II

_The extremes of mysticism and of pragmatism have their own

expressions of worship. Each has its form, and the difference

between them is the difference between_ deus ex machina _and_

deus machina est.

--_E. Hunter Waldo_

"Of course it will open," said Hoskins. He strode past the stunned pilot

and confidently palmed the control.

The port didn't open.

Hoskins said, "Hm?" as if he had been asked an inaudible question, and

tried again. Nothing happened. "Skipper," he said over his shoulder,

"Have a quick look at the meters behind you there. Are we getting

auxiliary power?"

"All well here," said Anderson after a glance at the board. "And no

shorts showing."

There was a silence punctuated by the soft, useless clicking of the

control as Hoskins manipulated it. "Well, what do you know."

"It won't work," said Johnny plaintively.

"Sure it'll work," said Paresi swiftly, confidently. "Take it easy,

Johnny."

"It won't work," said Johnny. "It won't work." He stumbled across the

cabin and leaned against the opposite bulkhead, staring at the closed

port with his head a little to one side as if he expected it to shriek

at him.

"Let me try," said Ives, going to Hoskins. He put out his hand.

"_Don't!_" Johnny cried.

"Shut up, Johnny," said Paresi.

"All right, Nick," said Johnny. He opened his face plate, went to the

rear bulkhead, keyed open an acceleration couch, and lay face down on

it. Paresi watched him, his lips pursed.

"Can't say I blame him," said the Captain softly, catching Paresi's eye.

"It's something of a shock. This shouldn't _be_. The safety factor's too

great--a thousand per cent or better."

"I know what you mean," said Hoskins. "I saw it myself, but I don't

believe it." He pushed the button again.

"I believe it," said Paresi.

Ives went to his desk, clicked the transmitter and receiver switches on

and off, moved a rheostat or two. He reached up to a wall toggle, turned

a small air-circulating fan on and off. "Everything else seems to work,"

he said absently.

"This is ridiculous!" exploded the Captain. "It's like having your keys

home, or arriving at the theater without your tickets. It isn't

dangerous--it's just stupid!"

"It's dangerous," said Paresi.

"Dangerous how?" Ives demanded.

"For one thing--" Paresi nodded toward Johnny, who lay tensely, his face

hidden. "For another, the simple calculation that if nothing inside this

ship made that control fail, something outside this ship did it. And

_that_ I don't like."

"That couldn't happen," said the Captain reasonably.

Paresi snorted impatiently. "Which of two mutually exclusive facts are

you going to reason from? That the ship can't fail? Then this failure

isn't a failure; it's an external control. Or are you going to reason

that the ship _can_ fail? Then you don't have to worry about an external

force--but you can't trust anything about the ship. Do the trick that

makes you happy. But do only one. You can't have both."

Johnny began to laugh.

Breaking Point · 第 10 / 38 题