18. For (there is the text) 'whatever he does with knowledge.'

The declaration made in the text 'whatever he does with knowledge that

is more vigorous,' viz. that the knowledge of the Udgîtha has for its

result non-obstruction of the result of the sacrifice, implies that the

result of works actually performed _may_ be obstructed. We thus arrive

at the conclusion that the text of the Sâtyâyanins,' his friends enter

upon his good works,' refers to those good works of the man possessing

knowledge the results of which were somehow obstructed (and hence did

not act themselves out during his lifetime, so that on his death they

may be transferred to others).--Here terminates the adhikarana of 'the

Agnihotra and the rest.'

19. But having destroyed by fruition the other two sets he becomes one

with Brahman.

There now arises the doubt whether the good and evil works other than

those the non-clinging and destruction of which have been declared, that

is to say those works the results of which have begun to act, come to an

end together with that bodily existence in which knowledge of Brahman

originates, or with the last body due to the action of the works last

mentioned, or with another body due to the action of the anârabdhakârya.--

The second of these alternatives is the one to be accepted, for there is

a text declaring that works come to an end with the deliverance of the

Self from the current bodily existence: 'For him there is delay so long

as he is not delivered (from the body), then he will become one with

Brahman' (Ch. Up. VI, 14, 2).--This view the Sûtra sets aside. Having

destroyed the other good and evil works the results of which had begun

to operate by retributive experience he, subsequently to the termination

of such retributive enjoyment, becomes one with Brahman. If those good

and evil works are such that their fruits may be fully enjoyed within

the term of one bodily existence, they come to an end together with the

current bodily existence; if they require several bodily existences for

the full experience of their results, they come to an end after several

existences only. This being so, the deliverance spoken of in the text

quoted by the Pûrvapakshin means deliverance from those works when

completely destroyed by retributive enjoyment, not deliverance from

bodily existence about which the text says nothing. All those works, on

the other hand, good and evil, which were performed before the rise of

knowledge and the results of which have not yet begun to operate--works

which have gradually accumulated in the course of infinite time so as to

constitute an infinite quantity--are at once destroyed by the might of

the rising knowledge of Brahman. And works performed subsequently to the

rise of such knowledge do not 'cling.' And, as Scripture teaches, the

friends of the man possessing true knowledge take over, on his death,

his good works, and his enemies his evil deeds. Thus there remains no

contradiction.--Here terminates the adhikarana of 'the destruction of

the others.'

The Vedanta-Sutras with the Commentary by Ramanuja Sacred Books of the East, Volume 48 · 第 305 / 339 题