JOSHUA BROAD EXPLAINS
THE sunlight was pouring through the windows of Maytree Cottage; the
breakfast things still stood upon the table, when the American began his
story.
“My name, as you rightly surmised, Mr. Elk, is Saul Morris. I am, by all
moral standards, a criminal, though I have not been guilty of any
criminal practice for the past ten years. I was born at Hertford in
Connecticut.
“I am not going to offer you an apology, conventional or unconventional,
for my ultimate choice; nor will I insult your intelligence by inviting
sympathy for my first fall. I guess I was born with light fingers and a
desire for money that I had not earned. I was not corrupted, I was not
tempted, I had no evil companions; in fact, the beginnings of my career
were singularly unlike any of the careers of criminals which I have ever
read.
“I studied bank robberies as a doctor might take up the study of
anatomy. I understand perfectly every system of banking—and there are
only two, one of which succeeds, the other produces a plentiful crop of
fraudulent directors—and I have added to this a knowledge of lockcraft.
A burglar who starts business without understanding the difficulties and
obstacles he has to overcome is—to use the parallel I have already
employed—like the doctor who starts off to operate without knowing what
arteries, tissues and nerves he will be severing. The difference between
a surgeon and a butcher is that one doesn’t know the name of the tissues
he is cutting!
“When I decided upon my career, I served for five years in the factory
of the greatest English safe-maker in Wolverhampton. I studied locks,
safes, the tensile qualities of steel, until I was proficient, and my
spare time I gave up to as important a study—the transportation of
negotiable currency. That in itself is a study which might well occupy a
man’s full time.
“I returned to America at the age of twenty-five, and accumulated a kit
of tools, which cost me several thousand dollars, and with these, and
alone, I smashed the Ninth National Bank, getting away, on my first
attempt, with three hundred thousand dollars. I will not give you a long
list of my many crimes; some of them I have conveniently forgotten.
Others are too unimportant, and contain too many disappointments to tell
you in detail. It is sufficient to say that there is no proof, other
than my word, that I was responsible for any of these depredations. My
name has only been associated with one—the robbery of the strong-room
on the _Mantania_.
“In 1898 I learnt that the _Mantania_ was carrying to France fifty-five
million francs in paper currency. The money was packed in two stout
wooden cases, and before being packed, was submitted to hydraulic
pressure in order to reduce the bulk. In one case were thirty-five
packets, each containing a thousand mille notes, and in the second case
twenty packets. I particularly want you to remember that there were two
cases, because you will understand a little better what happened
subsequently.
“It was intended that the ship should call at a French port; I think it
was Havre, because the trans-Atlantic boats in those days did not call
at Cherbourg. I had made all my plans for getting away with the stuff,
and the robbery had actually been committed and the boxes were in my
cabin trunk, substitute boxes of an exact shape having been left in the
strong-room of the _Mantania_, when to my dismay we lost a propeller
blade whilst off the coast of Ireland, and the captain of the _Mantania_
decided to put in to Southampton without making the French port.
“A change of plans, to a man of my profession, is almost as embarrassing
as a change of plan in the middle of a battle. I had on this occasion an
assistant—a man who afterwards died in _delirium tremens_. It was
absolutely impossible to work alone; the job was too big, and my
assistant was a man I had every reason to trust.”
“Harry Lyme?” suggested Elk.
“Joshua Broad” shook his head.
“No, you’re wrong. I will not tell you his name—the man is dead, and he
was a very faithful and loyal fellow, though inclined to booze, a
weakness which I never shared. However, the reason we were so
embarrassed was that, had we gone ashore at the French port, the robbery
in the strong-room would not have been discovered, because it was
unlikely that the purser would go to the strong-room until the ship was
in Southampton Water. I had fixed everything, the passing of my bags
through the Customs being the most important. This change meant that we
must improvise a method to get ashore at Southampton before the hue and
cry was raised, and, if possible, before the robbery was discovered,
though it did not seem possible that we should succeed.
“Fortunately, there was a fog in the Solent, and we had to go dead slow;
and, if you remember the circumstances, as the _Mantania_ came up the
Solent, she collided with a steam dredger that was going into
Portsmouth. The dredger’s foremast became entangled in the bowsprit of
the _Mantania_ and it was some time before they were extricated. It was
then that I seized my opportunity. From an open port-way on my deck,
where we were waiting with our baggage, ready to land, we were level
with the side of the dredger as she swung round under the impact. I
flung the two grips that held the boxes on to the dredger’s deck, and I
and my friend jumped together.
“As I say, a fog lay on the water, and we were not seen, and not
discovered by the crew of the dredger until we had parted company with
the _Mantania_, and although the story we told to the dredger’s captain
was the thinnest imaginable—namely, that we thought it was a tender
that had come off to collect us—he very readily accepted it, and the
twenty-dollar bill which I gave him.
“We made Portsmouth after a great deal of difficulty late in the
evening. There was no Customs inspection and we got our bags safely on
land. I intended staying the night at Portsmouth, but after we had taken
our lodgings, my friend and I went round to a little bar to get a drink,
and there we heard something which sent us back to our rooms at full
pelt. What we heard was that the robbery had been discovered, and that
the police were looking for two men who had made their escape on the
dredger. As it was the dredger’s captain who had recommended our
lodgings, I had little expectation of getting into the room and out
again without capture.
“However, we did, and as we passed out of the street at one end, the
police came in at the other. I carried one bag, my friend the lighter,
and we started on foot across country, and before the morning we had
reached a place called Eastleigh. It was to Eastleigh, you will
remember, Mr. Elk, that I came when I left the cattle-boat during the
war and suddenly changed my character from a hard-up cattle-puncher to a
wealthy gambler at Monte Carlo.
“That matter I will explain later. When we reached Eastleigh, I had a
talk with my companion, and it was a pretty straight talk, because he’d
got a load of liquor on board and was becoming more and more unreliable.
It ended by his going into the town to buy some food and not returning.
When I went in search of him, I found him lying in the street, incapably
drunk. There was nothing to do but to leave him; and getting a little
food, I took the two bags and struck the road. The bags, however, were
much too heavy for me, and I had to consider my position.
“Standing by the road was an old cottage, and on a board was an
announcement that it was to be sold. I took the address; it was the name
of a Winchester lawyer; and then I got over the fence and made an
inspection of the ground, to find that, at the lower end of the rank
garden, was an old, disused well, boarded over by rotten planks. I could
in safety drop the lighter of my burdens down the well and cover it up
with the rubble, of which there was plenty around. I might have buried
both; in many ways a lot of trouble would have been saved if I had. But
I was loth to leave all that I had striven for with such care and pains,
and I took the second box on with me, reached Winchester, bought a
change of clothing, and spent a comfortable day there, interviewing the
lawyer, who owned the cottage.
“I had some English money with me, and the purchase was effected. I gave
strict instructions that the place was not to be let in any
circumstances, and that it was to remain as it was until I came back
from Australia—I posed as a wealthy Australian who was repurchasing the
house in which he was born.
“From Winchester I reached London, never dreaming that I was in any
danger. My companion had given me the name of an English crook, an
acquaintance of his, who, he said, was the finest safe-man in Europe—a
man who was called ‘Lyme’ and who, I discovered many years after, was
the same Harry Lyme. He told me Lyme would help me in any emergency.
“And that emergency soon arose. The first man I saw when I put my foot
on the platform at Waterloo was the purser of the _Mantania_, and with
him was the ship’s detective. I dodged back, and, fortunately for me,
there was a suburban train leaving from the opposite platform, and I
went on to Surbiton, reaching London by another route. Afterwards, I
learnt that my companion had been arrested, and in his half-drunken
state had told all he knew. The thing to do now was to cache the
remainder of the money—thirty-five million francs. I immediately
thought of Harry Lyme. I have never suffered from the illusion that
there is honour amongst thieves. My own experience is that that is one
of the most stupid of proverbs. But I thought that at least I might make
it worth Lyme’s while to help me out of a mess.
“I learnt from the newspapers that there was a special force of police
looking for me, and that they were watching the houses of well-known
criminals, to whom, they thought, I might gravitate. At first I thought
this was a bluff, but I was to discover that this was not the case. I
reached Lyme’s house, in a disreputable thoroughfare in Camden Town. The
fog was thick and yellow, and I had some difficulty in finding my way.
It was a small house in a mean, squalid street, and at first I could get
no reply to my knocking. Then the door was opened cautiously.
“‘Is that Lyme?’ I asked. ‘He’s not at home,’ said a man, and he would
have shut the door, but my instinct told me this was the fellow I was
seeking, and I put my foot in the way of the closing door. ‘Come in,’ he
said at last, and led the way into a small room, the only light of which
was a lantern which stood on the table. The room was thick with fog, for
the window was open, as I learnt afterwards, to allow Lyme to make his
escape.
“‘Are you the American?’ he asked. ‘You’re mad to come here. The police
have been watching this place ever since this afternoon.’ I told him
briefly what my difficulty was. ‘I have here thirty-five million
francs—that’s a million, three hundred thousand pounds,’ said I, ‘and
there’s enough for both of us. Can you plant this whilst I make a
get-away?’ ‘Yes, I will,’ he said. ‘What do I get out of it?’ ‘I’ll give
you half,’ I promised, and he seemed to be satisfied with that.
“I was surprised that he spoke in the voice and tone of an educated man,
and I learnt afterwards that he also had been intended for some
profession, and, like myself, had chosen the easier way. Now, you’ll not
believe me when I tell you that I did not see his face, and that I
carried no very vivid impression away with me. This is due to the fact
that I concentrated my attention upon the frog which was tattooed on his
wrist, and which afterwards, at great expense, he succeeded in having
removed by a Spanish doctor at Valladolid, who specialized in that kind
of work. That frog was tattooed a little askew, and I knew, and he knew
too, that, whether I remembered his face or not, he had a mark which was
certain to guide me back to him.
“The arrangement I made was that, when I got back to America, I should
send a cable to him, at an address we agreed upon, and that he was then
to send me, by registered post to the Grand Hotel, Montreal, a half of
the money he had in the box. To cut a long story short, I made my
escape, and eventually reached the Continent by way of Hook of Holland.
Encumbered with any baggage, that would have been impossible. In due
course I left for the United States from Bremen, Germany, and
immediately on my arrival sent the cable to Lyme, and went up to
Montreal to await the arrival of the money. It did not come. I cabled
again; still it did not come.
“It was months after that I learnt what had happened. It came from a
cutting of a newspaper, saying that Lyme had been drowned on his way to
Guernsey. How he sent that, I don’t know and never have inquired. Lyme
was, in fact, very much alive. He had some six million dollars’ worth of
French notes, and his job was to negotiate them. His first step was to
move to a Midland town, where for six months he posed as a man of
business, in the meantime changing his whole appearance, shaving off his
moustache and producing an artificial baldness by the application of
some chemical.
“Whilst he was doing this, and determined that every penny he had taken
from me he would hold, he decided to make assurance doubly sure, and
started in a small way the Fellowship of the Frog. The object of this
was to spread the mark of identification by which I should know him, as
far and wide as possible. He may have had no other idea in his mind, and
probably had not, but to broadcast this mark of the frog, a little
askew, the exact replica of his. Obviously, no class would be willing to
suffer the tortures of tattooing for nothing. So began this curious
Benefit Fund of his. From this little beginning grew the great Frog
organization. Almost one of the first men he came into contact with was
an old criminal named Maitland, a man who could neither read nor write.”
There was a gasp.
“Why, of course!” said Elk, and smacked his knee impatiently. “That is
the explanation of the baby!”
“There never was a baby,” smiled “Broad.” “The baby was Maitland
himself, learning to write. The clothes of the baby, which were planted
for your special benefit in the Elder Street house, were put there by
Johnson. The toys for the baby were inventions to keep you guessing.
There never was a baby. Once he had Maitland properly coached, he came
to London, and Maitlands Consolidated was formed. Maitland had nothing
to do except to sit around and look picturesque. His alleged clerk, one
of the cleverest actors I have ever met, was the real head of the
business, and remained Maitland’s clerk just as long as it suited him.
When he thought suspicion was veering toward him, he had himself
dismissed; just as, when he thought you had identified him with the
Frog, he made one of his men shoot at him with a blank cartridge in
Harley Terrace. He was the real Maitland.
“In the meantime the Frog organization was growing, and he sat down to
consider how best he could use the society for his advantage. Money was
going out, and he naturally hated to see it go. New recruits were
appearing every day, and they all cost money. But what he did get from
this rabble were one or two brilliant minds. Balder was one, Hagn was
one, and there were others, who perhaps will now never be known.
“As the controlling force of Maitlands Consolidated, he had not the
slightest difficulty in disposing of his francs. And then he set
Maitlands speculating in other directions, and when his speculations
were failing, he found ways of cutting his loss. He was once caught
short in a wool transaction—the Frog maimed the only man who could have
ruined him. Whenever he found it expedient for the benefit of himself to
club a man, whether he was a military attaché or a very plain City
merchant speculating in his own stocks, Johnson never hesitated. People
who were bothering him were put beyond the opportunities of mischief. He
made one great mistake. He allowed Maitland to live like a hog in a
house he had bought. That was folly. When he found that the old man had
been trailed, he shifted him to Berkeley Square, got him tailored, and
eventually murdered him for daring to go to Horsham. I saw the murderer
escape, for I was on the roof when the shots were fired. Incidentally, I
had a narrow escape myself.
“But to return to my own narrative. Five years ago I was broke, and I
decided to have another attempt to get my money; and there was also the
fact that a very large sum of money waited reclaiming at Eastleigh,
always providing that I had not been identified as the man who bought
the house. It took me a long time before I made absolutely certain that
I was unknown, and then, with the title deeds in my pocket, I sailed on
a cattle-boat and landed, as you have said, Mr. Elk, with a few dollars
in my pocket, at Southampton. I went straight to the house, which was
now in a shocking state of repair, and there I made myself as
comfortable as I possibly could whilst, night after night, I toiled in
the well to recover the small box of money, amounting to a very
considerable sum. When this was recovered, I left for Paris, and the
rest, so far as my public history is concerned, you know.
“I then began my search for Frog, and I very soon saw that, if I
depended upon the identification of the tattoo marks, my search was
hopeless. Naturally, when I discovered, as I soon did, that Maitland was
a Frog, I narrowed my search to that office. I discovered that Maitland
was an illiterate by the simple expedient of stopping him in the street
one day near his house, and showing him an envelope on which I had
written ‘You are a fake,’ and asking him if he knew the address. He
pointed to a house farther along the street, and hurried in.”
“I knew that Maitland could neither read nor write when I learnt that
the children’s clothes had been left at Eldor Street,” said Dick, “and
from that moment I knew that Johnson was the Frog.”
“Joshua Broad” nodded.
“That, I think, is about all I have to say. Johnson was a genius. The
way he handled that huge organization, which he ran practically in his
spare time when he was away from the office, was a revelation. He drew
everybody into his net, and yet nobody knew him. Balder was a godsend;
he was perhaps the highest paid agent of the lot. You will find that his
income ran into six figures!”
* * * * * *
When “Joshua Broad” had gone back to London, Dick walked with Elk to the
garden gate.
“I shan’t be coming up for a little while,” he said.
“I never expected you would,” said Elk. “Say, Captain Gordon, what
happened to those two wooden boxes that were in the quarry hut last
night?”
“I didn’t see the boxes.”
“I saw them,” said Elk, nodding. “They were there when we took Miss
Bennett away, and when I came back with the police they were gone, and
‘Joshua Broad’ was there all the time,” he added.
They looked at one another.
“I don’t think I should inquire too closely into that matter,” said
Dick. “I owe ‘Broad’ something.”
“I owe him a bit too,” said Elk with a hint of enthusiasm. “Do you know,
he taught me a rhyme last night? There are about a hundred and fifty
verses, but I only know four. It starts:
William the Conqueror started his tricks,
Battle of Hastings, ten sixty-six.
That’s a grand rhyme, Captain Gordon. If I’d only known that ten years
ago I might have been a Chief Commissioner by now!”
He walked down the road towards the station, for he was returning by
tram. The sun glittered upon the rain-fringed banners of the hollyhocks
that filled the cottagers’ gardens. Then from the hedge a tiny green
figure hopped, and Elk stood still and watched it. The little reptile
looked round and eyed the detective with black, staring eyes.
“Frog,” Elk raised a reproachful finger, “have a heart and go home—this
is not your Day!”
And, as if he understood what the man had said, the frog leaped back to
the shelter of the long grass.
THE END
TRANSCRIBER NOTES
Misspelled words and printer errors have been corrected. Where multiple
spellings occur, majority use has been employed.
Punctuation has been maintained except where obvious printer errors
occur.