Rupert Confides in Thorndyke
Although few of its buildings (excepting the Halls) are of really
great antiquity, the precinct of the Temples shares with the older
parts of London at least one medieval characteristic: it abounds in
those queer little passages and alleys which, burrowing in all
directions under the dwelling-houses, are a source of endless
confusion and bewilderment to the stranger, though to the accustomed
denizen they offer an equally great convenience. For by their use the
seasoned Templar makes his way from any one part of the precinct to
any other, if not in an actual bee-line, at least in an abbreviated
zig-zag that cuts across the regular thoroughfares as though they were
mere paths traversing an open meadow. Some of these alleys do, indeed,
announce themselves even to unaccustomed eyes, as public passage-ways,
by recognizable entrance arches; but many of them scorn even this
degree of publicity, artfully concealing their existence from the
uninitiated by an ordinary doorway, which they share with a pair of
houses. Whereby the unsuspecting stranger, entering what, in his
innocence, he supposes to be the front doorway of a house, walks along
the hall and is presently astonished to find himself walking out of
another front door into another thoroughfare.
The neighbourhood of Fig Tree Court is peculiarly rich in these
deceptive burrows, indeed, excepting from the Terrace, it has no other
avenue of approach. On the present occasion I had the choice of two,
and was proceeding along the narrow lane of Elm Court to take the
farther one, which led to the entry of my chambers, when I caught
sight of a man approaching hurriedly from the direction of the
Cloisters. At the first glance, I thought I recognized him—though he
was a mere silhouette in the dim light—as the loiterer whom I had seen
on the night of my return. And his behaviour confirmed my suspicion;
for as he came in sight of me, he hesitated for a moment and then,
quickening his pace forward, disappeared suddenly through what
appeared to be a hole in the wall but was, in fact, the passage for
which I was making.
Instantly, I turned back and swiftly crossing the square of Elm Court,
dived into the burrow at its farther corner and came out into the
little square of Fig Tree Court at the very moment when the mysterious
stranger emerged from the burrow at the other side, so that we met
face to face in the full light of the central lamp.
Naturally, I was the better prepared for the encounter and I pursued
my leisurely way towards my chambers with the air of not having
observed him; while he, stopping short for a moment with a wild stare
at me, dashed across the square and plunged into the passage from
which I had just emerged.
I did not follow him. I had seen him and had thereby confirmed a
suspicion that had been growing upon me, and that was enough. For I
need hardly say that the man was Anthony Wallingford. But though I was
prepared for the identification, I was none the less puzzled and
worried by it. Here was yet another perplexity; and I was just
stepping into my entry to reflect upon it at my leisure when I became
aware of hurrying footsteps in the passage through which Wallingford
had come. Quickly drawing back into the deep shadow of the vestibule,
I waited to see who this new-comer might be. In a few seconds he
rushed out of the passage and came to a halt in the middle of the
square, nearly under the lamp, where he stood for a few moments,
looking to right and left and listening intently. And now I realized
the justice of what Madeline had said; for, commonplace as the man
was, I recognized him in an instant. Brown hat, blue serge suit, big,
sandy moustache and concave, pointed nose; they were not sensational
characteristics, but they identified him beyond a moment’s doubt.
Apparently, his ear must have caught the echoes of Wallingford’s
footsteps, for, after a very brief pause, he started off at something
approaching a trot and disappeared into the passage by which I had
come and Wallingford had gone. A sudden, foolish curiosity impelled me
to follow and observe the methods of this singular and artless sleuth.
But I did not follow directly. Instead, I turned and ran up the other
passage, which leads into the narrow part of Elm Court; and as I came
flying out of the farther end of it I ran full tilt into a man who was
running along the court towards the Cloisters. Of course the man was
Wallingford. Who else would be running like a lunatic through the
Temple at night, unless it were his pursuer?
With muttered curses but no word of recognition, he disengaged himself
and pursued his way, disappearing at length round the sharp turn in
the lane which leads towards the Cloisters. I did not follow him, but
drew back into the dark passage and waited. Very soon another figure
became visible, approaching rapidly along the dimly lighted lane. I
drew farther back and presently from my hiding-place I saw the
brown-hatted shadower steal past with a ridiculous air of secrecy and
caution; and when he had passed, I peered out and watched his receding
figure until it disappeared round the angle of the lane.
I felt half-tempted to join the absurd procession and see what
eventually became of these two idiots. But I had really seen enough. I
now knew that Wallingford’s “delusions” were no delusions at all and
that Madeline’s story set forth nothing but the genuine, indisputable
truth. And with these new facts to add to my unwelcome store of data,
I walked slowly back to my chambers, cogitating as I went.
In truth, I had abundant material for reflection. The more I turned
over my discoveries in Madeline’s flat the more did the incriminating
evidence seem to pile up. I recalled Polton’s plainly expressed
suspicion that the sender of the infernal machine was a woman; and I
recalled Thorndyke’s analysis of the peculiarities of the thing with
the inferences which those peculiarities suggested, and read into them
a more definite meaning. I now saw what the machine had conveyed to
him, and what he had been trying to make it convey to me. The
unmechanical outlook combined with evident ingenuity, the
unfamiliarity with ordinary mechanical appliances, the ignorance
concerning the different kinds of gun-powder, the lack of those common
tools which nearly every man, but hardly any woman, possesses and can
use: all these peculiarities of the unknown person were feminine
peculiarities. And finally, there had been the plug of knitting-wool:
a most unlikely material for a man to use for such a purpose, or,
indeed, to possess at all.
So my thoughts went over and over the same ground, and every time
finding escape from the obvious conclusion more and more impossible.
The evidence of Madeline’s complicity—at the very least—in the sending
of the infernal machine appeared overwhelming. I could not reject it.
Nor could I deny what the sending of it implied. It was virtually a
confession of guilt. And yet, even as I admitted this to myself, I was
strangely enough aware that my feelings towards Madeline remained
unaltered. The rational, legal side of me condemned her. But somehow,
in some incomprehensible way, that condemnation had a purely
technical, academic quality. It left my loyalty and affection for her
untouched.
But what of Thorndyke? Had his reasoning travelled along the same
lines? If it had, there would be nothing sentimental in _his_
attitude. He had warned me, and I knew well enough that whenever there
should be evidence enough to put before a court, the law would be set
in motion. What, then, was his present position? And even as I asked
myself the question, there echoed uncomfortably in my mind the
significant suggestion that he had thrown out only a few hours ago
concerning the bottle of medicine. Evidently, he at least entertained
the possibility that the Fowler’s Solution had been put into that
bottle after Monkhouse’s death, and that for the express purpose of
diverting suspicion from the food. The manifest implication was that
he entertained the possibility that the poison had been administered
in the food. But to suspect this was to suspect the person who
prepared the food of being the poisoner. And the person who prepared
the food was Madeline.
The question, therefore, as to Thorndyke’s state of mind was a vital
one. He had expressed no suspicion of Madeline. But then he had
expressed no suspicion of anybody. On the other hand, he had
exonerated nobody. He was frankly observant of every member of that
household. Then there was the undeniable fact that Madeline had been
watched and followed. Somebody suspected her. But who? The watcher was
certainly not a detective. Amateur was writ large all over him. Then
it was not the police who suspected her. Apparently there remained
only Thorndyke, though one would have expected him to employ a more
efficient agent.
But Wallingford was also under observation, and more persistently.
Then he, too, was suspected. But here there was some show of reason.
For what was Wallingford doing in the Temple? Evidently he had been
lurking about, apparently keeping a watch on Thorndyke, though for
what purpose I could not imagine. Still, it was a suspicious
proceeding and justified some watch being kept on him. But the
shadowing of Madeline was incomprehensible.
I paced up and down my sitting room turning these questions over in my
mind and all the time conscious of a curious sense of unreality in the
whole affair; in all this watching and following and dodging which
looked so grotesque and purposeless. I felt myself utterly bewildered.
But I was also profoundly unhappy and, indeed, overshadowed by a
terrible dread. For out of this chaos one fact emerged clearly: there
was a formidable body of evidence implicating Madeline. If Thorndyke
had known what I knew, her position would have been one of the gravest
peril. My conscience told me that it was my duty to tell him; and I
knew that I had no intention of doing anything of the kind. But still
the alarming question haunted me: how much did he really know? How
much did he suspect?
In the course of my perambulations I passed and repassed a smallish
deed box which stood on a lower book-shelf and which was to me what
the Ark of the Covenant was to the ancient Israelites: the repository
of my most sacred possessions. Its lid bore the name “Stella,” painted
on it by me, and its contents were a miscellany of trifles, worthless
intrinsically, but to me precious beyond all price as relics of the
dear friend who had been all in all to me during her short life and
who, though she had been lying in her grave for four long years, was
all in all to me still. Often, in the long, solitary evenings, had I
taken the relics out of their abiding-place and let the sight of them
carry my thoughts back to the golden days of our happy companionship,
filling in the pleasant pictures with the aid of my diary—but that was
unnecessary now, since I knew the entries by heart—and painting other,
more shadowy pictures of a future that might have been. It was a
melancholy pleasure, perhaps, but yet, as the years rolled on, the
bitterness of those memories grew less bitter and still the sweet
remained.
Presently, as for the hundredth time the beloved name met my eye,
there came upon me a yearning to creep back with her into the sunny
past; to forget, if only for a short hour, the hideous anxieties of
the present and in memory to walk with her once more “along the meads
of asphodel.”
Halting before the box, I stood and lifted it tenderly to the table
and having unlocked it, raised the lid and looked thoughtfully into
the interior. Then, one by one, I lifted out my treasures, set them
out in order on the table and sat down to look at them and let them
speak to me their message of peace and consolation.
To a stranger’s eye they were a mere collection of odds and ends. Some
would have been recognizable as relics of the more conventional type.
There were several photographs of the dead girl, some taken by myself,
and a tress of red-gold hair—such hair as I had been told often
glorifies the victims whom consumption had marked for its own. It had
been cut off for me by Barbara when she took her own tress, and tied
up with a blue ribbon. But it was not these orthodox relics that spoke
to me most intimately. I had no need of their aid to call up the
vision of her person. The things that set my memory working were the
records of actions and experiences; the sketch-books, the loose
sketches and the little plaster plaques and medallions that she had
made with my help after she had become bed-ridden and could go no more
abroad to sketch. Every one of these had its story to tell, its vision
to call up.
I turned over the sketches—simple but careful pencil drawings for the
most part, for Stella, like me, had more feeling for form than for
colour—and recalled the making of them; the delightful rambles across
the sunny meadows or through the cool woodlands, the solemn planting
of sketching-stools and earnest consultation on the selection and
composition of the subjects. These were the happiest days, before the
chilly hand of the destroyer had been laid on its chosen victim and
there was still a long and sunny future to be vaguely envisaged.
And then I turned to the little plaques and medallions which she had
modelled and under my supervision and of which I had made the plaster
moulds and casts. These called up sadder memories, but yet they spoke
of an even closer and more loving companionship; for each work was, in
a way, a joint achievement over which we had triumphed and rejoiced
together. So it happened that, although the shadow of sickness, and at
last of death, brooded over them, it was on these relics that I tended
to linger most lovingly.
Here was the slate that I had got for her to stick the clay on and
which she used to hold propped up against her knees as she worked with
never-failing enthusiasm through the long, monotonous days, and even,
when she was well enough, far into the night by the light of the
shaded candle. Here were the simple modelling-tools and the little
sponge and the Camel-hair brush with which she loved to put the final
finish on the damp clay reliefs. Here was Lanterri’s priceless
text-book over which we used to pore together and laud that
incomparable teacher. Here were the plaques, medals and medallions
that we had prised out, with bated breath, from their too-adherent
moulds. And here—the last and saddest relic—was the wax mould from
which no cast had ever been made, the final, crowning work of those
deft, sensitive fingers.
For the thousandth time, I picked it up and let the light fall
obliquely across its hollows. The work was a medal some three inches
across, a portrait of Stella, herself, modelled from a profile
photograph that I had taken for the purpose. It was an excellent
likeness and unquestionably the best piece of modelling that she had
ever done.
Often, I had intended to take the cast from it, but always had been
restrained by a vague reluctance to disturb the mould. Now, as I
looked at the delicate, sunken impression, I had again the feeling
that this, her last work, ought to be finished; and I was still
debating the matter with the mould in my hand when I heard a quick
step upon the stair, followed by a characteristic knock on my door.
My first impulse was to hustle my treasures back into their box before
answering the summons. But this was almost instantly followed by a
revulsion. I recognized the knock as Thorndyke’s; and somehow there
came upon me a desire to share my memories with him. He had shown a
strangely sympathetic insight into my feelings towards Stella. He had
read my diary. He now knew the whole story; and he was the kindest,
the most loyal and most discreet of friends. Gently laying down the
mould I went to the door and threw it open.
“I saw your light burning as I passed just now,” said Thorndyke as he
entered and shook my hand warmly, “so I thought I would take the
opportunity to drop in and return your diary. I hope I am not
disturbing you. If I am, you must treat me as a friend and eject me.”
“Not at all, Thorndyke,” I replied. “On the contrary, you would be
doing me a charity if you would stay and smoke a companionable pipe.”
“Good,” said he, “then I will give myself the pleasure of a quiet
gossip. But what is amiss, Mayfield?” he continued, laying a friendly
hand on my shoulder and looking me over critically. “You look worn,
and worried and depressed. You are not letting your mind dwell too
much, I hope, on the tragedy that has come unbidden into your life?”
“I am afraid I am,” I replied. “The horrible affair haunts me.
Suspicion and mystery are in the very air I breathe. A constant menace
seems to hang over all my friends, so that I am in continual dread of
some new catastrophe. I have just ascertained that Wallingford is
really being watched and shadowed; and not only Wallingford but even
Miss Norris.”
He did not appear surprised or seek for further information. He merely
nodded and looked into my face with grave sympathy.
“Put it away, Mayfield,” said he. “That is my counsel to you. Try to
forget it. You have put the investigation into my hands. Leave it
there and wash your own of it. You did not kill Harold Monkhouse.
Whoever did must pay the penalty if ever the crime should be brought
home to the perpetrator. And if it never can be, it were better that
you and all of us should let it sink into oblivion rather than allow
it to remain to poison the lives of innocent persons. Let us forget it
now. I see you were trying to.”
I had noticed that when he first entered the room, he cast a single,
swift glance at the table which, I was sure, had comprehended every
object on it. Then he had looked away and never again let his eyes
stray in that direction. But now, as he finished speaking, he glanced
once more at the table, and this time with undisguised interest.
“Yes,” I admitted. “I was trying to find in the memories of the past
an antidote for the present. These are the relics of that past. I
daresay you have read of them in the diary and probably have written
me down a mawkish sentimentalist.”
“I pray you, my friend, not to do me that injustice!” he exclaimed.
“Faithful friendship that even survives the grave, is not a thing that
any man can afford to despise. But for the disaster of untimely death,
your faithfulness and hers would have created for two persons the
perfect life. I assure you, Mayfield, that I have been deeply moved by
the story of your delightful friendship and your irreparable loss. But
don’t let us dwell too much on the sad aspects of the story. Show me
your relics. I see some very charming little plaques among them.”
He picked up one with reassuring daintiness of touch and examined it
through a reading-glass that I handed to him.
“It really is a most admirable little work,” said he. “Not in the
least amateurish. She had the makings of a first-class medallist; the
appreciation of the essential qualities of a miniature relief. And she
had a fine feeling for composition and spacing.”
Deeply gratified by his appreciation and a little surprised by his
evident knowledge of the medallist’s art, I presented the little
works, one after another, and we discussed their merits with the
keenest interest. Presently he asked:
“Has it never occurred to you, Mayfield, that these charming little
works ought to be finished?”
“Finished?” I repeated. “But, aren’t they finished?”
“Certainly not. They are only in the plaster. But a plaster cast is an
intermediate form, just a mere working model. It is due to the merits
of these plaques and medals that they should be put into permanent
material—silver or copper or bronze. I’ll tell you what, Mayfield,” he
continued, enthusiastically. “You shall let Polton make replicas of
some of them—he could do it with perfect safety to the originals. Then
we could hand the casts to an electrotyper or a founder—I should
favour the electrotype process for such small works—and have them
executed in whichever metal you preferred. Then you would be able to
see, for the first time, the real quality of the modelling.”
I caught eagerly at the idea, but yet I was a little nervous.
“You think it would be perfectly safe?” I asked.
“Absolutely safe. Polton would make gelatine moulds which couldn’t
possibly injure the originals.”
That decided me. I fell in with the suggestion enthusiastically, and
forthwith we began an anxious consultation as to the most suitable
pieces with which to make a beginning. We had selected half a dozen
casts when my glance fell on the wax mould. That was Stella’s
masterpiece and it certainly ought to be finished; but I was loath to
part with the mould for fear of an accident. Very dubiously, I handed
it to Thorndyke and asked:
“What do you think of this? Could it be cast without any risk of
breaking it?”
He laid the mould on the table before him so that the light fell
obliquely across it and looked down on it reflectively.
“So,” said he, “this is the wax mould. I was reading about it only
yesterday and admiring your resourcefulness and ingenuity. I must read
the entry again with the actual object before me.”
He opened the diary, which he had laid on the table, and when he had
found the entry, read it to himself in an undertone.
“Dropped in to have tea with Stella and found her bubbling with
excitement and triumph. She had just finished the portrait medal and
though her eyes were red and painful from the strain of the close
work, in spite of her new spectacles, she was quite happy and as proud
as a little peacock. And well she might be. I should like Lanterri to
see his unknown pupil’s work. We decided to make the mould of it at
once, but when I got out the plaster tin, I found it empty. Most
unfortunate, for the clay was beginning to dry and I didn’t dare to
damp it. But something had to be done to protect it. Suddenly I had a
brilliant idea. There was nearly a whole candle in Stella’s
candlestick, quite enough for a mould, and good, hard wax that
wouldn’t warp. I took off the reflector and lighted the candle, which
I took out of the candlestick and held almost upside down over the
clay medal and let the wax drip on to it. Soon the medal was covered
by a film of wax which grew thicker and thicker, until, by the time I
had used up practically the whole of the candle, there was a good,
solid crust of wax, quite strong enough to cast from. When I went
home, I took the slate with me with the wax mould sticking to it,
intending to cover it with a plaster shell for extra safety. But my
plaster tin was empty, too, so I put the slate away in a safe place
until I should get some fresh plaster to make the cast; which will not
happen until I get back from Chelmsford.
“Busy evening getting ready for to-morrow; hope I shall feel less
cheap then than I do now.”
As Thorndyke finished reading he looked up and remarked: “That was an
excellent plan of yours. I have seen Polton use the same method. But
how was it that you never made the cast?”
“I was afraid of damaging the mould. As you know, when I came back
from Ipswich, Stella was dead, and as the medal was her last work and
her best, I hardly dared to risk the chance of destroying it.”
“Still,” Thorndyke urged, “it was the medal that was her work. The
mould was your own; and the medal exists only potentially in the
mould. It will come into actual existence only when the cast is made.”
I saw the force of this, but I was still a little uneasy, and said so.
“There is no occasion,” said he. “The mould is amply strong enough to
cast from. It might possibly break in separating the cast, but that
would be of no consequence, as you would then have the cast, which
would be the medal, itself. And it could then be put into bronze or
silver.”
“Very well,” I said, “if you guarantee the safety of the operation, I
am satisfied. I should love to see it in silver; or perhaps it might
look even better in gold.”
Having disposed of the works, themselves, we fell to discussing the
question of suitable settings or frames; and this led us to the
subject of the portraits. Thorndyke glanced over the collection, and
picking up one, which happened to be my own favourite, looked at it
thoughtfully.
“It is a beautiful face,” said he, “and this seems to have been a
singularly happy portrait. In red chalk autotype, it would make a
charming little picture. Did you take it?”
“Yes; and as I have the negative I am inclined to adopt your
suggestion. I am surprised that I never thought of it myself, for red
chalk is exactly the right medium.”
“Then let Polton have the negative. He is quite an expert in autotype
work.”
I accepted the offer gladly and we then came back to the question of
framing. Thorndyke’s suggestion was that the portrait should be
treated as a medallion and enclosed in a frame to match that of the
medal. The idea appealed to me rather strongly, and presently a
further one occurred to me, though it was suggested indirectly by
Thorndyke, who had taken up the tress of Stella’s hair and was looking
at it admiringly as he drew it softly between his fingers.
“Human hair,” he remarked, “and particularly a woman’s hair, is always
a beautiful material, no matter what its colour may be; but this
red-gold variety is one of the most gorgeous of Nature’s productions.”
“Yes,” I agreed, “it is extremely decorative. Barbara had her tress
made up into a thin plait and worked into the frame of a miniature of
Stella. I liked the idea, but somehow the effect is not so very
pleasing. But it is an oblong frame.”
“I don’t think,” said Thorndyke, “that a plait was quite the best
form. A little cable would look better, especially for a medallion
portrait; indeed I think that if you had a plain square black frame
with a circular opening, a little golden cable, carried round
concentrically with the opening would have a rather fine effect.”
“So it would,” I exclaimed. “I think it would look charming. I had no
idea, Thorndyke, that you were a designer. Do you think Polton could
make the cable?”
“Polton,” he replied, impressively, “can do anything that can be done
with a single pair of human hands. Let him have the hair, and he will
make the cable and the frame, too; and he will see that the glass
cover is an airtight fit—for, of course, the cable would have to be
under the glass.”
To this also I agreed with a readiness that surprised myself. And yet
it was not surprising. Hitherto I had been accustomed secretly and in
solitude to pore over these pathetic little relics of happier days and
lock up my sorrows and my sense of bereavement in my own breast. Now,
for the first time, I had a confidant who shared the knowledge of my
shattered hopes and vanished happiness; and so whole heartedly, with
such delicate sympathy and perfect understanding had Thorndyke entered
into the story of my troubled life that I found in his companionship
not only a relief from my old self-repression but a sort of subdued
happiness. Almost cheerfully I fetched an empty cigar-box and a supply
of cotton wool and tissue paper and helped him tenderly and delicately
to pack my treasures for their first exodus from under my roof. And it
was with only a faint twinge of regret that I saw him, at length,
depart with the box under his arm.
“You needn’t be uneasy, Mayfield,” he said, pausing on the stairs to
look back. “Nothing will be injured; and as soon as the casting is
successfully carried through, I shall drop a note in your letter-box
to set your mind at rest. Good night.”
I watched him as he descended the stairs, and listened to his quick
foot-falls, fading away up the court. Then I went back to my room with
a faint sense of desolation to re-pack the depleted deed-box and
thereafter to betake myself to bed.