34. On account of taking and the declaration as to its moving about.

The text beginning 'And as a great king,' &c., declares that 'the Self

taking the pranas moves about in its own body, according to its

pleasure' (Bri. Up. II, 1, 18), i.e. it teaches that the Self is active

in taking to itself the prânas and moving about in the body.

35. And on account of the designation (of the Self as the agent) in

actions. If not so, there would be change of grammatical expression.

Because in the text 'Knowledge performs the sacrifice, it performs all

works' (Taitt. Up. II, 5) the Self is designated as the agent in all

worldly and Vedic works, for this reason also the Self must be held to

be an agent. And should it be said that the word 'knowledge' in that

text denotes not the Self, but the internal organ or buddhi, we point

out that in that case there would be a change of grammatical expression,

that is to say, as the buddhi is the instrument of action, the text

would exhibit the instrumental case instead of the nominative case 'by

knowledge, and so on' (vijñânena instead of vijñânam).

36. (There would be) absence of definite rule, as in the case of

consciousness.

The Sûtra points out a difficulty which arises on the view of the Self

not being an agent. Sûtra 32 has declared that if the Self were all-

pervading it would follow that there would be no definite determination

with regard to consciousness. Similarly, if the Self were not an agent

but all activity belonged to Prakriti it would follow that as Prakriti

is a common possession of all souls, all actions would result in

enjoyment (experience) on the part of all souls, or else on the part of

none; for as each Self is held to be omnipresent, they are all of them

in equal proximity to all parts of the Pradhâna. For the same reason it

could not be maintained that the distribution of results between the

different souls depends on the different internal organs which are

joined to the souls; for if the souls are omnipresent, no soul will be

exclusively connected with any particular internal organ.

The Vedanta-Sutras with the Commentary by Ramanuja Sacred Books of the East, Volume 48 · 第 183 / 339 题