Annie entered the presence of the famous lawyer pale and ill at ease.
This sudden summons to Judge Brewster's private office was so unexpected
that it came like a shock. For days she had haunted the premises,
sitting in the outer office for hours at a time exposed to the stare and
covert smiles of thoughtless clerks and office boys. Her requests for an
interview had been met with curt refusals. They either said the judge
was out of town or else that he was too busy to be seen. At last,
evidently acting upon orders, they flatly refused to even send in her
name, and she had about abandoned hope when, all at once, a clerk
approached her, and addressing her more politely than usual, said that
the judge would see her in a few minutes.
Her heart gave a great throb. Almost speechless from surprise, she
stammered a faint thanks and braced herself for the interview on which
so much depended. For the first time since the terrible affair had
happened, there was a faint glimmer of hope ahead. If only she could
rush over to the Tombs and tell Howard the joyful news so he might keep
up his courage! It was eight days now since Howard's arrest, and the
trial would take place in six weeks. There was still time to prepare a
strong defense if the judge would only consent to take the case. She was
more sure than ever that a clever lawyer would have no difficulty in
convincing a jury that Howard's alleged "confession" was untrue and
improperly obtained.
In the intervals of waiting to see the lawyer, she had consulted every
one she knew, and among others she had talked with Dr. Bernstein, the
noted psychologist, whom she had seen once at Yale. He received her
kindly and listened attentively to her story. When she had finished he
had evinced the greatest interest. He told her that he happened to be
the physician called in on the night of the tragedy, and at that time he
had grave doubts as to it being a case of murder. He believed it was
suicide, and he had told Captain Clinton so, but the police captain had
made up his mind, and that was the end of it. Howard's "confession," he
went on, really meant nothing. If called to the stand he could show the
jury that a hypnotic subject can be made to "confess" to anything. In
the interest of truth, justice, and science, he said, he would gladly
come to her aid.
All this she would tell Judge Brewster. It would be of great help to
him, no doubt. Suddenly, a cold shiver ran through her. How did she know
he would take the case? Perhaps this summons to his office was only to
tell her once more that he would have nothing to do with her and her
husband. She wondered why he had decided so suddenly to see her and,
like a flash, an idea came to her. She had seen Mr. Jeffries, Sr., enter
the inner sanctum and, instinctively, she felt that she had something to
do with his visit. The banker had come out accompanied by a richly
dressed woman whom she guessed to be his wife.
She looked with much interest at Howard's stepmother. She had heard so
much about her that it seemed to her that she knew her personally. As
Alicia swept proudly by, the eyes of the two women met, and Annie was
surprised to see in the banker's wife's face, instead of the cold,
haughty stare she expected, a wistful, longing look, as if she would
like to stop and talk with her, but dare not. In another instant she was
gone, and, obeying a clerk, who beckoned her to follow him, she entered
Judge Brewster's office.
The lawyer looked up as she came in, but did not move from his seat.
Gruffly he said:
"How long do you intend to keep up this system of--warfare? How long are
you going to continue forcing your way into this office?"
"I didn't force my way in," she said quietly. "I didn't expect to come
in. The clerk said you wanted to see me."
The lawyer frowned and scrutinized her closely. After a pause, he said:
"I want to tell you for the fiftieth time I can do nothing for you."
"Fifty?" she echoed. "Fifty did you say? Really, it doesn't seem that
much."
Judge Brewster looked at her quickly to see if she was laughing at him.
Almost peevishly, he said:
"For the last time, I repeat I can do nothing for you."
[Illustration: "I CAN DO NOTHING FOR YOU," SAID THE JUDGE.]
"Not the last time, judge," she replied, shaking her head. "I shall come
again to-morrow."
The lawyer swung around in his chair with indignation.
"You will----?"
Annie nodded.
"Yes, sir," she said quietly.
"You're determined to force your way in here?" exclaimed the lawyer.
"Yes, sir."
The judge banged the desk with his fist.
"But I won't allow it! I have something to say, you know! I can't permit
this to go on. I represent my client, Mr. Howard Jeffries, Sr., and he
won't consent to my taking up your husband's case."
There was a shade of sarcasm in Annie's voice as she asked calmly:
"Can't you do it without his consent?"
The lawyer looked at her grimly.
"I can," he blurted out, "but--I won't."
Her eyes flashed as she replied quickly.
"Well, you ought to----"
The lawyer looked up in amazement.
"What do you mean?" he demanded.
"It's your duty to do it," she said quietly. "Your duty to his son, to
me, and to Mr. Jeffries himself. Why, he's so eaten up with his family
pride and false principles that he can't see the difference between
right and wrong. You're his lawyer. It's your duty to put him right.
It's downright wicked of you to refuse--you're hurting him. Why, when I
was hunting around for a lawyer one of them actually refused to take up
the case because he said old Brewster must think Howard was guilty or
he'd have taken it up himself. You and his father are putting the whole
world against him, and you know it."
The judge was staggered. No one in his recollection had ever dared to
speak to him like that. He was so astonished that he forgot to resent
it, and he hid his confusion by taking out his handkerchief and mopping
his forehead.
"I do know it," he admitted.
"Then why do you do it?" she snapped.
The lawyer hesitated, and then he said:
"I--that's not the question."
Annie leaped quickly forward, and she replied:
"It's my question--and as you say, I've asked it fifty times."
The lawyer sat back in his chair and looked at her for a moment without
speaking. He surveyed her critically from head to foot, and then, as if
satisfied with his examination, said:
"You're going on the stage?"
She nodded.
"I've had a very big offer."
The judge leaned forward, and in a low voice, so that no one in the
outer office might hear, he said:
"Well, I'll give you twice as much if you refuse the engagement."
She laughed ironically.
"You mean that my father-in-law will give it," she said lightly. Then
she went on:
"You know it's no use your asking me to concede anything unless you
agree to defend Howard."
The lawyer shook his head.
"I can't--it's impossible."
"Then neither can I," she exclaimed defiantly.
Judge Brewster could not refrain from smiling. This young woman had
actually inveigled him into an argument. Almost mockingly, he said:
"So you're determined to have me."
"Yes," she said simply.
"But I don't argue criminal cases."
"That's just it," she exclaimed eagerly; "my husband is not a criminal.
He is innocent. I don't want a lawyer who is always defending criminals.
I want one who defends a man because he isn't a criminal."
Judge Brewster waved his hand contemptuously.
"Go and see some other lawyer--there are plenty of 'em."
She leaned eagerly forward. Her face was flushed from excitement, her
eyes flashed.
"There's only one Judge Brewster," she exclaimed. "He's the greatest
lawyer in the world, and he's going to help us. He is going to save
Howard's life."
The judge shifted uneasily on his chair. He didn't like this forceful,
persistent young woman. Almost fretfully, he said:
"You always say that. Upon my word, I shall begin to believe it soon."
"I shall say it again," she exclaimed, "and again every time I see
you."
The lawyer turned round. There was a comic look of despair in his face
which would have amused his visitor had her errand not been so serious.
"How often do you intend that shall be?"
"Every day," she replied calmly. "I shall say it and think it
until--until it comes true."
Judge Brewster tried to feel angry, although inwardly he had hard work
to keep from smiling. With pretended indignation, he said:
"You mean that you intend to keep at me until I give way--through sheer
exhaustion?"
She nodded.
"That's it exactly," she said.
The lawyer gasped.
"Well, I must say you--you--you're very brave."
Annie shook her head.
"No, I'm not," she said earnestly. "I'm an awful coward, but I'm
fighting for him. Howard Jeffries lifted me up when I was way down in
the world. He gave me his name. He gave me all he had, to make me a
better woman, and I'm grateful. Why, even a dog has gratitude, even a
dog will lick the hand that feeds him. Why should I hesitate to express
my gratitude? That's all I'm doing--just paying him back a bit of the
debt I owe him, and I'm going to move Heaven and earth to bring his
father around to my way of thinking. I've got you already----"
The judge bounded to his feet. Could his ears have heard aright?
"Got me already?" he exclaimed. "What do you mean by that?"
Annie returned his angry look with the utmost calm. She was playing her
cards well, and she knew it. She had hit the old man in a sensitive
place. Quietly, she went on:
"You'd say 'yes' in a minute if it wasn't for Mr. Jeffries."
"Oh, you think so, do you?" he gasped.
"I'm sure of it," she replied confidently. Boldly she went on: "You're
afraid of him."
Judge Brewster laughed heartily.
"Afraid of him?" he echoed.
"It isn't so funny," she went on. "You're afraid of opposing him. I'm
not surprised. I'm afraid of him myself."
The lawyer looked at her in an amused kind of way.
"Then why do you oppose him in everything?" he demanded.
Annie laughed as she replied:
"That's the only way I can get his attention. Why, when he met me out
there to-day he actually looked at me. For the first time in his life he
recognized that he has a daughter-in-law. He looked at me--and I'm not
sure, but I think he wanted to bow to me. He's kind of beginning to sit
up and take notice."
Judge Brewster frowned. He did not like the insinuation that he was
afraid to do the right thing because it might interfere with his
emoluments. Yet, secretly, he had to admit to himself that she had
almost guessed right. Now he came to think of it, he had taken this
stand in the matter because he knew that any other course would
displease his wealthy client. After all, was he doing right? Was he
acting in conformance with his professional oath? Was he not letting his
material interests interfere with his duty? He was silent for several
minutes, and then, in an absent-minded kind of way, he turned to his
visitor.
"So you think I'm afraid of him, do you?"
"I'm sure of it," she said quickly. "You liked my husband, and you'd
just love to rush in and fight for him. His father thinks he is guilty
and, well--you don't like to disobey him. It's very natural. He's an
influential man, a personal friend of the President and all that. You
know on which side your bread is buttered, and--oh, it's very
natural--you're looking out for your own interests----"
Judge Brewster interrupted her impatiently.
"Circumstances are against Howard. Your father judges him guilty from
his own confession. It's the conclusion I'm compelled to come to myself.
Now, how do you propose to change that conclusion?"
"You don't have to change it," she said quietly, "You don't believe
Howard guilty."
"I don't?" exclaimed the lawyer.
"No, at the bottom of your heart. You knew Howard when he was a boy, and
you know he is as incapable of that crime as you are."
Judge Brewster lapsed into silence, and there followed a perfect quiet,
broken only by the suppressed chatter of the clerks and clicking of the
typewriters in the outer office. Annie watched him closely, wondering
what was passing in his mind, fearing in her heart that she might have
prejudiced him against her husband only the more. Suddenly he turned on
her.
"Mrs. Jeffries, how do you know that your husband did not kill Robert
Underwood?"
"I know it," she said confidently.
"Yes," persisted the judge, "but how do you know it?"
Annie looked steadily at him, and then she said solemnly:
"I know there's a God, but I can't tell you how I know it. I just know
it, that's all! Howard didn't do it. I know he didn't."
The lawyer smiled.
"That's a very fair sample of feminine logic."
"Well, it's all I have," she retorted, with a toss of her head. "And
it's a mighty comfort, too, because when you know a thing you know it
and it makes you happy."
Judge Brewster laughed outright.
"Feminine deduction!" he cried. "Think a thing, believe it, and then you
know it!" Looking up at her, he asked:
"Haven't you any relatives to whom you can go?"
She shook her head.
"No," she said sadly. "My father died in--Sing Sing--and the rest are
not worth----"
"Yes, yes, I know," replied the judge hastily. "I got your family
history from Mr. Jeffries after your marriage. It is filed away among
the family archives."
She smiled sadly.
"It's a wonder you don't burn 'em up--my folks were not a very brilliant
lot." Earnestly she went on: "But my father was all right, judge. Blood
was thicker than water with him. He'd never have gone back on me in the
way Howard's father has on him."
The lawyer looked at her fixedly without speaking. Their eyes met, and
the silence continued until it became embarrassing. Judge Brewster shook
his head.
"It's too bad. I'm sorry for you, really, I----"
Annie laughed, and he asked:
"Why do you laugh?"
"What's the use of crying?" she said. "Ha! Ha! It's almost a joke.
You're sorry, my father-in-law is sorry, and I suppose my mother-in-law
is shedding tears for me, too. You're all sorry and you're all wearing
crape for us, but why can't some of you _do_ something?"
The lawyer said nothing. He still stared at her in a strange,
absent-minded kind of way, until finally she lost patience. Boldly she
said:
"Well, you sent for me. What do you want to see me about, judge?"
"I want to tell you that you mustn't come here again," he answered.
"Anything else?" she exclaimed.
The judge began to fuss with the papers on his desk, as he usually did
when embarrassed for words.
"Of course," he stammered, "you will be amply compensated."
"Of course," she cried. Rising from her chair, she shrugged her
shoulders, and said:
"Oh, well, this is not my lucky day. They wouldn't let me into the
prison to see Howard to-day. Captain Clinton doesn't like me. He has
always tried to prevent my seeing Howard, but I'll see him to-morrow,
captain or no captain. He can make up his mind to that!"
The lawyer looked up at her.
"Poor girl--you are having a hard time, aren't you?"
"Things have been better," she replied, with a tremor in her voice.
"Howard and I were very happy when we first----" A sob choked her
utterance, and she forced a laugh, saying: "Here, I must keep off that
subject----"
"Why do you laugh?" demanded the lawyer.
Already hysterical, Annie had great difficulty in keeping back her
tears.
"Well, if I don't laugh," she sobbed, "I'll cry; and as I don't want to
cry--why--I just laugh. It's got to be one or the other--see----?"
He said nothing, and she continued:
"Well, I guess I'll go home--home--that's the worst part of
it--home----"
She stopped short, she could go no further. Her bosom was heaving, the
hot tears were rolling down her cheeks. The old lawyer turned away his
head so that she might not see the suspicious redness in his eyes.
Moving toward the door, she turned around.
"Well, you have your own troubles, judge. I'll go now, but I'll come
again to-morrow. Perhaps you'll have better news for me."
The lawyer waved her back to her seat with a commanding gesture she
could not resist. There was determination around his mouth; in his face
was an expression she had not seen there before.
"Sit down again for a moment," he said sharply. "I want to ask you a
question. How do you account for Howard's confessing to the shooting?"
"I don't account for it," she replied, as she resumed her seat. "He says
he didn't confess. I don't believe he did."
"But three witnesses----"
"Who are the witnesses?" she interrupted contemptuously. "Policemen!"
"That makes no difference," he said. "He made a confession and
signed----"
Annie leaned forward. What did this questioning mean? Was the judge
becoming interested after all? Her heart gave a leap as she answered
eagerly:
"He confessed against his will. I mean--he didn't know what he was doing
at the time. I've had a talk with the physician who was called in--Dr.
Bernstein. He says that Captain Clinton is a hypnotist, that he can
compel people to say what he wants them to say. Well, Howard is--what
they call a subject--they told him he did it till he believed he did."
She looked narrowly at the lawyer to see what effect her words were
having, but to her great disappointment the judge was apparently paying
not the slightest attention. He was gazing out of the window and
drumming his fingers absent-mindedly on the desk. Utterly discouraged,
she again rose.
"Oh, well, what's the use----?"
The judge quickly put out his hand and partly pushed her back in the
chair.
"Don't go," he said. Then he added:
"Who told you he was a hypnotic subject?"
Her hopes revived once more. Quickly she said:
"Dr. Bernstein. Besides, Howard told me so himself. A friend of his at
college used to make him cut all sorts of capers."
"A friend at college, eh? Do you remember his name?"
"Howard knows it."
"Um!" ejaculated the lawyer. He took up a pad and wrote a memorandum on
it. Then aloud he said: "I'd like to have a little talk with Dr.
Bernstein. I think I'll ask him to come and see me. Let me see. His
address is----"
"342 Madison Avenue," she exclaimed eagerly.
The lawyer jotted the address down, and then he looked up.
"So you think I'm afraid of Mr. Jeffries, do you?"
She smiled.
"Oh, no, not really afraid," she answered, "but just--scared. I didn't
mean----"
Judge Brewster was enjoying the situation hugely. He had quite made up
his mind what to do, but he liked to quiz this bold young woman who had
not been afraid to show him where his duty lay. Striving to keep a
serious face, he said:
"Oh, yes, you did, and I want you to understand I'm not afraid of any
man. As to allowing my personal interests to interfere with my duty----"
Annie took alarm. She was really afraid she had offended him.
"Oh, I didn't say that, did I?" she exclaimed timidly.
Judge Brewster forced his face into a frown.
"You said I knew on which side my bread was buttered!"
"Did I?" she exclaimed in consternation.
"You say a great many things, Mrs. Jeffries," said the lawyer solemnly.
"Of course, I realize how deeply you feel, and I make excuses for you.
But I'm not afraid. Please understand that----"
He rapped the table with his eyeglasses as if he were very much offended
indeed.
"Of course not," she said apologetically. "If you were you wouldn't even
see me--let alone talk to me--and--and----" Pointing to the piece of
paper he held in his hand, she added: "And----"
"And what?" demanded the judge, amused.
Half hysterical, now laughing, now crying, she went on:
"And--and take the names and addresses of witnesses for the
defense--and--think out how you're going to defend Howard--and--and all
that----"
The lawyer looked at her and laughed.
"So you think I'm going to help Howard?" he said. "You take too much for
granted."
"You're not afraid to help him," she said. "I know that--you just said
so."
Judge Brewster raised his fist and brought it down on the desk with a
bang which raised in a cloud the accumulated dust of weeks. His face set
and determined, he said:
"You're quite right! I'm going to take your case!"
Annie felt herself giving way. It was more than she could stand. For
victory to be hers when only a moment before defeat seemed certain was
too much for her nerves. All she could gasp was:
"Oh, judge!"
The lawyer adjusted his eyeglasses, blew his nose with suspicious
energy, and took up a pen.
"Now don't pretend to be surprised--you knew I would. And please don't
thank me. I hate to be thanked for doing what I want to do. If I didn't
want to do it, I wouldn't----"
Through her tears she murmured:
"I'd like to say 'thank you'."
"Well, please don't," he snapped.
But she persisted. Tenderly, she said:
"May I say you're the dearest, kindest----"
Judge Brewster shook his head.
"No--no--nothing of the kind."
"Most gracious--noble-hearted--courageous," she went on.
The judge struck the table another formidable blow.
"Mrs. Jeffries!" he exclaimed.
She turned away her head to hide her feelings.
"Oh, how I'd like to have a good cry," she murmured. "If Howard only
knew!"
Judge Brewster touched an electric button, and his head clerk entered.
"Mr. Jones," said the lawyer quickly, "get a stenographic report of the
case of the People against Howard Jeffries, Junior; get the coroner's
inquest, the grand jury indictment, and get a copy of the Jeffries
confession--get everything--right away!"
The clerk looked inquiringly, first at Annie and then at his employer.
Then respectfully he asked:
"Do we, sir?"
"We do," said the lawyer laconically.