THE WHISPERS IN THE AIR.
There is a wide and populous world outside of Davy's Bend, from which
Allan Dorris recently came; let the whispers in the air, which frighten
every man with their secrets, answer why he had resolved never again to
see Annie Benton.
During his residence in Davy's Bend he had met the girl frequently,
usually at the stone church near his house, where she came to practise;
and after every meeting he became more than ever convinced, after
thinking about it,--and he thought about it a great deal,--that if their
acquaintance continued, there would come a time when he would find it
difficult to quit her society. The pleasure he enjoyed in the company of
the pretty organist was partly due to the circumstance that she was
always pleased at his approach, although she tried to disguise it; but
beyond this,--a long way beyond this,--there was reason why he should
avoid her; for the girl's sake, not his own.
He repeated this often to himself, as though he were a desperate man
ready to engage in any desperate measure; but his manner visibly
softened when he thought of the pretty girl whose ways were so engaging,
innocent, and frank. He knew himself so well,--the number of times he
had gone over the story of his life, in his own mind, since coming to
The Locks even, would have run up into the hundreds; therefore he knew
himself very well indeed,--that he felt in honor bound to give up his
acquaintance with her, although it cost him a keen pang of regret, this
determination to hear the music no more, and never again see the player.
Avoiding even a look at the church, which was a reminder of how much
pleasure he had found in Davy's Bend, and how much misery he would
probably find there in the future, he passed out of the iron gate of The
Locks, and set his face toward the quiet country, where he hoped to walk
until his body would call for rest at night, and permit him to sleep; a
blessing that had been denied him of late more than before he knew Annie
Benton, and when he thought that Davy's Bend contained people only fit
to be avoided.
But he was glad that he had resolved never to see the girl again,--for
her sake, not his own.
He had made this resolve after a struggle with himself, thinking of the
strange fatality that had made duty painful throughout his entire life;
and he walked toward the country because he believed the girl was in the
direction of the town; probably seated in the church at that moment,
watching the door for his approach. She was a comfort to him, therefore
he must avoid her; but this had always been the case--he was accustomed
to being warned that he was an intruder whenever he entered a pleasant
place.
There was something in store for her besides a life of hiding and fear,
and an unknown grave at last, with a fictitious name on the headboard;
and he would not cross a path which led toward happiness for one he so
much admired.
Thus he argued to himself as he walked along; but when he remembered how
dull his life would be should her smile never come into it again, he
could not help shuddering.
"But I have been so considerate of others," he said aloud, as he pursued
his way, "that even the worms in my path impudently expected me to go
round them, and seemed to honestly believe me unworthy of living at all
if I did not. Let me not show a lack of consideration now that my heart
is concerned."
Above his house, and so near the river that the water rippled at its
base, was a rugged bluff, separated from the town by a deep and almost
impassable ravine, and for this reason it was seldom visited; Allan
Dorris had found it during his first month in the town, and he resolved
to visit it now, and get the full benefit of the sunshine and delightful
air of the perfect summer day.
It occurred to him as he sat down to rest, after making the difficult
ascent, that he would like to build a house there, and live in it, where
he would never be disturbed. But did he want solitude? There seemed to
be some question of this, judging from the look of doubt on his downcast
face. When he first came to Davy's Bend, he believed that the rewards of
life were so unsatisfactory that all within his reach that he desired
was his own company; but an experience of a month had satisfied him that
solitude would not do, and he confessed that he did not know what he
wanted. If he knew what it was his heart craved, he believed that it was
beyond him, and unobtainable; and so his old habit of thinking was
resumed, though he could never tell what it was all about. Everything he
desired was impossible; that within his reach was distasteful--he could
make no more of the jumble in his brain, and finally sat with a vacant
stare on his face, thoroughly ashamed of the vagrant thoughts which gave
him a headache but no conclusions.
Even the pure air and the bright sunshine, that he thought he wanted
while coming along the road, were not satisfactory now; and as he
started to walk furiously up the hill, to tire himself, he met Annie
Benton in the path he was following.
She had been gathering wild flowers, and, as he came upon her, she was
so intent on arranging them after some sort of a plan, that she was
startled when he stood beside her.
"I was thinking of you," she said hurriedly, instead of returning his
greeting. "I intended sending you these."
Dorris could not help being amused that he had encountered the girl in a
place where he had gone to avoid her, but there was evidence in his
light laugh that he was glad of it; so he seated himself on a boulder
beside the path, and asked what she had been thinking of him.
"That you were a very odd man," she answered frankly.
"That has always been a complaint against me," he said, with a tone of
impatience. "I think I have never known any one who has not said, during
the course of our acquaintance, that I was 'odd;' whatever is natural in
me has been called 'odd' before. If I wanted bread, and was not
satisfied with a stone, they called me 'odd.' The wishes of the horse
that has a prejudice for being bridled on the left side are respected,
but there is no consideration for a man who cannot be contented simply
because it is his duty. I remember that we had a horse of this
description in our family when I was a boy, and if he injured any one
who failed to respect his wishes, the man was blamed, not the horse. But
the people do not have equal charity for a man who is not content when
circumstances seem to demand it of him, no difference what the
circumstances are, or how repugnant they may be to his taste. So you
were finding fault with me? I am not surprised at it, though; most
people do."
The girl had seated herself near him, and was busily engaged in
arranging the flowers until he inquired again,--
"So you were finding fault with me?"
"No," she answered, "unless it was finding fault to think of you as
being different from any other person I have ever known. It was not a
very serious charge to think of you as being different from the people
in Davy's Bend."
There was something in that, for they were not the finest people in the
world, by any means; nor could the town be justly held responsible for
all their faults, as they pretended.
"No, it is not serious," he replied; "but I am sorry you are looking so
well, for I am running away from you. It would be easier, were you less
becoming. I am sorry you are not ugly."
There was a look of wonder in the girl's face that made her prettier
than ever.
"Running away from _me_?"
"Yes, from you," he answered.
She began arranging the flowers again, and kept her eyes on them while
he watched her face. Dorris thought of himself as a snake watching a
bird, and finally looked down the river at the ferry, which happened to
be moving.
"Why?" she asked at last.
"Because I am dangerous," he replied, with a flushed face. "You should
run away when you see me approach, for I am not a fit companion for you.
I have nothing to offer that you ought to accept; even my attentions are
dangerous."
The bouquet was arranged by this time, and there was no further excuse
for toying with it, so she laid it down, and looked at him.
"I suppose I should be very much frightened," she said, "but I am not. I
am not at all afraid of you."
He laughed lightly to himself, and seemed amused at the answer she had
made.
"I know nothing whatever about women," he said, "and I am sorry for it,
for you are a puzzle to me. I know men as well as I know myself, and
know what to expect of them under given circumstances; but all those of
your sex I have ever known were as a sealed book. The men are always the
same, but I never know what a woman will do. No two of them are alike;
there is no rule by which you can judge them, except that they are
always better than the men. I have never known this to fail, but beyond
that I know nothing of your sex. I say to you that I am dangerous; you
reply that you are not afraid of me. But you ought to be; I am sure of
that."
"If you desire it," she said, "I am sorry, but I feel perfectly safe in
your company."
"It's a pity," he returned, looking down the river again. "If you were
afraid of me, I would not be dangerous. I am not liable to pelt you with
stones, or rob you; but the danger lies in the likelihood of our
becoming friends."
"Is friendship so dangerous, then?"
"It _would_ be between you and me, because I am odd. Look at me."
She did as requested, with quiet confidence and dignity.
"You say you are not afraid of me; neither am I of you, and I intend to
tell you what you can hardly suspect. I am in love with you to such an
extent that I can think of nothing else; but I cannot offer you an
honorable man's love, because I am not an honorable man, as that
expression is used and accepted. I have been looking all my life for
such a woman as you are, but now that I have found you, I respect you so
much that I dare not attempt to win your favor; indeed, instead of that,
I warn you against myself. Until I was thirty I looked into every face I
met, expecting to find the one I sought; but I never found it, and
finally gave up the search, forced to believe that such a one as I
looked for did not exist. I have found out my mistake, but it is too
late."
He jumped up from the stone on which he was seated, as if he intended to
run away, and did walk a distance, but came back again, as if he had
something else to say.
"I speak of this matter as I might tell a capable artist that I was
infatuated with his picture, and could not resist the temptation to
frequently admire it. I have no more reason to believe that there is a
responsive feeling in your heart than I would have reason to believe
that the picture I admired appreciated the compliment, but there is
nothing wrong in what I have said to you, and it is a pleasure for me to
say it; there can be no harm in telling a pretty, modest woman that you
admire her--she deserves the compliment."
Annie Benton did not appear to be at all surprised at this avowal, and
listened to it with the air of one who was being told of something
commonplace.
"You do not make love like the lovers I have read about," she said, with
an attempt at a smile, though she could not disguise the oddity of her
position. "I do not know how to answer you."
"Then don't answer me at all," he replied. "I am not making love to you,
for I have denied myself that privilege. I am not at liberty to make
love to you, though I want to; therefore I ask the privilege of
explaining why I shall avoid you in the future, and why I regret to do
it. The first feeling I was ever conscious of was one of unrest; I was
never satisfied with my home, or with those around me. If I thought I
had a friend, I soon found him out, and was more dissatisfied than ever.
Of course this was very unreasonable and foolish; anyone would say that,
and say it with truth, but while it is an easy explanation, I could not
help it; I was born that way, nor can I help saying that I am satisfied
with you. You suit me exactly, and I was never contented in my life
until I sat in the old church and looked at you."
Though the girl continued to look at him without apparent surprise, her
face was very pale, and she was breathing rapidly.
"You may regard what I have said as impudent," Dorris continued, "and
think that while you are satisfactory to me, I would not be to you. I am
not now, but I would give a great deal to convince you that I am the man
you dreamed of when you last put wedding-cake under your pillow,
providing you ever did such a ridiculous thing. It is not conceit for me
to say that I believe I could compel you to respect me, therefore I
regret that we have ever met at all, for I am not at liberty to woo you
honorably; if you want to know why, I will tell you, for I would place
my life in your hands without the slightest hesitation, and feel secure;
but it is enough for the present to say that nothing could happen which
would surprise me. I am in trouble; though I would rather tell you of it
than have you surmise what it is, for I am not ashamed of it. I can
convince you--or any one with equally good sense--that I am not nearly
so bad as many who live in peace. Would you like to hear my history?"
"No," she replied; "for you would soon regret telling it to me, and I
fear that you will discover some time that I am not worthy of the many
kind things you have said about me. I am only a woman, and when you know
me better you will find that I am not the one you have been looking for
so long and so patiently."
"Excuse me if I contradict you in that," he said with as much grave
earnestness as though he had been talking politics, and found it
necessary to take issue with her. "You _are_ the one. Once there came to
me in a dream a face which I have loved ever since. This was early in
life, and during all the years which have brought me nothing but
discontent and wretchedness, it has been my constant companion; the one
little pleasure of my life. From the darkness that surrounded me, the
face has always been looking at me; and whatever I have accomplished--I
have accomplished nothing in Davy's Bend, but my life has been busy
elsewhere--has been prompted by a desire to please this strange friend.
I have never been able to dismiss my trouble--I have had no more than my
share, perhaps, as you have said, but there is enough trouble in the
world to render us all unhappy--except to welcome the recollection of
the dream; and although I have often admitted to myself that this
communion with the unreal was absurd, and unworthy of a sensible man, it
has afforded me a contentment that I failed to find in anything else;
therefore the fancy made a strong impression on my mind, and it grew
stronger as I grew older, causing me many a heartache because there was
nothing in life like it. Most men have dreams of greatness, but my only
wish was to find the face that always came out of the shadows at my
bidding."
He paused for a moment, looking into the empty air, where his dream
seemed to realize before him, for he looked intently at it, and went on
to describe it.
"It was not an angel's face, but a woman's, and there was no expression
in it that was not human; expressions of love, and pity, and
forgiveness--you have them in your face now, and I believe they are not
uncommon. I have never expected unreal or impossible things, and as I
grew older, and better understood the unsatisfactory nature of life, I
became more than ever convinced that I would feel entirely satisfied
could my dream come true. At last I came to believe that it was
impossible; that I was as unreasonable as the man who pined because his
tears were not diamonds; but I could not give up the recollection of the
face, to which I was always so true and devoted, and comforted myself
with brooding over it, and regretting my misfortune. Instead of
greatness or grandeur, I longed for the face, and it was the only one I
ever loved."
Again he was gazing intently at nothing; at his fancy, but this time he
seemed to be dismissing it forever, after a careful inspection to
convince himself that the counterpart he had found on earth was exactly
like it.
"Until I met you," he said, looking at Annie Benton again, "this
sweetheart of my fancy lived in Heaven, Maid of Air. When you turned
upon me that afternoon in the church, I almost exclaimed aloud: 'The
face! My vision has come true!' Not a feature was missing, and your
actions and your smile were precisely what I had seen so often in my
fancy. Therefore you are not a stranger to me; I have loved you all my
life, and instead of worshipping a vision in the future I shall worship
you. Why don't you speak to me?"
"I don't dare to," she answered, looking him full in the face, and
without the slightest hesitation. "I am afraid I would say something I
ought not to."
He looked at her curiously for a moment, trying to divine her meaning,
and concluded that if she should speak more freely, he would hear
something surprising; either she would denounce him for his boldness, or
profess a love for him which would compel him to give up his resolution
of never seeing her again.
"That was an unfortunate expression," he said. "I am sorry you said
that, for it has pleased my odd fancy; indeed, it is precisely what I
was hoping you would say, but there is all the more reason now for my
repeating to you that I am dangerous. I know how desperate my affairs
are; how desperate I am, and how unfortunate it would be if you should
become involved. Therefore I say to you, as a condemned prisoner might
shut out the single ray of light which brightened his existence, so that
he might meet his inevitable fate bravely, that you must avoid me, and
walk another way when you see me approaching."
A hoarse whistle came to them from the ferry in the river, and Dorris
thought of it as an angry warning from a monster, in whose keeping he
was, to come away from a presence which afforded him pleasure.
"May I speak a word?" the girl inquired, turning abruptly toward him.
"Yes; a dozen, or a thousand, though I would advise you not to."
"Is what you have said to me exactly true?"
"Upon my honor; exactly true," he answered.
"Is there no morbid selfishness in it; no foolish fancy?"
"Upon my honor, none!"
"Do you believe I am your dream come true with the same matter-of-fact
belief which convinces you that there is a ferry in the river?"
She pointed out the boat as it moved lazily through the water, and as he
looked at it he seemed to resolve the matter carefully in his mind.
"Yes," he answered, "I am as certain that you are the woman I have loved
devotedly all my life, as I am certain that there is a river at the foot
of the hill. What I have said to you is generally regarded as
sentimental nonsense except when it is protected by the charity of a
sweetheart or a wife; but it is in every man's heart, though it is
sometimes never expressed, and my idle life here has made me bold enough
to state that it is true. I have been seeking contentment with so much
eagerness, and know so well that it is hard to find, that I have come to
believe that there is but one more chance, and that I would find what I
lack in the love of a woman like you. Even if I should discover by
experience that I am mistaken in this belief, I would feel better off
than I ever did before; for I would then conclude that my fancies were
wrong, and that I was as well off as any man; but this feeling will
always be denied me, for I am denied the privilege of happiness now that
it is within my reach. My lonely life here has wrung a confession from
me which I should have kept to myself, but it is every word true; you
can depend on that."
Annie Benton seemed satisfied with the answers he had made, and there
was another long silence between them.
"And your music--you play like one possessed," he said finally, talking
to the wind, probably, for he was not looking at the girl. "Every
sentiment my heart has ever known you have expressed in chords. Had I
not known differently, I should have thought you were familiar with my
history and permitted the organ to tell it whenever we met. What a voice
the old box has, and what versatility; for its power in representing
angels is only equalled by its power to represent devils. There is a
song with which I have become familiar from hearing you play the air; it
is a sermon which appealed to me as nothing ever did before. Before I
knew the words, I felt sure that they were promises of mercy and
forgiveness; and when I found them, I thought I must have been familiar
with them all my life; they were exactly what I had imagined. To look at
your cold, passionless face now, no one would suspect your wonderful
genius. You look innocent enough, but I do not wonder that you are
regarded as a greater attraction than the minister. I have been told
that you can kill the sermon, when you want to, by freezing the audience
before it commences, and I believe it. I have no doubt that you take
pride in controlling with your deft fingers the poor folks who worship
under the steeple which mounts up below us. I only wonder that you do
not cause them to cheer, and swing their hats, for they say that you can
move them to tears at will."
"I never feel like cheering myself," she answered, "and I suppose that
is why the organ never does. But I very often feel sad, because I am so
commonplace, and because there is so little in the future for me. If I
play so coldly at times that even the minister is affected, it is
because I am indifferent, and forget, and not because I intend it."
"If you are commonplace," Allan Dorris replied, "you have abundant
company; for the world is full of common people. We are all creatures of
such common mould that I wonder we do not tire of our ugly forms. Out of
every hundred thousand there is a genius, who neglects all the virtues
of the common folks, and is hateful save as a genius. For his one good
quality he has a hundred bad ones; but he is not held to strict account,
like the rest of us, for genius is so rare that we encourage it, no
matter what the cost. But I have heard that these great people are
monstrosities, and thoroughly wretched. I would rather be a king in one
honest heart, than a sight for thousands. But this is not running away
from you, as I promised, and if I remain here longer I shall lose the
power. My path is down the hill; yours is up."
He lifted his hat to her, and walked away; but she called to him,--
"I am going down the hill, too, and I will accompany you."
He waited until she came up, and they walked away together.
The girl had said that she was going down the hill, too, and would
accompany him; but Dorris knew that she meant the hill on which they
were standing, not the one he referred to. He referred to a hill as
famous as wickedness, and known in every house because of its open doors
to welcome back some straggler from the noisy crowd travelling down the
famous hill; but he thought that should a woman like Annie Benton
consent to undertake the journey with him, he would change his course,
and travel the other way, in spite of everything.
"Did I do wrong in asking you to wait for me?" she inquired, after they
had walked awhile in silence.
"Yes," he answered, "because it pleased me. Be very careful to do
nothing which pleases me, for I am not accustomed to it, and the novelty
may cause me to forget the vow I have made. A man long accustomed to
darkness is very fond of the light. What do you think of me, anyway?"
"What a strange question!" the girl said, turning to look at him.
"Be as frank with me as I was with you. What do you think of me?"
The girl thought the matter over for a while, and replied,--
"If I should answer you frankly, I should please you; and you have
warned me against that."
Dorris was amused at the reply, and laughed awhile to himself.
"I didn't think of that," he said, though he probably had thought of it,
and hoped that her reply would be what it was. "I am glad to hear that I
am not repugnant to you, though. It will be a comfort to me to know, now
that my dream has come true, that the subject of it does not regard me
with distrust or aversion. I am glad, too, that after dreaming of the
sunshine so long, it is not a disappointment. In my loneliness hereafter
that circumstance will be a satisfaction, and it will be a pleasure to
believe that the sunshine was brighter because of my brief stay in it. I
can forget some of the darkness around me in future, in thinking of
these two circumstances."
They had reached Thompson Benton's gate by this time, and, the
invitation having been extended, Dorris walked into the house. The
master was not due for an hour, so Dorris remained until he came,
excusing himself by the reflection that he would never see the girl
again, and that he was entitled to this pleasure because of the
sacrifice he had resolved to make.
It was the same old story over again; Allan Dorris was desperately in
love with Annie Benton, but she must not be in love with him, for he was
dangerous, and whether this was true or not, his companion did not
believe it. He told in a hundred ways, though in language which might
have meant any one of a hundred things, that she was his dream come
true, and of the necessity which existed for him to avoid her.
Occasionally he would forget to be grave, and make sport of himself, and
laugh at what he had been saying; and at these times Annie Benton was
convinced more than ever that he was not a dangerous man, as he said,
for there was an honest gentility in his manner, and a gentle respect
for her womanhood in everything he did; therefore she listened
attentively to what he said, saying but little herself, as he requested.
Although he made love to her in many ingenious ways, and moved Annie
Benton as she had never been moved before, he did not so intend it.
Could his motives have been impartially judged, that must have been the
verdict; but while he knew that his love was out of place in the keeping
of the girl, he could not resist the temptation of giving it to her, and
then asking her to refuse it.
Several times Annie Benton attempted to speak, but he held up his hand
as a warning.
"Don't say anything that you will regret," he said. "Let me do that; I
am famous for it. I never talked ten minutes in my life that I didn't
say something that caused me regret for a year. But I will never regret
anything I have said to you, for I have only made a confession which has
been at my tongue's end for years. I have known you all my life; you
know nothing of me, and care less, therefore let it be as I suggest."
"But just a word," the girl insisted. "You do not understand what I
would say--"
"I don't know what you would say, but I can imagine what a lady like you
_should_ say under such circumstances, and I beg the favor of your
silence. Let me imagine what I please, since that can be of little
consequence to you."
There was a noise at the front door, and old Thompson came in. Dorris
bowed himself out, followed by a scowl, and as he walked along toward
his own house he thought that his resolution to see Annie Benton no more
would at least save him from a quarrel with her father.