Zizi's Hunch
"He's afraid," and Norah wagged her head sagaciously, while her gray eyes
had an apprehensive expression.
"Afraid of what?"
"Afraid of the truth. You see, Mr. Brice, our friend Rivers is nobody's
fool. He's onto most points regarding this case, and now, he's getting
onto himself. That astute little scrap of humanity, Zizi, knows he is. Of
course, living with Miss Raynor, as she does, she has opportunities every
day to see Mr. Rivers, for he's eternally hanging around the Raynor
house. Oh, I don't mean he's an idler; not by a long shot. On the
contrary, his middle name is efficiency! He puts over a lot of work in a
day."
"What sort of work and how do you know so much about him?"
We were in my office, waiting for Rivers, who had promised to come to see
me, and to look into the Gately rooms. It was now nearly half an hour
after the time he had set for his call, and as it was not his habit to be
tardy, I was surprised. I had begun to look upon Rivers as a man of
importance, not only in the matters with which we were associated, but he
showed so much general ability and force of character that I wondered who
or what he would turn out to be. For I felt sure he would find himself,
and even if he never discovered who he had been he would make a new name
and a well worthwhile individuality for himself yet.
Norah, too, admired him, and seemed to know as much of his capabilities,
or more, than I did myself.
"I don't know just what sort of work, but I think it's connected with the
mysteries we're up against ourselves. And I know about him, because Zizi
told me. She sees everything he does,--when she's with him, I mean. Not a
gesture or motion escapes her notice. And she's watching his attitude
toward Miss Raynor. She says,--Zizi does,--that Mr. Rivers is over head
and ears in love with Olive, but he won't tell her so because he is, as
he puts it, a self-named man! Zizi heard him call himself that when
talking to Miss Raynor, and then he just looked away, and resolutely
changed the subject. But she thinks,--Zizi does,--that he's working night
and day to find out who he is, and she's sure he'll find out. And also,
he's working to find Mr. Gately's murderer, and he's hunting for Amory
Manning. No wonder the man's busy!"
"Well, why is he afraid to come here?"
"I'm not sure that he is; but you know Zizi has a hunch that he's the
murderer, and I think maybe he is. That snowflake sketch proves he was
there that day and as his presence isn't accounted for, why may he not
have been the slayer? And, why may he not have an inkling or a suspicion
of it, and dread to verify his fears?"
"But, good gracious, Norah, even granting he was in Gately's office that
day, he needn't have done the shooting. There are about one million other
errands he could have been there on. Perhaps he was a commercial
traveler, selling laces, and drew the design for a sample."
"Sometimes, Mr. Brice, you talk like a Tom-noddy! Drummer, indeed! I can
tell you whatever calling Case Rivers followed, it was far different from
that of a selling agent! I'll bet he was a lawyer, at least!"
"At least!" I mocked her; "understand, pray, I consider my profession
somewhat above the least of the professions!"
"Yes, for _you_ dignify it to a high standing," and the gray eyes flashed
me the smile of appreciation that I was looking for. I may as well admit
that I was growing very fond of those two gray eyes and their owner, and
I had a pretty strong conviction that after the present case was all
settled I should turn my attention to the winning of the exclusive right
to the tender glances those eyes could give.
But just now, I had to exclude all distracting thoughts, and forcing my
mind back to the present situation, I again marveled at the
non-appearance of Case Rivers.
"Perhaps he's fallen through the earth again," Norah suggested; "by the
way, Mr. Brice, what do you think about that fall? Mr. Rivers is no doubt
under some strange hallucination, but all the same, may there not be some
foundation on which he based his dream?"
"Maybe! There must be! That mind of his is too sure-fire to hang on so
desperately to a mere dream. He had some experience of a strange nature,
and it included something that he looks upon as falling through the
earth."
"Such as?"
"I don't know. But I've a vague idea of a motor accident. Say, a motor
car ran into a stone wall, and he was hurled high in the air, and landed
in the East River----"
"But I don't see how that implies falling through the earth."
"Well, say he slid down a high bank to reach the river----"
"There's no high bank near the morgue, and he was fished out in that
locality."
"But he needn't have fallen in there! In fact, he couldn't have,--he must
have floated or drifted a considerable distance to have had his clothing
torn from him--and to have reached the state of exhaustion and freezing
that so nearly culminated in death."
"Yes, but even yet, you haven't suggested anything like falling through
the earth."
"All right, Miss Smarty, what's your idea? I see you're dying to spring
something."
"Only what I've thought from the beginning. I believe he was in some cold
country, Canada, or somewhere, and fell down through a mine shaft, or
into a deep old well, or perhaps merely an excavation for a new, large
building. But, anyway, whatever it was, his last impression was of
falling down into the ground. Then when he struck he was knocked
unconscious. Then, he was taken to a hospital, or somewhere, and as the
fall had utterly blotted out his memory, he was kept in confinement.
Then, somehow he broke loose and came to New York,--or, maybe, he was
brought to New York for treatment by the doctors and he got away and
either threw himself into the river or fell in accidentally, and when he
was rescued he still remembered the fall but nothing else concerning his
disaster."
"Good enough, Norah, as a theory. But seems to me, in that case, he would
have been sought and found by the people who had him in charge."
"Ah, that's the point of it all! They don't want to find him! They know
just where he is, and all about him, but they won't tell, for it suits
their base purposes to have him lost!"
"Well, you _have_ cooked up a scheme! And he killed Amos Gately?"
"Maybe, but if so, he did it unknowingly. Perhaps these people who are
looking after him, secretly hypnotized him to do it----"
"Oh, Norah! come off! desist! let up! Next thing you know you'll be
having him in the movies! For you never thought up all that stuff without
getting hints for it from some slapstick melodrama!"
"Oh, well, people who are absolutely without imagination can't expect to
see into a mystery! But, you won't see any Mr. Rivers _this_ morning,--I
can assure you of that!"
She turned to her typewriter, and I took up my telephone.
I could not get Rivers at his home address, and I next called up Miss
Raynor.
She replied, in agitated tones, that Rivers had been to see her for a few
minutes, and that he had left half an hour before. She begged me to come
around at once.
Of course, I went.
I found her in a strange state of mind. She seemed like one who had made
a discovery, and was fearful of inadvertently disclosing it.
But when I urged her to be frank, she insisted she had nothing to
conceal.
"I don't know anything, Mr. Brice, truly I don't," she repeated. "I mean,
anything new or anything that I haven't told you. Mr. Rivers was here
this morning for a very short call. He said that while his memory had not
returned, he had a queer mental impression of being on a search for a
paper when he fell through the earth."
"Did he go down into the earth to seek the paper?" I asked, thinking it
best to treat the matter lightly.
"No," she returned, in all seriousness, "but he believes he was
commissioned to hunt out a valuable paper, of some sort, and while on the
quest he fell through the earth, by accident. It was the shock of that
that impaired his memory."
"Sufficient cause!" I couldn't help saying.
Olive bristled: "Oh, I know you don't believe his story,--almost nobody
does,--but I do."
"So do I!" and Zizi was in the room. One could never say of that girl
that she entered or came in,--she just--was there,--in that silent,
mysterious way of hers. And then with equally invisible motions she was
sitting opposite me, at Olive's side, on a low ottoman.
"I know Mr. Rivers very well," Zizi announced, as if she were his
official sponsor, "and what he says is true, no matter how unbelievable
it may sound. He says he fell through the earth, and so he _did_ fall
through the earth, and that's all there is about _that_!"
"Good for you, Zizi!" I cried. "You're a loyal little champion! And just
how did he accomplish the feat?"
"It will be explained in due season," and Zizi's big black eyes took on a
sibylline expression as she gazed straight at me. "If you were told, on
good authority, that a man had crossed the ocean in an aeroplane, you'd
believe it, wouldn't you?"
"Yes; but that doesn't seem to me a parallel case," I demurred.
"Neither is Case Rivers a parallel case," Zizi giggled, "but he's the
real thing in the way of Earth Fallers. And when you know all, you'll
know everything!"
The child was exasperating in her foolish retorts and yet so convincing
was the determined shake of her little black head that I was almost
tempted to believe in her statements.
"You're a baby sphinx, Zizi," and Olive looked at her affectionately,
"but honestly, Mr. Brice, she keeps my spirits up, and she is so positive
herself of what she says that she almost convinces me. As for Mrs. Vail,
she swallows everything Zizi says for law and gospel!"
"And just what is it you say, now, Zizi?" I asked.
"Nothin' much, kind sir. Only that Case Rivers is a gentleman and a
scholar, that his memory is on the home stretch and humming along, and
that if he's after a paper,--he'll get it!"
"And, incidentally he's Amos Gately's----"
A scream of agony from Zizi interrupted my speech, and jumping to her
feet she danced round the room, her forefinger thrust between her red
lips, and her little, eerie face contorted as with pain.
"Oh, what is it, Zizi?" cried Olive, running to the frantic girl.
Mrs. Vail, hearing the turmoil, came running in, and she and Olive held
Zizi between them, begging to know how she was hurt.
Catching an opportunity, Zizi looked at me, over Mrs. Vail's shoulder,
and the message shot from her eyes was fully as understandable as if she
had spoken. It said, "Do not mention any hint of Case Rivers' possible
connection with the Gately murder, and do not mention the snowflake drawn
on the blotter in Mr. Gately's office."
Yes, quite a lengthy and comprehensive speech to be made without words,
but the speaking black eyes said it as clearly as lips could have done.
I nodded my obedience, and then Zizi giggled and with her inimitable
impudence, she turned to Olive, and said: "I'm like the White Queen, in
'Alice,' I haven't pricked my finger yet, but I probably shall, some
day."
"What were you screaming about, then?" asked Mrs. Vail, inclined to be
angry, while Olive looked amused and mystified.
"Emergency," and Zizi grinned at her. "First aid to the injured,--or,
rather, prevention, which is worth a pound of first aid!"
"You're crazy!" said Mrs. Vail, a little annoyed at being fooled so. "I
thought you were nearly killed!"
"When you knew a lady once who was nearly killed did she yell like that?"
asked Zizi, with an innocent smile.
"Yes!" exclaimed Mrs. Vail; "but how did you know I once saw a lady
nearly killed?"
"Mind-reading!" replied Zizi, and then Pennington Wise arrived, and we
all shamelessly ignored Mrs. Vail and her yarns to listen to his report.
"There's a lot doing," he said, "and," he added, gently, "I'm sorry to
bring you unpleasant news, Miss Raynor, but you'll have to know sooner or
later----"
"I do know," said Olive, bravely; "you're going to tell me my guardian
was--was not a good man."
"That is so; it is useless to try to soften the truth. Amos Gately was
the receiver of important Government secrets, learned by Sadie Kent, the
telegrapher. She carried them to Rodman, who in turn transmitted them to
Gately, who, it seems, had a way of getting the information to the enemy.
Of course, the secret wireless station, recently discovered, was used, as
well as other means of communication. I won't go into details, Miss
Raynor, but Amos Gately was the 'man higher up,' who thought himself safe
from discovery because of his unimpeachable reputation for integrity, and
also because of the infinite precautions he had taken. Indeed, if he had
not fallen a victim to the personal charms of 'The Link,' his share in
the wrong might never have been learned."
Olive listened to all this, white-faced and still,--her lips a tense,
drawn line of scarlet,--her expression a stony calm.
Zizi, watching her closely, and with loving care, slipped her little
brown paw into Olive's hand, and noted with satisfaction the faint
answering smile.
"Perhaps," Olive said, after a thoughtful pause, "it is as well, then,
that Uncle Amos did not--did not live to be--disgraced."
"It is," said Wise, gravely; "he would have faced a Federal prison had it
all been discovered while he lived. That will be Rodman's fate,--if he is
not held for the crime of murder. But I think he will not be. For his
alibi clears him and it was to escape the graver charge that he has told
so much of the spy business."
"And so," I said, "we are as far as ever from the discovery of the
murderer?"
"You never can tell," Wise returned; "it may be we are on the very eve of
solving the mystery. Rivers is on the warpath----"
"I think I ought to tell you, Mr. Wise," Olive broke in, "that Mr. Rivers
was here this morning, and he seems to have a slight glimmer of returning
memory."
"He has? Good! Then it will all come back to him. I've been looking up
this aphasia-amnesia business, and quite often when the patient begins to
recover his memory, it all comes back to him with a bang! Where is
Rivers?"
"He went away--I don't know where----" Olive's lips quivered, and so
plainly did she show her feelings that we all saw at once she feared that
Rivers had fled, _because_ of his returning memory.
"It's all right," declared Zizi, stanchly; "Mr. Rivers is white clear
through! He'll come back, soon, and he'll bring the paper he's after."
"What paper?" demanded Wise.
"The poipers! the poipers!" scoffed Zizi; "did you ever know a case, oh,
Wise Guy, that didn't revolve round and hinge on a poiper? Well, the
dockyments in the case is what he's a-soichin' for! See?"
When Zizi acted the _gamine_ she was irresistibly funny and we all
laughed, which was what she wanted to lighten the strain of the
situation.
Rivers was a mystery, indeed. Every one of us, I think, felt that he
might be connected with the Gately affair. All of us, that is, but
Olive,--and who could tell what she thought?
But Pennington Wise had a question to ask, and he put it
straightforwardly.
"That day you were lured to Sadie 'The Link's' house, Miss Raynor," he
began, "you said, or rather, you agreed when Rodman said you were his
_fiancée_. Will you tell us why?"
Olive flushed, but more with anger than embarrassment.
"The man threatened me," she said, "he first tried to make love to me,
and when I repulsed him, he told me that unless I would promise to marry
him he would tell something that would be a living reproach to the memory
of my dead guardian. I declared he could say nothing against Amos Gately.
Then he whispered that Mr. Gately was a spy! I couldn't believe it,
and--yet, I had seen just a few things,--had heard just a few words, that
filled my heart with a fear that Mr. Rodman was speaking the truth. So I
thought I'd better say what he asked me to, though I knew I'd kill myself
rather than ever marry him. But I wasn't greatly afraid, except that I
knew I was in his power. Oh, I don't like to think about that day!"
Olive broke down and hid her face in her hands, while Zizi's thin little
arms crept round her and held her close.
"Only one more query, Miss Raynor," and Wise spoke very gently; "are
you,--were you engaged to Amory Manning?"
Olive lifted her face, and spoke composedly: "No, Mr. Wise, I was never
engaged to him. We were good friends, and I think he had a high regard
for me, but no words of affection ever passed between us. I admire and
respect Mr. Manning as a friend, but that is all." And then a lovely
blush suffused Olive's face, followed quickly by a look of pain,--and we
knew she was thinking of Rivers, and his possible defection. Never have I
seen a woman's face so easy to read as Olive Raynor's. Perhaps because of
her pure, transparent character, for in my enforced intimacy with her, as
I managed her estate, I had learned that she was an exceptional nature,
high-minded, fine, and conscientious in all things.
"I cannot think," Olive went on, "that Mr. Manning will ever be found. I
think he has been killed."
"Why?" asked Wise, briefly.
"You know, he was a Secret Service man. Many times he has had the
narrowest escape with his life, and--I'm not sure of this,--but I think
now, he was on the track of the nest of spies with which my--with which
Mr. Gately was mixed up. A few slight incidents, otherwise unexplainable,
make this clear to me now, though I never suspected it before. My uncle
disliked Mr. Manning, and it may have been because he knew he was in the
Government's employ. And though I know Mr. Gately would never have moved
a finger to put Amory Manning out of the way, yet George Rodman may have
done so. Oh, it's all so mysterious, so complicated,--but of this I'm
sure, Case Rivers is in no way connected with the whole matter. He is a
man from some distant city, he is unacquainted in New York, and he----"
here Olive broke down utterly and fell into a hysterical burst of
weeping.
Zizi rose and gently urged Olive to go with her from the room.
A silence fell as the two girls disappeared. It was broken by Mrs. Vail,
who remarked, dolefully, "I do hope that nice Mr. Rivers will come back,
for dear Olive is _so_ in love with him."
"What!" cried Pennington Wise, "Miss Raynor in love with Rivers! That
will never do! Why, we've no idea who he is. He may be a fortune-hunter
of the lowest type!"
"Oh, no, no!" denied Mrs. Vail, "he is a most courteous gentleman."
"That doesn't count," stormed Wise; "although, perhaps, I spoke too
strongly just now when I called him names!"
"Especially as he has no name!" I put in; "in fact, he calls himself a
self-named man!"
Wise smiled: "He is a witty chap," he conceded, "and I like him
immensely. But it's up to us, Brice, to safeguard Miss Raynor's
interests, and a possible suitor for the hand of an heiress ought, at
least, to know his own ancestors! And then, again, unless he recovers his
memory and can deny it, there's a fair chance that he had some hand in
the Gately murder. We can't get away from that snowflake pattern drawn on
the blotter. Rivers was there, in that room, he sat at Gately's desk,
opposite Gately himself,--I mean, of course, this is the way I
reconstruct the matter,--and if he didn't shoot Gately then and there, at
least, we have no proof that he didn't."
"I think he did," I admitted, for Wise's statement of the matter was
convincing,--and beside, Norah thought so, too.
"Well, you think again!" came in a wild little voice, and there was Zizi
at my elbow fairly shaking her little clenched fist in my face. "Mr.
Badman Brice, you've got a lot of follow-up thinks a-coming to you, and
you'd better begin 'em right now!"
She looked like a little fury as she danced around my chair and exploded
the vials of her wrath. "That Mr. Rivers is a perfectly good man,--I
know! He and Miss Olive are in love,--but they don't hardly know it
themselves,--bless 'em! And Mr. Rivers he won't tell her, anyway, 'cause
he's a nobleman,--one of Nature's maybe,--and again, maybe he's a real
one from Canada, or wherever he hails from. But, anyway, he no more
killed anybody than I did!"
"All right, Ziz,--bully for you! As a loyal friend you're there with the
goods!" Wise smiled at her. "But after all, you've got only your loyalty
to bank on. You don't _know_ all this."
"I've got a hunch," said Zizi, pounding one little fist into the other
palm, "and when it comes to certainty,--Death and Taxes have nothing on
my hunches!"