MR. PRESIDENT,--This question is not free from embarrassment,
especially where one is in favor of the line to Japan, and also in
favor of a line to the Sandwich Islands, as is the case with myself.
I am anxious to see each of these lines established, believing each
important to the general welfare, and especially to the commercial
interests of the country. But, strong as is my desire, I am not able
to see how the line to Japan can be advantageously held to turn aside
and stop at the Sandwich Islands. To bring these two objects into one
voyage is not unlike the idea of the elderly person who wished her
Bible to be the smallest size book and the largest size type. The two
things do not go together.
And yet, Sir, I confess that my interest in the Sandwich Islands
inclines me to do all that I can to strengthen and increase our
relations with them. I do not forget that these islands, though
originally discovered by a British navigator, are mainly indebted for
their present civilization to the United States. Missionaries of our
country have planted churches and schools at an expense of at least a
million dollars. One of our countrymen, the late John Pickering, of
Boston, the eminent philologist and scholar, invented the alphabet by
which the native language was reduced to a written text. The whalers of
New England have made these islands a resting-place. Our ships on their
way to China have made them a half-way house. Of all the foreign ships
which reach there five sixths are of our country. Such are the ties of
beneficence and of commerce by which we are bound to these islands. No
other nation there has an interest comparable in character or amount to
ours. Meanwhile the native population is constantly decaying, so that I
presume now it is not more than fifty thousand.
This brief review furnishes a glimpse of our interest in these islands.
They are the wards of the United States. We cannot turn away from them.
The Government must add its contribution also. On this account I have
heard with pleasure that a national ship, under the command of one
of our most intelligent officers, is to be stationed at the Sandwich
Islands. Her presence will exercise a salutary influence in sustaining
the interests of our people. This is something. But I confess that I
should like to see these islands bound to our continent by a steam line.
While declaring this desire, with my reasons for it, I am not
satisfied that it is proper to require the Japan line to perform this
service. It is clear, from unanswerable testimony, that the stoppage of
this line cannot be effected without such a deviation as materially to
interfere with its operations.
The testimony presented by the report is positive. Here, for instance,
is what is said by that eminent authority, Admiral Davis:--
“These considerations with regard to the eastern voyage appear
to dispose of the whole question. They show that touching at
the Sandwich Islands, on the return from China, would prolong
the voyage so many days unnecessarily that an additional line
of steamers must soon be established, provided the intercourse
between China and America is to acquire that importance which
is confidently expected.”
This concerns the voyage from Japan to San Francisco. But Admiral Davis
is also against stopping at the islands on the outward voyage.
It seems clear, then, that the Japanese line, in order to be effective,
and to accomplish what is so much desired, must be left to itself,
without being obliged to turn aside for any incidental purpose. It must
be a Japanese line, and nothing else; and you must not forget, that,
just in proportion as you impose upon it any additional obligations,
you will impair its efficiency as one of the splendid links of commerce
destined to put a girdle round the globe.
I am ready, therefore, to release the Japanese line from stopping at
the Sandwich Islands; but at the same time I declare my hope that some
other means will be found to secure a line to these islands.
In releasing the Company from this service, I am willing to leave to
them the full subsidy already appropriated; but I think they should be
held to shorten their voyage in proportion to the time gained. This
provision will remove an objection which has been made.
The joint resolution, as amended, passed the Senate,--Yeas
24, Nays 15,--but it was not considered in the House of
Representatives. At the next session a bill became a law,
authorizing the establishment of ocean mail steamship service
between the United States and the Hawaiian Islands.[40]