SUBTRACTION
Mark had not spent a more unhappy Easter since the days of Haverton
House. He was oppressed by the sense of excommunication that brooded
over the Abbey, and on the Saturday of Passion Week the versicles and
responses of the proper Compline had a dreadful irony.
_V. O King most Blessed, govern Thy servants in the right way._
_R. Among Thy Saints, O King most Blessed._
_V. By holy fasts to amend our sinful lives._
_R. O King most Blessed, govern Thy Saints in the right way._
_V. To duly keep Thy Paschal Feast._
_R. Among Thy Saints, O King most Blessed._
"Brother Mark," said Brother Augustine, on the morning of Palm Sunday,
"_did_ you notice that ghastly split infinitive in the last versicle at
Compline? _To duly keep._ I can't think why we don't say the Office in
Latin."
Mark felt inclined to tell Brother Augustine that if nothing more vital
than an infinitive was split during this holy season, the Community
might have cause to congratulate itself. Here now was Brother Birinus
throwing away as useless the bundle of palms that lacked the blessing of
a priest, throwing them away like dead flowers.
Sir Charles Horner, who had been in town, arrived at the Abbey on the
Tuesday, and announced that he was going to spend Holy Week with the
Community.
"We have no chaplain," Mark told him.
"No chaplain!" Sir Charles exclaimed. "But I understood that Andrew
Hett had undertaken the job while Father Burrowes was away."
Mark did not think that it was his duty to enlighten Sir Charles upon
the dispute between Brother George and the chaplain. However, it was not
long before he found out what had occurred from the Prior's own lips and
came fuming back to the Guest-chamber.
"I consider the whole state of affairs most unsatisfactory," he said. "I
really thought that when Brother George took charge here the Abbey would
be better managed."
"Please, Sir Charles," Mark begged, "you make it very uncomfortable for
me when you talk like that about the Reverend Brother before me."
"Yes, but I must give my opinion. I have a right to criticize when I am
the person who is responsible for the Abbey's existence here. It's all
very fine for Brother George to ask me to notify Bazely at Wivelrod that
the brethren wish to go to their Easter duties in his church. Bazely is
a very timid man. I've already driven him into doing more than he really
likes, and my presence in his church doesn't alarm the parishioners. In
fact, they rather like it. But they won't like to see the church full of
monks on Easter morning. They'll be more suspicious than ever of what
they call poor Bazely's innovations. It's not fair to administer such a
shock to a remote country parish like Wivelrod, especially when they're
just beginning to get used to the vestments I gave them. It seems to me
that you've deliberately driven Andrew Hett away from the Abbey, and I
don't see why poor Bazely should be made to suffer. How many monks are
you now? Fifteen? Why, fifteen bulls in Wivelrod church would create
less dismay!"
Sir Charles's protest on behalf of the Vicar of Wivelrod was effective,
for the Prior announced that after all he had decided that it was the
duty of the Community to observe Easter within the Abbey gates. The
Reverend Father would return on Easter Tuesday, and their Easter duties
would be accomplished within the Octave. Withal, it was a gloomy Easter
for the brethren, and when they began the first Vespers with the
quadruple Alleluia, it seemed as if they were still chanting the
sorrowful antiphons of Good Friday.
_My spirit is vexed within Me: and My heart within Me is desolate._
_Is it nothing to you, all ye that pass by: behold and see if there
be any sorrow like unto My sorrow, which is done unto Me._
_What are these wounds in Thy Hands: Those with which I was wounded
in the house of My friends._
Nor was there rejoicing in the Community when at Lauds of Easter Day
they chanted:
_V. In Thy Resurrection, O Christ._
_R. Let Heaven and earth rejoice, Alleluia._
Nor when at Prime and Terce and Sext and None they chanted:
_This is the day which the Lord hath made; we will rejoice and be
glad in it._
And when at the second Vespers the Brethren declared:
_V. Christ our Passover is sacrificed for us, therefore let us keep
the Feast._
_R. Not with the old leaven, nor with the leaven of malice and
wickedness; but with the unleavened Bread of sincerity and
truth. Alleluia._
scarcely could they who chanted the versicle challenge with their eyes
those who hung down their heads when they gave the response.
* * * * *
The hour of recreation before Compline, which upon great Feasts was wont
to be so glad, lay heavily upon the brethren that night, so that Mark
could not bear to sit in the Cloister; there being no guests in the
Abbey for his attention, he sat in the library and wrote to the Rector.
The Abbey,
Malford, Surrey.
Easter Sunday.
My dear Rector,
I should have written before to wish you all a happy Easter, but
I've been making up my mind during the last fortnight to leave the
Order, and I did not want to write until my mind was made up. That
feat is now achieved. I shall stay here until St. George's Day, and
then the next day, which will be St. Mark's Eve, I shall come home
to spend my birthday with you. I do not regret the year and six
months that I have spent at Malford and Aldershot, because during
that time, if I have decided not to be a monk, I am none the less
determined to be a priest. I shall be 23 this birthday, and I hope
that I shall find a Bishop to ordain me next year and a Theological
College to accept responsibility for my training and a beneficed
priest to give me a title. I will give you a full account of myself
when we meet at the end of the month; but in this letter, written
in sad circumstances, I want to tell you that I have learnt with
the soul what I have long spoken with the lips--the need of God. I
expect you will tell me that I ought to have learnt that lesson
long ago upon that Whit-Sunday morning in Meade Cantorum church.
But I think I was granted then by God to desire Him with my heart.
I was scarcely old enough to realize that I needed Him with my
soul. "You're not so old now," I hear you say with a smile. But in
a place like this one learns almost more than one would learn in
the world in the time. One beholds human nature very intimately. I
know more about my fellow-men from association with two or three
dozen people here than I learnt at St. Agnes' from association with
two or three hundred. This much at least my pseudo-monasticism has
taught me.
We have passed through a sad time lately at the Abbey, and I feel
that for the Community sorrows are in store. You know from my
letters that there have been divisions, and you know how hard I
have found it to decide which party I ought to follow. But of
course the truth is that from the moment one feels the inclination
to side with a party in a community it is time to leave that
community. Owing to an unfortunate disagreement between Brother
George and the Reverend Andrew Hett, who came down to act as
chaplain during the absence of the Reverend Father, Andrew Hett
felt obliged to leave us. The consequence is we have had no Mass
this Easter, and thus I have learned with my soul to need God. I
cannot describe to you the torment of deprivation which I
personally feel, a torment that is made worse by the consciousness
that all my brethren will go to their cells to-night needing God
and not finding Him, because they like myself are involved in an
earthly quarrel, so that we are incapable of opening our hearts to
God this night. You may say that if we were in such a state we
should have had no right to make our Easter Communion. But that
surely is what Our Blessed Lord can do for us with His Body and
Blood. I have been realizing that all this Holy Week. I have felt
as I have never felt before the consciousness of sinning against
Him. There has not been an antiphon, not a versicle nor a response,
that has not stabbed me with a consciousness of my sin against His
Divine Love.
"What are these wounds in Thy Hands: Those with which I was wounded
in the house of My friends."
But if on Easter eve we could have confessed our sins against His
Love, and if this morning we could have partaken of Him, He would
have been with us, and our hearts would have been fit for the
presence of God. We should have been freed from this spirit of
strife, we should have come together in Jesus Christ. We should
have seen how to live "with the unleavened Bread of sincerity and
truth." God would have revealed His Will, and we, submitting our
Order to His Will, should have ceased to think for ourselves, to
judge our brethren, to criticize our seniors, to suspect that
brother of personal ambition, this brother of toadyism. The
Community is being devoured by the Dragon and, unless St. George
comes to the rescue of his Order on Thursday week, it will perish.
Perhaps I have not much faith in St. George. He has always seemed
to me an unreal, fairy-tale sort of a saint. I have more faith in
St. Benedict and his Holy Rule. But I have no vocation for the
contemplative life. I don't feel that my prayers are good enough to
save my own soul, let alone the souls of others. I _must_ give
Jesus Christ to my fellow-men in the Blessed Sacrament. I long to
be a priest for that service. I don't feel that I want by my own
efforts to make people better, or to relieve poverty, or to thunder
against sin, or to preach them up to and through Heaven's gates. I
want to give them the Blessed Sacrament, because I know that
nothing else will be the slightest use to them. I know it more
positively to-night than I have ever known it, because as I sit
here writing to you I am starved. God has given me the grace to
understand why I am starved. It is my duty to bring Our Lord to
souls who do not know why they are starved. And if after nearly two
years of Malford this passion to bring the Sacraments to human
beings consumes me like a fire, then I have not wasted my time, and
I can look you in the face and ask for your blessing upon my
determination to be a priest.
Your ever affectionate
Mark.
When Mark had written this letter, and thus put into words what had
hitherto been a more or less nebulous intention, and when in addition to
that he had affixed a date to the carrying out of his intention, he felt
comparatively at ease. He wasted no time in letting the Father Superior
know that he was going to leave; in fact he told him after he had
confessed to him before making his Communion on Easter Thursday.
"I'm sorry to lose you, my dear boy," said Father Burrowes. "Very sorry.
We are just going to open a priory in London, though that is a secret
for the moment, please. I shall make the announcement at the Easter
Chapter. Yes, some kind friends have given us a house in Soho.
Splendidly central, which is important for our work. I had planned that
you would be one of the brethren chosen to go there."
"It's very kind of you, Reverend Father," said Mark. "But I'm sure that
you understand my anxiety not to lose any time, now that I feel
perfectly convinced that I want to be a priest."
"I had my doubts about you when you first came to us. Let me see, it was
nearly two years ago, wasn't it? How time flies! Yes, I had my doubts
about you. But I was wrong. You seem to possess a real fixity of
purpose. I remember that you told me then that you were not sure you
wanted to be a monk. Rare candour! I could have professed a hundred
monks, had I been willing to profess them within ten minutes of their
first coming to see me."
The Father Superior gave Mark his blessing and dismissed him. Nothing
had been said about the dispute between the Prior and the Chaplain, and
Mark began to wonder if Father Burrowes thought the results of it would
tell more surely in favour of his own influence if he did not allude to
it nor make any attempt to adjudicate upon the point at issue. Now that
he was leaving Malford in little more than a week, Mark felt that he was
completely relieved of the necessity of assisting at any conventual
legislation, and he would gladly have absented himself from the Easter
Chapter, which was held on the Saturday within the Octave, had not
Father Burrowes told him that so long as he wore the habit of a novice
of the Order he was expected to share in every side of the Community's
life.
"Brethren," said the Father Superior, "I have brought you back news that
will gladden your hearts, news that will show I you how by the Grace of
God your confidence in my judgment was not misplaced. Some kind friends
have taken for us the long lease of a splendid house in Soho Square, so
that we may have our priory in London, and resume the active work that
was abandoned temporarily last Christmas. Not only have these kind
friends taken for us this splendid house, but other kind friends have
come forward to guarantee the working expenses up to £20 a week. God is
indeed good to us, brethren, and when I remember that next Thursday is
the Feast of our great Patron Saint, my heart is too full for words.
During the last three or four months there have been unhappy differences
of opinion in our beloved Order. Do let me entreat you to forget all
these in gratitude for God's bountiful mercies. Do let us, with the
arrival once more of our patronal festival, resolve to forget our doubts
and our hesitations, our timidity and our rashness, our suspicions and
our jealousies. I blame myself for much that has happened, because I
have been far away from you, dear brethren, in moments of great
spiritual distress. But this year I hope by God's mercy to be with you
more. I hope that you will never again spend such an Easter as this. I
have only one more announcement to make, which is that I have appointed
Brother Dominic to be Prior of St. George's Priory, Soho Square, and
Brother Chad and Brother Dunstan to work with him for God and our
soldiers."
In the morning, Brother Simon, whose duty it was nowadays to knock with
the hammer upon the doors of the cells and rouse the brethren from sleep
with the customary salutation, went running from the dormitory to the
Prior's cell, his hair standing even more on end than it usually did at
such an hour.
"Reverend Brother, Reverend Brother," he cried. "I've knocked and
knocked on Brother Anselm's door, and I've said 'The Lord be with you'
nine times and shouted 'The Lord be with you' twice, but there's no
answer, and at last I opened the door, though I know it's against the
Rule to open the door of a brother's cell, but I thought he might be
dead, and he isn't dead, but he isn't there. He isn't there, Reverend
Brother, and he isn't anywhere. He's nowhere, Reverend Brother, and
shall I go and ring the fire-alarm?"
Brother George sternly bade Brother Simon be quiet; but when the
Brethren sat in choir to sing Lauds and Prime, they saw that Brother
Anselm's stall was empty, and those who had heard Brother Simon's
clamour feared that something terrible had happened.
After Mass the Community was summoned to the Chapter room to learn from
the lips of the Father Superior that Brother Anselm had broken his vows
and left the Order. Brother Dunstan, who wore round his neck the nib
with which Brother Anselm signed his profession, burst into tears.
Brother Dominic looked down his big nose to avoid the glances of his
brethren. If Easter Sunday had been gloomy, Low Sunday was gloomier
still, and as for the Feast of St. George nobody had the courage to
think what that would be like with such a cloud hanging over the
Community.
Mark felt that he could not stay even until the patronal festival. If
Brother George or Brother Birinus had broken his vows, he could have
borne it more easily, for he had not witnessed their profession; fond he
might be of the Prior, but he had worked for human souls under the
orders of Brother Anselm. He went to Father Burrowes and begged to leave
on Monday.
"Brother Athanasius and Brother Chad are leaving tomorrow," said the
Father Superior, "Yes, you may go."
Brother Simon drove them to the station. Strange figures they seemed to
each other in their lay clothes.
"I've been meaning to go for a long time," said Brother Athanasius, who
was now Percy Wade. "And it's my belief that Brother George and Brother
Birinus won't stay long."
"I hoped never to go," said Brother Chad, who was now Cecil Masters.
"Then why are you going?" asked the late Brother Athanasius. "I never do
anything I don't want to do."
"I think I shall be more help to Brother Anselm than to soldiers in
London," said the late Brother Chad.
Mark beamed at him.
"That's just like you, Brother. I am so glad you're going to do that."
The train came in, and they all shook hands with Brother Simon, who had
been cheerful throughout the drive, and even now found great difficulty
in looking serious.
"You seem very happy, Brother Simon," said Mark.
"Oh, I am very happy, Brother Mark. I should say Mr. Mark. The Reverend
Father has told me that I'm to be clothed as a novice on Wednesday. All
last week when we sung, '_The Lord is risen indeed, and hath appeared
unto Simon_,' I knew something wonderful was going to happen. That's
what made me so anxious when Brother Anselm didn't answer my knock."
The train left the station, and the three ex-novices settled themselves
to face the world. They were all glad that Brother Simon at least was
happy amid so much unhappiness.