Ivy Hayes
“I’ve no faith in the police, no faith in detectives and no faith in
anybody!”
This wholesale skepticism was voiced by Millicent Lindsay, and
addressed to her small audience of friends gathered in her library.
“It’s outrageous,” she went on, “nearly a week has passed since my
brother’s murder, and no real step has been taken to find his
murderer.”
“Steps have been taken,” said Louis, “but they all seem to have been
taken in the wrong direction.”
“At any rate they led nowhere,” Millicent went on. “Nobody knows
anything; nobody can explain the mystery of the two shots. Nobody
knows of any motive for the crime.”
“You’ve ceased to suspect Phyllis, then,” Philip Barry said, his smile
a little forced as he eagerly awaited the answer.
“I have and I haven’t,” Millicent returned, speaking slowly. “Of
course, it seems absurd to think a young girl like Phyllis would do
such a dreadful thing—but—she won’t tell where she was, and, too,
she didn’t like my brother—at least, she didn’t welcome his offer of
marriage, and if she knew of his will, and I think she did, why
shouldn’t I suspect her?”
“Well, quit suspecting her,” Louis growled. “Phyllis is as innocent as
a baby. You’re off your head, Millicent, to dream of such a thing.”
“All right, why won’t she tell where she was at the time of the crime,
then?”
“She doesn’t have to. Nobody really suspects her, and her affairs have
no reason to be inquired into. That right, Barry?”
“Yes, of course. I think Phyllis would be wise to say where she was at
the time. But, I say, Millicent, I’m going to get busy myself, and do
a little detective work. Like you, I feel the investigations so far
have led nowhere.”
“Have you a suspicion——” began Louis.
“Not a suspicion, exactly, but a pretty strong notion of which way to
look. I won’t say what it is, for I had another hunch, that pretty
much fell through; but now I’m going to work on a new line, and I
think I may unearth something.”
“You won’t,” said Millicent, despondently. “You’re all alike—dig up a
lot of evidence and then never prove anything from it. Do tell me,
Phil, what way your suspicions turn.”
“Why, yes, I’ll tell you, for I think you ought to be kept informed. I
can’t help leaning to the chorus girl theory. I feel sure that fur
collar was left by the girl at that time, and as I see it, she could
have gone there with some man, a friend of hers who either was jealous
of Mr Gleason, or who had it in for him for some other reason. Then
suppose, in a quarrel, the man shot Gleason—perhaps Gleason
threatened him—anyway, you can’t tell what occurred, but I’m going to
find the girl.”
“You’re all wrong,” said Louis, and his voice was so full of
concentrated passion that Barry looked up quickly.
“You’re all wrong,” Louis repeated; “the idea of a man shooting
another man before a girl! Do have a little sense of probability,
Barry.”
“I have, and it’s not an impossibility that the deed should have been
committed before the girl witness. I’ve thought it all out. I don’t
believe it was premeditated, but suppose the pair went there to settle
a grievance and Mr Gleason lost his temper and threatened his
visitor—the man—and in a quarrel, the pistol was flourished about,
and the visitor grabbed it and shot, maybe in self-defense.”
“All theory,” scoffed Louis. “Nothing at all to back it up.”
“I’m going to find out,” Barry persisted. “I’m going to find the owner
of that fur——”
“I wish you wouldn’t, Phil.” Louis’ face was white and his voice
trembled a little.
“Why, Louis,” Millicent exclaimed; “what’s the matter? Do you know
anything about this business? Actually, from your agitation you might
be unduly interested.”
“No! I don’t know anything about it, but I think it’s awful to hunt
down some poor little innocent girl——”
“I’m not hunting her—I’m hunting the man who was with her.”
“A purely imaginary man!” Louis exclaimed.
“So far. But if he doesn’t materialize, there’s no harm done.”
Just then, Phyllis came in with Manning Pollard.
“We’ve been for a walk,” she said, and the roses in her cheeks proved
the good effects of the exercise. “Mr Pollard said I needed more
outdoor air, so we walked forty-five blocks. I wish you’d go out,
Millicent, it would do you good.”
“Come on, Mrs Lindsay,” Pollard suggested; “I’ll take you next.”
“Thank you, I may go some other time. Now, we’re discussing the case.
Sit down, and tell us what you think, Mr Pollard.”
“My opinion is no secret. I incline to some earlier acquaintance of Mr
Gleason’s. Perhaps some one from his Western home, or from anywhere.
I’ve heard all the evidence that has been brought forward about any
one of his New York acquaintances, and I must admit there’s not a
shred of it worth considering. Indeed, there’s practically no
evidence—do you know of any, Barry?”
“Only the fur collar,” said Barry, with a decided nod of his head. “I
think, as that is the only piece of real, tangible evidence, it ought
to be run to earth. I believe Prescott tried to do so, but his effort
fell through, somehow. At any rate, I’m going to take up that clew,
and see if I can’t get a line on the truth.”
“All rubbish,” Louis growled. “Tell him not to do it, Pollard.”
“Why should I do that?” Pollard asked. “If Barry’s sleuthing leads to
anything, I’ll be glad of it. Like Mrs Lindsay, I want to know who did
this thing. I don’t have much faith in the fur collar sign-board,
myself, for I think the thing was left there by some little girl
caller, who had no connection whatever with the crime.”
“Maybe,” Barry acquiesced. “But in that case, I’ll do no harm. I
promise not to bother the little girl—why do we all assume her to be
little—if she knows nothing of interest to us.”
“How are you going about your task?” Louis asked. He was still annoyed
about it. His bent brows and frowning face showed a special interest
and a dislike of Barry’s plans. He moved uneasily in his chair,
suddenly sitting bolt upright, and then falling back in careless
relaxation.
“Do sit still, Louis,” said Phyllis; “you make me quite
nervous—acting like that. I wish you’d go out for a walk. You sit
mewed up here, brooding, until you’re in a perfect state of feverish
excitement. Run out, dear; go for a brisk walk. The air is fine and
bracing.”
Phyllis looked anxiously after her brother.
He returned her gaze, seemed touched by her concern for him, and
finally rose and followed her advice.
“I’ve always had the care of him,” Phyllis said, as she looked fondly
after him. “He’s a darling, but he has moods. And the best thing for
him is to get away from this eternal discussion of the ‘case.’”
“Perhaps you’d like to get away, too,” said Millicent, tartly. “I
don’t think you show any sympathy for me, Phyllis, in my trouble. But,
why should you? You’ve got your inheritance and you’re rid of a
troublesome suitor——”
“Don’t talk like that, Millicent,” Phyllis begged, tears in her eyes.
“Indeed, I do sympathize with you, and I’m ready and willing to do
anything I can to help you.”
“All right, then, turn your mind to thinking about who caused Robert’s
death. You’re a bright girl, you have a really clever mind. Why can’t
you ferret out the truth as well as a man? As I’ve been saying, I
don’t think the police detectives get anywhere. I think friends know
much more about the possibilities and probabilities——”
“We do,” Barry agreed. “And to prove it, I’m going to start on my
search at once. I’m going down to the Gleason apartment, I’m going to
get that fur and take it with me, and I’ll bet I’ll find somebody in
the house, some busybody or curious woman who has seen a girl there
with that fur on. We all know Mr Gleason had friends among the younger
members of the theatrical profession. There’s no use blinking that
fact, and I propose to find out something, at any rate.”
“Well, go on, then,” urged Millicent, impatiently; “don’t sit there
and talk about it! Start off, now.”
“I go!” and with a smiling good-by, Barry departed.
“He won’t do a thing,” Pollard said, with an indulgent smile. “He’s on
a wild goose chase. I’d like to help you, Mrs Lindsay, but I confess I
don’t take any stock in the girls. Now, have you any old letters or
papers of your brother’s that you can look over. I feel that in those
you might find a past acquaintance or some old quarrel or altercation
that might show you a way to look. This is only a theory, but it’s as
plausible as any other I’ve heard put forth.”
“It is, Mr Pollard,” Millicent agreed. “I’ve none of Robert’s papers
here—they’re all at his rooms still. And I suppose Mr Lane has charge
of them. But I can get them, and I shall do just as you’ve advised. Of
course, there may be something divulged that way, but I doubt if my
brother had an enemy out West. He was a much-liked man——”
“I know that,” Phyllis interrupted, “but you must admit, Millicent,
that even well-liked men may have enemies. There’s lots about a man’s
private life that would contradict the general impression of him.”
“That’s you all over, Phyllis! You never lose a chance to cast a slur
on my brother’s memory. I should think you would have a little
gratitude to the man who left you a fortune.”
“I have, Millicent. And you must not misconstrue my words as you do. I
am anxious, too, to find your brother’s murderer. And if, as Mr
Pollard suggests, it may be some Western acquaintance, we must try to
find him. And Mr Gleason’s private letters and papers may reveal
much.”
“Yes, I suppose so. Now, with Phil Barry after the chorus girl, and Mr
Pollard’s suggestions of hunting among the letters, we, at least have
something to do. I shall send word to Mr Lane at once that I want all
the papers from Robert’s desk.”
She went away to telephone, leaving Phyllis and Manning Pollard alone.
“It’s a mere chance,” said Pollard, thoughtfully; “it may well be that
Mr Gleason would destroy any letters that are indicative of the sort
of thing we’re looking for.”
“I don’t think so,” the girl returned. “I imagine Mr Gleason would
have kept such papers. You see, I knew the man better than you did.
You hardly knew him at all, did you?”
“No; I never met him more than two or three times, and that in the
most formal way.”
“Yet you threatened to kill him!”
“Don’t put it that way, Miss Lindsay—please. My idle words have been
repeated till I’m tired of hearing them! I did say I disliked the
man—and I did. That’s all there was about it.”
“I disliked him, too,” said Phyllis, slowly. “I always had a nervous
dread of him. I don’t know why, but he always affected me
unpleasantly, even when he was most kind.”
“Then you know what I mean. That unreasonable, inexplicable
detestation of his presence. So, of course, when the man was killed,
they assumed it was my work. I left it to them to find out where I was
at the time for I knew that would be a surer proof of my innocence
than if I vehemently denied guilt and tried to prove an alibi. But
you, too, I’m told, refuse to say where you were at the time of the
crime.”
“Yes,” Phyllis whispered. “Don’t ask me. I don’t want to tell. I have
good reasons for my silence, truly.”
“And not connected with Mr Gleason’s death.”
Pollard did not voice this as a question, but merely as a statement of
fact, and Phyllis gave him a glance of gratitude for his faith in her.
But she did not corroborate his assertion and his inquiring glance
that followed met with no definite response.
“Now is there anything I can do?” Pollard asked, after a more or less
desultory chat. “I’m at your command——”
“I thought you were a very busy man,” and Phyllis smiled at him.
“Not when I can be of any assistance to you or Mrs Lindsay. Though now
that you have come into a great fortune, perhaps an humble pen-pusher
will cease to interest you.”
“No,” said Phyllis, seriously; “on the contrary, I shall have more
need than ever of friends who can advise me in certain ways.”
“Surely your lawyer will do that. Lane is a most capable legal
adviser——”
“I don’t mean that. I mean in other ways—things on which I wouldn’t
dream of discussing with Mr Lane. Oh, I have awful troubles——”
“I’m so sorry.” Pollard’s serious, kindly manner carried conviction.
“I’d be glad to help you, but in important matters you’d better
consult some one of sound judgment and special knowledge. If you don’t
care to confide in Lane, ask him for the type of adviser you do need.”
“But, Mr Pollard,” the girl hesitated, “it isn’t a question of special
knowledge at all. I just want advice from some man of the world—a man
of our set, of our interests. Somebody who knows what to do in a
crisis——”
“Please, Miss Phyllis—don’t talk like that! If you do, I shall be
tempted to offer my own services, and I’m sure there are many better
fitted for the position.”
“Oh, I wish you would help me——”
“Why not go to Barry?”
“Phil Barry? He’s a dear, and a good friend to me, but he has what is
known as the artistic temperament—and you know what that means.
No—the weight on my mind—the awful quandary I’m in, couldn’t be
helped by him. He’s the last man to help me. Oh, Mr Pollard—I
oughtn’t to ask you—in fact, I oughtn’t to tell anybody—but I feel
so helpless. Perhaps Mr Lane would be the best one after all. I don’t
know what I ought to do!”
Pollard looked at the lovely face, so full of grief and uncertainty.
He wondered what it could be about. Was it the exaggerated fear of a
young girl, that had little or no real foundation. Or—could it be
possible that she had some knowledge, guilty or evidential, of the
Gleason affair.
After a pause the man spoke.
“Miss Phyllis,” he said, with a gentle courtesy, “I want to help you,
more than I can tell you—more than I ought to tell you. But I’m not
going to take advantage of what may be merely a mood of confidence.
You think things over; you consider your other friends—or legal
advisers—and after careful thought, if you want to make me your
confidant, I shall be honored, and I will advise you to the best of my
powers. But don’t be hasty. Think it over well, and—may I see you
to-morrow?”
“How kind you are!” the girl held out her hand with a pretty impulsive
gesture. “That’s just what I want; to think it over a little and
decide whether I want to tell Mr Lane,—or whether I’d rather confide
in a—a friend.”
“Of course you do,” was the hearty response. “And Lane, who has wide
knowledge, is also a good friend. Consider carefully, and decide
slowly. But depend on me to the last ditch, if I can be of help.”
Meantime Philip Barry was on his quest.
He had decided on straightforward measures, and, gaining an accurate
description of the fur piece, had gone directly to the home of Ivy
Hayes, whose picture, he knew, graced the Gleason apartment.
He found the young lady and obtained an interview without difficulty.
“Well?” she said, as she appeared before him.
He saw a slim young thing, who might have been any one of thousands of
young girls one meets everywhere, in the street or on the streetcars.
Muffs of dark hair over her ears; hand-painted cheeks and lips; saucy,
powdered nose, and a slender shape encased in a one-piece frock, both
scant and short.
“Miss Hayes?” said Barry, bowing politely.
“The same. And you are——?”
“Philip Barry.”
“Oh, are you? Hello, Phil, what’s the big idea.”
“Only to learn if you lost your fur collar?”
“H’m. My sable one—or my chinchilla?”
“Neither,” Barry couldn’t help smiling at the impertinent face; “your
gray squirrel.”
“Oh, that one. Now, s’pose I say no?”
“Then you’re out one piece of fur.”
“And s’pose I say yes?”
“Then you get your fur back, but you’ll be asked a few questions.”
“Guess it’s worth it. Where’s the pelt?”
“The police have it.”
“Lordy!” Ivy dropped into a chair and pretended to faint. “Now how
does that come about?” she asked, cocking one eye up at her caller.
“Oh, I fancy you know.”
“Come on—let’s put all the cards on the table. You don’t think I had
anything to do with the—the fatal deed, do you?”
“What fatal deed?”
“Don’t be silly. I told you to be frank. Old Gleason’s murder, to be
sure.”
“You left your fur there?”
“Yep, I did.”
“The day of the murder?”
“Sure. I was there that afternoon.”
“You admit this!”
“Why not? It’d be found out anyway, and, as I didn’t have anything to
do with the shooting, I don’t see why I don’t get my fur back. It’s an
awful nice little collar.”
“You’ll get it back, Miss Hayes; and now, instead of waiting for a
police detective to interview you, suppose you tell me all you know
about the matter.”
“I don’t know much, but what I have is yours. I went round there, that
afternoon, on—an errand.”
“What was the errand? You may as well tell as to have me drag it out
of you.”
“That’s so. Well, our old gentleman friend said he’d give a party for
me and a few friends. Oh, a nice, proper supper party—after the
theater some night. I’m in the chorus now. Used to be in the movies.
Anyway, he promised and promised, and never set the time. So I
telephoned and telephoned and I couldn’t get him to make a date, so I
just went round there to try and persuade him.”
“Did you see him?”
“Sure I did.”
“Did he make the date?”
“No; the old fourflusher! He crawled out of it, and said if I’d let
him off he’d give me a nice present. Said he’d take me to any jewelry
shop I chose, to pick it out. Said he’d take me the next day. Now, you
don’t suppose I’d croak a guy that was about to give me a bracelet, do
you?”
“I do not. And you were so excited you came away and left your fur
there?”
“Just that! I wasn’t sure I did leave it there, for I was at two or
three other places that day. When do I get the squirly?”
“Oh, in a few days, I should say. I’ll take your yarn to headquarters,
and they’ll do the rest. But, I say, when you came away from there, Mr
Gleason was alive and well?”
“You bet he was! He fairly shooed me out—he was in a hurry to get
ready to go to a party or something. Oh, my gracious!”
“What’s that exclamation for?”
“Nothin’. A pin stuck into me.”
Barry knew better. A sudden thought had come to the girl, a thought
that filled her with dismay for some reason. But Philip Barry felt the
matter was getting too serious for him, and he decided to put it in
the hands of the police.
He went straight back to the Lindsays’.
“Come in, Mr Barry,” was the first greeting he heard, as he entered
the library, where several people were sitting in conclave. “You’re
just the man we want!”
The speaker was Prescott, the detective, and he held an open letter in
his hand.
“We’ve nailed you,” he said to Barry. “No use your saying much. This
letter speaks for itself.”
Mechanically, Barry took the paper the detective handed to him.
It was a letter, typewritten, on club paper. In ran thus:
Mr Robert Gleason: Sir:
There is small necessity of words between us. Unless you
see fit to cease your attentions to a lady of our mutual
acquaintance, I shall take matters into my own hands and
shall so arrange things that it will be impossible for
you to annoy her further.
Philip Barry.
The signature, pen signed, was undoubtedly Barry’s own, and the date
was the day before the murder.