'"His Vanished Star," in all its well-defined, well-described human
interests, and its graphic account of grand and lovely scenery, is an
excellent novel.... The story is both charming and original.'--_Glasgow
Herald._
'A thrilling and pathetic tale, and one full of quiet humour and
intimate observation of human nature.'--_Morning Leader._
'There is not a page in it which will not cause a reader to respect the
writer for her good work.'--_Bookman._
'C. E. Craddock has given in "His Vanished Star" fresh evidence of
strong imaginative power and a faculty of vivid description, bold,
definite, and picturesque.... Its excellencies are undeniable, and not
of a common sort.'--_Scotsman._
'A remarkable study of nature as well as of character.... Rich in the
rather grim humour of a peculiar class, picturesque and in its way
powerful, "His Vanished Star" will recommend itself to the lover of
American fiction.'--_Morning Post._
'There is a good deal of interesting character-drawing, and the
spiritual impressions are strong and high. There is humour
too.'--_Athenaeum._
'As a vivid sketch of American life in its most primitive aspect, "His
Vanished Star" is undoubtedly a noteworthy book.'--_Speaker._