THE PETITIO PRINCIPII

--Gentlemen, began Prometheus, I do not pretend, alas! to interest you

by what I am about to say, so I was careful to bring this eagle with

me. After each tiresome part of my lecture he will play some tricks.

I have also with me some indecent photographs and some fireworks,

with which when I reach the most serious moments of my lecture I will

try to distract the attention of the public. Thus, I dare to hope,

gentlemen, for some attention. At each new head of my discourse I shall

have the honour, gentlemen, to ask you to watch the eagle eating his

dinner,--for, gentlemen, my discourse has three heads; I did not think

it proper to reject this form, which is agreeable to my classical

mind.--This being the exordium, I will tell you at once and without

more ado, the first two heads of the discourse:

First head: One must have an eagle.

Second head: In any case, we all have one.

Fearing that you will accuse me of prejudice, gentlemen; fearing also

to interfere with my liberty of thought, I have prepared my lecture

only up to that point; the third head will naturally unfold from the

other two. I will let inspiration have all its own way.--As conclusion,

the eagle, gentlemen, will make the collection.

--Bravo! Bravo! cried Cocles.

Prometheus drank a little water. The eagle pirouetted three times round

Prometheus and then bowed. Prometheus looked round the hall, smiled at

Damocles and at Cocles, and as no sign of restlessness was as yet shown

he kept the fireworks for later on, and continued:

V

--However clever a rhetorician I may be gentlemen, in the presence of

such perspicacious minds as yours I cannot juggle away the inevitable

_petitio principii_ which awaits me at the beginning of this lecture.

Gentlemen, try as we may, we cannot escape the _petitio principii_.

Now; what is a petition of principles? Gentlemen, I dare to say it:

Every _petitio principii_ is an affirmation of temperament; for where

principles are missing, there the temperament is affirmed.

When I declare: You must have an eagle you may all exclaim: Why?--Now,

what answer can I make in reply that will not bring us back to that

formula, which is the affirmation of my temperament: I do not love men:

I love that which devours them. Temperament, gentlemen, is that which

must affirm itself. A fresh _petitio principii_, you will say. But I

have demonstrated that every _petitio principii_ is an affirmation of

temperament; and as I say one must affirm one’s temperament (for it

is important), I repeat: I do not love men: I love that which devours

them.--Now what devours man?--His eagle. Therefore, gentlemen, one must

have an eagle. I think I have fully demonstrated this.

... Alas! I see, gentlemen, that I bore you; some of you are yawning. I

could, it is true, here make a few jokes; but you would feel them out

of place; I have an irredeemably serious mind.

I prefer to circulate among you some indecent photographs; they will

keep those quiet who are feeling bored, which will enable me to go on.

Prometheus drank a drop of water. The eagle pirouetted three times

round Prometheus and bowed. Prometheus went on:

Prometheus Illbound · 第 20 / 39 题