NO MAN IS COMPETENT TO BE HIS OWN CRITIC.

Unless he is a profound Anthropologist he has no standard of humanity,

no absolute standard with which to compare himself, and if he should

attempt to form such a standard, his personal defects would vitiate

the result.

I never go into society without witnessing examples of those who need

earnest psychic admonition. For example, among public speakers, I

would mention certain defects: A., with a broad forehead and richly

endowed intellect, has not sufficient development of the highest

regions of the brain to give him moral dignity or to enable him to

discriminate well between the noble upright and the cunning selfish.

His superior intellect is shown not by impressive eloquence, but by

energetic loquacity, and hence fails to receive full recognition. B.

has the dignity and power in which A. is deficient, but lacking in the

organs of love, sympathy and liberality, he becomes harsh, censorious

and bitterly controversial, making many enemies and leading a wretched

home-life. C. has a grand oratorical energy and dignity, but lacking

in the organs of reverence and humility, he overrates himself and

becomes famous for his vanity. D. has the intellect, wit, humor, and

social qualities to shine in company, but from lack of the organ of

self-respect, he fails to maintain the dignity of a gentleman and

command proper respect in society. E. had the power and genius to rank

among the most eloquent and distinguished men of the nation, but the

too broad base of his brain overcame all his nobler qualities, and,

after becoming an object of general contempt, he ended his life a

worthless sot. F. had an intellectual genius of the highest order, and

ought to have left a name among the great scientists of the age, but

the regions of moral energy, cheerfulness, and adhesiveness were

lacking in his brain, and hence he never attained any great success or

retained any satisfactory position. His life ran down into pessimism,

failure, and premature decay. G. had another splendid intellect and

made his mark on the times, but lacking in the region of dignity and

self-control, he failed to reach his just position in political life

and fell into premature mental decay from over-excitement. H., with

much less of intellectual capacity, but a better balanced organization

rose to the highest rank in the esteem of his countrymen. I., with an

intellect adapted to the exploration of the mysteries of science, of

which he gave good evidence, but lacking in all the elements of

strength of character lead a life of uniform failure, obscurity and

poverty, and yet I felt assured that a different education in youth

which would have developed his manhood and ambition and would have

carried him to eminence. J. is a man of superior intellect,

benevolence and strength of character, but the organ of love is

singularly defective in his head and his domestic life is therefore

void of happiness.

Neither the men nor the women in whom I have observed the deficiency

of the faculty of love, ever seemed to be aware of the fact or to

suspect that their intense antipathies were the product of a faulty

organization, and their discords chargeable to themselves.

K. and L. are two gentlemen richly endowed in intellect and in the

other virtues, but not in conscientiousness, in which they are

strangely deficient. This is the only defective region in their heads

and it is fully borne out in their lives, which are void of integrity

and truth, though they have escaped the condemnation of the law.

M. was a lady of intense ambition in whom the regions of love and

religion were deficient. Aspiring to be a leader in philanthropic

reform she had a limited following in an erratic course, but ended her

labors by obtaining a snug position for herself and repudiating all

she had done. N. was another would-be leader in philanthropic reforms,

who was at one time quite conspicuous, but while he had the ideal

speculative intellect to appreciate theories, he was lacking in love

and religion. His philanthropy did not pay, and he abandoned it

entirely for a life of selfish self-indulgence.

I might enumerate many more, with whose organic development I was

familiar, whose lives displayed conspicuously their organic defects of

brain, but who never seemed to understand their own deficiencies or

make any effort to correct them. Could they have been corrected in

adult life? Much might have been done if they had understood and been

admonished by Anthropology. I know of one in whom an organic defect

was pointed out, in his first manhood, who, by persistent effort, so

far overcame it as to modify the form of his head, and increase its

fulness in the moral regions. But, as the world goes, men are not

admonished, and they cherish their defects, refusing to believe that

they are faults.

It is in childhood and youth that the work of reformation is to be

accomplished, when parents and teachers shall have learned the

methods.

But reformation must begin farther back, with parents. It must begin

in the most faithful care and systematic loving culture during the

nine months of unborn life, which may do more than all subsequent

education.

And it must begin still farther back, in the refusal to propagate

evil, in the selection of mothers who are worthy and competent to bear

good children, and the selection of fathers whose characters are worth

reproducing, leaving an unchosen remnant to whom marriage should be

denied.

Buchanan's Journal of Man, August 1887 Volume 1, Number 7 · 第 15 / 30 题