CHAPTER XXX. HOW FAR REASON AND EXPERIENCE ARE SUFFICIENT WITHOUT

REVELATION.

The preceding chapters present the system of natural religion, as it may

be gained by experience and those principles of reason or common sense

with which all men are endowed.

Whether mankind ever have, or ever would, fully evolve this system of

religious belief without any aid by revelation from the Creator, is a

question which we can not readily decide—inasmuch as the claim of

Christianity is, that from the first, our race have been instructed by

revelations from God, which have been more or less preserved in traditions

and written records. It is certain that the elimination of this system, by

unaided humanity, is dependent on the development of both the intellectual

and moral powers, just as much so, as the physical discoveries of Newton,

Copernicus and Columbus were dependent on the intellectual progress of the

race.

In reference to the question of the necessity or importance of revelations

from the Creator, it is interesting to examine how far those nations that

have been most advanced in intellectual development, have secured this

system of common sense, independently of the revelations contained in the

Bible—revelations which also have been more or less incorporated by

Mohammed into the Koran.

In a brief review of the pagan systems, that of Boodhism occupies the

first place, as one which has had longest and largest control over

civilized pagandom—one which has been most unimpeded by resistance, and

one which now controls _one half_ the human race.

We have seen that the common‐sense system teaches an eternally self‐

existent Creator, perfect in knowledge, wisdom, power and benevolence,

administering a perfect system by laws—his chief design being to produce

the most possible happiness with the least possible evil. It teaches also,

that the right _voluntary_ action of mind, as a part of this system,

consists in _good willing_ toward the Creator, toward self, and toward our

fellow‐beings, _according to the laws_ of God, so as to secure what is

_best_ for all concerned—making it imperative that self be made

subordinate to the public good. It teaches also, that the most effective

mode of securing this right action is, first, by imparting a _knowledge_

of these laws and their sanctions, and thus influencing mind by the

motives of _hope_ and _fear_; next, by the motive influences of _love_,

_gratitude_, _sympathy_ and _example_, as mutually exercised by God, our

fellow‐men and self. Finally, it teaches that all questions as to what is

right and wrong, are to be regulated with reference to the risks and

dangers of a _future life_, and not with chief reference to this life

alone—and that in this estimate the interests of self are to be made

subordinate to those of the commonwealth.

We will now notice how far the system of Boodh corresponds with that of

common sense.

This religion(13) is one in which there is no intervention of any supreme

God, or any self‐existent being, or any Creator; on the contrary, all

souls and all the universe exist from eternity. All souls from eternity

have gone on transmigrating from one body to another, rising or falling in

the scale of existence according to their merit or demerit. Boodh is a

general name for a divinity or god. There have been innumerable Boodhs in

different worlds and different ages, but in this world only four. These

four are beings who have risen by merit through various transmigrations,

and then became incarnate in human bodies. At last they were annihilated,

none of them being now in existence—so that this world for centuries has

been without any God.

The last Boodh of this world was Gaudama. He passed through innumerable

transmigrations in four hundred millions of worlds, and attained immense

merit. At last, he was born into this world the son of a king, about six

hundred years before Christ. The moment he was born he exclaimed, “Now am

I the noblest of men; this is the last time I shall ever be born!” He

remained forty‐five years as Boodh of this world—performed all sorts of

meritorious deeds, promulgated excellent laws, and then was annihilated.

Ever since, this world has had no God, and will have none for eight

thousand years, when the next Boodh is to appear. The first three Boodhs

left no laws or sayings. Those of Gaudama, the last Boodh, were reduced to

writing A. D. 94, and these are the _Bedegat_, or Bible of the Boodhists.

These teachings of Gaudama are so obligatory, that disbelief of them is

the only crime that incurs _eternal_ punishment.

According to this system, true virtue or rewardable merit, consists in

obeying the teachings of Gaudama. These teachings relate first to sins to

be avoided. The five general laws are, not to kill, not to steal, not to

commit adultery, not to lie, and not to drink intoxicating liquors. These

are subdivided so as to include all sins of similar kinds under each head.

For example, the first law includes even the killing of animals for food,

also capital punishments and war.

Sins are divided into these three classes: first, those of the body, such

as killing, theft, fornication, etc.; those of the tongue, as falsehood,

harsh language, idle talk, etc.; and those of the mind, as pride,

covetousness, envy, heretical thoughts, etc.

These writings of Gaudama strongly denounce the evils of pride, anger,

covetousness, and all inordinate appetites. Men are exhorted to avoid

excess in perfumes, ornaments and laughter—also strong drink, smoking,

opium, night wanderings, bad company, idleness, anger under abuse,

flattery to benefactors, annoying jests, and all that leads to strife.

For all such sins the most awful conceivable punishments are to follow in

a future state, and for millions of ages.

Rewardable merit is of three kinds:

1. Obedience to all the preceding precepts and prohibitions, and the

performance of all duties _fairly deducible_ from them, such as integrity,

gentleness, lenity, forbearance, condescension, veneration to parents and

love to mankind in general.

2. Alms‐giving and votive offerings. This includes feeding priests,

building temples and accommodations for priests and for travelers, making

roads, tanks and wells, planting fruit and shade trees, feeding criminals

and animals, and finally, giving alms to all classes of men in need.

3. Prayers and reading the Bedegat, or religious books. Of this last kind

of merit, there are three kinds: the first is the senseless repetition of

prayers and reading; the second, reading intelligently; the last, is

performing these exercises with strong desires and feelings. Prayers are

not addressed to any God, as there is none existing now for this world.

Gaudama, at his death, advised that, in addition to obeying his laws, his

relics and image should be worshiped, and temples be built to his honor

till the next Boodh came.

Votive offerings of fruit, rice and flowers are made to priests or placed

in temples. The prayers consist of the repetition of soliloquies that

express our liability to bodily evils and to mental suffering, and our

inability to escape. Also of protestations of this kind, “I will not lie;”

“I will not steal;” “I will not kill,” etc.

There are four Sabbaths or days for public worship each month, when the

people go with votive offerings and prayers to the temple of Gaudama, but

they have no general united worship.

The Boodhists have a hierarchy very much like the Catholic church, with

varied grades and ranks. The priests are required to practice celibacy,

and are mainly supported by voluntary gifts from the people.

They reside in buildings erected especially for them, and as celibacy and

the avoidance of women are enjoined on all, these establishments very much

resemble Catholic monasteries. Few of the priests preach, and only by

special request, after which, presents are made to them. They attend

funerals only when invited, and then expect presents. Part of them spend

some time in teaching novitiate priests, but most of them, regarding work

as unprofessional, spend their time in sheer idleness. It is the rule that

each priest perambulate the streets every morning till he receives boiled

rice enough for his daily wants. The higher class of priests avoid this.

In Burmah the priests are at the rate of one to every thirty persons, and

they are well supported by the people, and without interference from the

government to enforce it.

As to the motives that sustain this religion, there being no God to the

Boodhist, all motives arising from relations and regard to him are

excluded. All the motives presented appeal to hope of good and fear of

evil to _self_. Those who attain a certain measure of merit in obeying

Gaudama’s teachings go to some of the celestial regions, according to

their attainments. These consist of twenty‐six heavens, one above another,

which offer various degrees of enjoyment according to merit obtained.

There are eight principal hells; four that torment with cold and four with

heat. In the other hells are other sufferings, although not connected with

heat and cold. Worms bite, bowels are torn out, limbs are racked, bodies

are lacerated, they are pierced with hot spits, crucified head downward,

gnawed by dogs, torn by vultures. These are described with minuteness in

the _Bedegat_ and often depicted by the native artists in drawings,

reminding one of Dante’s Inferno illustrated.

For killing a parent or a priest a man will suffer in one of the hells of

fire for inconceivable millions of ages. Denying the doctrines of Gaudama

incurs _eternal_ suffering in fire. Insulting women, old men or priests,

receiving bribes, selling intoxicating drinks and parricide, are punished

in the worst hell.

Merit gained by any good conduct in these hells enables the person to rise

even to the celestial regions.

The souls of all the universe have existed from eternity, transmigrating

for ever, and thus rising and falling in the scale of existence according

to the degrees of merit at each birth. This is decided not by any deity

but by immutable fate. In passing through these changes the amount of

sorrow is incalculable. The Bedegat declares that the tears shed by one

soul in its various changes are so great that the ocean in comparison is

but a drop. Sorrow is declared to be the inevitable attendant of all

existence, and therefore “the chief end,” and the highest reward of

Boodhism is, _annihilation_.

The system of Boodhism commenced about six hundred years before Christ,

and has pervaded eastern, central and southern Asia about as long and as

fully as Christianity has pervaded Europe. The Burman empire, where this

account of that faith was obtained, presents the most favorable results of

this system on the character and condition of its votaries.

In China, Buddhism (another name for Boodhism) is the popular religion.

With it is associated Confucianism, which is a system of morals and

politics instituted by Confucius, B. C. 550, which teaches nothing in

regard to any God or a future state. With them co‐exist the sect of

Laotze, which is a kind of rationalism. Most of the temples and priests

are those of Boodh or Budda, but there is no such organized priesthood as

in Burmah, nor is this religion maintained by governmental power. It is

also considerably modified by the more ancient system of polytheism.

In Thibet and Tartary, the religion of the Grand Lama chiefly prevails,

which is one form of Boodhism.

In western India, Brahmanism is in constant warfare with Boodhism, and the

two systems are perfectly antagonistic. Brahmanism teaches one eternal

deity and three hundred and thirty‐three millions of other gods, with

hosts of idols representing them; Boodhism has no deity at all, and only

one image, that of Gaudama. Brahmanism enjoins sacrifices; Boodhism

forbids killing. Brahmanism requires atrocious tortures; Boodhism

inculcates fewer austerities than even Popery. Brahmanism makes lying,

fornication and theft sometimes commendable, and describes the gods as

excelling in such crimes; Boodhism never confounds right and wrong, and

never excuses any sin. Brahmanism makes the highest good or chief end of

man to be absorption into the supreme deity; Boodhism makes _annihilation_

the highest hope and aim of existence. These two systems, together with

Mohammedanism, so prevail in Hindostan that the distinct results of each

can never be compared. These are the prevailing religions in the most

advanced pagan nations at the present time; and of the two, Boodhism is

the best, and probably has been the most fairly tested in Burmah.

In past ages the two most highly developed heathen nations were those of

Greece and Rome, and of their religion we have the fullest records. It is

not probable that any one will consider their system of religion superior

to this now exhibited of modern paganism.

The result is that the most highly developed heathen nations, as yet, have

attained but very imperfectly the system of common sense.

No heathen religion ever taught an eternally‐existing Creator, perfect in

knowledge, wisdom, power and benevolence. None ever taught that the chief

end of our Creator is happiness‐making on the greatest possible scale.

None ever taught that this also is the chief end for which man is created.

None ever taught that right moral action, or true virtue, consists in

_good willing toward the Creator, toward self, and toward our fellow‐

beings, according to the laws of the Creator, so that every mind shall

make the good of self subordinate to the general good_. None ever taught

that all questions of right and wrong, or what is for _the best_, are to

be decided with reference to the risks and dangers of a future life. None

ever presented communion with, and the care, sympathy, sacrifices, and

example of a “long‐suffering” Creator, as motives to secure virtuous self‐

sacrifice from his creatures. If all this is taught by revelations from

God in the Bible, it is what was never taught by any other religion yet

known on earth.

In the history of the heathen world, we find anxious inquiries on these

subjects pressing on every thoughtful spirit. Who made this world with its

profound and ceaseless sorrows? Are there contending deities, and are the

malignant powers in the ascendant? If there be one supreme Creator of all,

is he propitious or hostile to a race so guilty as ours? Does he feel any

pity or sympathy for our profound ignorance, our infinite sorrows? Can we

do any thing to gain his help in our darkness and misery? Where do we go

when we die? Does our short and painful span of being end in eternal

night, or are we to go on in another career of similar suffering and

change? When we lay our beloved ones in the grave, shall we ever meet them

again, or is “the only proper utterance of a broken heart, _vale, vale, in

eternum vale_?”

These have been the mournful questionings of every age and every race,

while the wisest sages of the wisest nations, without a revelation, have

been unable to give any satisfactory reply.

Greece and Rome were the most civilized of all ancient nations, and they

give us Socrates, Plato, Aristotle and Cicero, as their best and wisest

men, who most deeply pondered these great questions. Aristotle held to one

superior deity, but taught that the stars are true and eternal deities.

Cicero leads to the belief of many gods, and approves of worshiping

distinguished men as gods. Socrates held to a plurality of deities, and

also to transmigration. He held that the common sort of good men will go

into the forms of bees, ants, and other animals of a mild and social kind.

Plato held to two principles, God and matter, and that God was not

concerned either in the creation or government of this world. He argued

for the immortality of the soul on the ground of its _pre‐existence_, and

concludes some of his speculations thus:

“We can not of ourselves know what will be pleasing to God, or what

worship to pay him; but it is needful that a lawgiver be sent from heaven.

Such an one do I expect, and O how greatly do I desire to see him, and who

he is!”

An Appeal to the People in Behalf of Their Rights as Authorized Interpreters of the Bible · 第 30 / 53 章