Elsbeth spent her day in that meticulous and unnecessary arrangement and
re-arrangement of her house and person, with which woman, since time
was, has delighted to honour man, and which he, the unaccountable, has
as inevitably failed to notice. The clean cretonnes had arrived in time
and were tied and smoothed into place; the vases new-filled; and the
fire, though spring-cleaning had been, sprawled opulently in a brickless
grate. The matches, with the fifty cigarettes Elsbeth had bought that
forenoon, hesitating and all too reliant upon the bored tobacconist,
lay, aliens unmistakable, near Roger's probable seat, and the knowledge
of the supper laid out in the next room fortified Elsbeth as, years ago,
a new frock might have done. Alwynne, in every age and stage, dotted the
piano and occasional tables, and a photograph that even Alwynne had
never seen was placed on the mantelshelf, that Roger, greeting Elsbeth,
might see it and forget to be shy.
But it was Elsbeth that was shy, when Roger, very punctual, arrived amid
the chimes of the evening service. Yet Elsbeth had been ready since
five. They greeted each other in dumb show and sat a moment, smiling and
taking stock, while the clamour swelled, insisted, ebbed and died away.
Roger, still silent, began to fumble at a case he carried, while Elsbeth
found herself apologetically and for the thousandth time wondering to
her guest why she had taken root so near a church, while within herself
a hard voice cried exultantly, "He's his father, his father over again!
Nothing of Rosemary there!" and she tasted a little strange flash of
triumph over the dead woman she had been too gentle to hate.
But suddenly her lap was filled with roses, bunch upon tight masculine
bunch, and the formal sentences broke up into incoherence as Roger
stooped and kissed his second cousin Elsbeth.
They soon made friends. Roger, who had never quite forgotten her, found
the pleasant-faced spinster as attractive as the pretty lady of his
childhood. He examined her as he ate his supper. A spare figure, soft
grey hair, and square, capable hands; a kind mouth, not a strong one,
set in lines firmer than were natural to it; gentle eyes, no longer
beautiful, and a cheerful, tired smile; a sweet face, thought Roger, not
a happy one. Yet she had Alwynne! She fluttered a little over the meal,
and was anxious about his coffee, and full of little enquiries and
attentions that were never irritating. There was a faint scent of
verbena as she moved about him, and her silk gown did not crackle like
younger women's dresses. She listened well, but he guessed her no
talker, and later in the evening, gauged her affection for Alwynne by
her breathless fluency. He thought her charming and a little pathetic,
and wondered why nobody had ever insisted on marrying her.
Elsbeth's shyness soon dwindled; she slipped quickly into the informal
"aunt and nephew" attitude that he evidently expected, and found his
friendliness and obvious pleasure in her as delightful as it was
astonishing. She supposed, with a wistful little shrug, that she was
near the rose! Nevertheless she enjoyed herself.
They talked in narrowing circles: of his father a little; more of his
mother; of Dene, and Elsbeth's former visits. He described Compton and
The Dears, and his gardens and his roses. Then, with a chuckle, an
unauthorised attempt of Alwynne at pruning that had ended in disaster;
and so plunged into confidences.
"I expect you've guessed that I intend--that I want to marry
Alwynne,--with her permission," he added hastily, smiling down at her.
Elsbeth envied him his inches. For Alwynne's sake she did not intend to
be dominated; but she found his mere masculinity a little overpowering,
and did not guess that her frail dignity had made its own impression.
She smiled back at him.
"I'm glad you put that in. You should respect grey hairs."
"But I do."
"No. You imply that I'm a very blind and foolish guardian! My dear boy,"
her pretty voice shook a little, "I've hoped and prayed for this. You,
John's boy, and--and dear Rosemary's, of course--and Alwynne, who's
dearer to me than a daughter! Why, that's why I sent her down to Dene!"
She blushed the rare blush of later middle age. "Oh, my dear--it was
shameless! I was matchmaking! I was! And I've always considered it so
indelicate. But I wished so strongly that you two might come together.
When Alwynne wrote of you so often, I hoped: and then your letters made
me sure. You had got on so well without me these twenty-five years--and
then to feel the ties of kinship so very strongly all of a sudden--it
was transparent, Roger."
He laughed.
"I hadn't forgotten really--though it's the vaguest memory. You gave me
a rabbit in a green cabbage that opened. And one Sunday we shared Prayer
Books. You had a blue dress--a pale blue that one never sees nowadays,
and very pink cheeks."
"Ah! the _crêpe de Chine_," said Elsbeth absently.
"I always remembered--though I'd forgotten I did. Alwynne brought it
back. She's like you in some ways, you know. She made me awfully curious
to see you again. From the way she talked I knew you'd be decent to me."
He smiled. "Elsbeth--I'm tremendously in love."
"Have you told her so?"
"Alwynne's rather difficult to get hold of. She doesn't understand
anything but black and white."
"Clare Hartill--I suppose you've heard of Clare Hartill?"
"Have I not!"
"Clare Hartill says she has an uncanny ear for nuances."
"Also that she's thick-skinned! The woman's a fool."
"Oh, she's quite right, Roger, though I expect she was in a temper when
she said it. But it only means that Alwynne has been trained to listen
to women. She can't follow men yet. She has been advised that they are
grown-up children and that her rôle is to be superior but tactful."
He chuckled.
"Yes. When Alwynne's tactful--she's tactful! You can't mistake it, can
you? Have you ever seen her sidling out of a room when she thought she
wasn't wanted? Still, she can hold her own, on occasion. She simply
walked through my hints. But--how does she talk of me, Elsbeth, if she
does at all, that is?"
"She likes you, in the 'good old Roger' fashion."
"But you do think I have a chance?"
"That's why I wanted to see you. Frankly, at present I don't think you
have."
He looked at her coolly, not at all depressed.
"Why not?"
"Clare Hartill."
"Ah!" He sat down at the table again, his chin in his fist. "You think
her the obstacle?"
"I taught her once. Alwynne has been absorbed in her for two years.
Alwynne talks----" they both smiled. "I could compare. I ought to know
her pretty well."
"Yes. But how can she affect Alwynne and me? Of course I know what a lot
Alwynne thinks of her. She's rather delightful on the subject. Thinks
her perfection, and so on. Alwynne is naïve; conveys more than she knows
or intends, sometimes. And she never looks at her god's feet, does she?
'Clare' and 'Clare' and 'Clare.' Personally, I imagine her a bit of a
brute."
"I try to be fair. She is fond of Alwynne."
"Why not? But what's that got to do with Alwynne's caring for me, if I
am lucky enough to make her? And I'm--conceitedly sure--that it's only a
question of waking Alwynne up."
"You don't know Clare. If once she knows, she'll never let the child
go."
"But if Alwynne were engaged to me?"
"She'll never allow it. She'll play on Alwynne's affection for her."
"But why? I shouldn't interfere with their friendship."
"My dear Roger--marriage ends friendship automatically. Clare would be
shrewd enough to see that. And even--otherwise--she would never share.
You don't guess how jealous women are."
Roger leant back in his chair with a gesture of bewilderment.
"My dearest cousin! The age of sorcery is over. You talk as if Alwynne
were under a spell."
"Practically she is. Of course Clare would put it on the highest
grounds--unsuitability--a waste of talents. She pretends to despise
domesticity. Alwynne would be hypnotised into repeating her arguments as
her own opinion."
"Hypnotism?"
"Oh, not literally. But she really does influence some women, and young
girls especially, in the most uncanny way. I've watched it so often."
"She's not married?"
"She hardly ever speaks to a man. I've seen her at gaieties, when she
was younger. She was always rather stranded. Men left her alone.
Something in her seems to repel them. I think she fully realised it. And
she's a proud woman. There's tragedy in it."
"Does she repel you?"
"Not in that way. I dislike her. I think her dangerous. I'm intensely
sorry for her. And I do understand something of the attraction she
exercises, better than you can, though it has never affected me. You
see--eccentricity--abnormality--does not affect women as it does men.
And she's brilliantly clever."
"So is Alwynne--you wouldn't call her abnormal?"
"Alwynne? Never! She's as sound and sweet as an apple. But--and it means
a good deal at her age--she's in abnormal hands. Clare Hartill is
abnormal, spiritually perverse--and she's fastened on the child. They
adore each other. It's terribly bad for Alwynne. As it is, it will take
her months to shake off Clare's influence, even with you to help her.
That is, if you succeed in detaching her. I'm useless, of course.
Loving--just loving--is no good. You can only influence if you are
strong enough to wound. I merely irritate. I'm weak. But you could do as
you like, I believe. Take her away from that selfish woman, Roger! It's
blighting her."
"You think," he said, "that she would be content with me--with marriage
as a career? Of course, Miss Hartill's right about her talents."
"Alwynne? I don't think--I know. All her gifts are so much surface show;
she's a very simple child underneath. Content? Can't you see her,
Roger--with children? Her own babies?"
Roger beamed.
"It's rather a jolly prospect. Well, I must take my chance."
"Of course, you must wait; it's too soon yet. Even later, if Clare
really wants her--wants her enough to suppress her own perverse
impulses--I'm afraid you've little chance. But it's possible that she
will not want her as much as that."
"I don't follow."
"I mean that Clare, with that impish nature of hers, may hurt Alwynne."
"I should think she has already, often enough."
"Yes--but Alwynne has never realised it, never realised that it was
deliberate. She is always so sure that it was her fault somehow. If
once she found out that Clare was hurting her for--for the fun of it,
you know--for the pleasure of watching her suffer--as I'm sure she
does--it might end everything. Alwynne hates cruelty. That poor child's
death shook her. A little more, and she will be disillusioned."
"But loyal still?"
"Probably. But the glamour would be gone. She would be extremely
unhappy. There your chance would come. Though I don't think Clare will
give it you--for I believe Alwynne does mean more to her than most
things. But she's an unaccountable person: there is the chance."
"I see," Roger rose and straightened himself. "Practically I'm not to
depend on my own--attractions--at all." He laughed a little. "I am to
watch the whims of this--this unpleasant school-marm, and be grateful to
her for forcing Alwynne to prefer my deep sea to her devil. The
situation is hardly dignified."
Elsbeth laughed too.
"Love is always undignified, Roger. What does it matter if you want
her?" But she watched him anxiously as he walked to the window, and
stood staring out.
There was a silence. At last he turned--
"Elsbeth, dear, it's a beautiful scheme, and a woman could carry it
through, I daresay--but it's no good to me. It's too--too tortuous, too
feminine. I don't mean anything rude. It's merely that I'm not--subtle
enough, or patient. At least, I haven't got that cat-and-mouse kind of
patience. I can wait, you know. That's different. I can wait all right.
But I can't intrigue."
Elsbeth flushed.
"There is no intrigue. It's a question of understanding Alwynne and of
using the opportunity when it comes."
"To trick and surprise and over-persuade her into caring for me! It's no
good, Elsbeth. It isn't possession I want--it's Alwynne. Can't you see?
We should neither of us be happy. She would always distrust me and
remember that I'd taken an advantage. I should end by hating her, I
believe. Can't you see?"
Elsbeth was shaken by her own thoughts.
"I see," she said finally. "And I see that you don't love her--or you'd
take her on any terms."
"Would you?"
"Yes."
"Well, I wouldn't. And I do love her. But I want Alwynne on my terms. Do
I sound an awful prig? Cousin Elsbeth, hear my way! I'm going to have it
out with Alwynne."
"At once?"
"At once. As soon as I see her--no beating about the bush."
"Roger--she may be utterly out of the mood."
"Hang moods! I beg your pardon, Elsbeth. But I'm going to tell
her--certain things. If she doesn't like it I'm going back to Dene.
She'll know where to find me when she changes her mind. Elsbeth, don't
look so hopeless."
"You don't understand Alwynne."
"I don't want to understand her--I want to marry her. I must stick to my
own way. Can't you conceive that all this consideration, all this
deference to moods and dissection of motives, this horribly feminine
atmosphere that she seems to have lived in, of subtleties, and
reservations, and simulations--may be bad for her? It seems to me that
she's always being thought about. You, with your anxious affection--that
unholy woman with her lancet and probe--you neither of you leave her
alone for a second. She's always being touched. Well, I'm going to leave
her alone. It gives her a chance."
"I've never spoiled her." Elsbeth was off at a tangent.
"I'm sure of it. I can remember Father holding you up to Mother once. He
said you were the most judicious woman with children that he knew."
"Did he?" said Elsbeth.
"Mother was awfully annoyed." Roger chuckled. "I'd been bawling for my
fourth doughnut--and got it."
"I've never spoiled Alwynne," repeated Elsbeth tonelessly.
"No one could," remarked Roger with conviction.
Elsbeth looked up and laughed at him.
"So you are human!" she said. "I was beginning to doubt it."
"When I get on the subject of Alwynne's adorableness----" he laughed
back at her, "we're obviously cousins, aren't we? But, really, I've been
trying to be detached, and critical, and analytical, and all the things
you feel are important. I wanted to see what you meant, Cousin Elsbeth;
and I do see that we both want the same thing. But as to the means--I
believe I must go my own way."
She eyed him doubtfully. But he looked very big and solid in the little
room, comfortingly sure of himself.
"You think me a frantic old clucking hen, don't you? And are just a
little sorry for the duckling."
"I think you're a perfect dear," said Roger.
"You'll come to-morrow? Alwynne will be back, I hope."
"What time is she likely to turn up?"
"About four, if she comes. She would lunch with Clare, I expect."
He nodded whimsically.
"Very well. To-morrow, at four precisely, there will be a row royal.
To-morrow I am calling on Miss Hartill to fetch Alwynne home. Good-bye,
Cousin Elsbeth."
He turned again in the doorway.
"Elsbeth, there's a house at Dene I've got my eye on. There's a turret
room. My best roses will clamber right into it. That's to be yours. And
Elsbeth! Nobody but you shall run the nursery."
He had shut the door before she could answer, and she heard him laugh as
he ran, two at a time, down the shallow steps.
She went to the window and watched till his strong figure had
disappeared in the dusk.
"He is very like his father," said Elsbeth wistfully, glancing across at
the faded likeness.
The dusk deepened and the stars began to twinkle.
"He will never be the man his father was," cried Elsbeth, suddenly and
defiantly.
Her hands shook as she cleared away the remnants of the meal. She swept
up the hearth, picked the coals carefully apart, and tidied the tidy
room. Roger's roses still lay in a heap in the basket chair. She
gathered them up and carried them into the tiny bathroom, that they
might drink their fill all night. Their scent was strong and sweet. Then
she lit her candle and prepared for bed.
The sheets were very cold. She tried not to think of Roger's father
lying in the grave she had never seen. The old, cruel longing was upon
her for the sound of his voice and the sight of his face and the
sweetness of his smile. She broke into painful weeping.
The hours wore past.
Of course he would marry Alwynne.... Alwynne would be happy ... there
was comfort in that.... Roger would be kind to her.... A good boy ... a
dear boy....
"And he might have been my son," cried out Elsbeth to the uncaring
night.