Next day Smeaton sat in his official room, puzzling over the Monkton
case, and sorely perplexed.
He had followed several trails now, but all, it seemed, to no purpose.
Farloe and his sister had been shadowed without any result. The visit
to Millington had ended in failure.
Varney had discovered something, and he would follow the clue with the
pertinacity of a bloodhound pursuing a faint and elusive scent. But he
himself was thoroughly disheartened.
There suddenly came a tap at the door, and a constable entered.
"A very old gentleman wants to see you, sir. He says you will remember
him," and he handed the detective a slip of paper on which was written
"Mr Millington."
"The gentleman seems to have one foot in the grave, and half of the
other, to judge by appearances," the constable went on. "The journey
has tried him terribly. He's wheezing so, that you'd think each moment
would be his last. I made him sit down, and he's trying to recover
himself and get his breath."
Smeaton sprang up. It was with difficulty he could retain his official
calm. This plucky old man had not made the journey up to town for
nothing. He had remembered something, or discovered something.
"That's right. Baker," he said. "Give him time, and when he is ready,
show him in."
It was a full five minutes before Millington was in a fit state to
present himself. At last he entered, still husky of voice, but with a
beaming aspect.
Smeaton greeted him cordially. "Mr Millington, this is indeed good of
you. But why did you distress yourself with the journey? If you had
sent me a wire, I would have run down to you," he said.
"I owe you some amends, sir, for my failure yesterday. And besides, a
little jaunt does me good."
He smiled cheerfully, evidently wishing to convey that, at his time of
life, an excursion up to London was a tonic.
"Again many thanks," cried the grateful Smeaton. "Well, you came to see
me, because you have remembered something--or found something fresh--
eh?"
The old man spoke earnestly.
"All day after you left, sir, I was wild with myself to think what a
useless old cumber-ground I was; me that used to have such a good
memory, too. I thought and thought again, hoping that something would
come back from that twenty or twenty-five years ago."
"There was no need to distress yourself," said Smeaton kindly.
"And then in a flash I remembered another box in which I had stuffed a
lot of odd papers. Well, sir, I opened that box, went over those papers
one by one, and this is what I found."
He held out in his shaking hand an old letter. Smeaton took it from
him.
"Before you read it, Mr Smeaton, I must explain that this gentleman
always treated me in a very friendly way. We were both very fond of
heraldry, and he used often to come to my shop and chat over our hobby.
That accounts for the familiar way in which he addresses me."
This is what Smeaton read:
"Dear Mr Millington,--I enclose you a cheque for the last work you did
for me, which is as satisfactory as ever. It will be news to you that
my company, the Compagnia Corezzo, is about to go into voluntary
liquidation. I have accepted the position of manager of a big firm in
Manchester, and shall take up my new post in the course of a few weeks.
If I can possibly find time between now and then, I shall run in to say
good-bye.
"I may have an opportunity of putting further work in your way. If that
opportunity arises, I shall have the greatest pleasure in availing
myself of it. I am afraid I shall not come across anybody who takes
such a keen interest in my favourite hobby.--Yours truly, James Whyman."
Over Smeaton's face came a glow of satisfaction. He had got the name he
wanted. Was he on the right track at last? He took the threatening
letter out of his pocket, and compared the handwritings.
But here disappointment awaited him. They were totally dissimilar.
Whyman wrote a small and niggling hand, the hand of a mean man. The
other calligraphy was large, bold and free.
One thing was clear: James Whyman was not the writer of the threatening
letter. That letter had been put in an envelope which belonged to the
Compagnia Corezzo. Mr Whyman was, at that period, connected with that
company, and the man who had given instructions for the cutting of the
cipher. A visit to Manchester was the next item on the programme.
"It all came back to me with that letter," remarked the old man
presently. "I can see him standing in my shop, as if it were yesterday,
quite a young man, not a day over thirty, I should say; very fussy, very
precise, and always beating you down to the last farthing. But very
pleasant withal."
He was thirty at that time; he would, then, be in the 'fifties now,
reasoned Smeaton. The odds therefore were that Mr James Whyman was
still in the land of the living.
"Mr Millington, you have helped me very much," said the detective, as
the old gentleman rose to go. "Now, in your state of health I am not
going to allow you to fatigue yourself by catching 'buses and trains. I
shall get a taxi here, and it will drive you straight to Lower
Halliford, at my expense."
Poor Millington's frugal soul cried out aloud at such wanton
expenditure, but he was overborne by Smeaton. He departed in the
vehicle, beaming with the sense of his own importance, and conscious
that he was still of some use in the world.
The evening of that same day found the detective at the Queen's Hotel,
Manchester. It was pleasant to him to find that his investigations
produced a speedy result. Mr Whyman was a well-known citizen, so the
head-waiter informed him. He had been first manager and then director
of one of the largest businesses there. Two years ago he had retired
from active participation in the concern, and had, he believed, taken a
big house at Southport. He was a widower with two children. The son
had a post in Hong-Kong. The daughter had married and was living in
Cheshire.
The waiter added that he was popular, and highly respected by all who
knew him, perhaps a bit close-fisted, and hard at a bargain. Since his
retirement he was often a visitor at the Hotel.
The next morning Smeaton, having found Mr Whyman's address in the
telephone directory, rang him up. He announced his name and profession,
explaining that some documents had me into his possession which he would
like to submit for inspection. Might he take the liberty of coming over
to Southport during the day at some hour convenient to himself?
Mr Whyman's reply was given cordially and unhesitatingly. "With
pleasure, Mr Smeaton. Shall we say five o'clock? I am afraid I cannot
make it earlier, as I have got a very full day in front of me. I am
retired from business in a sense, but I am still interested in a lot of
things that require personal attention."
At five o'clock to the minute Smeaton was at the fine house of Mr
Whyman, near the end of the Esplanade at Southport, commanding a
splendid view of the Welsh and Cumberland hills. It was evident that
Mr Whyman had prospered in a worldly sense. The house was an imposing
one. A butler opened the door, and ushered him into the morning-room, a
square, lofty apartment, solidly and handsomely furnished.
A moment later the owner entered. He was a tall, finely-built man, with
regular, handsome features.
Smeaton regarded him closely as they shook hands. There was an obvious
frankness and geniality about his manner that fully accounted, for his
general popularity. The face was honest, its expression open. His eyes
met yours unwaveringly.
And yet this was the man who, according to the dead man, Giovanni
Roselli, had been the perpetrator of a great wrong to some person or
persons unknown. Well, Smeaton had too vast an experience to trust
overmuch to outside appearances. Still, he had never seen anybody who
looked less like a rogue than Mr James Whyman, as he stood smiling at
him with the most cordial expression in his clear blue eyes.
If he was, or had been at some period of his career, a rogue. Nature
had taken the greatest pains to disarm the suspicions of those on whom
he practised his rascality.
Whyman pointed to the table, on which were laid glasses, a decanter of
whisky, soda-water, and cigars.
"Let me offer you some refreshment after your journey. You smoke?
Good. I think you will like those cigars. Let me help you. Now, sir,
sit down, and we will get at once to the matter which brings you here."
Smeaton produced the envelope, and handed it to his genial host. "I
think you will recognise those entwined letters, Mr Whyman. I may tell
you that I traced the man who cut them--a man named Millington."
Whyman interrupted him in his brisk, bluff way, and there was not a
shade of embarrassment in voice or manner:
"Ah, my dear old friend Millington! Why, he must be quite ancient by
now, for he wasn't a chicken when I knew him."
"A very old man, and his memory is treacherous. At first he could
remember very little. But later on he found a letter from you which
brought it all back to him. I was then able to establish the two things
I wanted: your own name, and the name of the Italian company you
represented."
Whyman turned the envelope in his hand, after having cast a glance at
the cipher. The candid blue eyes regarded the detective steadily as he
spoke.
"Yes, that die was cut by my instructions, certainly. Now, in what way
can I assist you, Mr Smeaton, beyond confirming that fact?"
Smeaton passed him the threatening letter. "There is no question the
envelope came out of your office. Now, do you recognise this
handwriting?"
The other man read it carefully, and then passed it back, without a
trace of confusion.
"I am certain that I have never seen that handwriting before. How the
envelope was obtained I cannot pretend to guess. Hundreds of people, of
course, were in and out of my office during the time I was with the
company."
"I presume you had several clerks in your employ?"
Mr Whyman smiled. "Quite the opposite. It was a small and struggling
concern, unprosperous from the start. I only had three assistants at
the London branch: an elderly man, and two juniors. I should recognise
the writing of any one of those if it were put before me."
Was he speaking the truth or not? Was he honestly puzzled as he
appeared, or shielding the writer of that threatening epistle with his
assumption of ignorance? Smeaton could not be sure. The only evidence
he possessed as to character was that furnished by the deathbed
revelations of Roselli, and that was unfavourable.
He resolved to try a random shot. "I think at one time you were
acquainted with a man of the name of Giovanni Roselli, an Italian."
The shot went home. There was a flicker in the steady blue eyes, the
voice had lost its bluff and genial ring. He spoke hesitatingly,
picking his words.
"Ah, yes. Many years ago I knew a fellow named Roselli, in Turin--not
very intimately; we did a little deal in marble together on one
occasion. What do you know about him?"
Smeaton shrugged his shoulders carelessly. "Not much. In our business
we come across many little things that we have not set out to find, but
which emerge from greater issues. However, I did not come here to talk
about this foreigner, but in the hope that you might be able to help me
with that letter."
When Whyman spoke again all traces of his momentary embarrassment had
passed.
"I am only too sorry that I cannot. I should say that envelope must
have been stolen from my office."
"Very likely," said Smeaton quietly. Then he rose to go.
Whyman at once became effusively hospitable. "I wish you would dine and
stay the night with me. I should be most delighted to have a good long
chat with you, especially if you could tell me some of your experiences
which are no longer secrets. To-morrow, perhaps, I could take you for a
spin in the country in my car."
Smeaton hesitated. Why did this man, whom he suspected of being a rogue
under all this genial veneer, suddenly develop such a partiality for the
society of an utter stranger? Did he want to pump him as to what he
knew concerning Roselli, whom of course, he did not know was dead?
He decided he would stay. If it came to pumping, Smeaton flattered
himself he would prove the better of the two at that particular game.
He might even make Whyman betray himself in an unguarded moment.
They spent quite a pleasant time together. Smeaton was shown over the
house and grounds. The dinner was good, the wines and cigars excellent.
The detective entertained his host with reminiscences of work at "the
Yard" that involved no indiscretion. They sat up chatting till past
midnight. But the name of Roselli was not mentioned again on either
side.
"Good-night, Mr Smeaton, good-night. I have enjoyed your company
immensely. Breakfast at half-past nine--eh?"
He might be a rogue at bottom, and his wealth might not have been
acquired honestly, but he was a very pleasant one. And as a host he was
beyond reproach.
When Smeaton entered the dining-room the next morning, the butler was
waiting for him with a letter in his hand.
"Mr Whyman was called away early this morning, sir. He has left this
note for you."
"Dear Mr Smeaton," ran the brief epistle. "A thousand apologies for
treating you in this discourteous fashion. I received a letter just now
calling me abroad on urgent business that brooks no delay. I may be
absent some few weeks. Trusting we shall meet again--Yours sincerely,
James Whyman."
Smeaton was too accustomed to surprises to exhibit any emotion. He sat
down and ate an ample breakfast, and cogitated over the sudden departure
of his host.
The one obvious fact was that Whyman had flown. He need not waste time
over that. The important thing remained: what was the reason of his
hurried flight?
Before he left the room Smeaton crossed over to a writing-desk in the
window, and peered into the waste-paper basket at the side. A forlorn
hope--it was empty. A torn-up envelope might have revealed the
postmark.
But Mr Whyman was evidently too old a bird to leave anything behind him
that would enlighten one of the keenest detectives in England.