B. HAPPINESS OF OTHERS

It is inevitable for human nature that man a should wish and seek for

happiness, that is, satisfaction with his condition, with certainty of

the continuance of this satisfaction. But for this very reason it is

not an end that is also a duty. Some writers still make a

distinction between moral and physical happiness (the former

consisting in satisfaction with one's person and moral behaviour, that

is, with what one does; the other in satisfaction with that which

nature confers, consequently with what one enjoys as a foreign

gift). Without at present censuring the misuse of the word (which even

involves a contradiction), it must be observed that the feeling of the

former belongs solely to the preceding head, namely, perfection. For

he who is to feel himself happy in the mere consciousness of his

uprightness already possesses that perfection which in the previous

section was defined as that end which is also duty.

If happiness, then, is in question, which it is to be my duty to

promote as my end, it must be the happiness of other men whose

(permitted) end I hereby make also mine. It still remains left to

themselves to decide what they shall reckon as belonging to their

happiness; only that it is in my power to decline many things which

they so reckon, but which I do not so regard, supposing that they have

no right to demand it from me as their own. A plausible objection

often advanced against the division of duties above adopted consists

in setting over against that end a supposed obligation to study my own

(physical) happiness, and thus making this, which is my natural and

merely subjective end, my duty (and objective end). This requires to

be cleared up.

Adversity, pain, and want are great temptations to transgression

of one's duty; accordingly it would seem that strength, health, a

competence, and welfare generally, which are opposed to that

influence, may also be regarded as ends that are also duties; that is,

that it is a duty to promote our own happiness not merely to make that

of others our end. But in that case the end is not happiness but the

morality of the agent; and happiness is only the means of removing the

hindrances to morality; permitted means, since no one has a right to

demand from me the sacrifice of my not immoral ends. It is not

directly a duty to seek a competence for one's self; but indirectly it

may be so; namely, in order to guard against poverty which is a

great temptation to vice. But then it is not my happiness but my

morality, to maintain which in its integrity is at once my end and

my duty.

{INTRODUCTION ^paragraph 55}

The Metaphysical Elements of Ethics · 第 12 / 52 题