COUNSELORS' QUESTIONS.

1. A final judgment in the Circuit Court was brought by writ of error

directly into the Court of Errors and Appeals. Was this legal?

2. A widow, whose dower had not been assigned to her, remained upon the

homestead of her deceased husband and took to her own use the crops

growing thereon. Was she entitled to the same?

3. The Board of Aldermen of the City of J passed an ordinance that no

one should conduct a grocery store in the city unless he was a citizen

of the State of New Jersey. A, a citizen of New York, having been found

guilty of violating this ordinance, certioraried his conviction to the

Supreme Court. What should the Court do?

4. A mortgagee in a chattel mortgage held the same for ten days after

the delivery of the mortgage and then recorded it. In the meantime a

judgment was recovered against the mortgagor, execution issued and a

levy made upon the goods and chattels named in the mortgage. Which has

priority?

5. S agreed to take the automobile of T to a shop to be repaired and to

return it after it was repaired. He took it to the shop, but failed to

return it. It was later destroyed by fire while in the shop, and T sued

S because of his failure to return the automobile. Was he liable?

6. A purchased an automobile from an infant and sold it to B in good

faith for value, neither A nor B having notice of the infancy of A's

vendor. Was it a valid sale?

7. R was indebted to S and the latter started a suit to recover the

amount due. Thereupon G agreed with S that if he would discontinue his

suit and wait for three months before again suing, he would be

responsible for the debt. This was done. At the end of the three months

was G liable?

8. L agreed to do certain work, part of it to be done on Sunday. T

subsequently agreed to pay L for such work. Was he liable?

9. An agent received the instructions of his principal, knowing that in

order to carry them out he would have to commit a nuisance, and did

actually commit such nuisance. The person injured sued the agent. Was he

liable?

10. The partnership accounts between D and M were unsettled, although

they had dissolved partnership. D alone could settle them, but refused

to do so. What kind of action could M institute against D?

11. Smith purchased a horse from Jones, giving him in payment a check on

a bank which he (Smith) had had certified. Smith having learned that

Jones had no title to the horse stopped payment on the check. Jones sued

the bank which answered, setting up want of consideration for the check.

Could it do so?

12. A died January 1, 1915, leaving a last will wherein he bequeathed

$5,000 to his son, John, then aged 18, and $5,000 to the A hospital, and

the residue of his estate to his daughter, Jane. The legacies remaining

unpaid on January 1, 1918, John and the hospital sued the executors for

them, claiming also interest. From what date should interest be allowed,

if at all?

13. Mary Jones died June 1, 1921, leaving a husband, Peter Jones, by

whom she had never had children, and three children by a prior marriage.

She left a will devising her real estate to her children, but made no

disposition of her personal estate. To whom did her real and personal

estate go on her death?

14. B, a creditor of the insolvent firm of J. & S., agreed to sell and

assign his claim to D for the sum of $2,000. B thereafter refused to

make the assignment. D thereupon filed a bill in Chancery against B for

specific performance. Could he maintain his action?

15. A was in possession of a house and lot. B, his neighbor, insisted

that A's house was over his line by a foot. How could A test his title,

B refusing to bring an action?

16. Brown, as executor of Smith, filed his final account in the Orphans'

Court of Salem County, and gave notice of settlement. Grey, one of the

residuary legatees, desired to have the accounting in Chancery. Was this

possible? If so, how should he proceed and what must he show?

17. In the trial of an action for libel wherein plaintiff claimed

compensatory damages only, defendant offered in mitigation of damages

evidence that the publication was made in good faith and with honest

belief in its truth. The Court excluded the offer, and this ruling was

attacked on appeal. Was it correct?

18. Plaintiff, aged nine, who was struck and injured by an automobile

while crossing a street, brought suit. The defense was contributory

negligence. The Court charged that a child of that age could be charged

with contributory negligence, but that in considering that question it

was for the jury to consider whether the plaintiff had exercised the

caution which would reasonably be expected from one of his years. Was

this charge correct?

19. A, an owner of a dwelling house, brought an action against B, who

had a tannery in the next block, alleging and showing on trial that

noxious fumes from B's tannery had made plaintiff's house untenantable.

B moved to nonsuit on the ground that these fumes injured a large number

of houses, were a public nuisance and the only remedy was by indictment.

The court refused to nonsuit. Was this ruling correct?

20. In what case and under what circumstances can a writ of error issue

directly from the Court of Errors and Appeals to the Court of Oyer and

Terminer?

21. At common law what right had a husband in personal property acquired

by the wife during coverture? What is the rule in New Jersey?

22. The treasurer of a corporation died. There was no provision in the

by-laws for the election of his successor. How can the place be filled?

23. On a bill for the construction of a will, evidence was offered of

declarations made by the testator at the time of making the will as to

his meaning and intention. Should this evidence be received?

24. In a suit involving an account, it appears that the defendant had

admitted that a certain sum was due. The defendant, however, demanded

the production of the plaintiff's books and on refusal moved for a

nonsuit. Should the motion be granted?

The New Jersey Law Journal, January, 1922 Vol. XLV. No. 1. Jan., 1922 · 第 12 / 25 题