THE SENSE OF SIGHT DOES NOT POSSESS THE IMAGE SEEN WITHIN ITSELF.

In general the sensation of sight consists of perception of the visible

object, and by sight we attain it in the place where the object is

placed before our eyes, as if the perception operated in that very

place, and as if the soul saw outside of herself. This occurs, I

think, without any image being produced nor producing itself outside

of the soul, without the soul receiving any impression similar to that

imparted by the seal to the wax. Indeed, if the soul already in herself

possessed the image of the visible object, the mere possession of this

image (or type) would free her from the necessity of looking outside

of herself. The calculation of the distance of the object's location,

and visibility proves that the soul does not within herself contain

the image of the object. In this case, as the object would not be

distant from her, the soul would not see it as located at a distance.

Besides, from the image she would receive from within herself, the soul

could not judge of the size of the object, or even determine whether

it possessed any magnitude at all. For instance, taking as an example

the sky, the image which the soul would develop of it would not be

so great (as it is, when the soul is surprised at the sky's extent).

Besides, there is a further objection, which is the most important of

all. If we perceive only the images of the objects we see, instead of

seeing the objects themselves, we would see only their appearances or

adumbrations. Then the realities would differ from the things that we

see. The true observation that we cannot discern an object placed upon

the pupil, though we can see it at some little distance, applies with

greater cogency to the soul. If the image of the visible object be

located within her, she will not see the object that yields her this

image. We have to distinguish two things, the object seen, and the

seeing subject; consequently, the subject that sees the visible object

must be distinct from it, and see it as located elsewhere than within

itself. The primary condition of the act of vision therefore is, not

that the image of the object be located in the soul, but that it be

located outside of the soul.

Plotinos: Complete Works, v. 3 In Chronological Order, Grouped in Four Periods · 第 216 / 442 题