THE VERDICT
A few moments later Cunningham returned alone, and presently I heard
Ruth's step upon the stair. I arose and as she entered the room I
hastened to her and led her to a chair, giving her a reassuring smile as
I did so. She looked so little, and so tired, so in need of comfort that
it seemed a sacrilege to question her. As for believing her guilty of
murder, that was too preposterous!
But then the coroner was not in love with her, and he had his duty to
perform. I will give him credit for this, that as he looked into her
sweet, gentle face his duty became none too pleasant for him and he
conversed with a stranger who had entered the room before he again took
up his burden of office. When he did it was to say:
"Mr. Ames, the finger-print expert, has a word to say before we can pass
verdict on this case."
Before Ames could speak, Cunningham held up his hand.
"I would like you to hear what Mrs. Darwin has to say first before you
attempt to actually incriminate her," he said.
At his words Ruth turned and glanced at him sharply, with a puzzled
expression on her face which I could not account for, as she stared at
him uncomprehendingly, but as the full meaning of his words dawned upon
her, she turned her terrified eyes in my direction.
"Carlton," she said, and she raised her right hand solemnly, as though I
were the judge before whom she was taking an oath, "I am innocent of any
crime. In God's name, tell me you do not believe me guilty!"
She caught my hand and drew me down so that she could see my face.
"Ruth," I replied--it cost me an effort but for her sake I strove to
speak quietly--"when I found you in the study I was startled, but never
once have I believed you guilty, and now I know that you are innocent."
She released my hand and settled back in her chair with a sigh of
relief. As long as I knew her innocent what mattered what anyone
thought, was her attitude. But, alas, it was not I but the jury she
would have to convince.
"Mrs. Darwin, I should like very much to have your version of the events
of last night," said the coroner, and his voice was very gentle as he
addressed her.
"Ruth," I interposed quickly, "be careful what you say." I was in mortal
dread lest she incriminate herself beyond redemption, and yet I knew her
to be innocent! Explain the paradox as best you may. I could not.
"Well meant, but ill-advised," said Mr. Cunningham. "Your best plan,
Mrs. Darwin, is complete frankness."
Again that strange puzzled look on Ruth's face as she turned toward him,
then as if his words found an echo in her own heart, she looked once
more toward me and said simply, "Yes, Carlton, why shouldn't I tell him
all since I am innocent?"
I groaned and mentally anathematized the coroner for his choice of
counsel. I was powerless to help her in the face of her guileless
attitude and evident inability to realize the danger of her position.
Very quietly and very candidly she told the coroner all that had
occurred that fateful night, most of which was already known to those
present in the room, the only new evidence being her account of what
took place after she entered the study.
"The study was dark and as I left the door only barely ajar and the hall
was dim, it was impossible to see any objects in the room. I knew
however about where the table was located and I groped my way to it, and
found the drawer. It was closed and I had to pull quite hard to open it.
As I did so I thought I heard someone breathe quite close to me. I was
paralyzed with fright, but as moment after moment passed and I heard no
further sound, I decided I was mistaken and slowly put my hand in the
drawer and felt around for the letter that I had come to get. Just as my
hand closed around it I heard again that sound. Oh, it was horrible!
Like someone trying to breathe who couldn't!"
She broke off and hid her face in her trembling little hands, and at my
suggestion Mason brought her a glass of water. When she had sipped it
she thanked him with a sweet smile and I saw the old man hastily wipe
away a tear as he departed. I am not sure but that I did the same
myself, as Ruth resumed her narrative in a voice not quite so steady as
before.
"I snatched my hand from the drawer and had taken but two swift steps
away from the table, as I thought, when there was a sudden deafening
roar. I stood stock-still, unable to move, and when I did finally take
a step I trod on something hard. Mechanically, I stooped and picked it
up. It was then that the lamp lighted and I saw Phil lying
there--dead--almost beside me. I was stunned and stood like one stricken
until I heard Carlton's voice. I had no idea what I had picked up until
that moment, but when I saw what it was and what Carlton was thinking, I
cried out in horror--and fainted. That's all I know," she ended,
faintly.
I don't think they really believed her. The skeptical smile on the
coroner's face was reflected on the countenances of the jury. It was an
ingenious account but there was entirely too much that was still
obscure.
"Why did you not light the study instead of groping in the dark?" asked
the coroner.
"Because I knew that Mr. Orton was spying upon me, because I saw him in
the hall as I entered, and did not wish him to follow and see what I was
doing," she answered quietly, thereby drawing the noose tighter about
her own neck by providing with a perfectly good alibi the only other
person who could possibly have been in the room at the time!
But she was ignorant of their suspicions and failed to see the look of
relief that crossed the secretary's pallid face.
"Mrs. Darwin, do you recognize this pistol?"
"Yes. It is Phil's. It's the one I picked up."
The coroner scratched his head in perplexity. Either she was innocent or
she was a magnificent actress, for only in those two instances could she
answer these questions with so much directness and sincerity. I could
see that he inclined toward the latter assumption for his tone grew
harsher as he said abruptly: "You were not on good terms with your
husband. Did you know that he was making a new will when he was shot?"
Ruth opened her eyes wide in astonishment. "Why, how could I know what
he was doing when I did not know he was at home?" she asked naïvely.
"Do you know anyone by the name of Cora Manning?" pursued the coroner.
"Cora--Manning? No." Her voice trembled slightly as she pronounced the
name.
"You are sure?"
"I do not know her," repeated Ruth firmly.
"She is the lady whose name is on the unfinished will. Evidently your
husband must have thought a good deal of her for he had torn up his old
will and was apparently going to leave everything to her."
Ruth drew herself up proudly. "Excuse me, sir, but my husband's affairs
were his own. I take no interest in them whatsoever."
"Not even to the extent of losing several millions?" spoke up the juror
who seemed always to have so much to say.
But Ruth did not deign to answer him. Instead she addressed the coroner.
"By a legal agreement entered into at the time of our marriage my
husband was free to dispose of his wealth as he saw fit."
If her voice held a tinge of bitterness who can blame her?
"As you saw fit, since his murder gives it all to you," continued the
irrepressible juror.
"Your honor, I protest against such insinuations," I cried, for
Cunningham seemed to have fallen asleep.
"I don't understand you," faltered Ruth, her eyes growing dark as they
traveled over the stern, set faces of the jury. Then her hand fluttered
involuntarily to her throat. "I don't understand you," she said again.
As the juror opened his mouth to reply, the coroner silenced him with a
gesture. "Kindly permit me to conduct this investigation," he said
curtly, then to Ruth, "Mrs. Darwin, was your husband in the habit of
wearing rings?"
"I never saw him wear any," she answered. It was plain she was puzzled
by his question.
"Yet he might have done so last night?"
"I suppose so."
"You didn't happen to remove it, did you?"
"Most certainly not," she said, highly insulted by the implication.
"Your honor, may I make a suggestion?" Cunningham awoke suddenly to the
exigencies of the situation.
"Certainly, Mr. Cunningham," responded the coroner graciously.
"It has occurred to me that perhaps Mr. Darwin had in a moment of
sentiment slipped that stoneless ring on his finger, and then had
trouble in removing it. Of course it is only a suggestion,"
apologetically.
"No doubt it was just as you say," answered the coroner. "After all, the
ring has nothing to do with the actual murder. Thank you, Mr.
Cunningham."
As the lawyer resumed his seat with that sardonic smile upon his lips,
the coroner picked up the handkerchief. "Is this yours, Mrs. Darwin?"
"No."
"Are you sure?"
"Yes."
"May I see that handkerchief that you are holding so tightly in your
hand?"
Without a word she passed the bit of cambric to him and he held it up
beside the blood-stained handkerchief. They were exactly the same,
texture, pattern, and design!
"Well?" The coroner laid the two articles upon the table and bent a
flashing look upon her.
"I don't understand how it can be just like mine when it doesn't belong
to me," she said in a frightened voice. "Phil bought it for me at the
church bazaar--just after we were married. He--he only bought me one."
"Wasn't it strange--his buying only one?"
"No--no. I wouldn't let him get me any more. I--I didn't want him to buy
me anything at all."
"Then since it is quite evident that you did not love Philip Darwin,
will you explain why you married him at all?"
"Ruth," I said, warningly, and this time she heeded my advice.
"I can't discuss my private affairs, sir. They have nothing to do
with--with Phil's death, and they are my own," she said with troubled
dignity.
"Do you realize that your silence will militate against you?"
"I can't help it, sir," she answered with tears in her eyes.
"Just one thing more. What is your father's present address?"
"Daddy's address? Surely you can't think--but he wasn't here last
night!" she cried in terror.
"I know. It is merely a formality," replied the coroner, in a soothing
voice.
"Shall I tell him, Carlton?" she asked me, ignoring her counsel.
"Yes, I suppose you had better," I returned.
"He is staying with Mrs. Bailey at Tarrytown."
"Thank you, Mrs. Darwin. If you will remain where you are, please, we
will now hear from Mr. Ames," said the coroner.
The finger-print expert stepped forward. "My evidence is of the
briefest," he said. "I have examined the pistol and have taken an
impression of the finger-prints upon the handle. I have the enlargements
with me and I should like to compare them with a set made by Mrs.
Darwin. If you please."
He extended an inked pad toward Ruth and showed her how to make the
impressions that he desired. Then followed silence while he compared
them with the enlargements. Then with a brisk nod he passed the plates
to the jury.
"Well, Mr. Ames?" asked the coroner.
"Finger-prints, as you know, are infallible evidence," said the expert.
"The finger-prints on the handle of the pistol are the same as those
made by Mrs. Darwin here in your presence and there are no other prints
of any kind upon the pistol. Therefore I do not hesitate to say that the
only person who handled that revolver last night was Mrs. Darwin."
The expert sat down, and satisfied that the chain of evidence was
complete the coroner ordered the jury to leave the room and arrive at a
decision. We had not long to wait. No sooner had they filed out than
they were back again, nor do I think that anyone was surprised when
they found that the deceased had come to his death by a pistol shot
fired at the hands of his wife, Ruth Darwin.
"Carlton, do you still believe in me?" she asked dully.
"With all my heart and soul, Ruth, dear. I shall always believe in you
even against all the world," I answered simply.
She gave me a look of love unutterable, then for the second time in
twenty-four hours crumpled in a heap on the floor beside me.