XLII. From this experience Antonius, learning what he ought to do,

covered not only the rear, but also both flanks with many javelin men

and slingers, and led his army in the form of a quadrangle; and the

cavalry received orders to repel the attack of the enemy, but when they

had repulsed them, not to pursue far, in consequence of which the

Parthians during the four following days sustained as much damage as

they inflicted, and their ardour being dulled they thought of retiring,

as an excuse for which they alleged the approach of winter. On the fifth

day Flavius Gallus, a man of military talent and great activity, who

held a command, came and asked Antonius for more light-armed troops for

the rear,[414] and for some of the cavalry from the van, in the

expectation of having great success. Antonius gave him the troops, and

when the enemy made his attack, he fell upon them, not as on former

occasions, at the same time withdrawing towards the heavy-armed soldiers

and retreating, but resisting them and engaging with the enemy in a

desperate way. The commanders of the rear seeing that he was being

separated from them, sent and called him back, but he would not listen

to them. They say that Titius the quæstor, seizing the standards, turned

them round and abused Gallus for throwing away the lives of many brave

men. But as Gallus abused him in turn, and urged those about him to

remain, Titius retreated. While Gallus was pushing forwards against the

enemy in front, a large body of those in the rear got round him before

he perceived it. Being now attacked on all sides he sent for aid; but

the commanders of the heavy-armed troops, among whom was Canidius, a man

who had the greatest influence with Antonius, are considered to have

committed a great mistake. For when they ought to have moved the whole

line against the enemy, they sent a few at a time to help against them;

and again when these were being worsted, they sent others, and thus

these came near filling the whole army with defeat and flight before

they were aware of it; but Antonius himself quickly came with the

heavy-armed men from the van to meet the enemy, and the third legion

quickly pushing through the fugitives against the enemy stopped their

further pursuit.

XLIII. There fell no fewer than three thousand; and there were carried

to the tents five thousand wounded, and among them Gallus, who was

pierced with five arrows in front. Gallus did not recover from his

wounds; but Antonius, going about, visited the rest of the wounded, and

he encouraged them with tears in his eyes and deep sympathy. The men,

cheerfully grasping his right hand, begged him to go and take care of

his health and not to trouble himself about them, calling him Imperator,

and saying that they were all secure if he was only safe. For altogether

it seems that no Imperator of that age got together an army more

distinguished by courage or endurance or strength; but the respect

towards the commander himself, and the obedience combined with

affection, and the circumstance that all alike, those of good

reputation, those of bad, commanders, private soldiers, preferred honour

and favour from Antonius to their own lives and safety, left nothing

even for the ancient Romans to surpass, and of this there were several

reasons, as we have said before; noble birth, powerful eloquence,

simplicity, generosity and munificence, affability in his pleasures and

conversation. On that occasion, by the pains that he took and his

sympathy with the wounded, and by sharing with them whatever they

wanted, he made the sick and wounded more full of alacrity than those

who were whole.

XLIV. However the victory so elated the enemy, who were already worn out

and exhausted, and they despised the Romans so much that they even

passed the night[415] close to the camp, expecting that they should soon

plunder the deserted tents and the baggage of the Romans skulking away.

At daybreak the enemy crowded upon them in still greater numbers, and

there are said to have been not fewer than forty thousand horsemen, as

the king had sent even those who were always placed around himself, as

to certain and secure success; for the king himself was never present in

any battle. But Antonius, wishing to harangue the soldiers, asked for a

dark garment that he might appear more piteous. But as his friends

opposed him, he came forward in the purple dress of a general and

addressed the troops, praising those who had been victorious, and

upbraiding those who had fled. The former exhorted him to be of good

cheer, and the others making their apology offered themselves to him

either to be decimated or to be punished in any other way; only they

prayed him to cease being troubled and grieved. Hereupon, raising his

hands, he prayed to the gods, that if any reverse of fortune should

follow on account of his former prosperity, it might come upon him, but

that they would give safety and victory to the rest of the army.

XLV. On the following day they advanced under better protection; and

when the Parthians made their attack, the result was very contrary to

their expectations. For they expected to advance to plunder and booty,

and not to battle; but as they were assailed by many missiles, and saw

that the Romans were encouraged and fresh with alacrity, they were again

completely wearied of the contest. However the Parthians again fell upon

them as they were descending some steep hills, and galled them with

arrows as they were slowly retreating, whereon the shield-bearers[416]

faced about and placing the light-armed troops within their ranks,

dropped down on one knee and held their shields before them; those

behind held their shields before the front rank, and those who were

behind the second rank did the same. This form, which very much

resembles a roof,[417] presents a theatrical appearance, and is the

safest of bulwarks against the arrows, which thus glance off. But the

Parthians, who thought that the Romans bending on one knee was a sign of

exhaustion and fatigue, laid aside their bows, and grasping their spears

by the middle, came to close quarters. But the Romans with one shout all

at once sprang up, and pushing with their javelins which they held in

their hands, killed the foremost and put all the rest to flight. This

took place also on the following days, the Romans making only small way.

Famine also attacked the army, which could get little grain and that

with fighting, and they had few implements for grinding; for the greater

part were left behind, owing to some of the beasts dying, and others

being employed in carrying the sick and wounded. It is said that an

Attic choenix[418] of wheat was sold for fifty drachmæ; and they sold

barley loaves for their weight in silver. Then they betook themselves to

vegetables and roots; but they found few of the kind that they were

accustomed to, and being compelled to make trial of what they had never

tasted before, they ate of one herb that caused madness and then death.

For he who had eaten of it recollected nothing, and understood nothing,

and busied himself about nothing except one sole thing, which was to

move and turn every stone, as if he were doing something of great

importance. The plain was full of men stooping to the ground and digging

round stones and moving them; and finally they vomited bile and died,

for wine, which was the only remedy, failed them. As many were dying and

the Parthians did not desist from their attack, they say that Antonius

often cried out "O the ten thousand!"[419] whereby he expressed his

admiration of the ten thousand, that though they marched even a greater

distance, from Babylonia, and fought with many more enemies, yet they

made good their retreat.

XLVI. The Parthians, not being able to break through the Roman army nor

yet to separate their ranks, and being already often defeated and put to

flight, again mingled in a friendly way with those who went out for

grass or corn, and pointing to the strings of their bows which were

unstrung, said, that they were going back and this was the end of their

attack; but that a few of the Medes would follow still one or two days'

journey without annoying them at all, and for the purpose of protecting

the more distant villages. To these words were added embraces and signs

of friendship, so that the Romans were again of good cheer; and Antonius

hearing this resolved to keep nearer to the plains, as the road through

the mountains was said to be waterless. While he was intending to do

this, there came to the camp a man from the enemy, named Mithridates, a

cousin of Monæses, of him who had been with Antonius and had received

the three cities as a present. And he asked for some one to come near to

him who could speak the Parthian or the Syrian language. Alexander of

Antioch came to him, and he was an intimate friend of Antonius,

whereupon Mithridates, saying who he was, and intimating that they must

thank Monæses for what he was going to say, asked Alexander, if he saw

in the distance a continuous range of lofty mountains. On Alexander

saying that he saw them, he replied, "Under those mountains the

Parthians with all their forces lie in ambush for you. For the great

plains border on these mountains, and they expect that you will be

deceived by them and will turn in that direction and leave the road

through the mountains. The way over the mountains is attended with

thirst and labour to which you are accustomed, but if Antonius goes by

the plain, let him be assured that the fate of Crassus awaits him."

XLVII. Having said this, he went away; and Antonius, who was troubled at

these words, called together his friends and the Mardian who was their

guide, and had exactly the same opinion. For even if there were no

enemy, he knew that the want of roads in the plains and the mistakes in

the track which they might make there were matters of hazard and

difficulty; but he declared that the road over the mountains presented

no other risk than the want of water for a single day. Accordingly

Antonius turned aside and led his army by this route by night, having

given orders to the men to take water with them. But the greater part

had no vessels, and accordingly they filled their helmets with water and

carried them, and others took it in skins. As soon as Antonius began to

advance, the Parthians had intelligence of it, and contrary to their

custom they commenced the pursuit while it was still night. Just as the

sun was rising, they came up with the rear, which was in weak condition

through want of sleep and fatigue: for they had accomplished two hundred

and forty stadia in the night; and the enemy coming upon them so

suddenly when they did not expect it, dispirited them. The contest

increased their thirst, for they still advanced while they were

defending themselves. Those who were in the first ranks, as they were

marching onwards, came to a river,[420] the water of which was cool and

pellucid, but salt and of a medicinal nature; and this water, when drank

of immoderately, caused pains with purging and augmentation of the

thirst: and though the Mardian had warned them of this, the soldiers

nevertheless forced away those who tried to hinder them and drank of the

water. Antonius went round to the men and prayed them to hold out for a

short time, and he said there was another river not far off, and besides

this, the rest of the route was impracticable for horses and rough, so

that the enemy must certainly turn back. At the same time he summoned

those who were engaged in the fight and gave the signal for pitching the

tents, that the soldiers might at least enjoy the shade a little.

XLVIII. While then the tents were being fixed and the Parthians as usual

were immediately retiring, Mithridates came again, and upon Alexander

going up to him, he advised him to put the army in motion after it had

rested a little and to hasten to the river: for he said that the

Parthians would not cross it, but would follow up the pursuit as far as

the river. Alexander reported this to Antonius, and then brought out

from him numerous gold cups and goblets, of which Mithridates taking as

many as he could hide in his dress, rode off. As it was still daylight,

they broke up their tents and advanced, without being annoyed by the

enemy; but they made that night of all others the most painful and

frightful to themselves. For they killed and plundered those who had

silver or gold, and took the things that were carried by the beasts; and

finally falling upon the baggage of Antonius, they cut in pieces and

divided among them cups and costly tables, there being great disturbance

and confusion through the whole army; for they thought that the enemy

had fallen upon them and that flight and dispersion had ensued, Antonius

called one of the freedmen, who was on his guard, named Rhamnus, and

bound him by oath when he gave him the order, to push his sword through

him and to cut off his head, that he might neither be taken alive by the

enemy nor be recognised when dead. His friends broke out in tears, but

the Mardian encouraged Antonius by telling him that the river was near;

for a moist breeze blowing and a cooler air meeting them made their

respiration more agreeable; and he said that the time they had been on

the march confirmed his estimate of the distance, for what now remained

of the night was not much. At the same time others reported that the

disorder was owing to their own wrongful deeds and rapacity. Accordingly

Antonius, wishing to bring the army into order from their state of

disorder and confusion, commanded the signal to be given for pitching

the tents.

XLIX. Day was now dawning, and as the army was beginning to get into

certain order and tranquillity, the arrows of the Parthians fell upon

the rear, and the signal for battle was given to the light-armed troops.

The heavy-armed troops again covering one another in like manner as

before with their shields, stood the assault of the missiles, the enemy

not venturing to come near. The first ranks advancing slowly in this

form, the river was seen; and Antonius drawing up his cavalry on the

banks in face of the enemy, took across the weak first. Those who were

fighting were now relieved from apprehension, and had the opportunity of

drinking; for when the Parthians saw the river, they unstrung their bows

and bade the Romans pass over in confidence, with great encomiums on

their valour. Accordingly, they crossed, and recruited themselves

quietly; and then they marched forwards, but yet not with full

confidence in the Parthians. On the sixth day after the last battle they

reached the river Araxes,[421] which is the boundary between Media and

Armenia. It appeared dangerous both for its depth and roughness, and a

rumour went through the army that the enemy was in ambush there, and

would fall on them as they were crossing. When they had safely crossed

and had set foot in Armenia, as if they had just got sight of that land

from the sea, they saluted it and fell to shedding of tears and

embracing of one another for joy. In their progress through a fertile

country, during which they used everything freely after having suffered

great want, they were subject to dropsical and bowel complaints.

L. Antonius there made a review of his men, and he found that twenty

thousand infantry and four thousand cavalry had perished; not all by the

enemy, but above half by disease. They marched from Phraata

twenty-seven days, and they defeated the Parthians in eighteen battles;

but these victories brought neither strength nor security, because their

pursuits were short and ineffectual. And this mainly showed that it was

Artavasdes[422] the Armenian who had deprived Antonius of the means of

bringing that war to an end. For if the sixteen thousand horsemen whom

he drew out of Media had been present, who were equipped like the

Parthians, and were accustomed to fight against them, and if, while the

Romans put to flight the fighting enemy, they had overtaken the

fugitives, it would not have been in their power after a defeat to

recover themselves and venture again so often. All the army accordingly

in passion endeavoured to incite Antonius to punish the Armenian. But

Antonius upon considerations of prudence neither reproached him for his

treachery nor abated of his usual friendly behaviour and respect towards

him, being weak in numbers and in want of supplies. Afterwards, however,

when he again broke into Armenia, and by many promises and invitations,

persuaded Artavasdes to come into his hands, he seized him and took him

in chains to Alexandria, where he was led in triumph. And herein chiefly

he offended the Romans, by giving to the Egyptians for the sake of

Cleopatra the honourable and solemn ceremonial of his native country.

This however took place later.

LI. Antonius now pressed on his march, the winter having already set in

with severity, through incessant snow-storms, in which he lost eight

thousand men on the route. Going down to the sea-coast with a very small

body of men, he waited for Cleopatra[423] in a place between Berytus and

Sidon, called "White village"; and as she was slow in coming, he became

uneasy and restless, soon giving himself up to drinking and

intoxication, but yet being unable to continue at table; for while his

companions were drinking he would rise and often spring up to look out,

till Cleopatra arrived there by sea bringing a quantify of clothes and

supplies for the soldiers. There are some who say that Antonius received

the clothes from her, but that the money was his own, though he

distributed it as if it were a present to him from Cleopatra.

LII. A quarrel arose between the king of the Medes and Phraortes[424]

the Parthian, which originated, as they say, about the Roman spoils, but

caused the Mede to have suspicions and fear of being deprived of his

dominions. For this reason he sent to invite Antonius, and proffered to

join him in a war with his own forces. Antonius accordingly being put in

great hope--for the only thing as he thought which had been the cause of

his failing to subdue the Parthians, his having gone against them

without many horsemen and bowmen, he now saw was offered to him in such

way that his part was rather to do a favour by accepting than to ask for

one--was preparing again to march into the upper country through Armenia,

and after joining the Mede near the Araxes, then to recommence the war.

LIII. At Rome Octavia[425] was desirous of going to Antonius, and Cæsar

gave her permission; as the greater part say, not with the design of

pleasing her, but in order that if she were greatly insulted and

neglected, he might have a specious pretext for the war. On reaching

Athens she received letters from Antonius, in which he told her to stay

there, and informed her of his intended expedition. Though Octavia was

annoyed, and saw that this was only a pretext, she wrote to him to ask

to what place he would have the things sent which she was bringing to

him. And she was taking a great quantity of clothing for the army, many

beasts, and money and presents for his officers and friends; and besides

this, two thousand picked soldiers equipped as prætorian cohorts, with

splendid armour. A certain Niger, a friend of Antonius, who was sent by

Octavia, reported this to him, and he added commendation of Octavia such

as she merited and was just. But Cleopatra, seeing that Octavia was

entering into a contest with her, and fearing that if to the dignity of

her behaviour and the power of Cæsar she added the pleasure of social

intercourse and attention to Antonius, she would be invincible and get

complete mastery over her husband, pretended to be desperately in love

with Antonius, and she wasted her body by spare diet; and she put on the

expression of strong passion when he approached her, and of sorrow and

depression when he went away. She also contrived to be often seen in

tears, which she would all at once wipe away and affect to conceal, as

if she did not wish Antonius to observe it. She practised these arts

while Antonius was preparing for his expedition from Syria against the

Mede.[426] Flatterers, too, who were busy in her behalf, abused Antonius

as a hard and unfeeling man, who was causing the death of a woman who

was devoted to him alone. As to Octavia, she came to meet Antonius upon

business on her brother's account, and enjoyed the name of wife of

Antonius; but Cleopatra, who was the queen of so many people, was only

called the beloved of Antonius, and she did not shun nor disdain this

name, so long as she could see Antonius and live with him; but if she

were driven away from him, she would not survive. At last they so melted

and softened the man, that through fear that Cleopatra might destroy

herself, he returned to Alexandria, and put off the Mede to the summer

season, though the affairs of Parthia were said to be in a state of

anarchy. However, he went up into the country, and brought over the king

to friendly terms, and after betrothing to one of his sons by Cleopatra

one of the daughters of the king, who was still a young child, he

returned, being now engaged in preparing for the civil war.

LIV. When Octavia returned from Athens, as Cæsar conceived her to have

been insulted, he ordered her to dwell in her own house. But she refused

to leave her husband's house, and she advised her brother, if he had not

for other reasons determined to go to war with Antonius, to let her

affairs alone, for it was not even decent to be said, that of the

greatest Imperators, one through love for a woman, and the other

through jealousy, brought the Romans to civil war. This she said, and

she confirmed what she said by her acts; for she lived in her husband's

house, just as if he were at home, and she took care of the children,

both her own and those of Fulvia, in an honourable and liberal way; she

also received the friends of Antonius who were sent to Rome to get

offices or on business, and assisted them in obtaining from Cæsar what

they wanted. She thus unintentionally damaged Antonius, for he was hated

for wronging such a woman. He was also hated for the division which he

made among his children at Alexandria, which appeared to be

tragical[427] and arrogant, and to show hatred of the Romans. For he

filled the gymnasium with a crowd, and caused to be placed on a tribunal

of silver two thrones of gold, one for himself, and the other for

Cleopatra, and for the children other thrones which were lower; and

first of all he declared Cleopatra Queen of Egypt and Cyprus and Libya

and Coele Syria, with Cæsarion as co-regent, who was believed to be the

son of the former Cæsar, who left Cleopatra pregnant; in the next place

he proclaimed his sons and Cleopatra's to be Kings of Kings; and to

Alexander he gave Armenia, and Media, and Parthia, when he should have

subdued it, and to Ptolemæus he gave Phoenice and Syria and Cilicia. At

the same time also he led forth Alexander, dressed in a Median vest with

a tiara and cittaris[428] upright, and Ptolemæus in boots, and a

chlamys, and a causia with a diadem attached to it; for this was the

dress of the kings who followed Alexander, and the other was the dress

of the Medes and Armenians. After the children had embraced their

parents, a guard of Armenians was placed around the one, and of

Macedonians around the other. Cleopatra, both on that occasion and on

other occasions when she went out before the people, used to put on a

dress sacred to Isis, different from her ordinary dress, and she was

called the new Isis.

LV. By bringing these matters before the Senate, and often complaining

of them before the people, Cæsar excited the multitude against Antonius.

Antonius also sent and made recriminations against Cæsar. The chief

charges which Antonius made against him were, in the first place, that

though he had taken Sicily from Pompeius, he did not give him a part of

the island; second, that Cæsar had borrowed ships from him for the war

and had kept them; third, that after ejecting his colleague Lepidus from

his authority and degrading him, Cæsar kept the army and territory and

revenues that were assigned to Lepidus;[429] and, finally, that he had

distributed nearly all Italy in allotments among his own soldiers, and

had left nothing for the soldiers of Antonius. To these charges Cæsar

replied, that he had deprived Lepidus of his authority because he was

abusing it, and as to what he had acquired in war, he would share it

with Antonius, when Antonius should share Armenia with him. He further

said that the soldiers of Antonius had no claim to any share of Italy,

for that they had Media and Parthia, which they had added to the Roman

possessions by their brave conduct in war under their Imperator.

Plutarch's Lives, Volume 4 (of 4) · 第 22 / 66 段