chapel. There was the black government doctor, the negro owners of the
two or three farms so large as to be locally known as “estates,” the
island’s few school teachers—its policeman himself might have been there
had I not deprived him of the use of his “Candy Kid.” To tell the truth
they gave a rather good impression, decidedly a better one than the
traveler-baiters of St. Thomas. They were almost English in their cold
leisurely deportment, yet more volubly courteous, and with few
exceptions they frankly looked down upon white men. Many of them had the
outward indices of education, speaking with a chosen-worded formality
that suggested a national convention of pedagogues; not a hint of
hilarity enlivened their intercourse. Perhaps the most amusing part of
all was the overdone company-manner in which they treated their wives,
those same wives who no doubt would take up the chief family burdens
again, once the night had separated the gathering into its natural
component parts.
We found Carl Francis more nearly what it is to be hoped our new wards
can all gradually be brought to resemble. A member of the Colonial
Council, notorious throughout the colony as the man who dared tell the
congressional committee in public session that the chief trouble with
the Virgin Islands is the laziness of their inhabitants, he would
outrank many a politician of our own land in public spirit, for all his
ebony skin. He confirmed the famous statement above mentioned, but added
that there were other things which St. John needed for its advancement.
It needs a mail service, for instance, such as it had under the Danes,
instead of being obliged to go to Charlotte Amalie to post or receive
its letters. It needs more schools, so that its children shall not have
to walk miles over the mountains morning and evening. It must have
something in the nature of an agricultural bank to lend the inhabitants
wherewithal to replant the old estates, if St. John is to regain under
the American flag something of its eighteenth century prosperity.
* * * * *
If the _Virginia_ was unworthy of her calling, what shall I say of the
_Creole_, which carried me from St. Thomas to St. Croix? A battered old
sloop of a type so ancient that her massive wooden rail resembled that
of a colonial veranda, barely fifty feet long, and nearly as wide, her
bottom so covered with barnacles that she did little more than creep in
the strongest breeze, she represented the last stage in ocean-going
traffic. Not only were there no other whites on board, but not even a
mulatto. The passenger-list was made up chiefly of a batch of criminals
and insane who were being sent to their respective institutions in St.
Croix. Most of them wore handcuffs and leg-irons, and the rattle of
chains and the shrieks of their wearers suggested the slave-ships of
olden days. One of the mad women screamed for unbroken hours in the
lingo of the Dutch West Indies; another conducted single-handed an
entire church service, hymns, sermon, prayers, and all.
Yet the crew were at least grown men, and if they were monkey-like in
their playful moods, they had real discipline and a sense of
responsibility when the time came for it that was a welcome contrast to
the surly indifference with which the boys on the _Virginia_ carried out
their orders. The captain was a black man of the coast fisherman type,
but the most entertaining part of the voyage was the unfailing “sir”
with which the mate, a cadaverous old negro who wore a heavy wool
skating-cap and a sort of trench-coat fit for the Arctic even at high
noon, ended his careful repetition of the skipper’s every command.
Moreover,—for we are all apt to judge things from our own petty
personal-comfort angle—the captain and most of his men treated a white
man as if he were of royal blood. Not only did he find me a canvas
steamer-chair, but he refused any of the other passengers admittance to
the three-berth cabin, lest they should “disturb de gen’le-man.” If only
he had been able to adjourn the church service and the other uproar
beyond the bulkhead, I might have had a real night’s sleep.
We left at five in the evening, and by sunrise had covered the forty
miles,—though not, unfortunately, in the right direction. Had our
destination been Frederiksted at the west end of the island, we should
have landed early. But the _Creole’s_ contract calls for a service
between St. Thomas and Christiansted, the two capitals of our Virgin
group, and all day long we wallowed eastward under the lee of St.
Croix’s mountainous northern coast, while “de lepards,” as the sane
passengers called their unsound sisters below, shrieked their maudlin
complaints and the church service began over and over again with a
“Brethren, let us pray for her.”
Christiansted is prettily situated amid cocoanut-palms and sloping
cane-fields at the back of a wide bay, but a long reef with an
exceedingly narrow entrance gives it a poor harbor. Its white or
cream-colored houses, with here and there a red roof, lend it a touch
that is lacking in the half-dozen rather grim-faced villages and estates
that may be seen scattered to right and left along the rugged coast. The
town has wide, rather well-kept streets, many stone houses, an imposing
government building, and climbs away up the stony slope behind as if it
had once planned to grow, but had changed its mind. Old-fashioned chain
pumps supply it with water, from wells rather than from cisterns; a big
Catholic church is barely outrivaled in size by the Anglican; on the
whole, it seems better swept than more populous Charlotte Amalie. Its
people are simple-mannered, rather “gawky,” in fact, with a tendency to
stare strangers out of countenance, and have a leisureliness that shows
even in the long-drawn “Good ahftehnoon, sar,” with which they greet
passers-by.
Christiansted, and all St. Croix, has a special grievance against the
Americans. Under the Danes the governor spent half the year in this
second capital. Now the ruler of the islands only occasionally runs over
from St. Thomas in his private yacht, often returning the same day, and
the Croixians feel slighted. When the admiral and his aides land, it is
mildly like the arrival of royalty. A band or two and most of the
population are drawn up in the sanded space facing the wharf, whence all
proceed to a meeting of the Colonial Council in the old government
building.
Across the street from this is a shop in which Alexander Hamilton once
clerked. His mother, born in St. Croix, married a man named Levine, who
abused her, whereupon she went to live with a Scotchman named Hamilton
in the neighboring British island of Nevis. There Alexander was born,
but when his father went to seek his fortune elsewhere, the mother
returned to her native island. While clerking in the Christiansted shop,
the son wrote his father a letter describing a hurricane that had swept
St. Croix, the father showed it to influential friends, with the result
that Alexander was sent to King’s College (now Columbia University),
and, thanks partly to Aaron Burr, never returned to the West Indies.
Meanwhile his mother remained in St. Croix until her death, and was
buried on a knoll a few miles west of Christiansted. It is a pleasant
burial place, with constant shade and a never-failing trade wind fanning
the flowers above it, a quaint old homestead behind it, and a modern
monument erected by an American woman, inscribed:
Rachael Fawcett Levine
1736–1768
She was the Mother of Alexander Hamilton
St. Croix is far more of a real country than all the other islands of
the group put together. Not only is it much larger, being twenty miles
long and five wide, but is much more extensively cultivated. Three
splendid roads run nearly the length of the island, with numerous cross
roads in good condition. Only the rocky eastern end is a wilderness to
which deer, brought into St. Croix by the British when they controlled
it during the Napoleonic wars, go to hide after the cane-fields are cut,
such a wilderness that hunters rarely succeed in stalking the wary
animals in the dense undergrowth. There are far more signs of industry
in St. Croix than in St. Thomas; its estate-owners are on the whole an
intelligent, progressive class, with a social life quite different from
that on the more primitive islands. When one has seen St. Croix, the
twenty-five million does not seem quite so complete and irreparable a
loss.
* * * * *
I took the “King’s Road” through the middle of the island. It runs for
fourteen miles, from Christiansted, the capital, to Frederiksted, its
rival. These names being too much effort for the negro tongue, the towns
are known locally as “Boss End” (either a corruption of the French
_Bassin_ or an acknowledgement that the “bosses” of the island always
lived in the capital) and “West End.” The northern side is abrupt, with
deep water close to the shore, its highest peak, Mount Eagle, rising
1180 feet. South of this range are undulating, fertile valleys and
broad, rolling plains not even suggested along the northern coast, and
the land slopes away in shoals and coral ledges for several miles from
the beach. The highways are maintained by the owners of the estates
through which they run; therefore they follow a somewhat roundabout
course through the canefields, that the expense of maintenance may be
more evenly divided. They are busy roads, dotted with automobiles, of
which there are more than one hundred on the island, many donkeys, heavy
two-wheeled carts hauled by neck-yoked oxen, a kind of jaunting car of
the conservative gentry, and innumerable black pedestrians. The island
is everywhere punctuated with picturesque old stone windmill towers that
once ground cane, their flailing arms long since departed, and gray old
chimneys of abandoned sugar-mills break the sky-line on every hand. Some
of these dull-white heaps of buildings on their hilltops look like aged
Norman castles; there is something grim and northern about them that
does not fit at all with the tropics. They suggest instead the diligence
and foresightedness of the temperate zone. Old human tread-mills may
still be found among them, and slave-house villages that in some cases
are inhabited by the laborers of to-day. Rusted sugar-kettles, such as
are strewn through the West Indies from eastern Haiti to southern
Trinidad, lie abandoned here and there throughout the island.
Sugar-cane once covered even the tops of the hills, but to-day only the
flatter lands are planted, though there are splendid stretches of
cane-green valleys. The names of estates are amusing, and range all the
way from cynicism to youthful hopefulness,—“Golden Grove,” “Work and
Rest,” “Hope and Blessing,” “Whim,” “Slob,” “Judith’s Fancy,” “Barren
Spot,” “Adventure.” The ceiba, or “silk-cotton tree,” beautiful
specimens of the royal palm, the tibet-tree, full of rustling pods that
give it the name of “women’s-tongues” in all the English-speaking West
Indies, everywhere beautify the landscape. Ruins of the slave rebellion,
of the earthquake of 1848, of the disastrous hurricane of 1916, are
still to be found here and there. There is a marvelous view from King’s
Hill, with its old Danish gendarmérie, now a police station, from which
the central highway, lined by palms and undulating through great valleys
of cane, may be seen to where it descends to “West End” and the
Caribbean. In the center of the picture sits Bethlehem, the largest
sugar-mill on the island, with its cane railway and up-to-date methods.
For the modern process of centralization is already spreading in St.
Croix; the small independent mills are disappearing, and with them much
of the picturesqueness of the island. These big mills, as well as most
of the small, are owned by Danes, half the stock of the largest being
held by the Danish government. Unfortunately St. Croix has put all its
eggs in one basket, or at most, two, sugar and sea-island cotton.
There is not a thatched roof on the island. The people live in moderate
comfort, as comfort goes in the West Indies. Toward sunset the roads are
lined with women cane-cutters in knee-length skirts, with footless
woolen stockings that suggest the tights of ballet-dancers, to protect
their legs in the fields, pattering homeward, with their big cane-knives
lying flat on the tops of their heads. Bits of colored rags sewed on the
hatbands of the men indicate that they are members of the newly
organized labor-union. They still bow and raise their hats to passing
white men, yet one feels something of that bolshevistic atmosphere which
their black leaders are fostering among them. The King’s Road passes a
large distillery, which prohibition has closed. Formerly St. Croix made
much rum; now it is giving its attention rather to syrup than to sugar,
as there is more money in the former; but estate-owners are threatening
to give up cane-growing and turn their fields into cattle pastures, so
greatly have the wages of field laborers increased in the last two
years—from twenty-five cents to a dollar a day. For St. Croix is one of
the few islands in the West Indies where “task work” has never taken the
place of a fixed daily wage. Cattle are plentiful on the island, from
which they are sent to Porto Rico in tug-towed open barges. Some of them
are so wild that they are brought down to the coast in cages on wheels,
and all of them are roped and swung on board with little regard to their
bodily comfort.
Fredriksted, the third and last town of our Virgin Islands, is a quaint,
“Dutchy” place some five blocks wide and seven long, with wide sanded
streets, two-storied for the most part and boasting no real public
sidewalks; for though what look like them run beneath the arcades that
uphold the upper-story verandas, they are rather family porches, shut
off by stairways or barricades, which force the pedestrian to take
constantly to the sun-scorched streets. The town has only an open
roadstead; indeed, there is not a good harbor in the island. A native
band recruited by the American navy breaks the monotony of life by
playing here once a week, as it does daily in Christiansted. The cable
company is required by law to furnish the world’s news to the press, but
as the pathetic little newspapers are so small that they can publish
only a few items at a time, the despatches are habitually some two weeks
old, each taking its chronological turn irrespective of importance.
* * * * *
I visited several schools in the Virgin Islands. When an American school
director arrived early in 1918 he found no records either of schools,
pupils, or parents. By dint of going out and hunting them up, he
discovered nineteen educational buildings on the three islands. Ninety
per cent. of the population can read and write after a fashion, but the
majority usually have their letters written by the public scribe, of
whom there is one in each of the three towns, in a set form that gives
all epistles a strong family resemblance. The school system was
honeycombed with all sorts of petty graft. A man who received three
dollars a month for keeping a certain school clean had not seen the
building in years. The town clock of Christiansted has not run for five
years, yet another favored person received a monthly stipend for keeping
it in order. The new director and his two American assistants have still
to contend with many difficulties. There are no white teachers; those
now employed were trained either in Denmark or in the Moravian schools,
and the “English” of most of them almost deserves to be ranked as an
independent dialect. The highest teacher’s salary is seventy-five, the
average twenty-four dollars a month. Boys of sixteen, drawing the regal
income of ten dollars monthly, conduct many of the classes. Those who
served a certain number of years under the Danes receive a pension from
the famous twenty-five millions. They are small pensions, like those
that went to all the small government employees whom the Danes left
behind, and those who still hold their places protest against telling
their new employer how much they draw from Copenhagen, fancying it may
result in a corresponding loss in the increase they fondly hope for
under American rule. Lack of funds has forced the director to maintain
many of the incompetents in office. One rural school we visited is still
taught by the local butcher, whose inefficiency is on a par with his
custom of neglecting his educational duties for his more natural
calling. But as the island budget does not permit an increase of his
monthly thirty-five dollars,—and in every case it is merely Danish, not
American, dollars,—no more competent substitute has yet appeared to
claim the butcher’s ferule.
The country schools have few desks; the children sit on backless
benches, their feet usually high off the floor. The tops of the desks
are in many cases painted black and used as blackboards. A rusty tin cup
was found doing service for all the thirsty; when the Americans
attempted to improve this condition by introducing a long-handled dipper
with an edge cut in repeated V shape, the teachers bent the sharp points
back and returned to the old dip-your-hand-in method. Lessons are often
done on slates or pieces of slate, which the teacher periodically
sprinkles with water from a bay-rum bottle, then requires the sums to be
erased in rhythmical unison. Formerly the teachers sat in the middle of
one large room, surrounded by eight different grades, and the resultant
hubbub may be imagined. The Americans put in partitions, and the uproar
is now somewhat less incoherent. In some of the larger schools there
were half-height partitions, with little sliding-doors, through which
the principal could peer without leaving his central “office.” Loud
protests have been heard because the Americans nailed these up, forcing
upon the sedentary gentlemen in charge the exertion of walking around to
the several doors. The teaching methods were, and in many cases still
are, of that tropically medieval type in which the instructor asks long
questions that require a single-word answer, even that being chiefly
suggested by the questioner.
“What is the longest river in America? Now, then, Miss-Mis-sissi—”
The answer “pi!” by some unusually bright pupil, is followed by
exclamations of praise from the teacher. Like most negroes, the Virgin
Islanders have tolerable memories, but little ability to apply what they
learn. Not the least of the difficulties confronting the new director
was the reform of the Catholic schools, which had long put great
emphasis on matters of religion and treated other subjects with scant
attention. The attempt to better matters sent shrieks of protest to
Washington, whence the director’s hands were more or less tied by
misinformed coreligionists. Bit by bit the Virgin Island schools are
being improved, however, a decree permitting superintendents to fine the
parents of pupils absent without due cause, simply by sending a
policeman to collect the sum assessed, without any troublesome process
of law, having given a badly needed weapon against the once wide-spread
inattendance. Parents who decline, or are unable to pay the fines, are
required to work one day on the roads for every dollar unpaid.
There is no agriculture worth mentioning in St. Thomas and no employing
class in St. John, hence labor troubles have been chiefly confined to
St. Croix. The present leaders of the movement in the larger island are
three negroes, all of them agitators of the more or less violent type,
differing only in degree, and all more or less consciously doing their
best to stir up those of their own color. The one considered the most
radical is the least troublesome, as he can readily be bought off.
Another, a man of some education, runs a newspaper advocating civil
government,—that is, negro government,—preaching that the white man is
the enemy of the black, that St. Croix belongs by right to the latter,
and openly accusing the white officials of incompetency and dishonesty.
In addition to this, he publishes secretly a scurrilous sheet that is
doing much to inflame the primitive minds of the masses. The third
announced in a public meeting that “if the governor don’t do what we
want, we’ll take him out in the bay and send him back where he come
from.”
“Since the Americans came, it is all for the niggers,” said an old
English estate-owner. “The niggers even steal our fruit and vegetables,
carrying them to town a bit at a time in their clothes, for the
policemen are all friendly or related to them. Let those black agitators
go on a bit longer, and we whites will have to leave the island.”
There are signs that the whites are in peril of losing the upper hand in
the island, particularly with the methods of the present governor, who
caters to the negroes with un-American eagerness. As an example, though
his private yacht may be on the point of steaming from St. Thomas to St.
Croix or vice versa, even American white women are left to the mercies
of the filthy _Creole_, lest the local merchants complain that trade is
being taken away from them. Yet native negro girls are readily carried
back and forth, because they happen to be the daughters, relatives, or
dependents of members of the colonial council, or of some other local
officials of the islands we are paying taxes to support.
The negro newspaper man sees much “social injustice” in St. Croix, of
which certainly a customary amount exists; but he seems incapable of
noting the great disinclination to work and the fact that the “paltry
dollar a day” buys scarcely one tenth the amount of labor which
constitutes a day’s work in the white man’s countries with which he
strives to compare his own. In 1916 he went to Denmark and raised funds
to establish several labor-union estates on the island, where the
negroes might raise cattle, cane, and the like, each to get permanent
possession of the piece of land on which he was working as soon as he
had paid off the mortgage. But the farms are already, after a bare two
years in the hands of the union, largely overgrown with weeds, bush, and
miserable shacks, and about the only result of the move has been the
loss of more land to world production, and the infliction of the sponsor
with an exaggerated self-importance that has made him lose the one
virtue of the Virgin-Islander—his courtesy.
On the other hand, the employing class is by no means immune to
criticism. The larger sugar companies were paying cane-growers from six
to seven cents Danish for sugar at the same time that they were selling
it for from twelve to fourteen cents in American money. The diligent
Yankee who controls the lighterage, wharfage, and many other monopolies
at “West End,” as well as sharing with the newspaper man the political
control of the island, cannot be acquitted of the native charge of
exorbitance. A Danish company whose profits in 1919 were more than a
million sent all its gains to Copenhagen, instead of helping to
stabilize the exchange by depositing them in New York.
Among the troubles of St. Croix is the problem of what to do with the
“immigration fund.” Sugar production requires much labor; ever since
slavery was abolished St. Croix has been constantly faced with the
difficulty of getting enough of it. A large percentage of the negroes
would rather become public charges than work more than a few days a
week. In 1854 the planters voluntarily assessed themselves ten cents an
acre to establish an immigration fund, the Government making up the
deficit. Laborers were brought from the other West Indian islands,
particularly from Barbados. Therein lies another grievance of the
planters, who assert that though Barbados implored the Government of St.
Croix to relieve the former island of some of its over-population, when
the request was granted, the Barbadian authorities emptied the jails and
sent out all their riffraff. With the establishment of American rule, it
became illegal to bring in contract labor, and though the immigration
fund now consists of more than seventy thousand dollars, it is
impossible to use it as originally intended. Does the money belong to
the planters, to the United States, or to the Danish Government? The
Croixians are still heatedly debating the question, and at the same time
are complaining of the scarcity and high price of willing labor.
* * * * *
Politically, St. Thomas and St. John, with their numerous neighboring
keys and islets, constitute one municipality, and St. Croix another.
Under the Danes the executive power was vested in a colonial governor
appointed by the crown; the legislative authority being held by a
colonial council in each municipality, some of the members likewise
crown appointments, some elected. With an American admiral as governor,
and naval officers as secretaries and heads of departments, this system
has continued, and will continue until our busy Congress finds time to
establish another form of government. Though the navy men explain to
them that they are virtually under a civil government without the
necessity of supporting it themselves, the natives are not satisfied.
Among other things the labor leader elected to the colonial council of
St. Croix demands the jury trial and “suffrage based on manhood.” The
vote is at present extended to males over twenty-five having a personal
income of three hundred dollars a year or owning property yielding five
dollars a month. Moreover—and this, I believe, is more than we demand
even in the United States—the voters must be of “unblemished character.”
Thus the Danes sought to insure the ballot only to men of responsibility
and there was good reason for the limitation. To the casual observer it
seems that the growing tendency to give the natives the universal
franchise should be combated, unless the islands are to become Haitian.
Last year one of the agitators went to the United States on the hopeful
mission of getting all the offices filled by natives—that is, negroes.
Luckily, his demands were not granted. Civil service already applies;
there is nothing to prevent a native from holding any but the higher
offices if he is fitted for the task; but native ability is not yet high
enough, nor insular morals stanch enough, to give any hope that a native
government would work efficiently without white supervision.
There is more justice in the plea for a homestead act that will turn the
uncultivated land over to the people, though even that should be framed
with care. One of the chief troubles with nearly all the West Indies is
the ease with which lazy negroes may squat on public land. The islanders
have one real kick, however, on the state of their postal service. Under
the Danes there were mail-carriers in the towns, there were country
post-offices, and a certain amount of rural delivery; all
school-teachers sold stamps, and mail was sent by any safe conveyance
that appeared. To-day there are only three post-offices and no mail
delivery, the country people must carry their own letters to and from
one of the three towns, those living on St. John being obliged to bring
and fetch theirs from Charlotte Amalie, and though a dozen steamers may
make the crossing during the week, the mails must wait for the languid
and uncertain _Virginia_ or _Creole_. There are only four postal
employees in St. Thomas, in addition to the postmaster, a deserving
Democrat from Virginia who, in the local parlance, “does nothing but
play tennis and crank a motor-boat.” When one of the mail-schooners
comes in, the population crowds into the post-office in quest of its
mail, disrupting the service, each hopeful citizen coming back again
every half-hour or so until he finds that the expected letter has not
come. Yet carriers were paid only thirty-five dollars Danish under the
Danes, and three or four of them obviated all this chaotic confusion.
Roughly speaking, the St. Thomas division does not want civil
government, feeling it cannot pay for it, and St. Croix does, though her
colonial council has asked that no change be made for the present and
has implied that it expects the expense of government to be chiefly
maintained by congressional appropriation even after the change is made.
But this same body demands full jurisdiction over all taxation, the one
thing it is least competent to handle properly, for it would result in
the powerful and influential and their friends escaping their just share
of the burden. There are queer quirks in the taxation system left by the
Danes. Buildings, for instance, are taxed by the ell, or two square
feet, with the result that old tumble-downs often pay more than smaller
modern and useful structures. There is a tax on wheels, so that the
largest automobile pays five dollars a year, as does the poor man’s
donkey-cart. Moreover, this money does not go to the maintenance of
roads, but into the colonial treasury, as does every other cent of
revenue. Under the Danes, even with lottery taxes yielding a hundred
thousand dollars a year, and a large income from liquor taxes, the
islands were never self-supporting. Our income tax in place of these
amounts to little, especially as many find ways to get out of paying it.
The public revenues of the islands are barely a quarter million a year.
We contribute an equal amount directly, and three hundred thousand
dollars a year in navy salaries besides, for the governor and his
assistants get no other recompense than their regular pay as naval
officers. There are a few persons, not Virgin-Islanders of course, who
advocate annexing the group to Porto Rico. Theoretically, this plan
would greatly simplify matters; in practice there would be certain
decided objections to it, though the scheme might be feasible if worked
out with care. Two things are indispensable, however, that during the
life of the present generation the islands be given no more autonomy
than they have at present, and above all that they be taxed by
disinterested outsiders.
A new code of laws, based on those of Alaska and reputed to contain all
the latest improvements in government, has recently been drawn up for
the Virgin Islands. Unfortunately, the colonial council can reject that
code if they see fit; that is another weakness in the treaty. Already
they have marked for the pruning-knife every clause designed to improve
the insular morals. The marriage ceremony, for instance, has never been
taken very seriously by the natives. Unions by mutual consent are so
numerous that our census-takers were forced to include a fifth class in
their returns—the “consentually married.” Illegitimacy runs close to
eighty per cent., far out-distancing even Porto Rico. In fact, the mass
of the islanders have no morality whatever in that particular matter.
Girls of fourteen not only have children, but boast of it. The Danes are
largely to blame for this state of affairs, for there were few of them
who did not leave “gutter children” behind, though it must be admitted
that our own marines and sailors are not setting a much better example.
The negro, being imitative, is particularly quick to copy any easy-going
ways of his superiors; hence there is almost a complete absence of
public sentiment against such unions among the blacks. Formerly a
special excuse was found in the high cost of legal and church marriages,
the fees for which were virtually prohibitive to the poorer classes.
To-day they are only nominal, and many an old couple has been married in
the presence of their grandchildren. The Danish laws compel the father
to contribute two dollars a month to the support of his illegal
children, but though the man seldom denies his possible parentage, the
woman has frequently no unquestionable proof of it. The new code would
force men to marry the mothers of their children.
“But how can we do that?” cried a member of the colonial council, often
referred to as “the best native on the island,” yet who makes no secret
of having his progeny scattered far and wide. “Most of us are married
already; besides, we would have to legalize polygamy to carry out this
proposed law. We are quite willing to continue the two dollars a month
to our outside children, but how can we marry their mothers? They are
not even of our own class!”
Illegitimacy gives rise to another problem. By the Danish laws still in
force every minor must have a guardian, and that guardian cannot be a
woman, even though she be the mother. Her older brother, her father, or
some more distant relative, slightly interested in his task, commonly
becomes the legal sponsor for her fatherless offspring. The duties of a
guardian are, succinctly, to “take charge of the minor’s property,” with
the resultant abuse to be expected. Policemen are now and then appointed
the legal guardians of a dozen or more young rascals, and it goes
without saying that they do not lie awake nights worrying about the
moral and material advancement of their wards.
Another clause that is not likely to escape the blue pencil of the
councils is that giving the authorities the right to search the persons
and carts of those carrying produce and to demand proof of its legal
possession. Yet without some such law there is slight hope of stamping
out the wide-spread larceny of growing crops.
One of our most serious problems in the Virgin Islands is to combat
disease. The Danes had only three doctors on the islands; now sixteen
navy physicians are busy all the time. Their fees are turned into the
colonial treasury, an arrangement nowhere else in force in American
territory. Half the children die as a natural course, though the islands
are really very healthful, and no white child born under proper
conditions has died since American occupation. There is no hookworm and
little malaria; but much pellagra and “big leg,” or elephantiasis.
Tuberculosis is common, and tests indicate that eighty per cent. of the
population is infected with a hereditary blood disease. There is a leper
colony in St. Croix. The present generation, in the opinion of the navy
men, is hopeless. In the improvement of the next they are hampered by
the ignorance, indifference, and superstition of the parents. The
doctors of “West End” found nothing unusual in the case of a baby that
was brought to the hospital already dead because the father had taken it
first to a native healer, who put “chibble” (pot herbs) under its nose
to cure it of acute indigestion.
But there is a worse problem than that facing us in the Virgin
Islands—the elimination of the habit of trying to live off the exertions
of others. Thanks to their race, history, and situation, the islanders
are inveterate, almost unconscious, beggars. Young or old, black or
white—for environment has given even those of Caucasian ancestry almost
the same habits and “ideals” as the negro—they are all gifted with the
extended palm. If they do not all beg individually, they do so
collectively, in a frank, shameless assertion that they cannot support
themselves. The Danes left a “rum fund” that is designed to aid all
those who “have seen better days,” and to judge by the applicants the
entire population ranks itself in that category. The native woman clerk
at the “West End” police station does not hesitate to give any one, even
the four-dollars-a-day sugar-porters on the wharves, a certificate that
he is unable to pay for medical attention, though the navy doctors’ fees
are nominal and, even when they are paid, go into the colonial treasury.
The admiral-governor gave a reception to the natives. Food was provided
for five hundred—and was carried off by the first hundred street women
and urchins who surged through the door. Next day a large crowd came to
demand their share, saying they had got nothing the day before. One of
the “labor leaders” told the negroes of St. Croix to hide their mahogany
bedsteads and phonographs and sleep on drygoods boxes while the
congressional committee was scheduled to visit the island. Of the entire
crowd appearing before that committee not one had the general good of
the islands on his lips, but all came with some petty personal complaint
or request.
In short our new wards want all they can get out of us. They want Uncle
Sam to provide them with schools, with sanitation, with irrigation, with
galvanized hillsides, with roads—even in St. Croix, which has better
highways than almost any State in the Union—with public markets, with
libraries, with means of public transportation, with anything else
which, in his unsophisticated generosity, he chooses to give, so long as
he does not require them to contribute their own means and labor to that
end. The colonial council of St. Croix “hopes means will be found to get
Congress to appropriate a half million a year, a sum far beyond our own
means, so that we can live up to the high ideals of our great American
nation.” It never seems to occur to them that the schools, libraries,
and streets in our cities are paid for by the inhabitants thereof; they
have the popular view of Uncle Sam as the world’s Santa Claus. Yet many
of the very members of that council have made fortunes in St. Croix and
probably could themselves pay a large part of the sum demanded without
any more difficulty than the average American finds in paying his taxes.
Naïve as they are, the Virgin Islanders can scarcely expect Americans to
adopt them and never let them work or want again, yet they talk as if
they had some such thought in mind. Or, as a congressman put it during a
public hearing, “I doubt whether the farmers of my State of Kansas will
be willing to get up at four all summer and pay money into the federal
treasury so that you can sleep until nine in the morning and stroll in
the park the rest of the day.”
There is no reason why the Virgin-Islanders should not be sufficiently
taxed to support their own schools and other requirements. Even if St.
Thomas is now largely barren, many of its shopkeepers are steadily
growing wealthy. The Danish planters of St. Croix send fortunes home to
Denmark every year; at the present price of sugar they alone should be
able easily to contribute a sum equal to that they are demanding from
Congress. Should not even dollar-a-day negroes pay something in taxes?
It might develop their civic spirit. The Virgin-Islanders need many
things, it is true; but there are millions living in, and paying taxes
to, the United States who have by no means what almost every
Virgin-Islander has, or could have for a little exertion. The future of
the islands depends largely on whether or not we succumb to our national
tendency to make our wards mendicants for life, or give them a start and
let them work their own way through the college of civilization.
Whenever I look back upon our new possessions I remember a significant
little episode that took place during our first day in St. Thomas. A
negro woman was sitting a short way up one of the great street stairways
that climb the hills of Charlotte Amalie. A descending friend paused to
ask her what was the matter, and she replied in that slow, whining
singsong peculiar to the community:
“Me knees jes wilfully refuse to carry me up dem steps.”
That is the trouble with most of the Virgin-Islanders. Their own knees
jes wilfully refuse to carry them up the stairway of civilization. They
will have to be lifted—or booted.
THE BRITISH WEST INDIES